Counter theory: the portion of this scandal where the US administration allegedly ignored it for ~12 months is really bad optics for them. And they are now trying to spin this as "she wasn'treally a spy! It's just a conspiracy theory perpetrated by the left to make us look bad!", in an effort to save face.
post
Can the press now forget this fake 007 bullshit and focus on the fact that this guy broke the law to make billions of profit?
I'm not defending any tradewar laws. I just want the rich to be able to see consequences for their actions. Huang should be in court, not in the tabloids.
The fact is that she illegaly imported massive amount of GPUs into China. Illegaly according to both US and Chinese laws. You don't do that without some connections.
It's a thin line between "Chinese spy" and "Chinese smuggler connected to intelligence services"
The exact same AI bros (see All In Podcast, but not an actual recommendation) insist that Jenen did nothing illegal and he must be put back as CEO in order to KEEP OUR AI ADVANTAGE OVER CHINA. The cognitive dissonance among these types is staggering.
I think it is pretty obvious these guys are more terrified by a tech CEO being topped so quickly and just make any word salad as to why that is bad.
Most people defending the elite are not the temporarily embarrassed billionaires so often brought up, but rather people who believe in the hierarchy, and so believe that the people at the top of the hierarchy deserve to be there.
Tech bro enthusiasts, though, really seem to be much more likely to see themselves as just one good idea or lucky break away from being the next Huang or Musk, and to be much more personally affected by these assholes being exposed to any kind of consequences for their actions.
I don't think China gives a fuck, legally speaking.
It's a crime in Singapore, which is why she was banned.
Yeah, she suddenly had several billions of US dollars to buy these chips for through a fake company, after having been an ordinary wage slave.
They keep saying in the article that he was ousted. He resigned. Maybe he was pressured but they didn’t fire him. Maybe, just maybe, he had an idea about what was going on and thought it best to step down. Maybe he was trying to keep the additional affairs from coming to light. Either way, to say this was somehow the result of a political shift that doesn’t even happen until January reeks of AI bros wanting their boy to come back.
being ousted or resigning is mostly the same when it comes to big corp CEOs. The board ask them to resign and they do since they'll get tons of money anyway.
Listen, I’m not an AI bro who wants America to “win the AI race”. I don’t give a shit about Nvidia (although I wish they’d make consumer graphics cards at reasonable prices again).
But I also wouldn’t put it past Marco Rubio and Trump to pull some shit like this. Trump already admitted he knew about the affair with Alice Huang for a year.
It wouldn’t matter if she was a spy or not. They’d just say some shit. Besides, how easy is it to make that association to the paranoid American public? Everyone from big scary China could be a spy! For some extra racism you make some shitty joke about “shifty eyes” or something.m, and even the right wing of the liberals will eat that shit up. The American public actually has no idea how much they get lied to by their government to manipulate markets and move money.
I’ve seen a lot of memes and heard jokes about the affair(s) but not much, outside of the billionaire oligarch controlled media, about the alleged spy.
The circumvention of the embargo on China and market manipulation through circular financing have drawn a lot more ire.
Forget the spy crap (although it's bad enough, especially for Huang personally - although I don't think the US DOJ would currently go after him, the potential Treason and violation of trade restrictions do not disappear so soon, and different people at the helm might yet try to uphold the law) - a lot more important is the fact that NVidia practically gave money to their clients to make them buy their overflow of silicon, just to make sure prices don't go down. This means all numbers regarding their own revenue are untrustworthy and not representative of reality. Heck, it practically burns money to keep the money coming in and to get rid of overproduction ordered from TSMC.
Has anyone tried to remove all this virtual revenue from their balance sheets and then looked at how this reduced demand would affect prices and therefore the margin?
Edit: https://finance.yahoo.com/markets/stocks/articles/michael-burry-real-nvidia-story-034429855.html talks about this: if financing slows, their commitments towards companies like CoreWeave (they are backstopping them, meaning they will practically pay them to do nothing if they can't find costumers) do not disappear. This discrepancy will directly impact margin.
IMO it might also cause banks to say no to financing any more datacenter deals. A substantial part of NVidias revenue is practically coming out of their own pocket because of a missing costumer base that is willing to pay the prices asked. The income is a gamble, while the obligations are guaranteed. The GPUs bought from NVidia also act as a collateral for loans, meaning the perceived value of these cards are the reason they actually got their loans. If they are valued much too high because of NVidias little games... then the banks now sit on loans that are not secured by anything of value, much like 2008.
There's also the issue with "Zombie Unicorns", startups that are valued above one billion US$, but can't go public to cash out because their valuation would not survive contact with the market, and the AI market is full of these - any investment made in the hopes of cashing out at the IPO might just not realize any gains because the potential payout is less than the investment + interest rate (Here the high inflation also comes into play). It is not clear yet which of those or how many might be undead (I think it is a sizable amount - there's not enough income for all of them available, especially since they all sell somewhat the same with some modifications). Any respectable bank should try to minimize the impact of these facts on themselves.
IT DOESN'T MATTER IF THIS PERSON IS A SPY. His affair exposed him to kompromat regardless if his paramour was working for China or not. He also lied to Nvidia execs about his behavior. That's proof he knew that his behavior could harm him. His rapid fall is proof that this affair was a threat to his standing and reputation and that anyone threatening to leak it would have had great influence.
Huang still cheated on his wife with at least three women, call me old fashioned, but that calls your judgement and character into serious question.
Judgement and character? You know he was a CEO right? 😄 Are they expected or required to have either? Isn't their sole function to be marketeers and sellrats* to investors and the sweaty masses?
"Great men are almost always bad men" (Lord Acton ~1905; and Shelly nearly a century before) is as true today as it was then.
And he's a guy who advertised to the world with his wardrobe choices that he's a teenager living in the Miami Vice era.
But despite what I've said, I don't disagree. We have the system (and people) we incentivise for - that's Economics 101.
*A salesperson reference from a Peter F. Hamilton sci-fi series.
Why is everyone trying to wash this guys reputation? Doesn’t matter if she was officially a spy or not. He still skirted export controls and shipped chips to China that should not have gone there. Oh yeah, and he artificially inflated the price of GPUs with circular financing of AI startups. And, you know, he cheated on his wife at least three times.
Ok, can we go after this asshole for fraud or something? Because it kinda seems like he's been doing some fraudulent price fixing bullshit.
Add a side order of GPU manipulation - actually this is the big story.
Doesn't matter he got caught in a compromised position with a woman not his wife, while in a position to affect the lives of thousands of people.
He's about to go through a messy divorce that will take half his wealth.
He obviously cannot be trusted.
Honestly he sounds like the new republican presidential candidate
SemiAnalysis, a respected AI research firm
Now there's an oxymoron.
Maybe I missed the beginning of it all but wasn't the first headline about this case 47 trying to bury it all to protect his buddy Jensen? I suppose you could stretch that into the conspiracy theory as well, if you really tried.
As the boss of a company you represent it. Bad PR is bad PR. Admitting to an extramarital affair is bad enough. Whether she spied for China or didn't is already more of a secondary, compounding factor. The let's duck out of the Cosplay Coldplay kiss cam couple also lost their jobs, didn't they.
Edited amusing auto correct.
IF ONLY SOMEBODY TOLD US ABOUT THE NVIDIA GPU SMUGGLING
(For context: Gamer Nexus did a very detailed expose on the Chinese GPU black market and how NVIDIA was supplying them. So, no, this is not new, and everybody involved should have fucking known about it.)
Then why the fuck do I care? He dated a spy therefore he and his AI are awful at determining character and he's a moron. She's not a spy and he's still a moron that got caught cheating.
Jensen Huang is just a moron. Full stop.
Because if the affair is nothing-sauce, it means he was pressured out by someone, for a reason serious enough to lie about CIA assessments.
The US intelligence community is a large part of the push to get Jensen out of Nvidia
Business insider is reporting that spy allegations are likely trumped up and Huang was just ousted because he holds a more moderate position on China.
You should care because the more the US and China need each other, the less likely WW3 is.
I wonder if the US intelligence community are the ones digging up all this dirty about Jensen’s affairs and hyping them up in the media.
Jensen Huang was sympathetic to China, and he also wanted China to be the US’s customer.
Trump and Rubio are racists and are big mad that China got rich off the American economy (ironically enough thanks to businessmen trying to get rich by saving money by doing business with them) and their big strategy is to hide all the AI in America where “CHIYAINAH” can’t get it and they have to come crawling to us. And they’re dumb enough to think that’ll work.
Your explanation is exactly what happened. The WMDs are coming from inside the house.
Spy allegations aside, did he not illegally export chips to China?
on paper Jensen didn't, who did, allegedly, was the alleged chinese spy's business (which they hold a chief position in) that is based on singapore, but apparently a good chunk of the gpus weren't actually smuggled into china, but rented from singapore based data centers for chinese customers, it is possible she was just a corporate spy trying to get better deals and insights on nvidia for her business
It was like the most blatant affair anyone has ever had. There are news reports going back a few years showing the two together. They weren't exactly discreet.
Wow the pr firm hired by jensen to get his job back is everywhere
I seriously hope this piece of shit does not go back to being nvidias CEO.
I have 0 hope in humanity left. People only care about their wallets, and do not give a shit about ethics and kindness and being a good person. Case in point: both Sam Altman and Jensen are wanted by their employees.
Its somewhat irrelevant? He was sacked after he was also accused of having an affair with the companies vice president of healthcare.
Whether or not the first affair is a spy or not is dramatic but doesnt change the fundamentals. The CEO has multiple affairs, it was damaging the company and the board sacked him for it.
It'll be interesting to see where this all ends up. Is one person really so crucial to a companies success? I dont think so but someone like Elon Musk clearly needs us all to think so as that what's props his own companies values up.
But the nvidia share prices show how irrational the valuations of companies are - Huang is gone but the company still has its big slice of the supposedly amazing AI future. The company has lost 25% of its value in the last month but is only down 12% overall in the past year and still up 353% over the past 5 years.
i think Elon is a special case because he is able to maintain crazy high, wildly out of touch valuations and share prices just based on hype and image. He’s kind of a one man bubble so if he goes, I think the bubble pops. I think you’re right that he sees personal benefit in folks believing in the myth of the magical CEO or founder being 100% crucial.
Steve Jobs is a popular example. He absolutely drove the design at Apple and made the company what it is today in the most ideal example of the magical visionary leader. But when Jobs died, Apple didn’t implode because the company was profitable and had huge market share and sky high margins and all the good fundamentals. Post Jobs, the UI and UX have gone to shit and there isn’t a lot of new exciting vision, but they can tread water like that forever.
Starting to.
If this never occurred to you, you need to more to harden yourself against propaganda, especially propaganda that comes from "your side".
That US intelligence might lie isn't a "wild conspiracy theory". For them it's Tuesday.
At first the comments were, of course he did and they'll find more, and now they say, of course it was fake and blah blah blah lol.
Huang supported open weight AI models. This doesn't play nicely with big corporations nor governments. This is the primary reason he was targeted and removed in lieu of someone that is more willing to play ball and maintain the overarching control of closed source frontier models.
I literally said this was bullshit when the story broke. "Starting to look shaky" is the understatement of the century. It was obviously a lie from the start. Pro tip if the CIA comes out and accuses some random chinese person of being a spy don't believe them!
I can see how the woman was a corporate spy who happens to be chinese, that does kinda of fit "chinese spy", now when the USA intelegence agencies first publicly said that it definetly seemed like they were implying she was working the Chinese intelengence directly
UNCLE HUANG DID NOTHING WRONG
all 55 comments