Microsoft SSH agent persistently stores your unencrypted private keys in the registry. They're still there unlocked and usable after you reboot.
post
does this company intentionally want users to stop using it? cuz day by day either theres a new windows bug or just shittier softwares
Our lives are in the hands of morons. What the fuck.
Safety and security are foundational to Microsoft Edge. Access to browser data as described in the reported scenario would require the device to already be compromised. Design choices in this area involve balancing performance, usability, and security, and we continue to review it against evolving threats.
"We value user safety and usability, but if you're already compromised you can go fuck yourself"
No, if you are already compromised there is just no way anyone can help you anymore besides wiping your whole system.
True, but there's a big fucking difference between handing over the keys without being asked, and doing basic fucking due diligence and not loading all your passwords in plain text into memory by default.
(@iglou@programming.dev ) I can't defend MicroSlop because that mentality is pants on head stupid and is directly in opposition to any statement that they care about security. Because, again, they made their browser behave this way for no real reason besides blowing smoke up our ass. Chromium handles passwords properly, MicroSlop chose to do it insecurely and is hiding behind the dumbest defense. Because their OS has more holes than Swiss cheese and they refuse to plug a basic security hole that they put there intentionally.
Chrome's handling is barely more secure. A compromised device will have a much easier time reading Chrome's encrypted store than scanning your RAM to find passwords.
Remember that if you don't need to input a password to open the store, then anything with access to your device can also read it.
Wether it's encrypted in your RAM or not barely makes any difference in how difficult the task is.
The only solution is: Browsers should require a password. Or even better: Use a dedicated, properly secured password manager.
Chrome's handling is barely more secure. A compromised device will have a much easier time reading Chrome's encrypted store than scanning your RAM to find passwords.
Regardless, they're still loading them into memory in plain text, and knowing this exists, is going to be an easier task to grab than dealing with the encrypted store chromium uses. At least chromium uses the in built credential api to try to protect the secrets, the fact edge doesn't is an egregious security hole.
I don't disagree that users need to have to enter a password to view their stored passwords, but you're hand waving a massive and intentional decrease in security on Edge's part. No matter how easy it is to get out of another browser, this is a violation of basic secure development practices. Security is only as strong as the weakest link, and edge is determined to not even close one of the easiest links in the chain.
I will disagree on the RAM scanning being easier. It is my opinion that the weakest link here is the password store.
The security hole here is a password management system that can work without external secret. It is shocking that this is still common practice and that people use them.
Yeah, I can't believe I'm defending Microsoft but that's probably what they meant. No browser password saving feature is safe if your device is compromised.
Use a proper encrypted password manager
2026 is gonna be the year I finally move to Linux. I have huge concerns about many aspects of switching, but they're being overtaken by concerns about staying with Windows. I don't even mind if my overall user experience is a bit worse on Linux (I am trying to have reasonable expectations that it won't be the walk in the park Linux advocates on Lemmy like to claim), I just have much more faith in its security, privacy, customisability and - most importantly - the motivations and intentions of its developers.
Best of luck! If you've got questions or problems feel free to DM me (or reply here) and I'll try to help as best I can. I've been using linux since the mid 90s, so I have a decent idea of how it all works :)
If you move to one of the big supported distributions, you'll be extremely surprised how easy it is.
If you just want things to stay consistent and easy, I can't recommend Linux mint enough. I installed it on my son's laptop almost two years ago and he's never needed my help to fix anything since.
The installation walks you through everything, just like Windows, but it'll only take about the third of the time. Everything just works and there's no trash to uninstall or debloat scripts to run when you're done.
If you do any gaming you might want to run Fedora or bazzite (fedora with training wheels), but if you're using KDE for the desktop that's almost as easy and seamless.
Can confirm, Bazzite is ridiculously easy. If you don't want to dual-boot it's easier to install than Windows. I have it on my laptop and all my games run better now.
Except Tropico 6. For some reason that made my entire system go crazy. 😄
I switched my mom to Linux because teaching her how to use Linux as her daily driver was easier than trying to unfuck windows on her computer.
Back up your data and then go nuts.
Just made the move a few months ago. Only headache was a missing headset driver, but Claude was able to one shot one for me that's been stable ever since.
Not looking back. There have been very few things that haven't worked so far. Take the leap!
I have huge concerns about many aspects of switching, but they’re being overtaken by concerns about staying with Windows.
Do not. Use. Mint.
That shit bricked my computer for 3 years as a teen with an unpatched bug that impossible to ever download any file to my PC again, including any potential fixes. Spent months on stackexchange forums. No solution lol
Windows has yet to screw me over that hard. (Yet.)
Around what year was this issue? Both windows and Linux were pretty unstable until - someone correct me on this - 2012? Windows 8 was the last unrecoverable crash I had. Oddly never had an issue with Linux, but I know it happens, I've just been lucky.
HOLY @#%^ WHAT IN THE @#%^ DO THEY MEAN "NOT TO WORRY"?????????????????
Well, hold on now, maybe Microsoft has a reasonable explanation for how they actually do secure their passwords...
This is an expected feature of the application.
... Never mind.
Design choices in this area involve balancing performance, usability, and security
Nothing to do with usability since decrypting your passwords one by one is perfectly fine. So they are saying this is about performance ? Holy fuck...
This is sort of like saying "I leave my valuables in plain sight by my door because it has a lock on it and door locks are trustworthy." I'm not super into cyber security and stuff but it seems like one of the most common problems is programs managing to get access to memory they shouldn't have access to. It seems to happen all the time! Just like many locks for you door are trash.
Defense in depth is a concept they teach you in cybersecurity 101. But that's expensive and time consuming, so you end up with shit like this.
It’s ridiculous. It presupposes that cybersecurity doesn’t value or employ defense in depth. Completely untrue.
Look at the attack vector researchers were trying to solve when they created OAuth2.0 w/ PKCE.
"Yeah totally secure! Just trust me!.." basically
This is LITERALLY isn't secure; they should atleast make it encrypted. This is just the same as using your notes app as password manager! But it's microsoft, and they're willingly giving your bitlocker encryption key to the FBIs for your drives. So I'm not surprised..
Access to browser data as described in the reported scenario would require the device to already be compromised.
Yes you can open our safe with just a good yank but if a thief can do that they’re already in your house.
If the thief is already in your house, he can also eat your meal and steal your furniture.
Defense in depth is a thing. You don't give up just because someone made it through the first layer.
And who in their right mind would break in to a house built by Microsoft?
Microsoft - So secure we ROT13 encode everything... TWICE!
I don’t worry, I just don’t use Edge or Windows or any MS software really (except for Teams at work)
Nothing in this timeline surprises me any more.
They say not to worry because they know nobody uses that dumpster fire of a browser so there's no actual risk of your passwords being leaked since you're not using it anyways.
phew it’s an expected feature, thank goodness!!!
if they patch this, they should be dragged through the town square after that comment
You guys are using edge?
Edge is on my computer, and I can't delete it, at least not with my limited IT experience. It's buried deep in the operating system, and it opens up seemingly randomly, I use firefox.
Looking online about getting rid of it, others described it as cancer.
It's not that hard, all you need is usb drive and choosing a distro (the hard step)
Not sure how it works in Win11 but historically it has not been possible to remove Internet Explorer or Edge from Windows.
That is an anti-competitive practice and illegal in truth. Against the laws of the United states, the ones that aren't enforced anymore.
I have refused the upgrade and I'm still on Windows 10 which also sucks by the way. The old 2013 ish operating system, I think windows 7, had a task manager that could actually help manage your computer even if you don't know everything about a computer.
And so much more, everything is going to shit especially in electronics. We seriously need just a complete set of Open Source or otherwise trustworthy alternatives.
Or a way to wipe the programming off of products we buy and install our own programming, but they would make that illegal if that caught on.
The solution is to use Linux Mint.
I'm afraid as I am on my backup computer, and I worry that if I try to change over I will not do it correctly as has been the case every single time I've tried to download a program to accept zip files, or torrents I don't know what my deal is.
I really do want to switch over, I am working on fixing my better computer. More than anything I want a graphene OS phone.
Good that you want to switch, take your time, don't be afraid. There are many resources online for how to switch without accidentally deleting or losing access to things. I have been using Linux Mint for over a year now switching from Windows 10 and I haven't run into any limitations or issues. It's been a great learning experience and has overall lead to me being more technologically savvy. If you have any questions there are many places to discuss, feel free to ask.
This is why gamers should reject kernel anti cheats. A single dev at a single company that requires one could read them as easily as any other file. I'm not exaggerating, unless I'm misinformed
Just use a separate boot for games
M365 chat also fetches a copy of whatever secured file links you send to each other. Goes without saying, but never use Microsoft products if you value security.
How will the NSA spy on you if Microsoft doesn't hand them your passwords?
Eh. To be honest it indeed does not matter much. Scanning your RAM for passwords is much harder than simply reading them off the browsers files. Sure, it is encrypted and the key is not necessarily on your computer, but remember that if the software can decrypt your passwords without you inputting a password or similar, then anything with access to your device can as well.
Don't use your browser's password manager.
Btw, don't ever copy&paste from your password manager, if that's a problem. That's what memory protection mechanisms in hardware and software are for.
The problem is, the weird way it is implemented in Edge and how MS handles the issue.
Btw, don't ever copy&paste from your password manager, if that's a problem
Maybe, but at least with my password manager, they'd only get passwords as I use them and not the keys to the kingdom when I open it.
The problem is, the weird way it is implemented in Edge and how MS handles the issue.
"Handles the issue" is a weird way to say they don't give a shit about protecting your passwords. They had to change this behavior, because chromium doesn't do this by default, so it's not really even negligence in Microsoft at that point. They chose to do this.
What is even the point of the DPAPI?
How can a company manage to be so bafflingly incompetent and why are there people out there still standing for it.
I haven't used a Microsoft browser or operating syatem in almost 25 years.



top 97 comments