Because the people widely supported the purges and Stalin himself, and Mao did not create the famine but instead responded to one, with the people widely supporting him.
comments
I have speed-read through this one and can affirm it, and I gave you added context when you brought out specific passages. I'm sorry, but sometimes you need to do in-depth study of a subject if you are to understand the whole. Read the entire section on the PRC, for example, it doesn't take long compared to the entire book.
Old Guard/corporate liberals, maybe.
Otherwise known as the big, historic players in the DNC.
"Liberal" is a pretty wide net that includes some people that fit your description and some people that do not.
I'm definitely not a fascist apologist, no.
One mod in the Memes community decided I'm an imperialist apologist because I said liberals like soviet bloc housing.
"What you are worried about is real too in a way, but it’s not a class. In a socialist state,"
- oh no, im not against socialism, im against non-representative governments. and this isn't hypothetical, we see it all over the world including the US right now with voter suppression and super PACs. I just argue that the single-party rule that many communists espouse is not a great solution to the ills of capitalism, which themselves are very real. I'm all for the state owning the means of production at what ever breadth is required to provide dignity, safety, and health to the people, but the people must wield ultimate power to turn the government without having to resort to violence.
It's almost as though you don't have anything worthwhile to say.
Shut up bubble boy!
- liberals, probably
And also other liberals.
fascist apologists like yourself have no place here. As usual, you lot are projecting a lot with the echo-chamber accusations. We can see your modlog dummy
Don't forget what they said earlier
I’m gonna just drop the truth nuke here so that I can get closer to my “banned from .ml award” quicker:
As usual, people with a lot of hate towards .ml reveal themselves to be chauvinistic and racist. EVERY TIME. Probably going to make a stink over on yet another .world feudposting about .ml and crying about how much of a victim they are.
"Managers in a McDonalds do not actually have the ability to sell or make total calls over what to do with it, the owners do. Administrators are similar, they are joint owners with the entire working class."
- why did no one recall stalin during his great purge, or Mao during the great famine?
If dissent in echo chambers is "prodding" and "trolling," I'm guilty as charged.
But that same kind of unwanted dissent in echo chambers saves a great many impressionable people from silly and awful lines of thought, including younger versions of myself, so I'm not planning on stopping.
If we were federated with fascist instances I'd be there telling them when they're wrong too.
your negative experiences here are from your deliberate prodding, cherrypicking and trolling by ignoring everything said to you.
nationalized industry under a capitalist mode of production just turns the state into a collective capitalist
Besides the fact that Engels saw "state capitalism" as he defined it as a positive, final stage of capitalism (he was wrong on that since the transition to socialism has always occurred in feudal countries, not in the core countries where capitalism is strongest, but that discussion is better suited to lemmygrad or hexbear), as Lenin and later socialist leaders noted, state capitalism has different potential definitions:
“For socialism is merely the next step forward from state-capitalist monopoly. Or, in other words, socialism is merely state-capitalist monopoly which is made to serve the interests of the whole people and has to that extent ceased to be capitalist monopoly”
- Marx
“The state capitalism, which is one of the principal aspects of the New Economic Policy, is, under Soviet power, a form of capitalism that is deliberately permitted and restricted by the working class. Our state capitalism differs essentially from the state capitalism in countries that have bourgeois governments in that the state with us is represented not by the bourgeoisie, but by the proletariat, who has succeeded in winning the full confidence of the peasantry.“
- Lenin
None of these socialist thinkers meant the term to be used in the ultraleft definition you're using, as a tool to demonize actually exist socialist states and decry them as "not socialist enough".
China's economy still runs on wage labor, commodity production, capital accumulation,
Good, developing the productive forces, building a thriving socialist market economy and putting that capital to use to serve the whole people, is the goal of every current socialist state.
massive billionaire class extracting surplus value
As I linked below, the PRC is a mixed economy, where the publicly owned and planned sector predominates, and there is also a restricted private / capitalist sector. I don't expect an ultraleft to be familiar with the "bargain" strategy, but having a capitalist sector within an overall planned economy, has resulted in the export of tech and production to China, with it becoming an economic powerhouse and primary trading partner for most of the world, and real wages rising 4x in the past 30 years alone. The limited and short term wage exploitation in the private sector (in reality, its a small expense to buy off private capital and keep them operating within the socialist legal framework), has under a socialist government resulted in those incredible economic gains, whereas the capitalist 3rd world is still writhing in poverty, and completely at the mercy of western finance capital.
Plus, you can't claim the working class controls the state when independent unions are banned, strikes are suppressed,
False. The PRC even supports more strikes than nearly any other country, which clearly irks the western finance rag I linked. Also, people don't have much reason to strike because of the people's congresses in nearly every workplace, and the wages rising so much recently. They of course don't allow US-sponsored strikes and slowdowns, which do happen occasionally.
private CEOs literally sit in the national legislature
A small number of them do, which of course is a good thing if you want to make sure that they're working towards the betterment of the country, and to avoid them organizing an opposition. Regardless, they do not control the state, and capital has no enshrined rights, especially to organize.

If you're going to demonize socialist countries in the future, at least post sources for your claims.
you said you read it, you should be able to find the proof you say is in there easy. if you read it you likely already know what chapter it's in.
Maybe you could think about it like that: capitalists are the class that, in order to exist, is forced to continuously take capital and invest it to make profit or they are outcompeted by other capitalists. It's not that they are all evil or "corrupted by power", they are not just incentiveized, but forced to act in destructive ways: steal surplus value from workers, increase exploitation above what people can take, chase profits on an exponentially expanding mass of capital in a finite world destroying the planet, cause a crisis about every seven years, cannibalize their own state and infrastructure that they rely on for short term profit, etc.
They inevitably run into these contradictions due to living on a finite planet and having to put individual interests above all else while the modern economies distribution of work and global value chains absolutely require working together.
What you are worried about is real too in a way, but it's not a class. In a socialist state, a managerial part of the working class is not forced by competition to continuously pursue personal gain, but some of them still might become corrupt and do so anyway. At that point, they have betrayed the working class and they might even do so in favor of real capitalists domestic or abroad who haven't yet completely disappeared as a class. It's a possible problem, but other than the class conflict between workers and capital, it's not inevitably the dominating principle of society.
Rather than worrying about a hypothetical future betrayal of fellow workers in thriving and prospering China, we should focus on how many western workers have already often betrayed the rest of the global working class and continue to do so by supporting terrible imperialist wars, mostly in turn for cheap goods at Walmart.
I did, you didn't read it.
Managers in a McDonalds do not actually have the ability to sell or make total calls over what to do with it, the owners do. Administrators are similar, they are joint owners with the entire working class.
As for your second question, recall elections. Read the book.
"The only thing missing is the element of randomness, which only makes the people making decisions less accountable and leaves the possibility of someone who’s views don’t represent what the people want getting into power."
- hence the vote-of-not-confidence I suggested and the randomness is intended to keep one group from being over represented in government than it's demographic make-up in the populace. but yeah that sounds great. I'm not against socialism, I'm against unrepresentative forms of government and obviously a socialist nation can find ways to be more representative and ensure the power ultimately derives from the people. very cool, and thanks for sharing that!
Maybe you could link to your argument. If it's so interesting I would like to read it.
it's all right there in black and white.
show me a definitive source that shows soviet, Chinese, and DPRK elections did/do not need approval from their respective communist parties.
"Capitalists do not merely “hold the levers of production,” they outright own it. My entire point is that control and ownership are different."
- what is the difference? the qualifier of owning something is the sole right to manipulate that thing in anyway definition of own: https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/own
"Socialist democracy does not remove the ability for people to hold administrators accountable. You invented this."
- how to workers peacefully remove administrators they don't like at any level of the communist party strata without explicit approval from the communist party?
Communism has not existed yet, so I see no reason for you to believe it to be almost impossible to build.
Regarding the USSR, they pivoted to a system of approval voting. Candidates were selected through consensus, and voted on accordingly, rather than in contested elections.
Regarding the DPRK, candidates are selected through consensus, then approved or not.
Regarding the PRC, you are writing about an internal party election, rather than a broader societal election.
Please be serious and read the book, rather than quote farming. You're already misrepresenting and misinterpreting the book.
Socialism in Power: On the History and Theory of Socialist Governance:
Page# 178 - Soviet Union "The subsequent articles in this chapter spell out what each of these terms meant in practice, including the process of nominating candidates, who would come from “public organisations and societies of the working people: Communist Party organisations, trade unions, cooperatives, youth organisations and cultural societies” (Supreme Soviet 1936a, article 141, 1936b, stat’ia 141)."
Page# 181 - Soviet Union "The drive for electoral democracy did not long live up to its lofty aims, with the most embarrassing retreat being from multi-candidate contested elections to single-candidate elections. At the same time, there was an even greater effort to ensure democratic accountability through elections internal to the Party."
page# 208 - DPRK "there are also distinct emphases in light of the DPRK’s concrete conditions. In terms of electoral democracy: while there is only one decision-making body, the Supreme People’s Assembly (along with regional people’s assemblies), there is also the Democratic Front for the Reunification of the Fatherland. This is not a governing body per se, but it plays a crucial role in the electoral process. Made up of all political parties, mass organisations, and religious groups, it proposes multiple candidates, debates their suitability, and approves one candidate for elections."
Page# 379 - China "Election to the position of Party branch secretary takes place at a plenary or general members meeting, although the election also needs to be approved by the regional Party committee"