It's great to see AI being used for moral, ethical, wholesome things for a change. I sure hope the company Mozilla partnered with hasn't been killing children or anything.
post
Defenders finally have a chance to win, decisively
I'm curious how it will turn out to be in a long term. Are we going to have safer software? Because not only defenders will have a powerful tool, but attackers too. But at the same time, number of bugs is finite... Can we in theory one day achieve literally zero bugs in codebase?
This fluff piece has quite the pie-in-the-sky attitude toward the blue-teaming applications of AI.
Some commentators predict that future AI models will unearth entirely new forms of vulnerabilities that defy our current comprehension, but we don’t think so.
How reassuring.
The defects are finite, and we are entering a world where we can finally find them all.
Could've said the same thing when enterprise anti-malware came onto the scene decades ago, but the reality was it was just another vector for the arms race between the red team and the blue team. The author seems to put a lot of stock in the whole "the blue team has access to these AI tools that the red team doesn't currently have access to" argument, which kinda ignores the fact that that reality is simply not going to last.
I could be wrong, but any article suggesting "zero-days are numbered" doesn't pass the smell test.
I could be wrong, but any article suggesting “zero-days are numbered” doesn’t pass the smell test.
Yeah, you're right.
The real story is that it is a bit better at finding bugs. Calling them zero-days and implying there's some major security implications is just to build hype.
It was able to chain a few of the bugs together to create a RCE exploit in a weakened browser, it's interesting but don't go to your fallout shelter just yet.
The author seems to put a lot of stock in the whole “the blue team has access to these AI tools that the red team doesn’t currently have access to” argument
I didn't read it like that. I think the point was that the red team had an edge over the blue team (by being able to spend a lot of effort on a single exploit), so when both teams have access to these same tools, it'll be more of an equal fight.
Perhaps I misunderstood the author's intent. Though even if their position is that the red team and blue team will be on a more even playing field when both have access to AI tools, I'm not sure I can agree with that assessment. The asymmetrical nature of offense and defense isn't fundamentally changed by the advent of AI tools. While the current slate of AI tools may be uniquely more useful for finding and patching bugs, I can't imagine a future in which AI tools aren't also being tailored for exploiting and penetrating. The red team isn't just going to sit around and not adapt the available toolset to favor their use cases as well.
Much like the arms race between anti-virus development and virus development, there will be defensive AI development and offensive AI development. Similar to what we've already seen with the arms race between LLMs and software that can detect if something was written by an LLM.
I agree that 0-days aren't numbered. There are so many layers on which tech can be exploited that this is a difficult claim to make.
On the other hand, there are two different kind of exploits: clear holes in the logic, a situation or code path not considered by the coder. And the much harder to catch extremely creative ways to make a program do things it was never designed to do.
I have not seen LLMs doing creative things ever, so I doubt it would catch this second category. But sure, catching some logic holes it can be helpful with.
Meanwhile on GitHub Claude Code has over 5k bug reports, currently open.
Some good debunking here: https://www.flyingpenguin.com/the-boy-that-cried-mythos-verification-is-collapsing-trust-in-anthropic/
We’ve led the industry in building and adopting Rust
Yeah, then you fired the team to pay the CEO a few million more.
How many vulnerabilities would’ve been found if we had spent several million dollars on human security researchers though?
That doesn't make sense. Don't the attackers have the same tools?
Mythos Preview is better at finding real vulnerabilities than existing public models and, for now, only a few have access to it.
I'm aware (unfortunately) of the marketing claims and even if they might be true, as you say it is "for now". So if it's only temporary for that arm race, especially if held by a company who leaked its own code just days ago, then I have a hard time understanding why 'zero-days are numbered' because this title claims the dynamic itself is gone. That's now my understanding, especially if other models are just marginally (which is hard to prove with models, finding proper metrics) worst than it.
See comment that shared https://techcrunch.com/2026/04/21/unauthorized-group-has-gained-access-to-anthropics-exclusive-cyber-tool-mythos-report-claims just few hours ago, and that's not even sophisticated.
Anthropic and OpenAI have multiple times used this arm race rhetoric before and it worked. Their models are supposedly "too dangerous" to be released thus consequently they have to control access.
It might be true but so far what we have witnessed is that roughly equivalent models get released by others merely weeks or maybe months after, sometimes open, but the "moat" never lasted long so I'm questioning why it would be different this time.
That lasted long
Actually untrue. The only thing mythos added was an automatic way to exploit vulns that other models also find. I read a good article on mastodon about it. I posted it elsewhere in the thread but also here https://www.flyingpenguin.com/the-boy-that-cried-mythos-verification-is-collapsing-trust-in-anthropic/
Slopzilla Slopfox 🙄
This isn't going to end well.
If it's finding valid vulnerabilities then it's just another tool like static analysis, fuzzers and sanitizers. There definitely seems to be a difference in quality compared to earlier generations that were behind the sloppy avalanch of reports.
Instead of 271 vulns, it was more like 2 vulns, found 271 different times.
Here's a o good article about it https://www.flyingpenguin.com/the-boy-that-cried-mythos-verification-is-collapsing-trust-in-anthropic/
I don't think these are all Mythos, but it's more than 2 fixes: https://infosec.exchange/@tomrittervg/116443139069130293
Look, I'm all for fuck AI, but this isn't that.
There's a difference between using AI to apply fixes for problems, and using AI to find problems that you didn't know about.
Mythos does the latter, not the former.
Software like Firefox is designed in a modular way for humans to be able to reason about its correctness. It is complex, but not arbitrarily complex.
So take out the free VPN and Pocket and it'll be less complex! ¯\(ツ)/¯
They killed Pocket (they didn't just remove it from FF) some time ago.
"Complex but not arbitrarily complex"? I need more coffee this morning already because I'm burning through my patience for idiotic things at an accelerated rate.
This is an arbitrary sentence, not structured to communicate any information.
See how I had to have that final comma clause so you could understand what the fuck I was even saying?
Firefox Forks (Waterfox/Librewolf/Ironfox) my beloved
Yeah, let's all use a fork that doesn't patch those AI slop vulnerabilities.
... You do realize that security patches are upstreamed, correct? These forks just don't include the ads, AI, or built-in VPN.
Didn't some of those promise not to merge AI slop? I guess I misunderstood.
1 comment