▲ 388 ▼ Dwarf Planets are people too (files.catbox.moe) submitted 7 months ago by Gork@sopuli.xyz to c/science_memes@mander.xyz 27 comments fedilink hide all child comments
[–] Apepollo11@lemmy.world 0 points 7 months ago (3 children) I'd be happy with: Pluto = planet Anything smaller than Pluto ≠ planet Nine planets. Now with clear non-stupid rules. permalink fedilink source parent hideshow 3 child comments replies: [–] Semjeza@fedinsfw.app 1 point 7 months ago (2 children) The arbitrary cutoff size being to ensure continuity of the scientific consensus in popular awareness when I was a child isn't a stupid rule. Not even when a larger kuiper belt object is found. Not even, when since mass is the primary means of estimating size until we fly a probe out there, we estimate a smaller but much with much more mass object to be larger and we debate a 10th planet yet again. permalink fedilink source parent hideshow 2 child comments replies: [–] Apepollo11@lemmy.world 1 point 7 months ago* (last edited 7 months ago) (1 child) Hey, if we find something bigger than Pluto, then by all means let's call it a planet. By any reasonable person's definition of a planet, Pluto is a planet. It's a rocky spherical mass that orbits the sun, with a varied terrain of mountains, plains and glaciers. It has days and seasons. It has its own system of moons. An additional grievance I have is that, by the IAU's stupid definition of a Dwarf Planet, Charon should really be called a dwarf planet too. It isn't a satellite of Pluto in a meaningful sense - both Pluto and Charon orbit a point between them. The other moons also orbit this space between Charon and Pluto. So, want to know why it isn't a Dwarf Planet? Because the IAU class it as a planetary satellite. What's the formal definition of a planetary satellite then? There isn't one. It was discussed, but a formal definition was not decided upon. Charon is literally a moon now because it was called a moon before the definition of a planet was changed and dwarf planets were invented. I'm all for formal definitions, but the IAUs current rules are just really sloppy. It's maddening. permalink fedilink source parent hideshow 1 child comment replies: [–] Semjeza@fedinsfw.app 1 point 7 months ago You're not wrong, but I've also seen people calling Pluto-Charon binary dwarf planets. But yes, the IAU tends to only pin down definitions when one is becoming unworkable - in this case the ever larger numbers of trans-Neptune objects that were potential planets. permalink fedilink source parent
[–] Semjeza@fedinsfw.app 1 point 7 months ago (2 children) The arbitrary cutoff size being to ensure continuity of the scientific consensus in popular awareness when I was a child isn't a stupid rule. Not even when a larger kuiper belt object is found. Not even, when since mass is the primary means of estimating size until we fly a probe out there, we estimate a smaller but much with much more mass object to be larger and we debate a 10th planet yet again. permalink fedilink source parent hideshow 2 child comments replies: [–] Apepollo11@lemmy.world 1 point 7 months ago* (last edited 7 months ago) (1 child) Hey, if we find something bigger than Pluto, then by all means let's call it a planet. By any reasonable person's definition of a planet, Pluto is a planet. It's a rocky spherical mass that orbits the sun, with a varied terrain of mountains, plains and glaciers. It has days and seasons. It has its own system of moons. An additional grievance I have is that, by the IAU's stupid definition of a Dwarf Planet, Charon should really be called a dwarf planet too. It isn't a satellite of Pluto in a meaningful sense - both Pluto and Charon orbit a point between them. The other moons also orbit this space between Charon and Pluto. So, want to know why it isn't a Dwarf Planet? Because the IAU class it as a planetary satellite. What's the formal definition of a planetary satellite then? There isn't one. It was discussed, but a formal definition was not decided upon. Charon is literally a moon now because it was called a moon before the definition of a planet was changed and dwarf planets were invented. I'm all for formal definitions, but the IAUs current rules are just really sloppy. It's maddening. permalink fedilink source parent hideshow 1 child comment replies: [–] Semjeza@fedinsfw.app 1 point 7 months ago You're not wrong, but I've also seen people calling Pluto-Charon binary dwarf planets. But yes, the IAU tends to only pin down definitions when one is becoming unworkable - in this case the ever larger numbers of trans-Neptune objects that were potential planets. permalink fedilink source parent
[–] Apepollo11@lemmy.world 1 point 7 months ago* (last edited 7 months ago) (1 child) Hey, if we find something bigger than Pluto, then by all means let's call it a planet. By any reasonable person's definition of a planet, Pluto is a planet. It's a rocky spherical mass that orbits the sun, with a varied terrain of mountains, plains and glaciers. It has days and seasons. It has its own system of moons. An additional grievance I have is that, by the IAU's stupid definition of a Dwarf Planet, Charon should really be called a dwarf planet too. It isn't a satellite of Pluto in a meaningful sense - both Pluto and Charon orbit a point between them. The other moons also orbit this space between Charon and Pluto. So, want to know why it isn't a Dwarf Planet? Because the IAU class it as a planetary satellite. What's the formal definition of a planetary satellite then? There isn't one. It was discussed, but a formal definition was not decided upon. Charon is literally a moon now because it was called a moon before the definition of a planet was changed and dwarf planets were invented. I'm all for formal definitions, but the IAUs current rules are just really sloppy. It's maddening. permalink fedilink source parent hideshow 1 child comment replies: [–] Semjeza@fedinsfw.app 1 point 7 months ago You're not wrong, but I've also seen people calling Pluto-Charon binary dwarf planets. But yes, the IAU tends to only pin down definitions when one is becoming unworkable - in this case the ever larger numbers of trans-Neptune objects that were potential planets. permalink fedilink source parent
[–] Semjeza@fedinsfw.app 1 point 7 months ago You're not wrong, but I've also seen people calling Pluto-Charon binary dwarf planets. But yes, the IAU tends to only pin down definitions when one is becoming unworkable - in this case the ever larger numbers of trans-Neptune objects that were potential planets. permalink fedilink source parent