How can you not give in to impulses and not believe that the solution is to resort to violence when you read certain things knowing that there is no justice in the world nor even any court that will ever convict these people.
post
This makes you reevaluate "truths" that you never thought you would need to reconsider.
I think wealth inequality is extremely important to keep discussing. I'll try to make an impassioned case for why. This may be long; please bear with me.
The broad strokes of this argument are:
- how the wealthy grow wealthier, and faster than renters
- how young and poor people don't have a chance to earn that money, effectively removing it from circulation for a portion of the population
- how the wealthy lobby against any policies that might reduce their wealth, in exchange for policies that raise income tax
An excellent video playlist of about 90 minutes is here: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLXuOBKrmFYbKytq9mkcd62sJPb6w12vpU
How the wealthy grow wealthier faster than Dave the renter
There are a few ways popular ways the average US'ian expects to grow their net worth passively: their stock investment portfolio, or their real estate holdings. (There are other methods such as producing something that commands royalties, but for now this is not important to the rest of the argument.) This is known as the "asset economy".
The wealthy don't store most of their net worth in cash in a bank account; they store it in the form of the assets mentioned above (stocks, property). While Dave the renter spends something like 28-33% of his income on rent, another 10% on discretionary spending, and saves 60% of his income (the common 60/30/10 rule of personal finance), a wealthy person has a paid-off house they only pay property taxes on, and the rest of their income is completely divided between discretionary spending and savings/investments.
If you are a wealthy person, your personal consumption habits are not very different from Dave the renter's. You both pay for food, transportation, clothing. If Dave is a high-income earner, you may also even get a similar class of luxury goods. But here, a larger proportion of Dave's income goes back into the economy, because he earns less but spends the same as you do. So, all else being equal, you both paid taxes on your income, but you save something in the limit of 100% of your post-tax income, whereas Dave saves ~60%.
Both the renter and the wealthy person invest in the same things. Let's say both do the same assets, stocks and property; neither has more information than the other. The only difference is that the wealthy person's income goes towards assets at a percentage close to 100%, whereas the renter's figure is about ~60%. The wealthy person accumulates return-generating assets much faster. The speed here is crucial to this understanding, the term to look up is the "velocity of money". This concept is not usually applied to individuals or classes, but i think it applies so again please bear with me.
The wealthy person's net worth grows much faster compared to Dave's (the assets' value grows at the same rate, but the wealthy person has more of the assets, and therefore netts more returns over time, and therefore accumulates more of the assets over time than Dave). The assets generate returns, and the wealthy person having nearly all their needs met will reinvest all of it into other stocks.
How assets are not money, and how money goes towards assets
When an asset is purchased, it is no longer money though it has a dollar value and may be exchanged for that dollar value. The value may go up or down, and this generates a return (a profit or loss). When either the renter or the wealthy person buys an asset, their hope is that that asset will generate positive returns.
When Dave pays rent, he's paying for the right to use an asset owned by someone else. In effect, he may be generating the very same return (or a portion of it) for the wealthy person. So Dave's income becomes the wealthy person's passive income. This passive income is used to purchase more assets by the wealthy person.
If that money is used to purchase assets instead of for discretionary consumption, there aren't a lot of new gainful employment opportunities in the wealthy person's area. Employment opportunities are limited to what discretionary spending from other people are: service jobs such as taking orders at restaurants and driving cabs. These are industries where there is a lot of competition, so wages are driven down and there isn't a lot of saving happening with this class of jobs.
But, the people working these jobs still have to pay rent. And who do they pay rent to? The people who own their homes, the asset-holding class. This is a net-transfer of wealth to the asset owning class. Again, I want to remind you that most of the returns generated by assets go towards accumulating more assets, and so the service-class of people are locked out of access to this money. If the money never circulates through the economy, but there is an upward transfer and concentration of wealth, then there is little to no chance to actually change your class. Dave may be fine for now; he may be a high-income earner. But there is already a "loser" somewhere nearby in terms of opportunity.
How wealth and income are treated differently, and how this is a problem
In the US, income taxes are applied at progressive brackets. The more you earn, the more the portion of your untaxed-income is taxed. Capital gains taxes, however, are applied at flat-rates. Meaning, for a wealthy or high-income person, the goal is to convert all cash to assets if you want to minimize your tax burden. After all, taxes don't nett you a return, and a tax drag reduces your ability to purchase assets.
However, being a wealthy person who can move millions at a week's notice, you also find yourself offered deals: cash loans from banks at lower interest rates than Dave the renter, the opportunity to participate in investments where you'll be paid a premium for bringing so much cash to the table. So again, I'm restating that the access the wealthy person has to return-generating opportunities is higher.
Additionally, the loans you got as a wealthy person, you can use your assets as collateral for. If you never sell your assets (and they never lose their value), you can keep accumulating your assets with your income while barely paying off your loans. When the loan term is called, you get a new cash loan, and pay off your old loan and use the remainder of the new loan for your discretionary spending and day-to-day expenses. Cash loans are not treated as income so they aren't taxed. You've optimized your income-to-asset-accumulation pipeline. Your cash loans grow, but you don't care; when you die your assets will be passed to your descendents, and upon your death the cost-basis for these assets will be updated to the price at the time of the transfer to your beneficiaries. You never paid capital-gains tax! They sell a portion of the assets you've accumulated to pay off your loans without a huge tax bill. You managed to live your life minimizing how much you pay in taxes (minimizing a revenue stream for the government to invest in social services with, like public education which can be a path towards gainful employment, or publicly-funded housing developments, or transportation infrastructure; all things that the lower and middle classes use but that wealthy don't), and now your heirs can do the same. This strategy is known as "buy-borrow-die".
All the while, because of the concentration of money in assets, the prices of the assets have been rising and locking lower classes out. At this point Dave himself may be wealthy, but someone who's just starting out and is in a similar position to Dave when he started out may not have a similar path available. This is the "death of the middle class", or the "K-shaped economy".
So, you're right in a way: the income discrepancy matters. But it's not correct to say that we should ignore wealth and only consider incomes. The problem already exists.
It's also important that it's 0.1% percent of the population that controls as much wealth as the bottom 50%. Like, it represents the scale of the problem. But these numbers don't individually give an insight into the scale of the problem; also look at what it is for the top 0.01% of the population, and for the top 0.001%.
So now, is it any wonder that the very high end of the wealthy don't actually care about income taxes? They've optimized their pipelines to minimize cash-income, and maximize asset-accumulation. The things they lobby against are estate taxes (a.k.a. "death taxes"; i.e. an opportunity for your government to act in your best interests if you are a member of the renter class of assets and recover some of the money inaccessible to you) and capital gains taxes (purely as an operational thing; they would not lose too much from a rise in capital gains taxes, but it would set a precedent that they'd rather not have and it might create more complications in their rather complicated personal finance system already).
An imperfect analogy
If i were to make an analogy, I'd compare it to the water cycle. We all learned about the water cycle; we also know that we're depleting our fresh-water sources faster than they're getting replenished. The issue is one of flows; we draw from underground sources but we don't replenish them. Deforestation means less water is absorbed by trees and becomes run-off. If this happens long enough, it means there's less moisture available in a region available for rain (assuming you're not by a large body of water that the run-off accumulated in). So eventually, your ability to even receive fresh water is diminished.
Similar to the reality of wealth inequality, your future generations, or your neighbor's future generation may be locked out of opportunities. As the economy divides into two groups (people with and without discretionary spending) you'll see goods and services increasingly bifurcated into either luxury or trash. Flights will add more First and Business class seating while removing Economy seating, and for Economy they'll be priced out of things like carry-on baggage or the ability to get refunds due to weather conditions. Computing will get more expensive; it will move to a model where regular people won't be able to afford laptops or desktops and will have to pay to rent a CPU and/or GPU in a data center that adds value to an asset-holder's portfolio. Housing will only get more expensive to purchase and to rent, despite not necessarily improving commensurate to the increase in cost.
Closing thoughts
- The playlist I linked at the beginning does a much better job of explaining these concepts than I do. Please give it a listen.
- Paying rent and paying a mortgage (housing loan) is not very different from this framework. When paying rent, your entire sum goes to your landlord directly. When laying a mortgage, you pay your bank interest, who pays the members of that bank an interest rate in exchange for leaving cash/assets at that bank, and the people who have more cash and assets get larger returns. In effect, this can be seen as a feature; the banks are insured by the government and you as a wealthy person don't need to purchase a property with all of the associated legal work and risk but you can still collect a portion of housing payments.
- When I said that taxes don't nett you a return, I don't think that's actually true; I was just repeating the argument of wealthy people. I personally think the benefits come from being surrounded from people who are have dignity and purpose. I benefit from living in a society with an educated population. I benefit when people are happy and fulfilled and have their needs met. I want my taxes to go towards that.
- Notice I didn't mention the Laotian farmer at all? While a farm is an asset, it has to be actively worked to generate returns; the land is not typically available to rent and generate a passive return. It isn't the appropriate comparison to make here.
- Also notice how the wealthy took advantage of cash loans and created debt to avoid taxation? Debt itself isn't a perfect indicator; you cannot get a complete idea of someone's personal finances with the equation Wealth_2026 = Income_2025 - Debt_2025 because a loan isn't considered income, but the amount you can borrow in a loan is determined in large part by Wealth_2025.
- If you are not a member of the wealthy class, and not currently a part of the middle class, or you think that this future isn't desirable, your deadline to change these things is rapidly approaching or already here.
Hi I made the original comment. After I posted I saw that the thread was a repost and that all the comments were on the original thread. Seeing as the original was already quite old and thinking the repost would not take off I just deleted my comment and moved on. So I was very surprised to see this replied to later. I would undelete it if I could.
Well I can reply back anyway. You gave a very detailed description on how wealth inequality appears and you explained a lot of basic economic theory. It's a great comment but I don't think we actually disagree. My point is not that wealth inequality is a non-issue. Of course it's a huge issue. But these headlines which say that the top x% has as much wealth as the bottom x% are close to meaningless for two reasons. One is that a huge amount of people have 0 wealth without necessarily being poor or having a low standard of living. This can be because of having student loans or from voluntarily not saving. It can also be people who are too young to have meaningfully saved anything. How many of these people with zero or close to zero wealth are actually poor? I don't know so these metrics don't say anything to me. Say 20% of the world population has 0 or negative wealth. Then I can say that the homeless man with 1 dollar in his pocket has more wealth than the bottom 20% of the world population. Would be a true statement but ultimately meaningless.
As income inequality is the true source of wealth inequality I prefer discussions about that. But if wealth inequality specifically is to be discussed, which it has all right to be, then a metric like the "top x% wealthiest own x% of the world wealth" is much preferable. A metric like that is actually understandable immediately and says much more about how unequal the wealth distribution is. The metric in this headline I see as sensationalism.
Oh and by the way land can absolutely be both rented out and sold. In many countries renting land is the main way to expand your farm as owners seldom want to sell their land. I work in agriculture so I often give agricultural analogies. Sorry if it wasn't easy to understand. Though I admit I don't know the specifics in Laos.
Thanks for replying! I see what you mean. I've thought very lightly about the metric you proposed and I do think it would work.
I'm from SEA and have family who work in agriculture, and I hadn't heard of renting out arable land being a popular practice. But I have no idea about common practices in other countries.
Very curious about the deleted comment that inspired this response.
It wasn't anything special. Just someone saying they didn't understand why people share wealth inequality statistics when the real problem is income inequality, and that wealth is just income - debt. They gave some examples of Dave the Renter who may earn a high income but spends it all on "slop" and therefore has 0 wealth, and a Laotian farmer who by nature of owning their farm is wealthy but doesn't purchase much.
I almost downvoted it and left but I'm trying to unlearn bad habits from a previous website and give people the benefit of being open to disagreeing comments.
Wonder if there's a way to force all outstanding Treasury notes outside of the country to need to return back to treasury for renewal or otherwise be written off at invalid debt.
Not while the people running the USA are the same people who hide their immense wealth overseas.
Given the last Panama paper and similar leaks it’s much broader than USA :(
It’s a global class issue.
When Ukraine ousted their previous dictator, the Planet Money podcast had a piece on how the Ukrainian presidential palace had been effectively looted, and traced the absurdly long chain of shell companies that kept the actual owner obscured.
Also, the Vox/Netflix documentary series “Explained” had a genuinely good episode about billionaires. One of the things they brought up was that oligarchs store a lot of money in US real estate, like super-expensive NY condos.
It was nearly a decade ago when I saw this, but there was a documentary, I think it was called The Spider's Web or something like that.
Basically it was about shell companies and "trusts," mostly centered in the Virgin Islands, where billionaires were keeping their real wealth obscured in off-shore banks.
It was mostly focused on wealthy Brits who derived their generational wealth from colonialism. It was pretty interesting though.
The guy was doing some investigative journalism, but obviously he wasn't let into any of the buildings, and once he started to attract notice he started receiving threats and stuff. But he traced money trails backwards and they basically never led to individual people who could be held accountable for the money or how it was used.
Looking back now, I wonder how much of Epstein's wealth was in those banks...
This book is good too. Started in Boston and part of why America even exists as a country.
Oh yeah, I just mean academically. We would need to be on a much different anti oligarchy footing to actually implement. But in the meantime, I like to noodle out systems and mechanisms.
Let's say we eventually get to a renewed trust buster energy like we used the last time we broke up the corporate giants long ago.
Is there anything we could realistically do even with full control of the government, or is that money basically propping up the entire interconnected world economy?
We need a global solution. The scale of economic power is larger than the scale of our democratically controlled political power. Nationalism won't save us.
Well you got to work ontologically. A nation is a system with existing controls. And national control is already dicey at best. Implementing a direct solution at the international level would require a system that to my knowledge doesn't even exists. We treat the UN like an optional club not a world government.
The scale at which we exert political control has been increasing consistently for, approximately, the last 10k years. The rate has been accelerating too. There's no reason to believe that the current hodge podge of 300 or so regional factions (nations) is the natural or final solution, and every reason to expect that political/economic power will escalate to the global level, and soon.
We should be focused on ensuring that transition is peaceful and collaborative, that the solution we converge on is fair and sustainable. We should especially be concerned with preventing that transition from being a dominance play by the players currently holding the greatest defacto power (i.e., economic, transnational corporations, and military, the USA).
One major impediment to this is the idea that all we---the ordinary people all over the world---can do is fight amongst each other at a national level about relatively trivial social issues (i.e., by voting for the marginally less bad alternative in our national elections). We can, and should, organise and strive for a democratic, fair, well-designed global political system that keeps economic power in check.
Other major impediments are the lies that a) the only alternative to the current system is totalitarian communism, or other 19th century political models, and b) that we---you and I---need to have a perfect solution in hand already. We can demand, via our respective nations, that the world's best minds come together and design the best system possible, and that was transition to that system peacefully and rationally.
Ah... So if I'm reading you right, you're saying:
Yes, no system currently accounts for what we NEED it to do. So the most DIRECT solution would be to create a new movement, a new SYSTEM of people, control, and influence that transcends existing abstractions like nationalities, race, culture, and have this ontologically encompassing system implement that change from its larger frame of reference.
I like that. I hadn't considered that approach and it's probably right on the money. I think the first step is recognition of the issue and the need for such a movement. As such... Have you thought about names?
Something you would call such an endeavor, or movement, or coalition. Something that would be instantly recognizable as to what the goal or at least spirit or attitude behind it would be? Probably seems like a silly thing to fixate on this early, but sometimes the right name is a powerful tool.

Lol.
I actually agree with most of your statement, except for "DIRECT". That's not part of my claim, and it shouldn't be a goal of yours.
The terrain has been rigged so that all the direct, the locally advantageous, locally practical solutions lead back to the same toxic equilibrium. We are stuck in a historical basin of attraction and need to escape it.
The only long-term stable/viable solution, the only solution that honours our responsibility to future generations, is to avoid the immediate direct solutions, the ones that the manipulated incentive structures are set up to anticipate, and to do what you described. I'm not claiming it's easy, or likely to happen, merely that it's our only chance to save our species from itself.
The problem is that most of these assets are digitally held. What we need is an anonymous type attack against these accounts, similar in style to what they did in Mr. Robot.
Make it near impossible for the government to claw the money back.
If you write off Treasury notes we have to either accept that MMT is real and that we can print money when needed.
Or we'd need to destroy an equal amount of money to the treasury note.
Or if MMT isn't accurate (unlikely) then we'd see inflation as the government would effectively be unsecuring it's debts.
Well could we somehow do it via serial number on the notes maybe? Like let's say we use the event to denote a switch to color money instead of green only. And then we say in 10 years, all green money is expired and worthless, so every note has to come back into the Treasury to get renewed, and at that time be potentially subjected to repatriation taxes.
Think something like that could work?
0.1% still equates to 8.1m people; instead, if we we’re to focus focus on the Top 1%, of the Top 1% of the Top 1% - that is only ~8,100 people.
Holding their feet to the fire, and getting them to co tribute their fair share - despite their dragon’s hoard of wealth - would quickly bring those below them with less wealth in line.
e.g. Make an example out of Elon Musk, and the Ellison’s would quickly fall in line.
Nah, I put that argument in the same camp as “if you tax them, they will move” in New York; pure bluster and ultimately an empty threat of Mutually Assured Destruction.
If a billionaire takes out a loan against their stock portfolio (as they so often do); force that to be treated as a Capital Gains taxable event. L
For real. If they aren't paying in, who cares if they leave wherever they are threatening to leave anyway. Just go, don't let the trickle hit you in the economics on the way out
Lmao, so this is fully excluding the official "net worth". Just a handful of trillions here and there
But still to manny ordinary people rage out when higher taxes for billionaires are discussed.
8.2 billion people, so 0.1% of that is 8.2 million people
2.83 trillion dollars held in accounts to evade taxes means that approximately $345,000 per person is held in accounts offshore.
That seems low, in a way. I expected it to be in the dozens of millions per person. It's also possible that my math is wrong.
I think it's 0.1% of wealth owning households, which would be closer to $1.42 million.
That would also mean the richest 0.01% are close to $8.85 million each.
Assuming 2 billion households, this is rough math.
The 0.01 holds 1.77 trillion so the distribution is skewed. Furthermore there are likely many thousands of accounts in the 'small' amounts of tens of thousands, ostensibly for every member of an extended family in things like trust funds, etc.
Yep, these people definitely have some sort of disease. No one needs nor would be able to spend that kind of money. Just completely insane.
It’s LITERALLY just 16 families. Far fewer people than .1 percent. It’s 2 ten millionths of one percent.
If it's off the books, why dont the people holding it just take the bag and run?
If America has a major revolution, I suspect many of the financial assets would turn out to be smoke and mirrors, rather than something of concrete value.
3.55 trillion in untaxed wealth
Say you taxed them 50% of their unrealized gains, and assuming 50% of it was to the US, what percent of the US deficit could be paid?
I'd guess around 2-3%?
This really needs to be reported on more. I wonder how many people are even aware of the warehouses housing enormous collections of art that is basically just transferred from rich person to rich person as a tax-free savings/investment vehicle.

all 22 comments