[–] 16 points 4 weeks ago* (last edited 4 weeks ago)

You did not actually follow the terms, though. It's trivial to extrapolate the data and compare to population sizes. Using the latest data and napkin math, over 51% of people total disapprove of the dissolution of the USSR, and we also know that those who lived in socialism tend to rate it higher based on separate polling targeting age groups, so it's logical to assume this number is a lowball.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 20 points 4 weeks ago (11 children)

    Socialism is a transition between capitalism and communism where social ownership is the rising aspect of society and the working class runs the state. Communism is a fully collectivized global economy. Neither socialism or communism require everyone to be "good."

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 20 points 4 weeks ago* (2 children)

    Cool, now break it down by population totals rather than pretending each country has an equal population. Further, it's important to separate those raised before and after the dissolution of socialism, not just looking at population totals, where later polls have more people born after the dissolution and more people who lived in it dead and no longer able to answer.

    The USSR was not a "Russian Empire," lmao.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 9 points 4 weeks ago

    I argue that class is inevitable under any form of administrative government. the goal is to tie ultimate power to the will of the people.

    Then you're disagreeing with the way all Marxists and even liberal academics define class: which is relation to production, and you're also completely wrong that power is divorced from production, or surplus value.

    The differerence between capitalist and socialist countries is the control over this surplus. US capitalists control production, the surplus, and have a puppet government enact their interests against those of its workers. Its members unilaterally decide how to use that surplus.

    The PRC has the major key industries nationalized, and in that sector surplus can only be controlled by democratic decision-making, not the whims of private capital. No member of the NPC can unilaterally decide how to use that surplus in the same way a private capitalist in the US can.

    A limited, restricted private sector of capitalists also exists, but they do not stand above political power, have no enshrined rights, and must follow the dictates of the worker state.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [+] -9 points 4 weeks ago* (3 children)

    Fine. I'll do it for you. From your source. Checks support your assertion, Xs do not.

    ✅A 2013 Gallup survey showed that 66% of Armenians thought the dissolution of the USSR was harmful, the highest of any country surveyed

    ❌A 2013 Gallup survey showed that 31% of Azerbaijanis thought the dissolution of the USSR was harmful, compared to 44% who thought it was beneficial.

    ✅Belarus is complicated but currently leans your way

    ❌In a 2017 survey, 75% of Estonians said the dissolution of the USSR was a good thing, compared to only 15% who said it was a bad thing

    ❌A 2013 Gallup survey showed that 33% of Georgians thought the dissolution of the USSR was harmful, compared to 37% who thought it was good.... Other polls mentioned, same results

    🟰2013 Gallup survey showed that 25% of Kazakhs thought the dissolution of the USSR was harmful, compared to 45% who thought it In a 2016 survey, around 60% of Kazakhs above the age of 35 believed life was better under the USSR.

    ✅2013 Gallup survey showed that 61% of Kyrgyz thought the dissolution of the USSR was harmful, compared to 16% who thought it was beneficial.

    ❌ In a 2017 Pew survey, 30% of Latvians said the dissolution of the USSR was a bad thing, while 53% said it was a good thing.

    ❌In 2017, Pew survey showed that 62% of Lithuanians believed the dissolution of the USSR was a good thing, compared to 23% who said it was a bad thing.

    ✅ A 2013 Gallup survey showed that 42% of thought the dissolution of the USSR was harmful, compared to 26% who thought it was beneficial.

    ✅ A 2013 Gallup survey showed that 52% of Tajiks thought the dissolution of the USSR was harmful, compared to 27% who thought it was beneficial.

    ❌ A 2013 Gallup survey showed that only 8% of Turkmen thought the dissolution of the USSR was harmful, the lowest of any country surveyed, compared to 62% who thought it was beneficial.

    ❌ A September–October 2022 poll by the Razumkov Center found that nearly 90% of Ukrainians did not want to restore the USSR.

    ❌ However, in 2016, only 4% of Uzbeks believed life was better under the USSR.

    ✅ And Russians do in fact want their empire back.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 9 points 4 weeks ago (10 children)

    Capitalists do not merely "hold the levers of production," they outright own it. My entire point is that control and ownership are different. I am not contradicting myself in any way, it is your point that any grouping of people whatsoever is a class.

    Socialist democracy does not remove the ability for people to hold administrators accountable. You invented this.

    Administrators are a type of worker, not a class. Power is held by the working class as a whole, not merely administrators. Administrators serve a specific function in large organizations of people, not a class in and of themselves. Socialist democracy begins from the people, not the party. The role of the party is in guiding the working classes as fellow workers, not as commanding the working classes from above.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 8 points 4 weeks ago (1 child)

    I propose a system that puts a percentage of plumbers into the halls of government equal to their percentage in the population. same with scientists, and psychologists, and doctors, and electricians, and mechanics, and fry cooks, and teachers, and cashiers, etc.

    How do elections work in Vietnam?

    What you describe of people from every profession being involved in government is essentially how the Vietnam Fatherland Front works. It's composed of 44 member organizations, primarily unions, a broad cross section of society that anyone can easily be a part of, and they conduct oversight over Vietnam's elections. The actual administration of the government is done by elected officials, who do not have to be members of the Communist Party, or the Fatherland Front. It's similar to what you proposed, except more democratic, since the cross section of society that makes up the Fatherland Front only oversees the elections, while policy is decided through the elections themselves. Even if you claim that the Fatherland Front secretly manipulates the outcomes, the system you're proposing seems to be one where something like the Fatherland Front would rule outright. The only thing missing is the element of randomness, which only makes the people making decisions less accountable and leaves the possibility of someone who's views don't represent what the people want getting into power.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [+] -7 points 4 weeks ago (11 children)

    then capitalists holding the levers of production doesn't necessarily make capitalists a class. you're deluding your own definitions.

    "Administrators share the same class interest with other workers: collectivization of the means of production and distribution."

    • removing the ability for the people to hold the administrators accountable is divorcing the workers from ownership over the means of production.

    "You have invented the idea of unilateral control, and have invented the idea that the working classes as a whole do not participate in mass democratization of society in unitary socialist democracies."

    • you have no adequately demonstrated how the vector of power points from the workers down to the administrators in unitary socialist democracies.
  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 3 points 4 weeks ago

    widely condemed by both China and the Soviet Union as a fascist masquerading as a comunist

    I don't think China did that, the MFA usually has a strict "non-interference in internal affairs" as per the five principles of peaceful coexistence. Deng met with Pol Pot multiple times in the 80s. When Vietnam invaded Cambodia in Dec 1978, China did a retaliatory 28 day invasion of Vietnam in Feb 1979. Kim Il Sung even had the Changsuwon palace ready for Prince Sihanouk to stay in during the coalition government insurgency against Vietnam.

    To my knowledge: China, Korea, and most of ASEAN at the time supported Pol Pot and the coalition government, while the the Warsaw pact countries (except Romania), Albania, Cuba, Vietnam, Laos, and the current Hun Sen government condemed Pol Pot. Romania and Yugoslavia stayed neutral. It was a fairly even split on the issue for communist countries.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 10 points 4 weeks ago (14 children)

    You can read Socialism in Power: On the History and Theory of Socialist Governance if you want to understand how socialist democracy actually works in real life. Recall elections are common protections, and candidates usually do not need to be approved by the communist party to be elected. This has varied throughout history, but in any case you are deeply misinformed, this isn't simple disagreement.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [+] -15 points 4 weeks ago (12 children)

    There is very big difference between socialism and communism. Communism is an idea and pretty idea but in this world it don't work because people are "not always good" and socialism is bad try to make communism.

  • source
  • [–] 13 points 4 weeks ago

    Wrong.

    Is China State Capitalist?

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 16 points 4 weeks ago (4 children)

    It does support it, check the "polling history" section. With few exceptions like Estonia, those with living memory of socialism support it. Socialism as it exists in the real world is a transitional system towards communism, the USSR was socialist, and did not reach communism as communism is a global system.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 9 points 4 weeks ago (12 children)

    Class is not "holding levers." I have established this over and over again. Shutting your eyes and ears and erasing the central role of ownership of the means of production and distribution does not make this fact go away. Administrators share the same class interest with other workers: collectivization of the means of production and distribution.

    You have invented the idea of unilateral control, and have invented the idea that the working classes as a whole do not participate in mass democratization of society in unitary socialist democracies. You have no coherent goal, nor plan to get there, all you have done is refuse to engage with the Marxist position on class.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] -5 points 4 weeks ago* (last edited 4 weeks ago) (15 children)

    "As for your bit on political parties, you’re continuing to argue against a caricature you invented in your head. Nobody has stated that elections must be controlled or exclusively of party membership. You have to argue against a strawman, because your point collapses when confronted with reality."

    • then please enlighten me how communist elections should work, because in China and the Soviet union candidates must be approved by the communist party.

    "Please be serious." you do not need to deride me just because we disagree. it shows a lack of maturity.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 15 points 4 weeks ago

    State ownership under a capitalist state is not socialism, correct. Private ownership under a socialist state is not capitalism either. You are entirely missing the point of Engels in Socialism: Utopian and Scientific. Socialism is a transitional mode of production and distribution between capitalism and communism, characterized by social ownership as the principal aspect, ie rising and dominant, aspect of the economy and the working class as in control of the state. Both apply to China right now. The path of socialist construction in China utilizes a Marxist understanding of economics that sees the material basis of markets as decentralized and underdeveloped production, and the material basis of planned economy as highly developed and centralized production.

    China maintains social ownership of the commanding heights of the economy which have already reached monopoly scale, and employs controlled marketization to accelerate the development of underdeveloped industry to create the basis for social ownership through development. The CPC stands at the top, a working class party with a strong basis in Marxism-Leninism with Xi Jinping Thought, and uses this dominance of the state to restrict the capitalists from forming a politically unified and coherent class that could undermine this socialist construction and derail it.

    Here's a diagram of that "stages of socialism:"

    They are currently developing towards the intermediate stage, with plans to reach it by 2049. That means they are already socialist, just developing towards higher stages of socialism.

    As for independent unions, why is the independence of a union from the socialist system a good thing? There is already a massive federation of trade unions, independence from this creates a fulcrum by which the capitalists could leverage against the system. You have a liberal idea of socialism that envisions it as just as disunified and disorganized as capitalism, but socialism is a process of collectivizing. Capitalists are barred from the highest levels of the CPC, and are prevented from ever having a large presence in it.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [+] -6 points 4 weeks ago (14 children)

    it completely creates a ruling class. the administrators hold the levers of government, irrefutably. and party administrators approved their candidates for elections. thus the ruling class chooses their members. that is a ruling class, even worse it is a ruling class with unilaterally controls over who in the nation can wield the levers of government.

    your idealist analysis of power divorces itself from the will the people.

    I argue that class is inevitable under any form of administrative government. the goal is to tie ultimate power to the will of the people.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 12 points 4 weeks ago (16 children)

    Regarding how advanced production needs to be for social planning, it must not be an impedement for production. Essentially, by the point that decentralized production has transitioned to monopoly, markets have played their role. That's why in a socialist country like China, the commanding heights are socially owned, while for developing industries these are privately owned to a large degree. At the monopoly level, privatization impedes progress.

    As for your bit on political parties, you're continuing to argue against a caricature you invented in your head. Nobody has stated that elections must be controlled or exclusively of party membership. You have to argue against a strawman, because your point collapses when confronted with reality.

    Please be serious.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • view more: ‹ prev next ›