I like having the games but if it becomes impossible then so be it. I was using Linux way before wine was particularly useful, proton wasn't even a thought yet. It doesn't really matter.
post
Whoa, there, Adobe. Save your energy. I already had more than enough reasons not to use your products.
Why would Wine be "on board"? They can implement what features they like and abstain from the rest.
That's my thought, wine isn't Windows, its a whiteroomed application right? Not a recompiled of windows source.
Bray says, “The platform reports the state; you own the policy.”
Nice to see microsoft is starting to replace their higher-ups with LLMs.
I don’t understand. If it’s just a flag for apps to check, can’t WINE just spoof it if the user wants?
Also… I have secure boot enabled, and I think that whole list enabled, on my dual boot Linux rig. Works fine.
And if you don’t enable secure boot, Windows stops getting feature updates, which eventually stops security updates, so you’re already kinda screwed without it anyway.
In other words, this headline feels like a nothing burger.
Windows 11 basically requires secure boot already, and if you already have it off, you don’t need it… unless you are like me and discover Windows literally will not update without it.
That's pretty doomery. It's a security check, is secure boot enabled, is this enabled. They're kernel flags at most. If individual apps refuse to run, we'll get mad then at those individual apps if Wine can't figure out a way around it.
It's not a security check; it's a lock-in mechanism, just like Safetynet/Play Integrity.
Microsoft has been wanting to do this sort of thing for decades.
The problem is that these apps likely will work on Linux ... If your system complies. It's part of the embrace, extend, extinguish which may have mutated over the years but never left us. Of course you'll be able to play your anti-cheat games on Linux - if your system meets the ever rising Microsoft established baseline, that is.
read up about measured boot, and how microsoft is already using it. it can be extended to verify the platform, and exclude specific hardware, old bios versions, virtual machines and more.
If individual apps refuse to run, we'll get mad
who "we"? all 200 of us on the whole world or what do you mean? the average person is too busy with scrolling facebook ragebait and tiktok dances to understand their tech and care about complex issues like this.
But how many games do you install from Microsoft. They'll attempt it as that's what a company does.
So I'll be playing my old untainted versions of WarCraft III, SW:EaW, SW:XWA, IL2, and whatever else I'll be able to remember, but for real I mostly don't play games anymore.
Sounds like an opportunity for a tool that fakes such things.
Or, just don't use the garbage apps that require this?
Also, this is where the average user will finally see the objectures of secure boot for Windows - it's to get a phone-like locked-down environment.
There are places where this is useful, say enterprise environments where it's arguably necessary. But for the average user it's just pushing towards you not owning the device in front of you.
I just don't understand why Microsoft does not default to opt-in.
Like, that would be the easiest thing they could do to garner the most good will.
All they would have to do would be to say, "Hey, we are now offering this feature, you can use it if you want to, if you don't, you don't have to do anything."
Literally, if I had the death note, every Microsoft executive would be in it right now, and every new executive right along with them until they hired people who understood consent.
For those that didn't read the story. It's not Windows that would block apps. It's the app author in control on this.
We don't like Linux running our programs. Well make a comparability layer to make our os special. 🙄
all 24 comments