
post
countries like the UK, France, Italy and Germany there are now around 5 vehicles for every 10 people
That's a weird way to say 1 car for every 2 people.
Provide better public options. It takes me 25 minutes to get to work by car and 75 minutes by public. Fuck that.
So many cities could be made completely car-free.
Just force people to park near the edge and use alternative transport from there. This would give city centers the space to be greener and safer to live in.
Especially in Europe this should be fairly easy. Some cities are pushing towards this too. Not sure if American cities are suited sadly enough, as many of them are built with cars in mind.
I say not less cars, but no cars. We need to move towards societies where we arent dependent on the asphalt industry.
We need to learn how to live slow again.
zero carz🦔
Im curious what people here would take to work. A 20 minute drive or an hour bike ride. Buses don't exist near me nor will they. What are my options. It's too hot, the weather is unpredictable, and im not spending an hour one way to work.
If you say there will never be buses near you, I presume you don't live in a city. If you did, I don't see why the city creating a bus line there wouldn't be possible.
For folks commuting from outside the city to inside, the best is a big car park outside the city next to a commuter train station. Make it frequent and reliable.
i dont want people commuting to jobs everyday that are 10km away. i dont want that to be typical. just my thoughts on the matter
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marchetti%27s_constant
People would in general change either their living place or place of work to be about a half hour's trip. That would take some time sure, but people mostly aren't going to bike an hour every day for many of the same reasons they don't drive an hour every day.
An hour ebike ride most days would be what I'd opt for. Doesn't matter if its like 100° and high humidity and a thunderstorm just means its a cooler bike ride.
In all honesty, I would probably drive in your situation, though I might invest in a folding bike/e-bike I can toss in the trunk. It's crazy how small those things are now! They had some Urtopias at the local bike shop last time I swung by, and I swear they fold up smaller than most adult scooters I've seen.
Fwiw my commute is about 35 min by regular bike, 25 by e-bike, 15 by car if the traffic is light (that's a big if), or around 45 by bus. E-bike is my preferred option.
A LOT of people would merrily choose the 1-hour bike ride provided they won't get murdered by car drivers.
My aunt has both a car and access to perfectly reasonable bus routes, yet often choses to WALK multiple kilometers to work in the summer.
Something i'm always annoyed by no one talking about: What about smaller cars?
Just making the cars smaller is a really easy way to make them less shit in basically every single way, no matter what.
Normalize moped cars.
Unless they're really small, like kei cars in Japan, and have different infrastructure to match, it doesn't do much good. They still take up the same amount of space in traffic because that's dominated by following distance rather than vehicle length, and they still take up the same amount of space at rest because all parking spaces are the same size.
you do realize there are other factors than just the physical size they occupy, right? Smaller cars means they're lighter (less wear on roads, less fuel usage, less damage when they hit things) and have better visibility.
Reposting in same community deserves downvotes, at least mine.
Reposting in the same community doesn't just deserve downvotes, it violates rule 5 and thus deserves removal.
But to the best of my knowledge, this article was never posted in this community before. !fuckcars@lemmy.world is not !fuck_cars@lemmy.ml or !fuckcars@lemmy.ca.
If that's incorrect, please cite the URL of the previous copy.
we also need fewer people
Yes. And this is easy to solve with decreased birth rates. People die naturally and populations reduce significantly on their own on fairly short periods of time
we know its you bro 😭😭😭
"Genghis Khan, who established the world's largest contiguous empire between the 13th and 14th centuries, has been branded the 'greenest invader' in history as his murderous invasion actually helped scrub about 700million tonnes of carbon from the atmosphere. According to a new research, the ruthless Mongol warrior killed so many people during his bloody invasions that huge swathes of cultivated land depopulated and returned to forest."
https://www.wwf.org.co/en/?199285%2FGenghis-Khan---the-greenest-invader-in-history=
Yes. I've been saying for years that electric cars and self driving cars are solving the wrong problem. The problem is if I need a car to get groceries. The problem is I'm not safe on the street because of all the cars.
People who have never lived someplace that doesn't need a car are very eager to tell you how it won't work, though.
The roads here are so wide (usually 6 lanes plus turn lanes and a median) that we could build wall2wall apartments/condos/flats on on half of the road and still have enough road left for 3-4 lanes of traffic and a detached dedicated bike path and sidewalks.
Cars take up way more space than people realize.
Public Transport for the win!
As an electric car owner, I completely agree. We were lucky enough to go from 2 cars to 1, but still not enough transit to go to zero
I got tired of waiting for EVs to become affordable and got an e-bike instead. I still drive at times when the bike doesn't cut it for various reasons. And now my car is getting super old and in need of replacement, but I'm not sure what to do?
EVs sound ideal, but the usual logic that the higher upfront cost will come back to you in fuel savings feels less compelling in my situation. Otoh another gas guzzler? One thing I can say is I don't see myself ever buying new again. It's just not worth it for how little I drive. I guess I'll leave EV/hybrid/conventional debate up to what's available on the used market.
If you barely use your car, you might not even need it anymore. Perhaps a taxi/rental/car pooling might meet the few times you still take it out of the garage? Specially when you put the numbers down and see how expensive it is to maintain a car
You have a point. My brother gets by fine now without owning his own wheels. And my grownup kids don't even have drivers licences.
I guess where my situation differs is that they live in big cities compared to me with all sorts of options for getting around. Also, I'm a part-time musician with a lot of gear I have to transport to gigs, particularly if I'm running sound.
Would you consider something like the Bestune Pony to be affordable? It retails for the equivalent of 8000 euros after 15% VAT. I am seeing it more and more and I live in a place where petrol is 0.50 euro a liter.
Well my wife is certainly fawning over it when I showed her photos!
So unfortunately in North America, there is a 100% tariff on Chinese EVs which, oddly enough, predates Trump. In Canada specifically, they are easing this somewhat so that 49,000 will be allowed in every year before the tariff kicks in. (That number apparently reflects EV sales before the tariff was implemented.)
But yes, I would definitely consider something like that if I could actually find one here.
Of course, because EVs do not address the problem and just do a misdirection.
The problem is publicly subsidised private vehicles.
When I was growing up, I was a sci-fi nerd. I loved the idea of cool little electric cars. But the ones I'm seeing around here are huge. We're also learning that even electric cars are fucking up the environment.
What I didn't imagine is electric bikes and scooters. So that's been a cool thing (I have both), but it has downsides too.
I volunteer at a local hospital, and we've seen a huge uptick of injuries from people riding electric scooters and bikes. The reason is that more people are on them, but our infrastructure in my city doesn't support them very well. So people are having to ride on busted sidewalks, roads with no bike lane, etc. So a lot of people crashing them (and not wearing a helmet).
So I think the only we can really reduce car usage is to make the city unfriendly to cars. But that ain't gonna happen here anytime soon. A strip of road near me actually was finally updated with a pretty wide bike lane last month because it's close to a school, but holy shit, people in my neighborhood are still bitching about how we didn't need it and it was a waste of resources. smh
So, the fewer humans argument is popular in countries with a low population density, or generally in the first world where populations have peaked and are projected to decline if they are not doing so already. I'm in Canada. It's a big talking point here.
When you study demographics, though, you start getting a different picture. 1st worlders have a HUGE per capita resource footprint compared to 3rd worlders. Like 10x or more. Our 40 million punches like 400 million in the developing world, which is not something to be proud of.
The point I'm trying to make is that anything we do in wealthier countries that reduces per capita consumption has an outsized effect globally. A car is over 10x more massive than a bike, and the costs reflect that however you measure it, be it in energy, manufacturing, infrastructure, etc.
The big problem with this transition is not whether we need fewer cars but that modern cities are not designed for alternatives. Any near term solution has to include EVs. It’s going to take a large redesign and investment at a time we can’t wait while we need to electrify everything.
Modern US cities.
Modern Australian cities too.
ironically australia is generally a great example of how easily american cities could unfuck themselves by just running trains on the railways they already have and building apartments near the train stations.
Like yeah brisbane isn't a paradise by any stretch, but remarkably it's not an endless hellscape of highways and single family houses! You can get a train to the airport! There's an actual downtown rather than a sea of parking lots with 7 shops!
It’s the suburban sprawl that is driving the car based transport. Suburbs are established further away with no proper infrastructure, shops and facilities. Cars are the only way to get about as everything is so hard to get to. Extending freeways to them doesn’t help as the commute time is lowest in a car.
But 1) apartments don't tend to be built in suburban sprawl, and 2) even the worst suburban sprawl in europe is still generally bikeable, there'll be a lidl or something within a reasonable distance.
Got this thread mixed up with another, similar one. Ignore this reply lol.
I was passing through the back blocks of Sydney, new suburbs that are a long way from anywhere. If you want to go anywhere it’s by car.
Infill of the inner areas especially around railways is happening which is great but the sprawl continues.
At this point i don't even demand fewer cars, i just want smaller cars.
90% of people do not need a 4-seat gas-guzzler with a massive trunk which literally outsizes a WW1 tank and a top speed of "yes", they can get by perfectly fucking fine with a little electric moped-car where the rear seats are foldable and the trunk fits maybe 3 grocery bags.
EVs weren't made to save the planet; they were made to save the car industry.
Theyre an improvement surely but mass transit, cycle lanes, and better urban planning are fundamentally more important to emphasize.
This article doesn't even touch on the fact that tires and brake dust still contribute to unhealthy air quality and adverse health outcomes.
EVs do not wear breaks like a normal car. I keep having issues with mine needing to be cleaned and lubricated because they get such low usage.
The tire thing is valid though.
I wore like 2mm off my break pads in 60k miles. A nice win on car maintenance costs as well.
I had this with an 80s civic. It would shut gas off from the injectors when decelerating, and downshift hard. It meant the engine became an air pump, and car would slow without brakes. The brakes lasted so long I had to get a gear puller to pull the wheel rims off the hubs. They had corrosions bonded themselves together
This is how nearly all ICE cars have operated since the mid-90s. Most people just haven't learned to take advantage, and still drive full speed up to red lights and slam on the brakes at the last second.
My original brake pads in my '17 Nissan Micra 5spd went 100k kms before failing inspection.
https://youtube.com/shorts/T4O_ib-8MeM
This lady speaks the truth
Not much use in saying we need fewer cars without questioning why we need so many.
I would happily stop driving TO A FUCKING USELESS OFFICE and give up my car to do it.
Want fewer cars, gotta work on the cause not the symptom. Shaming people for driving because they don't have a choice isn't useful.

all 26 comments