[–] 11 points 1 month ago (2 children)

We were discussing the eradication of absolute poverty, and went into what identified that and went into eradicating it. You return with a source on homelessness, which has the following to say:

Depending on how one defines homelessness, China has either a very tiny homeless population or an extremely large one. Compared to other countries, there very few vagrants: people living on the streets of China's cities without means of support. But if one counts the people who migrated to cities without a legal permit (hukou), work as day laborers without job security or a company dormitory, and live in overcrowded and unsanitary conditions on the edge of cities, there are nearly 300 million homeless.

Nobody denies the existence of underdeveloped housing in China. Calling them "homeless," however, is a stretch. The article itself identifies extremely low rates of vagrancy, which is much higher in capitalist countries. The ongoing development process in China now focuses on increasing the quality of housing and the availability of housing. What is not in question is that China consistently focuses on improving the lives of those most vulnerable in society, which does not improve at the snap of a finger, but through long development processes that drive real results.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [+] -11 points 1 month ago (5 children)

    and I find the implication that I must be Chinese and/or paid to talk about socialism

    Never claimed that. I am implying seeing what people say within this amazing country you are describing, of course ones that have found a VPN or something.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 12 points 1 month ago (6 children)

    No, and I find the implication that I must be Chinese and/or paid to talk about socialism seriously to be a pointless rhetorical dodge at best, and chauvanist at worst. If you cannot meaningfully engage with the discussion and would rather insult users while adding nothing of value, then I don't see why you don't have a better use of your own time elsewhere.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 8 points 1 month ago* (14 children)

    Mhm. Right, the evidence totally exists, you just "don't feel like showing it right now." And my girlfriend lives in Canada, that's why you never see her, no you can't see any evidence she exists, I just don't feel like showing you right now. Or ever.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [+] -10 points 1 month ago* (15 children)

    I don't feel like bringing evidence right now, I am having fun in these arguments. I also know I am not changing your opinion. I am not even that anti-communist, I am fine with siding with non-stalinist communists. Look around references in the wiki I mentioned before if you want evidence.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 11 points 1 month ago* (16 children)

    You asked someone earlier:

    How would I know you aren’t the one cherry picking?

    That's a great question. If we all just blindly believe whatever we feel is true, then there's no possible way to determine who's right and who's wrong. That's why it's important to ground your beliefs in evidence. Because that way, we can actually determine who's right and who's wrong.

    But there's clearly no point discussing anything with you, your views cannot be changed by evidence because they're not based on evidence. They're based solely on blind faith. They are fully unfalsifiable, and no matter what the world looks like in reality, there could never be any evidence that would change your mind. It's no different from arguing with a Flat-Earther.

    If you ever get tired of worshipping at the alter of anti-communist propaganda and decide to start basing your beliefs on evidence instead of faith, hmu and we can continue this discussion then.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 10 points 1 month ago (25 children)

    That's not how class works, or the state. Class is not merely a level of power, but a social relationship, to ownership of the means of production and distribution. In any given class society, this distributes society into two broad classes, with various subcategories. The state is a result of this class struggle, and represents the ruling class of society, based on which class owns the commanding heights of the economy.

    In socialism, the commanding heights are socially owned. Administrators do not have unique relations of ownership, but instead occupy socially necessary roles for the continuation of advancing production and distribution. In such a unified system, competing political parties do not at all prevent corruption, they enable it and accelerate it. The idea that decentralized competition in the political sphere is made to support a collectivized system is a bourgeois worldview of politics that sees the mechanisms of capitalism as eternal, rather than specific.

    Contrasting with capitalism, the competition in the political sphere is the competition of the ruling class, which does not seek collectivization but instead a bigger individual slice of the pie. Where socialist administrators seek further collectivization and unification, capitalist administrators represent this or that wing of the capitalist class, which all fights in unity to preserve private property, and against each other for a bigger slice of the pie.

    Socialist political parties are organizations of the most advanced of the working class politically. The most active, the most trained, the most developed. This does not make them a distinct class, this is a bourgeois view of class. Instead, it makes them occupy the social role of "proletarian intellectual" to borrow from Gramsci, which isn't a statement on intelligence at scale, but the social role they play in determining and shaping the thought of the entire proletariat as a class.

    How do you envision socialism, with multiple political parties, not devolving into factionalism and breaking-up of society in a manner that allows the bourgeoisie to resurge?

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [+] -11 points 1 month ago (17 children)

    Everyone's data on this sux. Not a representative of anything. Like the USSR once had a homeless rate of a grand total of zero because it was made illegal (I know I could bring the US or something into the example but it's actually funny seeing you get triggered by mention of the USSR). There are other biases like someone promising a bonus inside of the govt if there aren't any (reported) homeless people.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [+] -10 points 1 month ago* (last edited 1 month ago) (26 children)

    Ok, then marx bad too, single party rule is a horrible idea that consolidates power in a new class if elites.

    Your'e just trading capitalist robber barrons for party leaders, it's the same thing, different name.

    Rule of law should derive from mandate from he masses, not a small group of party officials or powerful politically aspiring billionaires.

    Single party rule is bad, two party rule is bad, the people should be represented by an amalgam of many varying policy views and have the ability to quickly remove politicians who fail to represent the people effectively.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 16 points 1 month ago* (27 children)

    No part of Leninism, in theory or practice, supports the idea of a single, near-totalitarian dictator. The term "dictatorship of the proletariat" originates in the era of Marx, and refers not to any individual dictator, but the working class itself as the rulers, makers, and dictators of society. The heads of state in socialist countries have all been selected with democratic processes, be they approval votes, votes based on elected delegates, etc. The heads of state have not had absolute power either, but instead often have less power than, say, the US head of state.

    The necessity of a single party is because socialism is, in effect, a unitary system meant to represent a single class, the working class. Democratic centralism does not mean the absence of democracy, but the absence of organized factionalism and opposition within the socialist system. The necessity of a single system was already present with Marx, the advance of the vanguard path to socialism by Lenin was made based on Marxist understandings of class and the state.

    If you believe Lenin is bad, then thinking Marx was good is hypocritical. Your issues with Lenin are based on a combination of sanitizing the views of Marx and accepting bourgeois misdirection about existing socialism as fact. If you truly believe Lenin was bad, then Marxism itself should also be seen as bad.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [+] -13 points 1 month ago* (last edited 1 month ago) (28 children)

    Depends on what you mean by communism, if you mean single party rule with a near totalitarian dictator at the helm then that is bad, but if you mean socialist policies that put workers well being at the forefront of government policy then that is good. Basically, marx good, lenin bad

  • source
  • [–] 12 points 1 month ago* (18 children)

    Lol, so you think any evidence that conflicts with your presumptions about reality is just fake.

    Even the fucking World Bank acknowledges that this data is accurate. Are you claiming they're faking numbers to make China look good? What, is George Soros behind it? How far does your conspiracy theory go?

    Maybe you should try basing your beliefs on evidence instead of propaganda and ignorant assumptions.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 4 points 1 month ago

    Glad you acknowledge it.
    Plenty here get real defensive for pointing that out.

    I guess we are slightly less indoctrinated into bootlicking the authoritarian state.
    We don't thank our regime troops for their service, our cops don't get free stuff in shops, etc...
    No comically large flags or killer jet fly overs at sports games either.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • view more: ‹ prev next ›