And before you know it, Android will no longer be open source for “security” reasons.
post
So like what mobile OS is there now? Graphene which itself is forked from Android? Like we have barely made it to 20 years with this tech and its locked the fuck up with no options for the people. Boutta be using a dumbphone for sure.
There's still a surprising amount of devices made by HMD (who own Nokia's consumer phone brand, so you'll sometimes see them as Nokias) that run Series 30+ (think old Nokia software with some very slight modern enhancements) but have 4G hardware to play ball on modern networks.
If you want a half functioning phone I've seen something called PostmarketOS. Seems nice and barely working
I really want PostmarketOS to succeed, even to be good enough as a secondary device. The long term support and software flexibility seems so promising, but it is still nowhere near ready for most people.
There are Linux Mobile OSs making promising developments, like KDE-Mobile. I'm planning on tossing it on a second-device, just to test it for myself.
Graphene is not a fork. They just harden the code published by Google. This is why the recent changes by Google have been causing them more work.
Stop calling this sideloading, it's just installing software on a computer. The term makes it an easy 'other' to be distrusted. And this concerns all apps not just apps coming from a different app store. Google wants to control all the apps you're allowed to install by them
And we have to pay for this? I thought it would be free. What a scam.
problem is that you can fork android or make a new linux based os but with manufacturers continuing to lock down bootloaders, good luck getting it on there without making a deal with a phone manufacturer.
At this point I think the only thing that may save Google is Larry and Sergey firing Sundar and hitting the reset. Google has been consistently doing the wrong thing for a long time.
I read their justifications but I must've missed the part where it justifies anything.
Google calculating:
- no more sideloading, so the privacy and pro freedom people will buy our phones for GrapheneOS
Oh, is this gonna put the kibosh on the Vanced series of apps?
Imagine Microsoft forcing all application developers to send them their ID for approval before users are allowed to install their application on Windows.
Sounds absurd, right?
But Google doing the exact same thing on Android? I wonder how this is not downright illegal. Why is there even a discussion about this?
The correct term is “installing” btw. Not “sideloading”. “Sideloading” is corporate speech for framing the installation of applications outside their walled garden as something shady/illegal/questionable.
You wouldn’t call it “sideloading” when installing an application on your desktop or laptop computer, why call it “sideloading” when installing an application on your pocket computer?
Notice how MS has been aggressively been pushing their app store and xbox live, more with each update to the OS.
Now consider that Win12 will probably come out in a year or so.
It's gonna be the same shit as what Google is doing.
Actually, I'd argue that google isn't banning sideloading apps, but it is banning installing them.
IIRC they will still let you do adb install from a PC (which I would say can be reasonably called sideloading, since you're pushing the app in from an external device), but banning installing unsigned apks from the device itself (which I agree is silly to call sideloading).
all 33 comments