Wow, so we can put an actual dollar amount on the lives lost. Most of the time karma isn’t so precise.
post
On the one hand, I can't imagine the county in question has the type of tax revenue to support $500 million, even if they were the type to have change to raise taxes (they're not). On the other hand, situations in which local governments can't afford essentials is exactly when you're supposed to have larger government (Texas, Feds) step in an subsidize, which of course they aren't willing under GoP rule. Meh.
I'm reminded of "a libertarian walks into a bear". Right wing folks have a poor model of the world
Why help myself if I have to spend money and do stuff?
Understandable when it comes to wearing pants. Not understandable when it comes to natural disaster warning systems.
Just in case anybody wasn't sure.
Couldn't they just use a system that sends texts or alerts using GPS / triangulation?
A lot of that area is remote or in canyons so cell service is spotty at best.
Edit: that is to say, you need a dedicated system specifically for warnings like this with real power sources, physical alarm devices, and either hard wired data systems, or data systems that are on radio towers high enough up to actually function and function properly in bad weather.
True, and maybe it would make sense for the county (or a cellphone company?) to invest in strategically located towers so that cell service would be less spotty in general there? Not just for this kind of emergency but also lost hikers etc.
I don't think something of this risk should be left to individual, non-publicly maintained or controlled devices. This is specifically an area where the time to act is short and oftentimes the public is either in the river or river adjacent so they wouldn't have their phone.
That said, there should be better cell service for the reasons you listed, I just don't think it is the solution to the loss of life here.
Remote areas and canyons are not the problem this solution addresses. Have you ever heard of tornado sirens or air raid sirens?
The bill would have funded improved disaster alert systems and provided grants for counties to build infrastructure like sirens and radio towers, according to the Texas Tribune.
many residents are believed to have not seen the warnings due to them being issued in the early morning hours, or lacked access to mobile devices altogether.
Yeah, I was trying to tell the poster above why a cell message or triangulated gps signal wouldn't work. This area is remote and needs proper infrastructure with dedicated alarms to function in a safety critical capacity.
There are already tornado sirens in the area around Seguin, so clearly they can afford some kind of warning, but then using budget as the reasons to avoid spending on this kind of thing has always been a bad faith argument.
How about this. Create a program where people can sign up to buy an affordable siren. Install sirens. Texas reimburses those people a percentage. Maybe a tax credit. People hate paying taxes. Texas charges another percentage to all people in Texas.
Maybe it's just me but if I had the option to install an affordable advanced warning siren I'd be interested. My phone works too but a siren has to be cheaper than a funeral for my family.
I don't know why people assume that the siren systems local governments install aren't the affordable option...
What do you think is cheaper and provides the most safety....a single siren loud enough to cover a very wide area, or the state reimbursing hundreds of people to buy inadequately installed and tested sirens all over the place?
I can guarantee that if you had everyone install their own systems a significant portion would not be installed correctly, and another significant portion wouldn't have the needed maintenance performed to maintain reliability.
I guess people don't understand the innate cost effectiveness of consolidation at scale?
Some lawmakers, including state Rep. Wes Virdell, voted against it due to its projected $500 million cost, though several now admit they're reconsidering in the wake of recent events
They’re not going to reconsider. Who’s buying this lie from consummate liars?
Oh good. We can put an exact dollar figure on the lives of those children. Convenient.
An unfortunate FAFO scenario.
Well now they can spend a billion rebuilding with very little of their own money. Socialism for me, not for thee.
Yeah, God forbid you spend a few hundred thousand dollars of easy to maintain equipment to to keep the people who pay you taxes safe
The article says it was projected to cost half a billion dollars. Not sure why it’s that high, but that’s what it says.
Texans do this to themselves. Fuck em.
While I share that sentiment at times, I think about how the rest of the world looks at America.
Like if someone said:
"Americans did this to themselves. Fuck them."
Like damn, I didn't do any of this I'm just trying to survive 😭
You did do this to yourselves, while the rest of us told you exactly what was going to happen for decades. You gave us the finger and renamed French fries. Even the best among you are complacent at best and whining cowards at worst.
“I’m just trying to survive.” Great, you do that while your country burns down around you. Just look out for yourself, someone else will surely save you.
Americans deserve what they’re getting.
You have a healthy sense of compassion
Yeah, no, I didn't vote for this, but yeah, Americans did this to ourselves and it sucks.
Of course, more people get shot to death than this flood killed. And since guns are safe and not killing people, the flood is even safer.
all 25 comments