I left when they blocked third-party APIs to force people to use their app
post
Reddit shadow banned my account for posting this diy candle idea on witches vs patriarchy. They won’t respond so I guess I’m barred from participating forever.

Been here since the Reddit API shutdown in July of 2023.
Gees was that 18 months ago?
Lemmy is a federated clone of Reddit, and Reddit has more users, so most likely, everyone here has either rejected Reddit, or been banned by Reddit, or they are using both platforms at once to reach a bigger audience.
I am here because I was very dissatisfied with Reddit's administration and moderation and with the way they screwed app devs.
I'm concerned that Lemmy uses the same basic moderation techniques as Reddit, and so it could fall into the same ruin as Reddit. But for now, the moderators I've interacted with here have been straight up legit good people. So I stick around.
me too, i hope it doesnt become like the same thing it swore to be an alternative too
I opened my first account in 2012 and I used it for the rest of the decade, then reddit went to shit and I went through another three accounts only lasting several months each for I gave up. Sometimes I still want to go back but everything I see suggests that would be a mistake.
thier recent filters and AI moderation makes it hard to say what you want on there.
I'm not banned, but I'm here because Reddit essentially in active decay. It's old. All the community names are taken. Some taken years ago. The site is too big to be effectively maintained by admins, leaving many communities badly-run, half-abandoned and being swamped by bots, trolls and whatever else. You can't grow anything there.
You can on the Fediverse. Community discoverability is by far much better on here, and the federated structure of it means that no-one can camp on communities to stop others from making it. You can just be replaced by someone else if you run it poorly.
There are many other problems too such as the site using AI to ban people, buggy notification system etc.
most of its bots anyways, outside of niche communties, most of the post are more less talking about trump, or trump adjacent in some form another, the only problem with that you are more likely to get astroturfed there.
naaah reddit works fine and many well modded communities are thriving
lemmy on the other hand is slowly losing users
i use old.reddit.com and RedReader. no ads, all free
10+ years on Reddit. Never banned on any subreddit or Reddit itself, ever. First came here during the 2023 API controversy. Went back to Reddit since the anime community was pretty small here, and I could still use my own API key for 3rd party apps.
Came back to Lemmy a week or two ago due to this bullshit. I'm not affected yet as I still have my own API key, so I'll be hopping back and forth between Reddit and Lemmy. But I know my time on Reddit is limited.
I just hope Lemmy and the rest of the Fediverse is polished up by the time of the next Reddit exodus. But based on the most recent API change, I think Reddit has learned to make smaller changes over long periods of time over one major change that angers everyone all at once.
yea i noticed that too, reddit did multiple massive purges this year alone all the way from election day. they saw to many people being purged, so now they make smaller background moderations. like deleting comments/posts unilateraly, shadowbanning instead.
im not surprised that reddit had to replace IRL engagement with fake bots posts.
The day the API changes went into effect, I logged in here and never looked back.
as soon as reddit went public is when shit starts to hit the fan, spez was and is more susceptible to outside pressure, like from MUSK complaining, thats actually what triggered the purges this year.
There are purges this year?
Big Time.
I got banned a couple of months ago over a metaphorically framed post. Was recenly talking to a co worker who's gotten back into No Man's Sky since the last update that added ship building and he hit the NMS sub on Reddit looking for help and was shocked to see how many posts and users had been deleted - from a decidedly non-political sub with some of the lowest drama out of all the gaming ones.
Reddit seems to be purging the oldest members with over a decade of being on the site the most aggressively.
Also, I tried to delete my account and it would not do it. So it seems it's banning users but not removing the accounts as some way to pad the site's user base numbers.
I had a hell of a time getting my unarchived posts deleted. The site kept kicking me out and refusing to let me at my posts and comments. Took me logging in with different computers to get everything I could delete, removed.
They are definitely gaming numbers and hoarding user's data.
Bad form, that.
Not me, I'm here since the reddit API disaster, and Lemmy is my replacement for reddit. I deleted my reddit account. I'm happy to have left. I feel like this is a nicer place. Healthier discussions. Calm. Not as much heated name calling.
Although some people have been rather rude as of late, so I try to remind them of how to act. But obviously there will be people who are still going to be assholes for no reason.
Everything you said is how I feel. I was enjoying reddit until the Brexit referendum, which was when it felt like it got taken over by the alt right. When the API thing came, I realised that money was the only thing that mattered and they were selling my discussion space to whoever would spend, and the alt right was spending big. We didn't matter, so like you, I left.
I was delighted to find people talking again here on lemmy.
Chiming in to say: same, though it took a step further for me before I quit in disgust. I was ready to accept the api costs argument in good faith until I learned that a dev could not make a reddit client that would use my own api token. Which meant they didn't (only) care about the api load, they care about ensuring that I see as many ads instead of posts that they can get away with.
Sadly, Google worsening their search results to juice their own (ad) numbers not long afterwards led to the general public learning about searching Reddit as a way to land on actual human-vetted info. Just as the core user base splintered and left in greater numbers than ever before, a tidal wave of new users joined and enthusiastically picked up the torch – without even realizing what they were contributing to.
i dont report people here, only rarely. on reddit i did alot because of so many misinformation, and trolls, and that ended up rubbed me the wrong way since reporting is a double edge sword on there,sometimes it works to get that troll off the sub, but sometimes the report, if the MOds dont agree with it you can get banned if they think your report doesnt actually have any violaiton on the reported.
I've reported a couple people recently. One person got banned from a community, which was rewarding. They were telling people left and right to kill themselves and shit.
But yeah that situation is not nice. A report shouldn't take in you getting banned, unless they find out you were the antagonist somehow. Reporting in itself shouldn't be considered abuse unless it happens very frequently by the same person. My two cents.
I wasn't banned, I just hate the official app and the overwhelming number of bots and ads. So I gave it up, and Lemmy fills that commenting niche for me. My account is still live on reddit, though. There's like 12 years of old comments and sometimes I like reading through them to see how stupid I used to be.
I have been working through deleting reddit comments. Then reddit repopulates them because they are hit by a Google search. So so I go through and delete them again.
When reddit blocked my favorite mobile app, I bailed. So I am now on connect for Lemmy. It works almost seemlessly now with a few bugs. It's basically the same user experience as the old Tapatalk for forums that they made almost 20 years ago now. A good user interface is a good userinterface.
I never bothered deleting any of my comments, but my understanding was that the best way to get rid of them was to use a script to automatically edit the text content to some static message like "This comment has been removed by the user in protest."
Can't do it if banned sadly, deleting posts just removed your name
left when reddit went public. nothing good happens when you have to answer to stockholders….
I left when they fucked over 3rd party apps.
Here since deleting Reddit post history at the time of 3rd party app api. I only go back (via RedLib) for niche communities.
Used to love Reddit but the drop in quality over there is shocking, the same shit reposted ad nauseum & bots galore. Much prefer it here, though still hoping niche communities will grow & become sustainable.
A small number of communities here have got a foothold & i find them better than the Reddit equivalents dispite far fewer posts so there's hope.
Yeah reddit has a lot of reposting, wich for some things i actually like, for example shitpost wich i think Is lacking here but It Will Just drop the quality here.
Yeah here its much smaller than reddit and i like It since i think It Will happen that you encounter the same people over and over again and i find that very funny
Yeah man…I was fully addicted to Reddit for years until quoting Worf from Star Trek got me a 3 day autoban.
I reflected at how much of the “content” was automated: any major sub had countless accounts posting nonsense to promote themselves, a product, a YouTube channel, a blog. It’s become the definition of enshitification.
I deleted my account and the app before the autoban expired…not looking back.
Like many others, my journey was Digg --> Reddit --> Lemmy.
Hopefully the federated design of Lemmy means I never have to update the graphic above.
Isn't everyone on here as an alternative to reddit?
You could consider the question of whether there is still something about reddit that you value. Seeking an alternative usually means you're trying to fulfill a value or need the previous option provided. While that was true when i first landed on Lemmy there's simply nothing i value about reddit anymore. So i no longer consider it an alternative.
There's also the alternative motive of valuing/supporting FOSS/federation.
Reddit has become unusable for me at this point. I will see 2-3 posts from my local subreddits and then everything else is "because you've shown interest in a similar community" of random cities I've never been to/ never will visit. It also won't stop showing me trainwrecks. I don't look for this content, and I mute every community it promotes and as someone who commutes by train everyday I really don't want to see that shit.
Not banned. I just like the idea of the fediverse. And also to have more "real people" in the comments.
I got banned, for evading a ban. (I didn't know I was banned, was just using one of my 3 alts for different hobbies and made a comment, instantly banned all 3, no appeals)
If you are banned from a sub they leave traps I guess? Instead of not showing me the sub on my front page or not letting me comment, they leave it up to catch people "evading bans."
Publicfreakout btw, no idea how I got banned from there, was just commenting on the front page to get karma up on the alt for my blender stuff with my content creator name.
That’s really what it feels like. Like…they have all this technology that associates multiple accounts with one person…but they don’t give you heads up even if they know damn well you’re the same person.
There must be some function of alternate accounts that benefits Reddit in some way.
thats what happen to alot of people. if you had a old ban, and you commented in a newer sub like years later, the recent purges just look at all your accounts that ever participated in it,(for example something you were ban in r/tech, r/news and you had old accounts that visited those subs but not ban, they were going after that too) and ban all of them. they never did this unless you were a serial ban evader. the theory goes around is that they want a read only site, people will just doom scroll on ads and propaganda all day.
Oh man…awhile back that happened to me: I complained to a mod in PM about racist posts in their sub - on my desktop account…then used the app on my smartphone because I wasn’t at home. It was different accounts because I’d forgotten my password at some point…but I didn’t actually care which account was what - I never cared about Karma and didn’t differentiate between them.
Little did I know the petty mod had given me a one-day ban for “harassment”…and both accounts got banned for “evading”. Back then Reddit admins weren’t swamped (I guess?) and the ban was overturned right away.
I think if that happened today it would have been an automatic autoban. It really feels like a set up. Why are they letting you have multiple accounts if they associate them with one person? What it feels like is Reddit given scammers tools that end up fucking over normal people.
Yep, if this is an issue, and they don't want alts, why can you swap and login to multiple accounts in the app. They made it very easy and convenient to do lol.
Yeah. The way it seems to function is Reddit itself has automated moderating…and the mods have almost absolute control over their own subs. Reddit itself doesn’t check for ban evasion…unless a mod requests it….so the sub mods have another layer of moderation that activates additional automated moderation. The very obvious problem with this is that too many mods are petty little dictators and know how to exploit the automated moderation system: ie there’s nothing preventing mods from taking note that a person uses two accounts, ban the account that person is not using when they want to prep for a site ban - then trigger the autoban to get rid of a user. The bans some subs give out are always horribly uneven…and now I see why. I’ve seen this scenario play out several times due to ideology or personal grudges, rather than the breaking of Reddit rules.
Short story long…”ban evasion” appears to be a gift given to sub mods to use at their pleasure.
R-word emigrant, checking in.
I think social media should not be connected to big tech billionaries. Call me crazy. :)
I was using Reddit Sync. When the API nonsense went down, the Dev announced that they were switching to Lemmy. I've stayed on the app and now feel like I'm part of a much richer community. I'm glad to be here.
Same. I just wish there were more niche communities.
I joined when Apollo for reddit died.
Ever since Apollo shut the doors I’ve not had a user there. I still keep tabs on a few communities that don’t really have a presence here, but only lurking, no participation.
I'm totally banned so here we are.
Was perma banned in Reddit a few years ago for discussing ACA compliance. I saw it coming for awhile, the any comment I made no matter how inauspicious was flagged over the course of a few weeks.
After banning I was unable to post on any of my accounts. But I could change prior comments so I used an app to generate AI gibberish and replace years of comments and participation with AI bullshit to salt the earth for Reddit.
Before you leave I recommend doing the same.
Fuck spez the 2023 canvas was the last time i used a account over there and when a search engine leads me there it makes me sick to see the new ui and overall culture.
Lemmy is lacking content badly, but noway I'm going back there.
I can’t straight up “quit Reddit” for Lemmy yet. There’s not enough of the content I want to see here, yet.
A while after Reddit practically blocked the Apollo app, I realized just how much I loved that app. It was the perfect Reddit interface. Not long after, I discovered how great Voyager did of replacing the experience, and that’s what ultimately brought me here “permanently.”
So, Reddit has lost browsing time from me big time, and that time is now shared with Lemmy.
Also, I love a good Rust project 🦀

top 98 comments