[+] -10 points 4 weeks ago (17 children)

"advanced enough to accommodate social planning, and administration needs to be advanced enough to facilitate it." -what qualifies as advanced enough? that is amorphous. "You keep separating the party from the people by erasing their shared relations to ownership of the means of production. The party is of, by, and for the working class, and is accountable to the rest of the working class." -no the party is separating the party from the people by removing any means of peaceful transition of power except through mandatory, open poll, party controlled elections of exclusively party members and through strict control of party membership.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 11 points 4 weeks ago

    Lenin established a socialist state, and Stalin was the second head of state in said socialist state. They did not reach communism, as communism must be global and fully collectivized, but they did reach socialism as a transitional state between capitalism and communism.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 11 points 4 weeks ago

    The transitional argument is that communism requires both highly developed productive forces, and collectivization of all of these highly developed productive forces. The socialist transitional period requires intense development of underdeveloped production, as well as building the necessary administration for planned economy, both of which take time.

    The idea of “bigdaddy” is nonsense, and isn’t found in either Marxism-Leninism in theory or in practice. There has not been a ceding of control to socialist leadership, but instead an expansion of democratization to the working classes, historically. The idea that MLs want a big strongman to push a button and delete all administration is a farce of both socialist construction and what communism looks like, as communism retains administration.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 8 points 4 weeks ago (15 children)

    No, this does not create "a new ruling class," nor do party leaders have sole discretion over who is in the party. Administration is labor, and creating an organization for such a task and the ideological components of socialism is not sufficient to create a ruling class. Administrators in socialism own just as much of the means of production and distribution as the rest of the working class, capitalists in capitalism directly own the means of production, even if managerial workers below them operate and control them.

    This is why your analysis falls apart, you have an idealist analysis of power that divorces itself from the material.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 12 points 4 weeks ago (18 children)

    Nobody is arguing for a party to have unilateral and unaccountable power. You are deeply confusing how unitary socialist democracy works by alienating the party from the rest of the people, and drawing a hard line between democratic participation in society and the party itself.

    Class is not shifting or amorphous. Class is a social relation to ownership of the means of production.

    1. Capitalists own the means of production individually.

    2. Workers sell their labor power.

    In socialism, workers jointly own the means of production.

    You are confusing the type of labor with class itself, which makes it amorphous.

    Transition is also not shifting or amorphous. Between capitalism, where there is privatized means of production, and communism, where all production is planned and socially owned, is a period where the means of production need to be advanced enough to accommodate social planning, and administration needs to be advanced enough to facilitate it.

    You keep separating the party from the people by erasing their shared relations to ownership of the means of production. The party is of, by, and for the working class, and is accountable to the rest of the working class.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [+] -7 points 4 weeks ago (16 children)

    you make the same mistake again, creating a single party where the party leaders get to decide who is in the party simply creates a new ruling class. they control all the means of production, and if the party leaders are not beholden to the workers, that is totalitarianism. this same issue exists largely in the united states but we have two parties instead of one, and the wealthy largely control who is in power, this is equally as bad as a single party.

    I dont care to what level the state controls private property, I only care that if the state begins to abuse that power, the workers can intervene and stop them.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 19 points 4 weeks ago (1 child)

    My wife grew up in a post-communist Eastern Europe. I’ll tell you who hates communism more than Republicans, people who lived under it.

    yeah people who were born and lived in a country without communism and going through capitalist plunder sure do think it's communism's fault.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 10 points 4 weeks ago* (last edited 4 weeks ago) (17 children)

    The reason I am telling you that classes are not simply any way we can categorize people but instead have specific relations to ownership of the means of production and distribution is because I am explicitly agreeing with Marx that the history of class society is the history of successive societies of 2 broad classes in conflict, defined by their relationship to ownership of the means of production and distribution.

    Plumbers are not a class. Managers are not a class. Both are workers, and share the same relation to ownership of the means of production. Power is not the enemy, the system that divides us based on ownership is.

    The rest of your comment is a ridiculous strawman of a party that is unaccountable and that dominates all. Nowhere in socialist history has this happened in practice or in theory. The working class as a whole decides who should be in the party and government. The party is a subset of the working class, with the same social relations to the means of production and distribution. You are arguing against a caricature.

    As for revolution, it's the only way to change a state historically.

    As for "mixed economies," all economies are "mixed" today. What separates them is their principal aspect, and the class in control of the state.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [+] -12 points 4 weeks ago* (19 children)

    I simply argue that a single party with unilateral control creates a totalitarian dictatorial state. and totalitarian states lead to accelerated suffering.

    I also argue this is true for two party systems. and proposes a system based on demographic representation with a safe guard to remove bad actors from political power. under my proposal, the state could choose to take control over the means of production if enough people chose. I welcome new forms of political ideas, not single minded adherence to party dogma.

    and 'waxing poetic' would require me to be much less specific than I have been.

    you are waxing poetic with these strange, shifting and amorphous ideas of "class", and "transitional periods" while providing no concrete roadmap for how unilateral single party control of a state elevates the workers to control over the means of production.

    in reality it simply shifts control over the means of production to cronyism. single-party rule creates a party-class and a working class, and the party-class is in no way beholden to the working class.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 8 points 4 weeks ago* (1 child)

    Always love knowing I can drop a comment with minimal context and I got shooters out here that will pick up on the context for others. I couldn’t have explained this better myself, though I didn’t expect the pol pot one to be the bait. I should have put Che / Cuba or Sankara / Burkina Faso but the intention of my comment remains the same. You are absolutely correct.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [+] -8 points 1 month ago (22 children)

    your'e the one saying 'power is not class' I disagree, I say dividing people by the power they have inherently creates classes, which is why I suggest a lottery to divide that power equally among the demographic makeup of a nation. how are plumbers not a class if they control the means that create and maintain the plumbing industry? its all still a class. I propose a system that puts a percentage of plumbers into the halls of government equal to their percentage in the population. same with scientists, and psychologists, and doctors, and electricians, and mechanics, and fry cooks, and teachers, and cashiers, etc. the

    government should be made up of people. I reject the idea that certain groups of people among us are more fit to govern, particularly when that system removes demographics of largely under-represented groups and replaces it with more affluent individuals.

    revolutions are a last resort, the people deserve a means to change their government without violence.

    there is no generic state? only socialist and capitalist? have you heard of mixed economies?

    "A truly democratic society is one where the working class as a whole is organized and capable of electing the best among themselves to higher organs,"

    • who decides who is the best among you? the party leaders already in power according to single party rule. that is why I propose a ranked choice vote of those individuals selected from the lottery based on their policy proposals.

    "You are explicitly rejecting a competency-based"

    • no, I am explicitly rejecting the idea that the party in power is selecting the most competent. rather they are picking their friends and family or who ever can pay more in money or quid pro quo.

    my electoral process removes money and nepotism from the equation by selecting individuals first from the general population, then allowing them to come up with policy proposals then allowing their constituents to elect them in a ranked choice vote. no campaigns means no campaign finance, no special interested counter funding candidates, no political parties platforming their insiders.

    persons selected from the lottery will post their policy proposals on the same election website as every other candidate, debates will be organized by the election office and all candidates would be present.

    " This can be organized via a single political party, that being the organization of the most politically developed of the working class."

    • who decides who is the most politically developed of the working class? the party, thus nepotism, not a mandate of the masses
  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] -4 points 1 month ago (2 children)

    It's not your average user's fault for not knowing, but some moderators definitely over-reach with removing and banning.

    Last week I caught a ban for being a "troll" from the Memes community here for saying that liberals generally like Khrushchevkas (AKA Soviet Bloc apartments) and cite them as one of the things the USSR did right.

    You don't see the bans and removals because the people and their posts are gone.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 11 points 1 month ago* (27 children)

    You're doing the thing. You're opening the interaction pre-aggrieved and from a self-imposed prone position, awaiting the boot. Just relax, man. Most groups of people, anywhere in the world, are very chill if you don't approach them aggressively, or in this case passive-aggresively.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 13 points 1 month ago* (20 children)

    No? The transitional argument is that communism requires both highly developed productive forces, and collectivization of all of these highly developed productive forces. The socialist transitional period requires intense development of underdeveloped production, as well as building the necessary administration for planned economy, both of which take time.

    The idea of "bigdaddy" is nonsense, and isn't found in either Marxism-Leninism in theory or in practice. There has not been a ceding of control to socialist leadership, but instead an expansion of democratization to the working classes, historically. The idea that MLs want a big strongman to push a button and delete all administration is a farce of both socialist construction and what communism looks like, as communism retains administration.

    Utopia is also not promised, Marxists rail against utopianism.

    Please be serious here, throughout your comments here you've done nothing but demonstrate a lack of care for the subject matter and wax poetic about lottery-voting while ignoring the crux of the argument.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • view more: ‹ prev next ›