Without reading I can give a most likely answer: money. If the job is exhausting and dangerous but pays a tenth of what middle management makes, which is a tenth of what the CEO makes, then I think we might have the reason.
post
Without reading, I'm just going to guess most of it has to do with low wages.
I’m not a big financial expert and I haven’t read the article but the answer is most likely: the pay is shit.
They don't want to train anyone. Same story as always. They won't invest in their workers.
When people say it's about Money, specifically, it is about Profit. They are making obscene profits, and they can't sacrifice one single penny of it; in fact, they have to have even more of it. They can't continue to exist without a constant stream of ever increasing profits, to hear them tell it.
The Federal Minimum Wage has been increased only twice since 1997 for a total of $2.10. It has been at $7.25 since 2009. When people demand an increase in the minimum wage, there are only two outcomes expected from it - higher prices, or lost jobs, and it is always presented as if those are the ONLY two options available. It never occurs to anyone to perhaps demand that corporations should MAKE LESS PROFIT.
That profit should go back to the workers who actually EARNED that profit through their sweat equity. The argument that they already earn enough doesn't wash when employed people are living in their cars as a housing choice. Push those sorts of lifestyle compromises long enough, and they become normalized. Someday soon, we'll have celebrities on TV talk shows going on about how they lived in their car for the first few years they were in town, and it was AWESOME!
Since Covid, Transnational Corporations and their Sociopathic Oligarch owners have reset the costs of living in America, raising prices on everything, without any adjustment on the compensation for labor side.
We've been screwed since Congress redrew the Tax Code in 1974, which baked Trickle Down Economics into the tax code. Ever since then, more and more money is transferred from the middle/working classes to the wealthy. They've been stealing from us for decades, and they just want to keep doing it.
The median salary of $43K in 1975 has increased to only $50K today, while they would have been making $92K if the tax code hadn't been steadily re-written to enrich the wealthy at the cost of the middle class and poor.
In that same time period, the mean income for the top 1% went from $289K to $1.384 million, while they would have been making $630K under the old tax codes.
Thats a 17.4% increase in the lower median, and an increase of 321.6% in the 1% median. Clearly there has been an upwards distribution of wealth at the expense of the middle class since the tax codes started to be re-written in 1974 to favor the top economic tier.
Read more about it :
New York Mag: http://nymag.com/intelligencer/amp/2020/09/rand-study-how-high-is-inequality-us.html
Fast Money: https://www.fastcompany.com/90550015/we-were-shocked-rand-study-uncovers-massive-income-shift-to-the-top-1
For those of you unwilling to actually read the article, it's not money.
The pool of blue-collar workers who are able and willing to perform tasks on a factory floor in the United States is shrinking. As baby boomers retire, few young people are lining up to take their place.
...
For some companies, remaining globally competitive involves the use of sophisticated equipment that requires employees to have extensive training and familiarity with software. And employers cannot simply hire people right out of high school without providing specialized training programs to bring them up to speed.
...
“We spent three generations telling everybody that if they didn’t go to college, they are a loser,” he said. “Now we are paying for it. We still need people to use their hands.”
...
The country is flooded with college graduates who can’t find jobs that match their education
...
The Trump administration’s aggressive cuts to training programs for blue-collar workers have also hurt efforts to train a new generation of factory workers.
It's money. Companies don't want to pay people to train them. They want to hire people already trained.
Someone has to spend the money to train people. Company, government, or person.
People did what they were told. They paid money for college training. Not company training.
And employers cannot simply hire people right out of high school without providing specialized training programs to bring them up to speed.
It is 100% money. You are so close to seeing the point with this sentence. If the factory owners paid for specialized training programs for new hires, then they would have specialized employees who can do the job. They are neither willing to invest money in new people, stubbornly insisting that people already come fully trained, but also not willing to appropriately compensate those who are both trained and willing to put their bodies at risk on a factory floor.
it is always money. this is how labor works. need training? pay for it. need me to be trained before hiring? make it affordable. again: money.
This is why I make it abundantly clear to people who ask me about my college choices that i am going to college to LEARN - not for job training. I am willing to pay money to people to teach me new things. I am NOT willing to pay money to get trained to do a job for someone else.
I shouldn't have to pay for training, let the evil overlords sacrifice a pittance and also pay well. Otherwise, detail cars, clean houses, mow lawns. Tell evil people "bye!"
"this job requires specialized training we're not willing to provide" is the same management failure as "the wages offered for this job are not sufficient to attract workers."
Raise the latter, and give the former with a reduced wage for a set number of years.
They also mention that they’re physically demanding jobs with inflexible schedules.
Even if I had the training I’d still want way more to have to leave my house and put on pants to potentially get injured, either acutely or chronically.
That's a lot of down votes for the truth
Yeah, well, dog-piling is Lemmy's whole thing. Especially when someone points out that there are much more specific factors to blame besides "capitalism bad".
Fabrication companies don't (always ‡) pay for your welding certification, hospitals don't pay for doctors to go to med school, software companies don't pay for your CS degree, HVAC techs don't train you straight off the street, etc. People forget trade schools are a thing / alternative to college degrees and that you're expected to take those paths yourself. Even apprenticeships expect you to have at least some background as to not waste time on you, unless they're just super desperate.
But no, everything that ails you has to boil down to "capitalism bad" even if that's as technically true as "breathing oxygen eventually leads to death".
‡ It's not unheard of for them to pay for that certification (I can speak for at least one instance), but it's definitely not the norm.
They’ve tried everything but paying more.
No, no, they've paid more. The board just approved a 20% pay bump to the CEO for dropping labor costs over the last fiscal year. Told him "there's more where that came from" once he can figure out how to fill the staffing shortages.
It's really not more complicated than "the pay isnt enough." If you can't compete with McDonald's or Home Depot, you're not looking for workers, you're looking for victims.
I would be reluctant to take a factory job, even if it paid more than my college educated job. You are more than likely going to be forced to move to the middle of nowhere to develop hyper-specific skills. Once the company decides they had a bad quarter, they're going to lay you off and you'll face moving away entirely again to find another job. And you'd better hope you were performing tasks with transferable skills, otherwise the next factory is going to start you off on the same five or ten year cycle of working for raises and better positions before it happens all over again.
The modern boom-bust-layoff cycle tells me that I should never invest in a company, because nobody is offering guarantees and they are especially not offering contracts. And if they do, there's no way it'll be for my benefit.
With my college education, I at least know I have transferable skills and have been able to pick an industry I actually enjoy, instead of settling for what was nearby or available.
all 52 comments