I guess I would have thought panic would trigger other threads to abort as well. Admittedly I haven't really done any multithreading in Rust. I was thinking it was more like exit(status) in C/C++ that immediately terminated the entire process. Exception unrolling in general I feel is something that should be avoided if you care at all about error conditions.
If panics are isolated to one thread, then I guess mutex poisoning is a better default error case than a deadlock where the process never exits. An entirely independent thread might still be unaware the rest of the program has crashed though.
