How long until they no longer support their web client? Killing Vencord and third party clients in the process
post
I tried spinning up a Mimble server recently and people just wouldn’t go for it. It works really well but setup and user experience in general is not as friendly, despite great sound quality. We had to move back to discord. I’m not sure what to do as Discord is going to surely get worse with their need to make money.
Fluxer is a really good open source alternative, if you're ever trying to move a community off Discord that one is probably your best bet.
Still missing federation but I check every month
Yup.
I will literally spin up an instance the second federation is implemented at least experimentally.
I already tested it and it works pretty well, only thing missing for me is proper encryption. Server owner being able to read all guild and private messages is horrifying.
Why not sooner? Start testing it and stuff. It works really well already.
Because without federation I won't have anyone to test it with?
Who tf cares how well it works on an instance with a single user?
Until federation is ACTUALLY implemented, my interest remains entirely theoretical. Why would I waste my time at this point?
Make a free server and try it out with your friends?? That's what I did and we like it. Jesus Christ, chill out lol, wtf.
You literally asked me why I'm waiting, in response to me saying I'm waiting for the one thing that that's most important to me.
Who the fuck does that?
Our use cases are not the same. Telling me it works fine right now, but without the ONE THING I MENTIONED I WANT does literally nothing for me.
I just don't understand why federation prevents you from trying it with your friends? I was able to try Fluxer with my friends without federation implemented yet. You just join the same instance.
Like, why are you cursing my way? I'm just here trying to help, and I possibly also don't understand what you mean. Neither of those things deserve the absolutely unwarranted hostility you are giving me here. What is wrong with you?
"Just ask your friends to create accounts on your lemmy instance, you don't need federation."
I want to replace everything discord does. A single instance can only replace a single Discord guild. Which is maybe 2% of how I use Discord.
Solving the friend group DMs problem is easy in comparison, but I am interested in the parts of Discord that allows large global communities to function. A single unfederated instance will never allow me to participate in communities with thousands of members.
The fact that my interest in it specifically relies on it one day being federated should have clued you in, yet here you are, telling me to "just try it with my friends" when the friend group problem isn't the one I'm looking to solve.
I already run my own federated matrix instance, I wrote and maintain four lemmy bots, and I moderate over a dozen lemmy communities. You do NOT need explain instances and federation to me.
I'm annoyed. I'm showing that I'm annoyed. Because while not meaning to, you are being supremely annoying by essentially talking down to someone who is very clearly just as informed as you are.
My very first comment makes it very clear I am waiting on federation, specifically. You ASSUMED I'm doing so without reason, and tried to tell me to give it a go anyway. When it should be VERY CLEAR TO YOU IT WONT DO WHAT I NEED IT TO. Because the feature I want is MISSING!!
If I didn't know better, and weren't able to instantly tell that your advice is bad for me, I mightve wasted my time by following it.
So yeah. I'm responding with a "don't fucking do that".
JFC you're still yelling in caps and cursing at someone who was only trying to be nice.
At least you explained it all to me, so, thanks, I guess.
Have a better day tomorrow than you've had today, bud. Sorry for ruining it for you...
Edit: reading your stuff more carefully, and I'm not trying to explain shit to you bruh. My god. We just had different use cases for this app and I didn't get it. Okay? I just don't use discord as a community software. I just talk and game.
You feel me? So relax and understand that misunderstandings can happen. I'm not trying to "talk down to you", oh wise genius. You're extremely smart and know exactly what you're talking about. Got it. No problem. 👍👍👍👍👍
"I'm waiting for a feature."
"Why are waiting for that feature? Everything else already works."
"Because I want that feature."
"Do you not get that you can just have your friends use the same instance? You don't need federation."
"I know. And I do though."
You ignored the one single reason I said I was waiting to host fluxer. Even if an misunderstanding on your part... Doing that is rude. I am allowed to get pissy when someone decides a part of what I said wasn't important.
And when I made it very clear federation wasn't optional for me, you replied as if I was stupid, rather than acting based on different needs.
You didn't need to get it. You just needed to read "I am waiting for federation" and go "huh, well this guy can't use it yet, then".
That's it. If you ignore something like that and try to be "helpful", you'll get a "fuck off" in person just as fast as you did from me.
I expect federation to be testable early 2027, full release later in the year
Here's their roadmap
I'd wait till they have E2EE and federation implemented. They say it should come around early 2027.
I stumbled upon https://armada.buzz recently. It's based on nostr protocol, should be e2ee. Can't really tell more as I have to do a proper research. So far it looks very well, judging by my very limited experience.
What is the issue with Movim? https://movim.eu/
The popular opinion on Lemmy seems to be Discord sucks, but in my experience, it is far and away the most complete and feature rich chat platform for gamers. Privacy aside, it's better. That is why it's so hard to get everyone off it, besides the network effect.
That said, I'm still trying to get my friends off of it (They seem to be open to trying Signal). They don't care about all those features for the most part, so maybe I have a chance.
Feature complete in what way?
You need text channels and voice channels, and a decent way to navigate them. Everything else is just fluff.
So it's not features people stay for, but luxuries. And perhaps also some sunk cost fallacy to boot, since many spend on nitro and group boosts.
Different people rely on different things, screen sharing and video calling come to mind as features some people use regularly.
Those exist elsewhere already.
No one wants to use 4 or 5 different pieces of software to do the same thing if it can be avoided.
You could just as easily say we dont need a client to do voice and text because we could just use any of the hundreds of voice or text only clients.
No, those exist elsewhere, as in, those that do all those things together in one app. And without being tied to a centralised service which contributes to invasive surveillance and literal, actual fascism.
But even then, using 5 different apps would still be a better choice over going belly up for invasive surveillance and fascism for a convenience.
Those who say otherwise can drop dead.
Is just fluff for you.
I need recursively nested channels because I need really fine-coarsed structure for my projects and stuff, and that's not present ik the 90% of communication apps.
Hell, even Discord seems too feature-incomplete for me, because of my specific needs. If your needs are so basic, good for you, but you're not every people in the world.
That said, Matrix >>>>> everything else.
Me and a friend spun up a Matrix server with Sable as the client and nobody followed. Our solution was to ditch our friends. Both me and him agree that if they're alright with fascism and authoritarianism because of some convenience they're not friends.
You no longer consider these people friends because they use Discord? Christ, with friends like you, who needs enemies...
Your only real alternative is fluxer. Everything is is beyond dog shit as far as normal users are concerned.
That's cool. Thanks for giving our data to Palantir you fucking goons. Can't wait for that civil suit.
I don't give a shit about their process spying features, if anything the fact that they didn't work was a plus.
This is kind of cool I guess. Too bad I deleted my discord account back in February
I can't bcause friends are stuck on PlayStation and it only has discord for comms with PC :(
What you guys don't have phones
curious if they vibecoded the new client or not
It is absolutely vibecoded.
Suspiciously, as soon as LLMs are able to generate passable code, all of a sudden a ton of apps for Linux appear, that can all do something long thought to be either impossible or too difficult to be worth the effort.
Now, this isn't necessarily bad in itself. More apps for Linux, that work reasonably well, is great.
What's bad is this will be used as an argument that AI is wonderful and beneficial for everybody. When all of this could have been easily achieved if a handful of megacorporations just didn't invest resources into sabotaging non-Windows and non-MacOS software.
As long as they dont let the AI spew @unsafe lines everywhere or whatever the annotation is, at least a rewrite in rust should have some semblance of stability at least though?
Just using safe rust to produce correct software is not enough, you can still crash program by using something like unwrap, or by violating interial mutability rules in Mutex (But crashing program is still better than C)
They very quickly come out with these features shortly before announcing they're switching to Rust, so I guess yeah.
Also, a number of features coming to Discord are things which exist in Sable v2, which is also Rust. So while I'm not making an accusation, I'm certainly making a suspicious stare...
So discord started the switch to Rust back in 2019-2020. They have an extensive breakdown as to why they made that switch. https://discord.com/blog/why-discord-is-switching-from-go-to-rust
Not saying they aren't vibe coding now, but it's not that they just randomly started doing it this year. They've been a Rust shop for over 6 years now.
But end of day we should all find alternatives IMO.
They very quickly come out with these features shortly before announcing they're switching to Rust, so I guess yeah.
Couldnt they have waited to announce it when it was close to being finished?
Any FOSS alternative for games?
I have successfully launched my own Fluxer instance for me and my friends on my server a week ago. Runs super well, and the audio/video/streaming quality is superb.
Don't mind me. I'm just going to sit quietly in my little corner and play Doom, Heretic, Hexen, Rise of the Triad, and Quake. These where my first taste of gaming and I found all that I need to be happy.


all 80 comments