Meat has a bad reputation. Most people think of meat, especially red meat, as dangerously unhealthy. However, meat has unique properties that make it more nutritious, easier to digest, and less likely to irritate your body than vegetables. Does the science behind meat-phobia hold up under the microscope?

TLDR - Yes, meat is healthy - eat it.

top 98 comments

sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[–] 3 points 4 months ago* (9 children)

This post has gotten a lot of interesting discussion. The real world is so messy though.

Most of us don't have the willpower or desire to eat like the carnivores on the sub. They eat meat as fried chicken, cheese burgers, or pizza toppings with coke and alcohol etc.

So maybe we can say it's not a superfood for everybody.

  • source
  • hideshow 9 child comments
  • [–] [S] 3 points 4 months ago* (8 children)

    Most of us don't have the willpower or desire to eat like the carnivores on the sub. They eat meat as fried chicken, cheese burgers, or pizza toppings with coke and alcohol etc.

    I know you know better. Zero carb carnivore is not fried chicken, that has seed oil. It is not pizza, that has carbs. It is not a cheeseburger, that has buns. Sure, as hell is not Coke and alcohol. You have been stalking our community for long enough that you know zero carb carnivore is none of those things. To represent it as those things is disingenuous and quite frankly offensive. You know better

    maybe we can say it's not a superfood for everybody

    The meat is the superfood, every bad thing in your example was from the plants.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 8 child comments
  • [–] 3 points 4 months ago* (2 children)

    You have been stalking our community for long enough

    Nowadays, it's been one of my favorite ways to pass time 😆. These kinds of discussions are rare in other communities and they draw me in. I also used to watch modern day debate on YT a lot.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] [S] 2 points 4 months ago* (1 child)

    Have you found any good debates between doctors? I found a few but they were just talking past each other. A good faith debate would be interesting

    The closest I found was a neurosurgeon debating a naturopath but the naturopath didn't share their references before the debate, so it was kinda a waste of everyones time because they asserted things from their references and wouldn't budge so half the "debate" was the neurosurgeon saying "I haven't read that reference"

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 3 points 4 months ago

    The same one you posted in the community? Yea I didn't find any debates like that. It seems most of the diet people prefer making response videos.

    The ones I used to watch were mostly on religion, philosophy, and politics.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 3 points 4 months ago (2 children)

    Zero carb carnivore is not fried chicken, that has seed oil.

    yes. I'm not criticizing the ZC carnivore lifestyle. I'm questioning whether it can work out in a world full of hedonistic people. For example there are so many who know smoking or doing drugs is bad and still do it.

    The meat is the superfood, every bad thing in your example was from the plants.

    yea the way you eat it is probably healthy.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] [S] 2 points 4 months ago (1 child)

    I think it can work with hedonistic people, we have to make people aware they are being hedonistic, and they are carbohydrate addicts. It's just like alcohol addiction. They have to be supported, but they have to be aware they have a problem. Carbohydrates are so pervasive that most people don't even realize they're a bad thing, working against their health goals

    So yes, smokers, drugs, people know they're bad, you just need to bring the general level of nutritional knowledge up to that level. So people know that it's the plants that are causing their long-term problems, not the meat.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 3 points 5 months ago (6 children)

    are there any studies on the impact of a meat-only diet on the gut microbiome?

  • source
  • hideshow 6 child comments
  • [–] [S] 3 points 5 months ago (5 children)

    Sure are, here you go https://lemmy.zip/post/64353462

    TLDR - the gut is healthy and diverse.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 5 child comments
  • [–] 4 points 5 months ago (4 children)

    thanks! i found this:

    However, the beneficial effects appear to be dependent on broader lifestyle factors. Participants who followed a carnivore diet also simultaneously engaged in sufficient sleep, physical activity and stress management. This highlights that the carnivore diet in isolation is unlikely to be universally beneficial

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 4 child comments
  • [–] [S] 3 points 5 months ago (3 children)

    Our findings suggest that the carnivore diet could potentially have therapeutic relevance for gut barrier impairment or other forms of functional dysbiosis (Bischoff et al. 2014). However, the beneficial effects appear to be dependent on broader lifestyle factors. Participants who followed a carnivore diet also simultaneously engaged in sufficient sleep, physical activity and stress management. This highlights that the carnivore diet in isolation is unlikely to be universally beneficial and must be contextualized within an overall health-promoting lifestyle.

    You need to contextualize it!

    Ultimately, this study supports the growing notion that there is no universal dietary prescription for optimizing gut microbiota composition or function. In particular, our findings challenge the assumption that high dietary fiber intake is essential for a healthy microbiota, especially a highly diverse one

    I assume your initial question was about fibre - the point is you can have a diverse gut microbiota without fibre.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 3 child comments
  • [–] 3 points 5 months ago (2 children)

    yes. i'm re-thinking the "eat more fiber" propaganda

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] [S] 3 points 5 months ago

    yes. i’m re-thinking the “eat more fiber” propaganda

    Well, it's not really propaganda, it's just advice for a different metabolic context. Fibre is a anti-nutrient, it reduces what you absorb from food. If your eating bad food, like highly processed sugars/carbs then fibre is reducing the damage. Fibre also ferments in the gut producing some short chain fatty acids which do feed the gut, however in a ketogenic metabolism SCAFs are produced in the liver and get delivered to the whole body.

    So, in a high-carb highly-processed food context - fibre is a net positive because the food is so deleterious to health, and it does provide a tiny amount of SCFAs for people who are not in ketosis. The secret here is the standard diet is so bad (typically called SAD), almost any change will improve health.

    In a low-carb ketogenic diet with healthy food - fibre is unnecessary.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 3 points 5 months ago* (last edited 5 months ago)

    I'm not sure if it's propaganda either, it likely originated from the hypothesis Dr. Denis Burkitt had in Uganda where he observed that Africans eating high-fibre unrefined diets (likely high-carb low-fat in modern parlance) had stools that were bulkier and transited more rapidly compared to Westerners.

    https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2659900/

    In other words it was an observation. It was not controlled nor randomized and the fact that fibre has this huge health halo was in my opinion caused by the fact that processed foods such as oatmeal could then be marketed using fibre as a selling point.

    Even in this 2006 review we already had better studies showing that fibre had no positive health effects associated with colorectal cancer:

    The combined data showed no outcome difference between the intervention and control groups in the number of subjects with at least one adenoma or a new diagnosis of colorectal cancer. The Cochrane reviewers (7) concluded that there was no evidence from randomized controlled trials to suggest that increased dietary fibre intake would reduce the incidence or recurrence of adenomatous polyps.

    Nor was fibre clearly associated with positive effects in GI issues such as diverticular disease or irritable bowel syndrome.

    DD:

    In one of the first randomized, placebo-controlled trials of the role of bran in patients with DD (17), the authors concluded that dietary fibre supplements do nothing more than relieve constipation, and the impression that fibre helps DD is “simply a manifestation of western civilization’s obsession with the need for frequent defecation”.

    IBS:

    In practice, many patients with IBS complain of bloating with higher doses of natural fibre, likely due to bacterial fermentation producing short-chain fatty acids, increasing colonic gas and distension, and hence, aggravating IBS symptoms.


    Edit: figure it might help to put fibre stuff in one place. Here's the only study that I know of studying fibre and idiopathic (unknown medical causes) constipation: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3435786/

    TL;DR Idiopathic constipation and its associated symptoms can be effectively reduced by stopping or even lowering the intake of dietary fibre.

    Lastly, here's a wonderful talk by two experts, Dr Zoë Harcombe and Dr Peter Brukner on the topic.

    Apologies for writing a wall of text.

  • source
  • parent
  • [+] 6 points 5 months ago (79 children)
  • [–] [S] -1 points 5 months ago (78 children)

    wasn’t super bad for the environment

    Good news! Ruminant meat is part of the biosphere, and is essential in maintaining soil health.

    conceptually feed eight billion people a carnivore diet.

    Let's make progress, we don't have to worry about perfection right now, lets make sure everyone in the global south has access to at least one egg a day.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 78 child comments
  • [+] 4 points 5 months ago* (last edited 5 months ago) (77 children)
  • [–] [S] 4 points 5 months ago (76 children)

    Please add the rapid depletion of top soil to your list - which has a very sustainable solution that involves embracing the natural biocycle.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 76 child comments
  • [+] 3 points 5 months ago* (75 children)
  • [–] [S] 3 points 5 months ago (74 children)

    Do you know how many resources the world is spending taking care of nearly a billion type 2 diabetes every year? A sick population is a expensive population .

    Much less the absolute ecological insanity of suggesting a carnivore diet.

    It's a tool, a very powerful health tool, and should not be diminished or hidden from people for philosophical reasons.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 74 child comments
  • [+] 4 points 5 months ago* (last edited 5 months ago) (73 children)
  • [–] [S] 3 points 5 months ago* (72 children)

    I think there’s a false equivalence happening. Diabetes is not necessarily caused by a plant based diet or a reduced meat diet.

    Type 2 diabetes is caused by persistently elevated insulin over a long period of time, which happens because of persistently high blood glucose levels over a long period of time, which is caused by persistently high carbohydrate consumption over a long period of time. Carbohydrates only come from plants. So yes, Type 2 Diabetes is a plant based diet problem. To be fair, there are many whole food plant based diets that don't result in type 2 diabetes, but this is not a danger of a fully animal based eating pattern .

    Update - Technically there is a miniscule amount of carbohydrates in meat in glycogen stores, but not enough to matter.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 72 child comments
  • [+] 3 points 5 months ago* (last edited 5 months ago) (71 children)
  • [–] [S] 3 points 5 months ago* (last edited 5 months ago)

    When the body goes without carbohydrates for a long time, it switches to burning fat for fuel.

    Fun fact, we store fat for energy. When we sleep, between meals we are always burning fat. Babies burn fat for fuel all the tiem.

    to save what little glucose it has for the brain, the muscles temporarily become “insulin resistant.”

    Insulin resistant is the wrong term here, the body is not flooded with high levels of insulin in a fat metabolism. The proper term is glucose sparing, most of the body is going to burn fat for energy in this state with the major exception being red blood cells and about 5-15% of brain energy.

    fail a standard oral glucose tolerance test.

    Will fail a improperly administered oral glucose tolerance test, OGTTs must be primed for accuracy. The body's response to insulin is very sensitive, but the pancreas isn't maintaining a hot cache of insulin, because you arn't using very much insulin. We have discussed this in detail before https://lemmy.world/post/46537093 . This is normal, your body doesn't waste energy. This has no negative downsides because the pancreas will just make more glucose on demand when you consume carbohydrates and elevate glucose levels, and fill up the quick release cache.

    High intake of certain saturated fats can sometimes lead to an accumulation of fats inside muscle and liver cells (called intramyocellular lipids).

    Citation please - typically this condition is caused by super high elevated insulin levels and full fat cells (and the fat has nowhere to go) typically in a pre-diabetic state.

    This buildup can interfere with insulin signaling, potentially worsening cellular insulin resistance under the hood.

    The fat in the muscles wont cause insulin signaling issues, your confusing cause and effect. The fat is ectopically stored around the body BECAUSE of the elevated insulin. visceral fat, intramuscular fat is a hallmark of metabolic dysfunction caused by hyperinsulinemia. In fact this is EXACTLY how marbled meat is made in cows, they are forced to eat excessive carbohydrates leading to this very condition

    While a carnivore diet frequently causes a drop in blood sugar levels because you aren’t eating sugar, it does not automatically make someone immune to developing insulin resistance or diabetes over the long term.

    Citation please - How can a diet without elevated blood glucose, and thus without elevated insulin lead to a condition of carbohydrate intolerance (type 2 diabetes). I already addressed the failings of a unprimed OGTT above in the ketogenic post i linked .

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 2 points 5 months ago* (5 children)

    Is this LLM generated? As a quick test, tell me what insulin resistance is in 3 other words? And how would you correctly conduct an OGTT for someone fat adapted?

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 5 child comments
  • [+] 1 point 5 months ago* (last edited 5 months ago) (4 children)
  • [–] [S] 2 points 5 months ago

    It does generally mean a massive reduction in one’s environmental footprint at least in terms of feeding them.

    A single cow can feed a adult for over a year, on land that can't grow human edible crops.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 2 points 5 months ago* (2 children)

    See rule 6. Your account is also 8 days old. This is a small specialist community for the discussion of metabolic health, so please read the rules and keep in mind rule 4. If you do wish to cite studies and evidence, you should have read the papers you are citing and be willing to engage in good faith discussion.

    I don't consider LLM generated posts good faith discussion.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] [S] 2 points 5 months ago (63 children)

    Hey, please don't add substantive additions to a message after you sent it. I had missed your updates.

    eating a plant based or reduced meat diet doesn’t mean someone will develop diabetes. Your original statement was a false equivalence.

    I stand by what I said - type 2 diabetes is extremely expensive and is driven by the hyper-vegetarian food environment the world finds itself in. Yes a whole food plant based diet is less likely to develop T2D, but there are still fat vegans, so its not a guarantee.

    We shouldn’t be dragged down into the discussion equivalent of side quests when there’s a main quest to manage.

    Yes, people should not be afraid of meat and they should embrace it has a health tool.

    Once again the background to this discussion is essentially the apocalypse aka a serious mass extinction in which 70% to 99% of all life on earth dies. Even if you were completely right (which you aren’t) the trade-off just isn’t there.

    I disagree with your premise - right now 20% of the world calories from from animals, with human ingenuity we can increase this... but the real plague is metabolic impairment and while carnivore is probably the single most power tool here, it isn't the only tool - getting most people into a low carb or ketogenic state is going to be a massive improvement, and carnivore as a health tool can be used for people who still have issues (mostly gut issue, autoimmune, etc)

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 63 child comments
  • [–] 2 points 4 months ago (3 children)

    right now 20% of the world calories from animals

    Where did you get that number? Our world data says it's more like 5%.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 3 child comments
  • [–] [S] 3 points 4 months ago (2 children)

    Honestly, do you think 5% sounds anywhere near accurate? Does that reflect your observations as a human? The people around you? Please apply some critical thinking to the things you read

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 3 points 4 months ago (1 child)

    It's hard to decide just based on my observations. I've travelled quite a bit.

    In the west we can easily see 20-40% of calories coming from meat. But many people in the east like China and India eat meat only occasionally—like once a week.

    So who knows it probably brings down the average to 5%?

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] [S] 3 points 4 months ago

    One problem with the our would in data graph is its calories from protein. Animal sourced foods include fat too, which is actually the bulk of the calories.

    Honestly, lots of our world in data graphs are problematic, I wouldn't recommend using them as a primary source.

    But yes, 20% of human energy is derived from animal sources (well 18% but 20 is easier to say), africa the least as you surmised.

    https://doi.org/10.1080/23308249.2022.2124364 - Contribution of Fish and Seafood to Global Food and Feed Supply: An Analysis of the FAO Food Balance Sheet for 2019

    Globally, animal food products supplied 18.0% of total calorie intake, 39.9% of total protein supply, and 44.2% of total fat supply; terrestrial meat represented the largest source of animal protein consumed (44.1% total animal protein intake), followed by milk (25.9%), fish and seafood (16.5%), and eggs (9.2%; Table 1). Fish and seafood supplied 6.6% of total animal calorific supply, 16.5% of total animal protein supply and 3.1% of total animal fat supply on a global basis (Table 1); freshwater fish supplying over 43.0% of total fish and seafood animal protein supply, followed by pelagic fish (20.3%), demersal fish (15.0%), crustaceans (9.1%), other marine fish (6.0%), cephalopods (3.3%), other mollusks (3.3%) and other aquatic animals (0.4%; FAO 2022a)

  • source
  • parent
  • [+] 2 points 5 months ago* (58 children)
  • [–] [S] 3 points 5 months ago (2 children)

    Please stop adding content after you sent a message, I didn't see your update -

    Once again a plant based diet doesn’t infer people will develop diabetes in the same way a carnivore diet does not infer someone will not.

    You ABSOLUTELY will not develop type 2 diabetes eating zero carb.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] [S] 3 points 5 months ago (54 children)

    if it was 1% and causing the same ecological devastation it would still be the same problem

    The ecological devastation is coming from mono-cropping.

    Right now meat production is already too destructive.

    How is a cow eating grass, churning the soil, fertilizing the soil - destructive? This is how the soil was created in the first place.

    There’s a lot we can do like changing to more efficient sources such as specific insects, farmed fish, and poultry while avoiding meat sources such as cattle and pigs.

    Why are farmed fish and poultry ok but not ruminants? Ruminants have a super power - they can eat food humans can't eat, growing on land that can't raise human crops, and turn that into human usable fat and protein!

    Also lab grown meat could be a real silver bullet for the issue.

    Not really, it's a highly processed food composed of many things, but a mega-dose of seed oil (which is very not good for health).

    Generally speaking though we need to emphasize a plant based and reduced meat diet for the vast majority of the global population

    Why? People need to be health, meat is a super health food. People need to have a optimal metabolism, carbs and processed carbs and seed oils are antithetical to that. Healthy people eat less food, can eat local food that doesn't need to be shipped around the world, and don't need expensive chronic medical care.

    You keep doubling down on the false assumption that you can’t be low carb and plant based or mostly plant based.

    Oh I agree, you absolutely can do plant based keto, and that is much better then SAD (standard australian diet). This entire conversation is a huge WHATABOUTISM - remember the post is about the health benefits of eating meat.

    At this point it’s more of a cult than actually based on truth

    I think you will find the keto / zero carb communities extremely science based - self experiments, empirical validation, actually reading the literature.

    Sidebar I do understand the vast majority of what is in grocery stores in more developed countries is essentially carbs, processed oils, preservatives, artificial food colors and flavoring. I’m not advocating for a diet based on that in the way I think you think I am.

    Any change from the standard diet is a improvement. Our schism is over red meat .My understanding is I made a post about red meat being great, and we are talking about side things because in your estimate the world can't afford to provide meat for everyone. You have said some negative things about keto but haven't made your own dietary choices clear. Your advocating for a anti-red meat solution (which might include keto, you left the door open).

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 54 child comments
  • [+] 1 point 5 months ago* (last edited 5 months ago) (51 children)
  • [–] 3 points 5 months ago (49 children)

    You think the majority of food we are feeding cows is grass?

    yes. beef cattle graze for most of their lives, before being grain finished.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 49 child comments
  • [+] 1 point 5 months ago (48 children)
  • [–] 3 points 5 months ago (47 children)

    as I said, that's how most beef cattle are raised. I can't say about dairy.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 47 child comments
  • [+] 1 point 5 months ago (46 children)
  • [–] 3 points 5 months ago (44 children)
  • [+] 2 points 5 months ago (42 children)
  • [–] 3 points 5 months ago (41 children)

    i just can't imagine it's worth anyone's time. what i said is true, and easy to verify.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 41 child comments
  • [+] 1 point 5 months ago* (40 children)
  • [–] 3 points 5 months ago (39 children)
  • [+] 2 points 5 months ago* (last edited 4 months ago) (38 children)
  • [–] 1 point 5 months ago (37 children)

    you didn't link to anyone saying beef should be the primary source of calories for 8 billion people, because you can't, because no one said that.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 37 child comments
  • [+] 1 point 5 months ago* (36 children)
  • [–] 3 points 5 months ago (35 children)

    I've read every comment on this post.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 35 child comments
  • [+] 1 point 5 months ago (34 children)
  • [–] 2 points 5 months ago (33 children)

    first, the ecological argument is lacking in scientific rigor, so let's do away with that distraction.

    second, and more importantly, no one is saying that everyone should eat a carnivore diet.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 33 child comments
  • [+] 1 point 4 months ago* (last edited 4 months ago) (32 children)
  • [–] 2 points 4 months ago (31 children)

    I'm quite confident in my position, but if you are going to insist on making an ecological argument, cite something so we can evaluate it's methodology.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 31 child comments
  • [+] 1 point 4 months ago* (last edited 4 months ago) (30 children)
  • [–] 2 points 4 months ago* (29 children)

    I never suggested there aren't ecological problems. none of this shows that meat production is to blame

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 29 child comments
  • [+] 1 point 4 months ago (28 children)
  • [–] 3 points 4 months ago (11 children)

    Advocating for a carnivore diet is ecological madness, particularly a beef based diet when there are more ecologically friendly ways to achieve a carbohydrate deficient diet.

    these are the claims i'm telling you are not rigorously proven.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 11 child comments
  • [+] 1 point 4 months ago* (10 children)
  • [–] 2 points 4 months ago* (last edited 4 months ago) (2 children)

    it’s primarily caused by farming livestock

    cattywumpus, that is the crux of this ridiculously deep thread, as we keep trying to tell you. This is why [citation needed] exists on Wikipedia.

    Also, it's off-topic! The OP is about meat being a superior source of nutrition, and not about the ecology of producing meat. We have indulged you this once, but please stay on topic next time. One more time: c/carnivore is a community for metabolic health discussion.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [+] 1 point 4 months ago* (last edited 4 months ago) (1 child)
  • [–] 2 points 4 months ago

    We have addressed this point multiple times.

    You seem to have difficulty comprehending this, so for the last time, in very simple words: unhealthy people cost society a lot of money. We are living proof of zero carb's effectiveness. I was pre-diabetic. Everyone on Dave Mac's channel No Carb Life (@zerocarb) had a health problem that was put into remission with zerocarb.

    I'm afraid I will have to put you into time-out if you insist on bringing up points that we have brought up before, because this discussion has become meaningless. I'd lock this thread if I could.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 2 points 4 months ago* (last edited 4 months ago) (6 children)

    i'll tell you what: i opened every one of those links, then i went ahead and started clicking through to the actual papers. when you can present a peer reviewed study and explain how the methodology led to the conclusion you are making here, i'll be happy to discuss that paper (or all of them. i think you'll find that the gish gallop of links you dropped here actually draw on about 12 different studies, but most of them rely heavily on poore-nemecek 2018, so you could start there if you like.)

    edit: a word of warning. the earth.org link is a mess. i was able to find most of the other papers, but i doubt you're going to find that to be a worthwhile or even fruitful venture. sticking with the stanford link should still glean you about 6 or 7 papers we can evaluate together.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 6 child comments
  • [–] 2 points 4 months ago (1 child)
  • [–] [S] 2 points 4 months ago*

    jesus. here’s how i spent the last 20 minutes.

    The person your talking to hasn't read their own sources, wont read them, uses a "fast" llm to generate "whataboutisms", and will pivot the conversation as soon as you nail anything down. They WANT to burn you out with asymmetric effort.

  • source
  • parent
  • [+] 1 point 4 months ago* (3 children)
  • [–] 2 points 4 months ago*

    We want you to read the papers you cite. Please. So we can discuss them. But a better community for this would be an ecological one, since none of these papers relate to nutrition or metabolic health.

    Look, don't cite papers you haven't read, because this is what happens.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 3 points 4 months ago (4 children)

    your first link is just a labyrinth of uncited claims. the actual papers are at least 3 clicks deep. the fact that you cited it at all speaks to a weak understanding of what i have been saying this whole time. in fact, none of the links you provided are scholarly articles.

    if you can't explain the methodology for the conclusions youre parroting, i'm not going to bother being the one who actually finds all your citations and their methodologies.

    i will tell you that i know that poore-nemecek 2018 is the basis of a lot of pretty specious claims, and hayek 2014. so when you come back, with actual evidence, please know that i'll be dismissing improperly combined lca data outright.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 4 child comments
  • [–] [S] 2 points 4 months ago (3 children)

    combined lca data

    What does LCA mean here?

    People are mixing estimates with different methodologies and assumptions? That doesn't seem very scholarly

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 3 child comments
  • [–] 3 points 4 months ago (2 children)

    life cycle assessment. if you read the references in poore-nemecek 2018, you will find that they didn't even gather the studies themselves. they are doing a meta study of meta studies. when you read their sources, those papers talk explicitly about the problem of combining disparately methodized study data, but then go on to do so. poore-nemecek doesn't even acknowledge this faux pas.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] [S] 2 points 4 months ago (1 child)

    Ahh meta-meta-analysis! That makes sense - something we see used in nutrition too frequently

    Unrelated, but since you appear to be well read - can you recommend papers on red meat ecology and sustainability? It's not a area i've read with any depth, but I am curious.

    Another open vexation I have is what a sustainable plant based farm with no animal inputs or fertilizer inputs would look like, if it's even possible. From what I could gather it's not doable with no examples (they import fertilizer)

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 2 points 4 months ago* (last edited 4 months ago) (10 children)

    First things first: don't assume that the person you're having a discussion with "will be confidently wrong twice." That's not a discussion, that's an argument on the internet.

    Now that that's out of the way:

    Please cite primary sources. I will only pen my thoughts for one paper you linked that I read, since I suspect this is one more paper than you have read. I'd like to demonstrate how I approach a paper, even if I'm only scanning through it:

    https://journals.plos.org/climate/article?id=10.1371%2Fjournal.pclm.0000010

    It's important to actually read the papers to know how the research was conducted, and by whom. Case in point: the paper is written by the CEO of Impossible Foods. Could it possibly be biased at all, I wonder?

    We assumed in all these hypothetical scenarios that non-agricultural emissions would remain constant;

    I'm no expert, but that's not right at all. Just look at what datacentre buildouts are doing to emissions! This already invalidates their model, so now we are solidly in spherical cow territory. But let's keep going.

    Our default model also assumes that biomass will recover linearly over 30 years, following [1], but there is considerable uncertainty in the literature

    Assuming that land reverts completely to its native ecosystem without livestock is a daring assumption, considering grassland ecosystems co-evolved with grazing animals! No wonder there is "considerable uncertainty." The cows are getting more and more spherical.

    we did not attempt to predict how global food production and consumption might change with growing populations, economic development, advances in agriculture, climate change and other socioeconomic factors. Nor do we tackle the social, economic, nutrition and agricultural challenges inherent to such a large change in global production.

    Paragraph speaks for itself.

    We calculated the combined impact of reduced emissions and biomass recovery

    So this model only considers emissions and biomass (manure) recovery. What about, for example, soil health, water infiltration, nutrient cycling, or other factors that regenerative farming techniques try to optimize for? Or the old chestnut that animals can graze on non-arable land?

    The cows are definitely very spherical now.

    Existing crops could replace the calories, protein and fat from animals with a vastly reduced land, water, GHG and biodiversity impact, requiring only minor adjustments to optimize nutrition

    Aha, there it is. The fundamental assumption that the entire paper is operating off of. This is unfortunately misinformation; plant nutrition is incapable of replacing animal nutrition, even if we only think of vitamin b12. But we also know about heme iron, the fat soluble vitamins ADEK, anti-nutrients, toxins, and so many other things. Read the community's posts to find out more :)

    If you're curious, please start with "The Great Plant Based Con" by Jayne Buxton. Don't waste your time with these industry-funded papers.

    p/s at least for this paper, tar wasn't wrong.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 10 child comments
  • [–] 3 points 4 months ago (5 children)

    We combined livestock production data with average species and product-specific land use data from [12] to estimate species, product and country-specific land use data associated with animal agriculture.

    they just take poore-nemecek and plug it into their research. no discussion on the problem of combining disparately methodized lca data.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 5 child comments
  • [–] 2 points 4 months ago (4 children)

    I have to admit to being a complete layperson when it comes to this domain, so the best I could do was a general critical reading of the paper, based on what little I know.

    Thank you for providing some details as to how to start. I will look up and read Poore-Nemecek 2018.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 4 child comments
  • [–] 3 points 4 months ago (3 children)

    I'm totally out of the loop on the nutritional side of this so I usually stay in my lane. I've read a lot of the lit on the environmental side and I can say with certainty that all the claims made about food production might be true, but the research simply isn't properly methodized to support it.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 3 child comments
  • [–] [S] 2 points 4 months ago (2 children)

    This also applies 100% to the state of nutritional science:

    I can say with certainty that all the claims made about food nutrition might be true, but the research simply isn’t properly methodized to support it.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 3 points 4 months ago (1 child)

    it's actually a tragic state for the academy. no reproducible studies. bad methodology. and everyone citing each other uncritically. it would be nice to have good data on ecology and nutrition, but everyone is so focused on just getting the paper out that no one is trying to advance the science.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] [S] 2 points 4 months ago

    Indeed, throw in some philosophical motivations and we the modern literature. In nutrition we see people outside the normal western academic circles doing studies and collecting data not aligned with the previous zeitgeists - so there is hope the literature will start to have meaningful impact going forward.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] [S] 2 points 4 months ago

    Assuming that land reverts completely to its native ecosystem without livestock is a daring assumption, considering grassland ecosystems co-evolved with grazing animals! No wonder there is “considerable uncertainty.” The cows are getting more and more spherical.

    I would love to see a example of rewilding without animals..... even if it grows trees, soil health has to be measured. We need a agronomist! Quick call Peter Ballerstedt

  • source
  • parent
  • [+] 1 point 4 months ago* (2 children)
  • [–] [S] 2 points 4 months ago

    You don’t have links?

    Have you even read the article this post is about? I've given you links in other aspects of your comments, and you have ignored them. The difference between you and us is we have read what we cite.

    I don’t agree with the methodology of these studies?

    The reason this is a question is because you haven't read your own studies yet?

    Can we cut to the chase here where you kick

    Right there with you - you are not participating in good faith, you have not read your citations, you have used a LLM to generate points you ignore when addressed, you are in violation of rule 1, rule 2, and rule 3, and rule 4, and rule 6. Most importantly you don't keep the conversation interesting, you repeat the same points with ever increasing insults to others.

    I think it's time you find a new community to participate in.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] [S] 2 points 4 months ago

    Right now i can’t manage the 30 whole minutes to debunk the madness on this sub but I’ll get there. Even then I doubt anyone will change their mind.

    We mostly care about the health aspects and the tools they represent to improve health. You would find us more receptive if you spent your time showing us the data on better health outcomes (preferably without using epidemiology)

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] [S] 2 points 5 months ago

    You think the majority of food we are feeding cows is grass? Also yes mono crops are bad, we are feeding our livestock from mono crops which we would require drastically less of to feed people a plant based or mostly plant based diet.

    That is the sustainable way to raise ruminants. Factory farms (both animals and crops) are not sustainable, and need to change.

    in particular insects would be about at par with plant based protein sources.

    When discussing plant based protein you NEED to account for bioavailability and liebig's amino acid barrel. You have to eat a huge volume of food to get protein in the right amounts

    graph

    Once again we’re not talking about hyper specific cases that are incapable of producing enough food for the global population (comically so if everyone switched to a carnivore diet).

    I made a post about the healthiness of meat, you are on a huge WHATABOUTISM crusade. WE are not talking about the same things, because you keep moving the goal posts. I admit right now only 20% of the global food supply is animal based, that is no reason to give up on red meat - the single most valuable and useful food source on the planet.

    Once again we cannot convert our current levels of meat production to a sustainable method short of changing to something like insects or lab grown meat.

    Don't forget the current mono-cropping is unsustainable and requires huge fossil fuel fertilizer inputs. This population bomb hysteria isn't productive, and doesn't move the conversation forward in how to improve human health.

    So is lab grown meat for what it’s worth but I wouldn’t consider its current capability ready for the global market

    Lab grown meat isn't a panacea, we don't know how it interacts with humans. If your referring to plant based meat analogs they are terribly unhealthy and won't work towards human health.

    Simply put a plant based or mostly plant based diet is still the all around winner. For feeding humanity and health outcomes.

    You have not demonstrated the health improvement on plants, if you have read Dr. Ede's article this post is about you will see why that isn't likely.

    I highly suggest the book Eating Animals by Johnathan Foer. Its a very honest and direct look at how we produce meat irl.

    Please read the "The Great Plant-Based Con" by Jayne Buxton

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 0 points 5 months ago* (1 child)

    How is a cow eating grass, churning the soil, fertilizing the soil - destructive? This is how the soil was created in the first place.

    The cow is actually eating corn feed, or at least the grass is being supplemented with corn feed.

    Cows eating only grass can't feed everyone who wants to eat red meat. The only way for beef to be a staple for billions of humans is through factory farming. It's just not possible to have sustainable cattle agriculture when our population is this large.

    And as the population grows, other forms of meat will become impossible to sustain as well: chicken, fish, doesn't matter.

    Some day soon, the only way to eat meat will be to eat bugs.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] [S] 3 points 5 months ago* (last edited 5 months ago)

    The cow is actually eating corn feed, or at least the grass is being supplemented with corn feed.

    This is not how cows should be fed in a sustainable fashion.

    Cows eating only grass can’t feed everyone who wants to eat red meat. The only way for beef to be a staple for billions of humans is through factory farming. It’s just not possible to have sustainable cattle agriculture when our population is this large.

    Unfortunately we are going to have to figure this out. As the world becomes richer the previously impoverished are going to demand meat.

    Some day soon, the only way to eat meat will be to eat bugs.

    I do love a nice fried cricket

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] [S] 2 points 5 months ago

    Georgia Ede is a great writer, but a real boomer when it comes to website design, yes there is a popup straight out of the 1990s.

  • source
  • load more comments
    view more: next ›