3 or 5. I need to click the button on top 10 times a second. There's no way I'm giving that up.
post
Got converted to the pilot G-2 club (5) by someone who goes through an ink refill a week with them. They are precise, reliably dark, and silky smooth to write with. I am actively disappointed when forced to write with average pens instead
- Good and reliable. Any with ink like 5 are annoying to use left handed.
I'm left handed and stick with the dry ass bic crystal. Everything else smears or just stops working in the middle of a letter.
Where's my fountain pen? Say Lamy Safari.
These are all newbie pens.
😔
Respect. Although, I prefer a TWSBI 580.
4 by a wide margin.
1 is good but it skips more in my experience.
2 is probably better for art. The long thin tip is less obstructive to vision, but it's fragile enough that I wouldn't want to lend it.
3 It's a gel pen, which is a good compromise between rollerball and ballpoint in many ways. However, if you can handle the problems of a gel pen, you can handle a rollerball and get better results.
5 (see number 3)
6 The writing equivalent of nails on a chalkboard. I can feel the texture of the paper on my teeth when I write with a felt-tip pen. No cost or performance benefit over other options, to my knowledge. Probably just an outdated technology.
7 The best general-purpose pen in terms of cost per mile. Prone to smudging even years afterward, it's probably the lowest quality and least secure option here. Very easy to wash out, even accidentally with hand sanitizer.
4 is the supercar of the disposable pen world perhaps overshadowed only by the rare disposable fountain pen. Least likely to skip, by far. The specialized ink soaks into paper and becomes insoluble to water, alcohol and acetone once dried. Won't leak on an airplane like some pens. Problems include smearing wet ink and bleed-through. Smearing is mostly a skill issue for right-handed writers. Blotters are always an option, too. Bleed through is about paper quality and technique.
I didn't come to Lemmy to be sold a new pen, but today you've convinced me to try the supercar of the disposable pen world.
4 is so smooooooooth
With 3 and 5 you're missing out on the click action and the nice finger grip. I love me a good soft finger grip.
2 - Pilot Precise v5 plz
I'm gonna be chaotic and say that I have no preference unless any are felt tip. I don't want those.
Felt tip hate FTW
They are good for certain things, but they are atrocious as a general purpose pen.
Thanks for the additional perspective. What's their best use case?
I like them when I need to write on corrugated cardboard. Better than ball points anyway. Don't need as much pressure to write so I'm not accidentally poking through the cardboard.
That's all that comes to mind. I just assume there are other use cases.
Really useful when doing artwork because you can angle and bend the thickness really well.
#7, because it doesn't say I will be magically provided any pens, and that's the only style I know how to easily obtain. Which is important because I lose pens often.
1,4,5 or nothing.
I gotta know why you selected two uniball rollerball pens and one pilot gel pen but not the pilot rollerball pen.
3 and 5. The gel ink on 3 is superb, and 5 is smooth, if not with a bit of friction.
If you've been using those for a long time, I don't suppose you've noticed any change in quality in the last say, 10 years compared to before that? I used to love those pens but the ones I've gotten my hands on recently leak a lot and the writing is inconsistent, which is something I feel like never used to happen a long time ago.
I fuck with 1, 5 and 6 if they are 1mm. I don’t fuck with 0.7 pens.
0.7 is way too thick. 0.5 is acceptable if there aren't any 0.38 available.
Right? I'll use 0.7 rarely for flare on a birthday card or something like that, but not for routine use. 1mm is insane. Might as well use a chisel-tipped marker.
.038 need to be used carefully or you will destroy the tip and it will skip a lot. Feel good when not going too quickly and are writing with intention.
They are also terrible for anything requiring multiple carbon copy layers such as waybills or deposit slips. Cuts through the top layer or doesn't reach the bottom layer
i pick the fountain pen i’m already carrying with the fatass german medium nib and enough ink to last a year between refills.
5 writes like silk. I really love that pen, especially that chonky boy 1.0mm
- But honestly after using the Pilot G2 0.7 for years, I've found the Pentel Energel Kuro 0.7 to be the superior comparable pen.
2 if it's the same tip size I have at home but something else if it's thicker. My handwriting is not great so thin = more definition = better chance of reading whatever I scratched.
As long as its ISO 12757-2 certified i dont care. But would be a hassle if not because if i cant use any other pencil i cant sign documents.
Like think 5 is an eraseable one and in case of 7 ive never seen some certification on the ink tube so they would be ruled out
I think #2 is a v5, nice pen, but the v7 is much better.
If #2 is a v5 then I go for #3, the sharpie s-gel. All solid choices, 6 is a little more niche and most of these can't replace 6, nor can it replace a standard writing implement. 6 is a trick entry
3 and 5 tied for first. 1, 2, 4 tied for second. 7 if there's really no other option. 6 can fuck right off unless there's a very specific reason I need it.
#3 is a fine writing pen, I have to admit. But my heart goes to #5. There's something about that rounded clicker that feels just right against the teeth and gums and tongue and...
Wassast?...
No, I've never been diagnosed. Why?...
S Gel is just as good as the g2 but black ink > blue ink so s gel for me
the build of the g2 is superior though, but ink > build imo at least the s gel build is tolerable but the clicker is subpar and I'm not too big a fan of the grip
edit: oh shit ignoring ink color g2 obviously. If only for the compatibility of the refills
I will absolutely not ignore the colour of ink
4. The vision elite in BLX ink. Archival quality ink and very smooth point.
That being said I prefer fountain pens to all of these if it's gonna be my one and only
If #5 is a Zebra Sarasa 7mm gel ink pen, then that's the one.
The lack of Zebra and Pentel, over representation of Uniball and felt tip, as well as no Fisher narrows the capabilities of the options. The Uniballs are going to smear for a lefty, the felt are going to have the tip degrade and be inconsistent across paper types, the fat pens are more difficult to position the start/stop on the ruler or lettering guide, so the Bic Cristal or the Pilot G2 are the best choices, but I have no experience with Sharpie Gel.
No mechanical pencil options? If I have to give up my Pentel Graphgear 1000 for some inky un-erasable bullshit I'm ending it all.
I don't get the allure of the G2 pilot. I've used so many of them and they are nothing special.
I'll take a box full of Number 7, please. Basic bitch is best.


top 93 comments