
post
If you're going to jettison 90% of the plane to let it fall with parachutes, why not avoid all the complications of modularity and instead just have a parachute system that could let the entire plane float down? Or if the wings are the issue with floating down via parachute, just ditch those? Surely better than letting the pilots go down with the failing plane.
I know this design was for safety, with a shit ton of parachutes on the passenger cabin, but modularity generally fucks the economics of a plane design. You have to have a self-contained module, a plane that is flyable (and landable) without it, and you need a way to securely connect one to the other. Things get chunky real quick, and chunky is expensive, and modern passengers are basically "walking mozzarella sticks who think that $300 and a photo I.D. gives them the right to fly through the air like one of the guardian owls of legend. (!30rock@dubvee.org) For cargo planes, a lot of older designs would drop capacity by 20-30%.
modern passengers are basically "walking mozzarella sticks who think that $300 and a photo I.D. gives them the right to fly through the air like one of the guardian owls of legend.
What does that mean? Do you want only Pilots with 5k flying hours minimum on a plane that have a military survival training?
Public transportation needs to be boring, and for some reason airplanes are not there yet it seems.
I've seen the exact same design years ago sold as a way to quickly prepare the plane for takeoff. Passengers would board the detached module so the whole plane doesn't have to sit there waiting. I imagine you would have more passenger modules than engine modules. The more expensive engine modules would fly non-stop: land, drop the passenger module, pick up another module and take off before even the first plane deboarded. No idea if this could actually work. It's just strange to see the exact same design done for a dumber reason.
you know eventually someone will dump the passengers during the flight
Pretty sure there was an episode of Thunderbirds that did this back in the 60s
I'm a little surprised we don't do it that way. It would make it a lot easier logistically, and it could be much more accessible. Time waiting on the tarmac for humans to shuffle single file is utility wasted.
I'm sure technically we could build a plane like that but I don't think we're at a developmental level that would allow us to make them cheap and secure enough and to handle the logistics involved. Boeing is struggling to make normal planes safe and the entire flight control system in US is close to a breaking point. Imagine adding more possible failure points to the planes and more complex logistics at the airports...
I mean yes, but those problems are there because we refuse to work together and rather have "competition create progress". If all the aviation firms would agree to share knowledge and adopt common standards and thus work together more than compete, we could have nicer things everywhere.
But people are stupid and selfish so we can't have that, fight is all we can.
And I'm not saying aviation firms specifically are about that, rather all humans everywhere.
That time is used by the ground crew to prepare the plane for the flight and go over safety systems. Planes can't just land and takeoff again immediately. Things can go wrong, and you can't pull over in the air. Sometimes those delays are mechanical, and some times those delays are shift changes, bad crew scheduling/staffing levels. Airports are pretty fucking efficient over all. From the planes flying people around perspective, not the human shuffling element. We are just cattle to them after all.
Whereupon, it deploys parachutes and drops to the ground... or ocean, or mountain top, or into the arctic circle. But, I'm sure it would be fine.
Or a cannibal island full of mutants.
Or a mutant island full of cannibals.
If they’re all mutants they’d think I’m the one that looks messed up, so they’d avoid eating me like I was Blinky the fish
It might fall through a wormhole, and leap forward in time thousands of years, where Roddy McDowall clones dress up as apes and terrorize the populace. I mean nothing in physics disallows this, as far as I know.
Or fall out of sync with time itself, where they have to discover a way back to the present before the supernatural creatures who consume the timeline behind us eat them alive. This possibility hasn't been definitively disproven, either!
Alternately, it'll be sold as a premium feature.
"Normal ticket, on an old fashioned deathtrap plane: $299 NOTE: CRASHES HAVE AN ALMOST 0% SURVIVAL RATE. PLEASE CHECK THIS BOX TO ACKNOWLEDGE ACCEPTANCE OF YOUR IMPENDING DOOM. [ ] PLEASE SUBMIT NEXT-OF-KIN NOTIFICATION PHONE NUMBER ______
"Premium SafetyFirst^TM^ plane ticket: $1999.
"ERROR: Please check the box indicating you give consent for next-of-kin notification numbers to be shared with selected third-party service providers to proceed."
Let's entertain this concept:
The chute for the passenger compartment (if there is one) would need to deploy before separation, and looking at this design it can not.
As soon as the compartment tips and catches airflow it will just rotate straight down uncontrollably.
top 38 comments