"Just ask your friends to create accounts on your lemmy instance, you don't need federation."
I want to replace everything discord does. A single instance can only replace a single Discord guild. Which is maybe 2% of how I use Discord.
Solving the friend group DMs problem is easy in comparison, but I am interested in the parts of Discord that allows large global communities to function. A single unfederated instance will never allow me to participate in communities with thousands of members.
The fact that my interest in it specifically relies on it one day being federated should have clued you in, yet here you are, telling me to "just try it with my friends" when the friend group problem isn't the one I'm looking to solve.
I already run my own federated matrix instance, I wrote and maintain four lemmy bots, and I moderate over a dozen lemmy communities. You do NOT need explain instances and federation to me.
I'm annoyed. I'm showing that I'm annoyed. Because while not meaning to, you are being supremely annoying by essentially talking down to someone who is very clearly just as informed as you are.
My very first comment makes it very clear I am waiting on federation, specifically. You ASSUMED I'm doing so without reason, and tried to tell me to give it a go anyway. When it should be VERY CLEAR TO YOU IT WONT DO WHAT I NEED IT TO. Because the feature I want is MISSING!!
If I didn't know better, and weren't able to instantly tell that your advice is bad for me, I mightve wasted my time by following it.
So yeah. I'm responding with a "don't fucking do that".