you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 1 point 10 hours ago (2 children)

I'm not sure anyone has a good solution (though we'll see if our PM's plan to end homelessness works/helps) but I will absolutely grant that it feels like my city/province's (Vancouver/BC) progressive policies have made things worse.

We tried decriminalizing small amounts of drugs, the most noticeable effect of which was folks doing drugs wherever, which seems to have led to more ugly confrontations and bad scenes. One of our friends lived near a safe injection site and after some very unpleasant experiences she finally moved from a place that she'd loved because coming home was getting way too sketchy.

As a guy, I'm less worried about my physical safety so I'm personally less bothered by that. Selfishly, the ones that frustrate me are the multiple open air bike chop shops run with impunity. Infuriatingly, there's one usually running by some of our supportive housing.

I don't know that conservatives have an answer but it's an issue where it feels like a lot of progressive policies have either made it worse or done nothing to make it better. It got to the point where even my wildly progressive city elected a conservative city hall pretty much on a law and order campaign. They didn't do much on the issue (and have thankfully been turfed out) but I get why Vancouverites were so frustrated that we were willing to try a conservative government.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 2 points 7 hours ago (1 child)

    Thanks for providing context, I see your point a bit better now. However, I think a large effect is that with decriminalization problems become more visible, not necessarily increase per se.

    One of our friends lived near a safe injection site ...

    I mean of course here the problem is the injection site. If you didn't allow it, there would be less problematic people around. This is why no one wants to live close to a rehab center or homeless shelter. But the injection sites come necessarily with decriminalization policy, and they have to be located somewhere. The goal is to reduce overall harm, and that's very difficult to see if it means your local area gets more shady.

    I don’t know that conservatives have an answer

    Their answer typically is more policing, harsher penalties and drive problems out of sight. This plays to the hands of organized crime and makes it difficult to seek help as an addict. Frankly, to the majority of the public this probably works well enough, since the problems are cleaned out somewhere where they can't see them.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 1 point 4 hours ago* (last edited 4 hours ago)

    However, I think a large effect is that with decriminalization problems become more visible, not necessarily increase per se.

    I think it's both. Existing problems have become more visible but also spreading out beyond the area upon which we'd all given up (Hastings) has definitely created new problems. Having spread injection sites and allowing drug use wherever, what was the main entertainment strip has, at times, looked like a war zone. Literal shit on the streets and sidewalks in major areas is a fairly new problem.

    A heartbreaking example is an elementary school downtown by a field where a lot of drug users hang out. (I play in a coed soccer league at that park, the girls have for years refused to change in change rooms as they're usually shooting galleries, and occasionally, a prostitute's working space.) Parents have been complaining after "a series of concerning incidents involving people carrying knives, drug use, and passed-out individuals near the schoolyard.... The group outlined repeated incidents of open drug use, off-leash dogs, coyote sightings, and the presence of human feces and drug paraphernalia on school grounds... A deceased body wasn't even completely tented off in the park before school hours last month — children saw it on their walk to school"

    Those are new problems and just not shit that should be inflicted upon children.

    But the injection sites come necessarily with decriminalization policy, and they have to be located somewhere. The goal is to reduce overall harm, and that’s very difficult to see if it means your local area gets more shady.

    Unfortunately, most of downtown, except for the obscenely wealthy parts, have become intolerably shady. At some point, there's a trade-off where everyone else's standard of living has to be considered. Weighing lives against standards of living is tricky but, as someone who assiduously avoids sweatshop clothes, I always get annoyed when someone starts to lecture about how no price is to high for other people to endure to save a drug user's life while they themself are wearing child slave made clothes,.

    Their answer typically is more policing, harsher penalties and drive problems out of sight.

    The truce we'd had until our recent spate of progressive policies was a few blocks of the city was widely understood to be drugtopia. Police dealt in those very concentrated few blocks, social services were clustered, and outside of the occasionally bewildered tourist who stumbled two blocks the wrong way, most non drug folks stayed away. (Unless you're going to a concert at the Rickshaw because fuck yeah.) But, progressive ideals, like the desire for more injection sites and "reducing the stigma of drug use", all done with the **best ** of intentions, have made things substantially worse. To the point where our comically progressive city voted by an almost 2:1 margin to for "strengthening [Vancouver] laws to forbid open-air hard drug (Heroin, Meth, Fentanyl, and Crack) use in public spaces." Even my neighbourhood, Grandview Woodland, the hippiest, most progressive part of the city baaaarely voted against it.

    I dunno, especially when we read about some absurd percentage of the property crimes being committed by the same few dozen addicts, they start to make a pretty compelling case for involuntary treatment etc.

    All of this to say, there are issues where I don't think progressives have it entirely right. I think there are many more that conservatives have wrong but...

    Edit: Okay, thinking about the plebiscite made me curious as there was also a question about involuntary treatment... It passed by huge margins overall (68% to 32%) but surprisingly, even in my neighbourhood and other progressive strongholds.

  • source
  • parent