Yet they were denied access again. Too bad there aren't any punishments for ignoring the judicial system.
post
First question. As a Nazi pedo dictator why do you hate free speech?
Obama did this with Helen Thomas and no fucks were given.
They're all lap dogs to propaganda.

I honestly think your downvotes are because you didn't explain how these two things are connected. I also just glanced through the Wikipedia article and like...based.
During the speech, Thomas said: "Congress, the White House, Hollywood and Wall Street are owned by Zionists. No question, in my opinion."[78][81] Thomas defended her comments on December 7, telling Scott Spears of Marion, Ohio radio station WMRN, "I just think that people should be enlightened as to who is in charge of the opinion in this country."
And then like the ADL cancels her and it's all just kind of what we're doing now but 16 years ago before most of us USians knew that Israel was a genocidal fascist state.
The next day, the Anti-Defamation League called for journalism schools and organizations to rescind any honors given to Thomas. The organization said that Thomas had "clearly, unequivocally revealed herself as a vulgar antisemite" in the speech.[83] Wayne State University in Detroit discontinued the Helen Thomas Spirit of Diversity in Media Award, which it had been granting for more than ten years, citing what it called her antisemitic remarks.[78] Thomas objected, saying that "the leaders of Wayne State University have made a mockery of the First Amendment and disgraced their understanding of its inherent freedom of speech and the press."[84] Asked by the Detroit Free Press how she would respond to people who say she is antisemitic, Thomas responded: 'I'd say I'm a Semite. What are you talking about?'"
Unless there is something else in the controversy it seems like she spoke the truth about Israel 16 years ago and had her reputation drug through the mud for it. She spoke truth to power and it sure seems like the power tried to crush her for it.
OC, you just gave a very "both sides" sounding example with 0 context for those not already in the know. Some of us are still learning or have brains with the retention of a sieve, provide context and you'll likely see a more positive response.
I'm going to preface this by saying I don't think she deserved to be cancelled over her comments. There is a huge difference between an organization and other entities pushing to cancel a journalist, and the president is the United States directly banning certain journalists. Both are bad, but one is significantly worse than the other.
Agreed, there is a difference, but I think there are similarities and direct ties to now. The Anti Defamation League is explicitly part of the Israel lobby. Getting cancelled by Israel has been known to be bad for a career. I think we can connect that directly to today.
I'm sorry I didn't spell it out. Okay. Weird how folks can feel so strongly about something they demonstrably don't understand. Huh?
Thanks, man.
I just read her wiki page. I don't understand how you can say "Obama did this" too. It seemed like everyone was cancelling her. Also, Obama didn't kick her out, she retired.
Just more disingenuous "both sides" bullshit.
How can a person legitimately believe that these things are even close to the same thing? Either they simply haven't read (and comprehended) the OP article, or they're being purposely disingenuous.
If Obama even suggested doing what Trump did here, Congress would have immediately brought articles of impeachment against him.
She was forced to retire. Saying Obama's administration had nothing to do with it seems a little naive, but whatever makes you feel better.
She died three years later, and I can't help but think that was also related. The WH press pool was her life.

All U.S. Presidents are scum, some just more than others.
She died three years later, and I can’t help but think that was also related. The WH press pool was her life.
Shocking that a 92 year old woman would just up and die like that.
You wanna keep Mitch McConnell around too? He’s been in the senate so long; it would be a shame to make him quit.
Wow. That's an obscene comparison. Why?
Just say you didn't like the questions she was asking.
It's not, their both old ass shit, it's a natural conclusion to make, especially when their not doing anything anymore.
a pound of hamburger costs more than minimum wage under republican rule, gas is through the roof, food safety is gone, and our first amendment rights are impacted because the press is banned from asking questions
not to mention the never ending war we’re in now the actual war crimes committed and how bad we look on the world stage
but yeah, “Obama did this with Helen Thomas and no fucks we’re given”
I've gotten so goddamn sick of this fucking double standard. It's present everywhere, and has been instrumental in allowing fascism to take control of our country.
I think it's worth mentioning, especially for why she was kicked out and why Trump won, the Democrats support for a genocidal occupation.
We should all say her name. We should all strive to be more like her.

Was it all a ruse to build demand for state media? Or was the admin simply too incompetent to forsee this outcome?
I would strongly bet on incompetence, I think Trump just threw a dumbass narcissistic temper tantrum and lashed out at these organizations because he's a cornered rat and he knows it and his lawyers just had to scramble to put the best presentation on it they could, which got laughed out of court because they're a bunch of idiots trying to justify the actions of an even bigger idiot
Hanlon's razor is an adage or rule of thumb that states, "Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity.
How is this a bad outcome for Trump? He's wasting a lot of resources for those news outlets that hang to fight this
All they got was a 14 day access order, which the Trump admin did not even initially honor, costing the outlets even more time and resources
Wasting his administration's own resources just as much as everyone else involved is, except he's wasting resources for a losing effort. Also I'm pretty sure like five different non-profit media advocacy organizations jumped in to represent these networks and did the heavy lifting for them, so really they just got free advertising out of this.
All they got was a 14 day access order
Which is almost certainly going to be extended within 14 days, so it's effectively a permanent access order
SO? He hasn't obeyed ANY laws or social norms his entire life. What makes anyone think he will this time?
I hear you, but the first sentence of the article states that he (or the Whitehouse, at least) has already actively complied with the ruling.
I’m just going to hazard a guess that they didn’t create an entire streaming network in two days, and they’ve been planning the press lock out for a while.
So since they are hoping to rake in the cash and nobody will enforce this injunction junction, nothing will happen and they’ll keep doing it.
I’m just going to hazard a guess that they didn’t create an entire streaming network in two days, and they’ve been planning the press lock out for a while.
That would have required planning and subterfuge.
More likely: feelings got hurt, and a rich donor had a failed streaming platform that needed a rescue.
Saw an article yesterday where the viewership on trump TV was like 500 people.
So, exactly as successful as any other trump venture.
Ha ha ha ha, he needs them more than they need him. I guess they still don't realize that yet, even after the sound fiasco.
Not just the sound, Trump TV is already failing.
The Daily Beast reported that roughly 8,000 people watched at launch, with the count briefly reaching 8,500. Within 90 minutes, it had fallen by more than half. Fewer than 1,000 were watching early Tuesday, and the outlet observed the count dip below 500 at times on Wednesday.
That's total viewers, worldwide. Including other press with it on for various reporting reasons.
Those ratings are terrible at every stage. And considering how much Trump focuses on TV ratings... I'm sure there's ketchup all over every wall in the WH.
If they DONT Comply we're going to Send ANOTHER Strong Letter!
-Judges who COMPLAIN people Don't listen to Them!

all 31 comments