People can forget that when it comes to the South, this is a real old front.
We're tired, and all this ride or die republicanism is because we're still here. We need the help
People can forget that when it comes to the South, this is a real old front.
We're tired, and all this ride or die republicanism is because we're still here. We need the help
They're not unsalvagable, but they won't be the vanguard either. They will come when the tide starts to turn, so efforts need to be put at tide turning. Expect local efforts. Local efforts are critical everywhere.
People who cheer when southern kids die in a natural disaster because it will hurt their parents, who might have voted Trump: why won’t these stupid fucks vote for my team?
My opinion is that we are all people and the southerners have been steeped in racist and capitalist propaganda for a very long time. Their media environment is turning them racist and afraid to the point where the effort needs to turn them around would be extreme. We don't need to abandon our Southern brothers and sisters, but one we get power we should begin reconstruction reeducation. And just accept that a lot of them are too far gone for saving.
You aren't sincerely and completely unironically suggesting fucking re-education camps, right?
Right?
Not camps, but for every news report of Mexican and other people being violent rapists thugs before taking power, we will need the same amount or more news reports on how those people are just like us, not bad, not good, just human.
People who are ideologically racist should have their platforms removed so the only way they can spread their hate is through friends and relatives.
There should propaganda produced that calls racists idiots, low IQ, and whatever else. Just shame them generally.
I don't like the idea of any physical harm coming to them, but they will either grow out of it or live in a country that is antithetical to their ideology.
(Painfully) agree with the first part, second part misses the mark imo. My neighborhood is better because it doesn't have as many racists in it.
I've written off the entire states as unsalvageable (unless broken up) as someone from the northern Provinces
At this point I'm just hoping for reduced federal influence over blue states and measures to help out refugees from the places whose own state governments are working against them.
I appreciate posts like this. It's nice to see people calling out this shit.
Every time I see so-called "progressives" talking about succeeding from the union or writing off southern states, I feel incredibly terrified and abandoned as a queer person born and raised in Texas.
So... What? I just get to die? I'm just an "unfortunate casualty" Collateral? I get it's tiresome. I get it's scary what's happening. But don't call yourself an ally if you're not willing to fight tooth and nail for us. Cause I guarantee, if states started succeeding, it would be game fuckin', over for a lot of minorities. There would be no way out of the shit holes we're trapped in, and nobody to speak up or fight for us when they start actually shipping us off to "Wellness Farms."
Idc I'm not American I just want you guys to collapse so each state is its own country and maybe have a European union style relationship with each other so that y'all stop being so internationally inflammatory. Stg the main reason for considering learning a language other than English is to enter a conversation that defaults to excluding Americans.
As someone living in the heart of South Louisiana.
The Southern States are lost and we need to focus on trying to get people out instead of trying to change the minds of a bunch of xenophobic hicks.
I'm 100% for breaking up the union and expelling the Republican states.
I am 100% against giving Republicans political sovereignty and adjacent territory.
We don't need to be changing the minds of xenophobic fucks but we do need to take their political power. Red state governments can and will cause problems for you no matter where you live.
I really hate that the country is so bad I agree with you on this
It truly is sad, but people's minds won't be swayed without totally restructuring our economic and political systems which dictate their material interests, and that won't happen without a total revolutionary war against the system. I don't like it anymore than the next person but that's just the logical conclusion to the reality we exist in.
Humans, as a species, are generally very stupid, selfish, and simplistic with short attention spans. We all simply want the easiest and most effective way to meet our material needs, regardless if a less convenient method would have better results, unless we actively train ourselves, through years of education, to be in the habit of going against our instincts and thinking critically about the world around us.
Unfortunately, due to our current systems, many people have tied their ability to meet those needs with the economic interests of the owning class, which intrinsically is oppositional to the needs of the working class. Most don't understand that the small gains from doing so are simply going to be funneled towards the owning class anyway. Yet, it allows them to be better off than others and that is enough to scare them into contentment with their lot in life.
Additionally, the system is designed to be so convoluted that those who are uneducated in how it fundamentally works can readily be convinced of certain falsehoods, such as increasing wages results in increased price of goods or that immigrants are "stealing jobs", because they simply have no understanding of how those claims are blatant falsehoods.
And they don't question it, because it plays on the inherent flaws of human psychology by appealing to basal fears of the unfamiliar and playing on how our minds are predisposed to certain logical fallacies.
Those regressive polices many wright off the south for exist in the rest of the country, but in different forms better suited to the context of the area. They come across as particularly brutal and overt to other areas simply because they’re not tailored to be hidden from them.
My only problem with the point this image is making, is that it doesn't matter if we are supportive or dismissive.
They're still, as a whole, as a group, going to be terrible people.
Compassion fatigue is a real thing, and while I don't want anything bad to happen to anyone, you can only save somebody from themselves so many times before you realize they're going to do bad things and nothing can stop them.
Fuck this.
Let's be real bare bones about this.
In Tennessee, 2 million people voted for Trump.
1 million voted for Harris.
The vibe is, "Those 1 million people can't fix their situation so they should be just as fucked as the other 2."
And that's wrong. It's wrong to condemn whole swaths of humanity based on where they live, but even if you're dick enough to say "FAFO" when real humans suffer, you shouldn't be willing to throw your own allies under the bus based on arbitrary lines on the ground.
And I'm a first responder, don't talk to me about compassion fatigue, it's not an excuse not to help someone who needs it.
I hear you. But if you are a medical professional then you must also know about the concept of Triage.
The sheer balls to try and fucking mansplain to a first responder. Holy shit.
not the person you're replying to, but I thank you for your work ❤️
I didn't even respond. The audacity to compare dark decisions made to maximize saving life with an attitude of political apathy had to be trolling. Deeply unserious.
The vibe is, "Those 1 million people can't fix their situation so they should be just as fucked as the other 2."
No, the vibe is that the population literally chose to do this to themselves. Which is true. 2 million Trump voters and 1.5 million nonvoters all decided this was something they were cool with. And now it's happening. It sucks for the ~20% who did oppose this, but the overwhelming majority literally were fine with this.
it's not an excuse not to help someone who needs it.
And how should you be helped? Because you literally can only help yourselves.
Agreed, they are people just like us. They have been turned so racist that they vote against their own interests. It wasn't their choice to be turned racist, but now that they are, there isn't much we can do. You can't use logic move them from a position they didn't use logic to get to.
I want to add that these people usually vote R because they're told it's the right thing to do, not because they actually understand what they're voting for or against. When asked about policy, they generally agree with leftist policies. If we get the chance to show them that leftist policies actually work and what they are, we may stand a chance to change their minds.
That's why I think the NYC mayoral election is pretty important. If he's elected he can actually do good things that Democrats and Republicans have told people to be scared of. He can show that people have been lied to and it's actually good. The problem will be getting this information to the uninformed voters. They'll hear about it, but it'll mostly only be that it's bad, actually, and they won't hear about the victories.
TIL about compassion fatigue.
I don’t think we’re responsible for anywhere near enough compassion to be fatigued by it
Here's an idea: focus your attention on your community. Join an organization and build coalitions locally. Do the work to improve the material conditions of those around you, acting in good faith with solidarity toward your neighbors.
Then, when you've realized how inane and pointless it is to generalize about populations numbering into the millions, mind your own fucking business and quit wishing ill on people you will never meet. Compassion fatigue is your problem, and calling the population of an entire state terrible is just bullshit no matter which way you cut it.
We don't need your kindness, we don't need saving, we need cooperation and community. If that's not in your wheelhouse, then keep to yourself.
Signed, a "terrible" floridian who's fed up with dipshit northerners telling me that I deserve to die in a hurricane because my governor sucks.
My neighborhood is better because it has Pride flags instead of rebel flags and BLM chapters instead of Klan chapters.
It’s not that I don’t recognize there are good people there worthy of assistance. It’s that I doubt our ability to help them. The fascist powers there are too entrenched to uproot. We need to focus on the places the battle is winnable first. Then if we succeed we can turn to the South.
Fascism is a cancer. If you don't cut off the necrotic, metastisized flesh, it will infect and kill the whole host.
I'd rather blue states direct their tax dollars into programs to help political refugees escape red states. Red states are welcome to do the same and use their own funds to get the fascists out of here. They can frame it as "Christian refugees", idgaf as long as it removes the cancer
At this point, I support just dissolving the US completely. The Constitution you learned about in school is dead and buried, and John Roberts killed it. Every four years we now hold an election for national dictator. This nation just isn't worth saving. It had a good run, but frankly, we can do better. We can write far better constitutions than what the Founding Fathers managed. We have a lot more experience and a lot more examples to draw from.
I support granting all 50 states independence. Then they can come back together into whatever new nation or nations they want to form. The US as a functioning democracy no longer exists. We're just playing pretend that we still live in the same nation.
So very agreed.
You can't help people who don't want help. And a large portion of the South not only doesn't want help, but inflicts harm on the rest of the US. It's fixable but not near term.
Well ackhshually - a neighbourhood with wood fired pizza & craft beers is definitely better in my book than one without. It's just quality of life innit ?
And I am sure you can find both in all the red states. Fuck, Austin alone would probably give all the west coast a good run for its money.
You have clearly not been to the west coast.
If we’re restricting the competition to craft beers and wood-fired pizza, Austin is not running at any competitive disadvantage. They will go hard.
If you want to open the field to, say, west coast fresh variety, with your Cambodian-Somali fusion cuisine and sushi etc, then you have to answer some difficult questions about barbecue as well.
I am ready for this competition.
My neighborhood is better because it has brick oven pizzerias and craft breweries.
I'm in Atlanta.
Ima be real not that many people in the south fight any of the policies, most peoole here don't give a shit or make excuses for why the policies aren't actually that bad. Plus the truth is people do vote for this shit, look at kerville in tx they denied help from the federal government cause it was woke and all that now they are suffering the consequences. Of course not every person in the south is some far right nuthead but ima be real they are the majority hence why it is the way it is here.
As long as the people in charge of those states continue to implement regressive policies - including voter disenfranchisement - yes, I will write them off.
Once the people in charge of those states either do a complete 180 (ha, right), or are removed from any position of power (by any means) and replaced with progressives, then we can talk.
Decries marginalization by other marginalized groups.
Closes with ironically tone-deaf fuckstick yap that undermines initial point.
Typical. 🤦🏼♂️
Does no one even grasp the definition of "logical fallacy" anymore? Fuck.
That requires an education system that hasn't been forced into failing generations of people.
I have to protect my own state from red states, and help you idiots out too? Nah fuck you we are no longer in this together
As someone who lives in a southern state, there's a bunch of us that hate the shit here. Please move here and help us outnumber the others.
Sorry, I already had to flee a southern state when you rat bastards decided to take my civil rights away. You're on your own. At this point I'm in favor of just dissolving the US completely, granting all 50 states full independence, and letting them come together in whatever new nation or nations they wish to form.
You are no longer my countrymen.
They had their chance in the 1860s, they had their chance in the 1960s, at what point do you give up giving them more chances and write the whole thing off as a bad job.
Lol somebody’s man. This reads like a low-effort version of Sweet Home Alabama, a song written because Neil Young’s Southern Man dared to politely ask the souther states to be better during a time of bonkers racism.
As others have said, it’s not the fucking pizza and you know it.
all 63 comments