Google loves to benefit from open source when it benefits them and when they control everything. But, it’s all just a ruse.
post
IMHO GrapheneOS was a on borrowed time from the start, because Google was always going to lock its platform down. A lot of smart people spent a lot of time & effort on a corporate monopoly platform. I wish that time had been spent building a truly independent one.
the fact is that even without grapheneos, Google pixels are the most secure devices you can buy because of the titan chip. graphene's ultimate goal is security. Motorola had to seriously up their device security to be compatible with GOS at the point of matching the pixel. that being said it doesn't matter anyways if legitimately nobody can use it now regardless. but I'm sure it will be fought in court so we will see.
AOSP is open source and Google's main form of control over the market (you are not allowed to ship devices with forks, if you want your device certified "Android" / have access to Play Store) was stopped in 2018. Graphene has a deal with a vendor, so they're in a good position.
I'm glad now that I've made the switch to graphene and I hope that they have enough money and connections to push this through a system captured by their adversaries -- they're definitely going to need it.
Could this be anti-competative behaviour in EU?
without a doubt. unfortunately theyve already been sued for this and the ruling has changed nothing. they'll keep getting away with it and the EU will keep pretending to care.
It's also anticompetitive behavior in the US, if only our government would enforce it's existing laws.
No doubt the "0.1% of their yearly profits just from their EU operations" fine that they might, possibly, have to pay after a process that takes 10+ years (in between regulators actually getting around to doing something and it being appealed in Court all the way to the limit), is already seen as just the cost of doing business and accounted into their ROI calculations.
Precisely this. When Graphene OS wins against Google in court their status will be of the brave has beens that lost battle on real ground while they get consolation prize 10 years too late.
In EU it's up to 10% of the company group’s worldwide annual turnover from the preceding business year and/or prison time for the CEO/responsible person at highest rank. Wdym only 0.1%? Wdym profit?
Up to.
10% of turnover has never happenned.
If I'm not mistaken for a large company it has never exceed 1% and nobody ever ended up in jail.
Go check the size of the fines large American tech companies have got so far - I don't think any one has exceeded 1 week worth of their European profits.
Further, check how many EU Commissioners and EU Parliament members ended up leaving their seats in the EU directly to work in very well paid positions in a large American Tech company.
The Law is there, the Will is not.
America, we need you to do a Standard Oil on these motherfuckers
Good luck with that, Google huddles up hard to those in power.
Standard oil didn't help America spy on the governments, top corporations and citizens of most of the world. Google isn't going anywhere due to its cooperation and its illegal monopoly activities only help the US government lean on it to do their spying and bidding for them or else they might pursue them.
Fucking Google.
We're very interested in talking to @AGToddBlanche

A real Linux phone is the only real solution for the surveillance, shamelless wholesale privacy violations and state-backdoors problem in smartphones, IMHO.
I love the idea of a Linux phone, I'm not against it, but GrapheneOS already exists, and all it needs is hardware to not be dicks, which a real Linux phone also needs.
If there was one hardware manufacturer that could just put out a respectable handset that wasn't actively trying to sabotage some kind of community effort, I think it would be a great boon to both Linux phones and GOS users alike.
I think it's fairer to say that Graphene OS makers AND Hardware makers are both being dicks.
If either side conceded I bet Graphene OS would be far more prevalent, even if it had to be "Graphene OS Basic" rather than the full maximum security version.
How is having hardware requirements being "dicks"? The whole point of GrapheneOS is privacy and security is important for strong privacy. Lowering our standards doesn't help the project or our users. Having a less secure version of the OS would effectively mean a lot more work for a worse OS. We'd need to hire a lot more people to support that additional OS as well as all the new devices we'd support. It just doesn't make sense.
It only doesn't make sense if you're taking A SIDE.
For anybody looking at it from the outside, the objective of smartphones freed of big-corporation controlled OS is being blocked BOTH by GrapheneOS refusing to have a version of their OS that works without very specific hardware that's only needed for highly hardenned security AND by phone makers being unwilling to make phones with that hardware.
Either side conceding would solve the problem for the rest of us and any evidence-free claims that it's easier for one side than the other are just bullshit excuses from those taking sides rather than looking at the big picture.
That's not how security works though. There are hardware requirements in order for certain software features to work.
To make a less secure phone in both OS and hardware is more marketable, but it defeats the purpose.
Funny your confident proclamations about how security works or not.
Security isn't an absolute and in fact there is no such thing as absolutely secure - as smart-chip technology long ago showed when attackers started reverse engineering the keys stored in the supposedly secure smart-chip hardware by tracking energy consumption when the chips were using them for encryption or digital signing, even supposedly super secure hardware is only secure against certain kinds of attackers.
(Also don't get me started on techniques involving liquid nitrogen and electron microscopes)
Security is a range and IT Security design is done on the basis of answering the question "secure against which kind of attackers?", which is why banking system security is not the same as blog website security.
So the question is, can GrapheneOS make a system which is secure against external attackers whilst not having specific cryptographic hardware?
Because it would be a big fucking leap forward if your smartphones couldn't be remotely turned into surveillance devices or their contents accessed by Google or by those who can get Google's cryptographic keys for things like software updates (i.e. state actors), and generally the cryptographic hardware is only needed to secure systems against access by people with physical access to the hardware, not against remote access, especially not against the OS maker themselves.
Sure, some people do worry about the likes of the TSU confiscating and cloning their phones at a border entry and latter hacking its contents - and those people should stick to GrapheneOS and whatever the hardware that team things is needed for it to be safe against that - but most people just want their private data to remain private in everyday life, and everyday life for most people does not involve their smartphone being confiscated by the authorities of authoritarian nations like the US.
Would grapheneos basic == lineageos?
GrapheneOS already strips out Google's tracking, and the desktop Linux architecture is worse for security than Android's, though it would definitely be nice to see an independant alternative where Google doesn't control the direction of the base OS of nearly all smartphones except Apple's.
GrapheneOS is severely limited in the devices it can run, plus it's a security-above-all smartphone OS rather than a general consumer OS that's decently secure, respects user's privacy and where owners are the ones that de facto own the device rather than the device being controlled by Google or the hardware maker that customized the OS.
What we need is just smartphones of all kinds and prices shipped by default with a Linux OS for use by common people, in addition to the ultra-secure phone OS for the 1 in a million people who are very security consciencious and know how to choose a compatible smartphone and install that OS themselves in it.
We need a privacy-respecting general consumer OS for smartphones and, given that it demands certain hardware to be present for maximum security in order to support a phone, right now Graphene OS ain't it, IMHO.
Linux in general does have a trajectory and track record of not only being privacy-respecting and de facto under control of the user rather than some external entity, and remaining so even after being used for decades even after reaching a massive market share in some areas (such as server-side), so it seems to me that from that point of view it might be the best option for that. Also judging by how it evolved to become a very capable Desktop OS, I expect it can do the same to become a very respectable Smartphone OS.
What about:
-
- Tails vs. GOS?
-
- Qubes OS vs. GOS?
-
- NixOS with security focus vs. GOS?
You specifically said architecture. Do you mind elaborating on the above 3 specifically?
All three provide differnet improvements however they still are not perfect. Tails relies on an infection being wiped when the system is shut down, Qubes isolates it in seperate virtual machines, and NixOS uses an atomic architecture to freeze the core of the system.
However each is mostly specialied in its one specific thing rather than being secure across the board and being easy for everyday usage.
Secureblue is probably the best secure Linux desktop because it combines kernel hardening, Flatpaks to isolate apps, and an atomic architecture all together, where the weaknesses of just one of those steps are filled in by the other two, and that is of course the case for GrapheneOS which takes Android's architecture and adds hardening.
Yes, however the main problem is not technical. It's politics: governments need to protect citizens against oligopolies.
It's extremely difficult to market unlocked competitive hardware in this market (PinePhone is dead, Fairphone is hardly competitive...), but the main issue is worse: cryptographic lock for identity verification (banking, governments, more and more social networks access and an endlessly growing list). Without that key, your device is basically useless as a daily driver, whatever OS/software you run. Only Google and Apple have that key for most countries, China probably being a sad exception, and the EU Commission wants to have its own to lock down Europeans.
Oh, it's pretty damn obvious what governments should do.
The problem is that this deep in Neoliberalism, governments do not do that and the politicians who should make them do that are so thoroughly bought and paid for by large corporate interest and the ultra wealthy that they will never do that.
Further, it's in the interest of a lot of governments, quite a lot of them supposedly Democratic countries, that the devices that people carry in their pockets are easy to turn into surveillance devices, and that's a lot easier to achieve if those devices are de facto controlled by companies which can be pressured by said governments to cooperate in making it so.
Last but not least, as long as foreign companies dominate Smartphone OSes, even if our own governments elsewhere in the world are under the control of impeccably honest people who are doing all the right things, we are still exposed to the choices of the Governments in the nations were those companies are based, which right now is the US (the greatest shit-show wannabe Democracy around and who have been surveillance mad for over half a century) and the next likely prospect is China which isn't at all better when it comes to not eavesdropping on people and respecting their privacy.
This is why I think a trully open and open source solution controlled by no company is the safest solution, now and quite likely for a long, long time.
Right, but there's no magic wand. An independent, open source device can access only unlocked services: no banking, no public services, no social networks, etc.
That is indeed the greatest problem and very much the core chicken-and-egg part of this situation, similar to what you see in the Desktop between Linux and Windows.
That hasn’t stopped Linux from improving and slowly gaining market share on the Desktop (still small, but it’s now well beyond just ultra-geeks).
As I see it, the whole thing has to start by there being an open hardware platform for smartphones, similar to how PCs are (though Microsoft is trying to close it down under the excuse of “security”). I suspect Linux can only grow in a platform when people can freely and easilly install it, even if the early adopters are always going to be those with higher technical expertise. This means at the very least phones with bootloaders unlocked or easy to unlock (none of the bullshit so common now) and at the very least full documentation for peripherals, ideally the hardware makers actually doing the work of creating the Linux drivers and/or device tree configurations for them.
Maybe the path to that doesn’t go via existing Smartphone makers but actually starts from the Embedded Systems side were Linux is dominant and via Linux in devices such as Tablets and eBook Readers spreads out and eventually also ends in Smartphones. Nowadays there are quite a lot of smartphone makers in China who are cottage size and not at all widelly known in the West, so maybe in the Smartphone worlds we’re quite a lot closer to the situation in PCs where there’s a ton of assemblers out there, than it might seem if all you do is only ever look at big brand names.
That’s why it’s disappointing all the effort going into graphene OS hasn’t been spent building a more independent alternative.
Sure but that’s a pipe dream unfortunately. There’s just no market for it.
I hate Google. This company is mediocre and unfair. Isn’t threatening to shut down Android enough? Are we just their puppets? They collect our data, and now this? Things just keep getting worse. Google wants to screw over everyone who uses Android.
If I could go back, I would’ve bought a phone that came with GrapheneOS instead of using this damn Samsung, Google’s lapdog.
Are we their puppets?
No, we'd be so lucky. A puppet is a capital asset and needs to follow the standard devaluation curve. We're the users. Not even customers or consumers anymore. We're a part of their product, in their minds we're not humans or persons anymore. Just the thing that uses the thing and they're desperately trying to replace us because we push back.
So it’s better to give up and get away from big tech. If I had a PC, I’d already be working on making my Android phone’s operating system more secure. I’d have switched to something safer by now something that doesn’t treat me as an object to collect information from.
Thanks Google for making it a bit easier to degoogle my life since this will be the last Pixel I'll ever own 😊
you're going to switch to motorola?
what will do you do once motorola starts doing it to?
Personally, I'm learning how to write mobile-friendly Linux apps and hoping I can run Linux on my next phone. It's not quite ready for daily driving, but I'm hoping it can get there before I need to upgrade.
I kinda doubt GOS will just shut down if it turns out they can't specialize in Pixel phones from here. They use Pixel because it best allows them to achieve their security goals but I doubt it's entirely out of the question to pivot to other OEMs, especially if Google forces their hand. At least I hope that's the case 🙈
edit: to be clear I'm aware they also partner with Motorola, I just see that as more of a side gig and if they can't work with Pixels going forward they'll have to expand more
not OP,
I'll likely move to hallium, ubports, then once drivers are all ready a full blown nixos on phone. That'll take a while tho
Google’s business side is threatening to revoke android licenses from phones that support GOS - wasn't this what the Microsoft anti trust was about?
My problem with GOS was always that it makes people buy google phones. It feels silly to get away from google by giving google money. Even buying second hand, makes it more attractive for people to buy new pixel phones.
I get the whole uber privacy focus, but that puts smaller manufacturers in a corner, where either they make a ridiculously expensive phone that has the hardware requirements for GOS, or an affordable phone with no GOS.
I am really happy with my Fairphone 6 with e/os. I like to support a smaller manufacturer that cares about fairness in its supply chain and long term affordable reparability. I know hardware wise, my phone isn't as secure as a pixel with GOS, but it's secure enough for me, and most important, private.
Hopefully many many years from now, when I do have to upgrade, I'll likely go with a Jolla phone next. But this is after my current phone is truly dead.
The thing is, the point of GrapheneOS is not to kill off Google per se, it's to target a specified set of security measures. I doubt they would have much problem with Google if they weren't making it harder to achieve that set of measures. So if your #1 priority is hurting Google, then yes, Graphene has perhaps not ever been the move. Might change soon. I'd hope.
Motorola and GOS are working together to make a GOS compatible range of phones. The first one will be a premium model, but we can hope for more affordable options next.
Pixel are the proof that you don't need to be flagship level to support GOS. It cerainly has a cost, but not that high.
And I doubt Google will stop at GOS. They will come after all alternative to Google Android.
The good news here is Google might be going overboard, triggering a massive move to get rid of their control, both from phone makers but from governments also.
One can hope!
Yeah, at least Motorola (Lenovo) don't seem to be a terrible company. Not sure how bad their sourcing and productions pipelines actually are though. As an aside for anyone looking into them, the Motorola that makes phones, and the Motorola that makes survailance equipment and actively supports Israel's military, are two different companies.
For me, besides the privacy component, I prefer to buy from company with fair production practices, and good reparability and long term support. I am willing to sacrifice perfect security in the name of those things.
damn, they have come a long way. i switched from a fairphone 4 to a pixel 9, but if fairphone keeps going the way they're going, i'm gonna switch to whatever they have available when my pixel gives out
Pixels were, until recently, the only devices that we could support. Strong privacy relies on hardware security, so supporting more devices would defeat the whole point.
Manufacturers have approached the project but chose the easier and cheaper route. Does that mean the project should relax its requirements? We don't even support 11th generation Pixels because they don't meet the requirements.
As for /e/OS, I'd look into issues with them. Their director, Duval, has said very concerning things about privacy and security, their OS is regularly behind on updates and is very insecure, their online services have had issues like messing up account IDs and people were getting their data synced to the wrong people's devices, etc. It's a stretch to call /e/OS private.
I think it's a case of making the perfect the enemy of the good. But as a project they can have whatever goals they seem fit. It just means its not for me.
From on what I've seen from e/os, they are at most a few weeks behind, but for me that's good enough from a security standpoint. Would I prefer better, of course. As for the Murena services, I don't use them and don't know about the privacy of it. The OS is private though. There is nothing sending data anywhere built in, and their built in tracker blockers work great.
My priority was to get a phone that was built as ethically as it is possible to build a phone, have cheap and easy reparability, and long term support. Bonus point of it was an European company. What fit my requirements was the Fairphone. The most private OS for it as of now is e/OS. For my requirements, is is private and secure enough. Would I prefer if it were more secure, sure. But it checks the most important boxes for me.
Anyone got a linux phone recommendation for the US? I've looked around a few times and most of the options I see are for Europe.
Not a linux phone per say, but I just ordered the Motorola Signature 27 yesterday on pre-order. It's meant to get here on December 8th and is the first direct partnership between the Graphene team and an android manufacturer besides Google. The price is a little eye watering to some, but it's not subsidized by data harvesting and its a proper flagship device.
12,000 nits peak brightness
512 GB of storage
12 GB RAM
DXOMARK's 2nd overall global camera system
Snapdragon's latest processer
Gorilla glass's top of the line glass front
NOT a glass back 🙌🏼
There's been a ton of pessimism about it from people online talking about how its too expensive for a Motorola or that they won't support the software updates...etc. But they haven't even waited for it to ship before naysaying every potential shortfall. I'm taking a chance on it because they sruck their necks out to support Graphene when no one else has. That means something to me.
Yeah, but the topic at hand is that Google is trying to kill GrapheneOS on any phone.
Admittedly, I'm not well versed in this arena. I'm a tech literate normie by the standard of someone that understands the full architecture of this system, but given that Motorola has announced a partnership with Graphene to support GrapheneOS in the future–that would give them legal standing to sue Google for anticompetitive practices and monopolistic behavior if it targeted Motorola's ability to release phones that support GrapheneOS. And since that lawsuit would be coming from a corporation rather than a citizen or political administration, I feel like it would actually be enforced.
Maybe I'm wrong. I very likely could be, but that's a plausible scenario in my head that could hopefully restrict Google from pressuring OEMs in this manner.
It’s completely reasonable to complain about a phone costing more than 2-3 laptops with equivalent compute power.
You're comparing apples to beef Wellington. They serve two entirely different purposes. I carry my phone around in my pocket at all times. It's not reasonable to carry around and use a laptop in every space. I don't want to pull out a laptop anytime I want to browse the web. That's ignoring the fact that they rely on Wifi, don't have a camera system to capture moments I want to remember, or a form factor that makes it easy to handle.
I love my flx1s: https://furilabs.com/shop/flx1splus/
I wouldn't say it's ready for a "normie" to use, but if you are willing to be a bit patient, and if you like to tinker, it works.
Even with GOS, ice assholes can track people with gsm spoofing.
What we need is to think outside the box, perhaps a thin-client device, with a self-hosted computer at home connected via meshtastic/reticulum.
This setup would even be cheaper, a refurbished mini-pc costs 200, and thin client with other hardware would be at max 300 so a total of 500.
So day to day should be covered by this, and we can carry a dumb phone that is only activated when needed or perhaps we can get voip on the thin client.
All data would be on the personal cloud where security can be better controlled.
Finally Mask off? Googles mask off was already far in the past, with several convictions and high fines behind in the EU. Trying to kill GrapheneOS is only one of many actions.
Is it time to ask Mozilla to come back to FireFox OS? Firefox OS Wiki
I think the repo to is still up and forked.
So how hard would it be to get most of Linux contributors to revoke Google's right to redistribute their code in the Android kernel in retaliation?
what is the option for Graphene then? other than rant on Mastodon.
top 83 comments