At this point radical measures are necessary to right the wrongs committed by the rich. Taxes are a good start but not enough.
post
Figuratively, but yes, I agree.
Financial obesity is an existential threat to any society that tolerates it, and needs to cease being celebrated, rewarded, and positioned as an aspirational goal.
Not a fan fat shaming that gets bundled in with that but basically. It's the vice of greed, plain and simple.
Like imagine rolling up to a potluck and just buying the table, leaving naught but a bag of chips for the rest of the party. Even if you can afford it, it's still a crime against your fellows.
The (original) Nazis are rightfully considered monsters for killing millions of people in the 20th century. What will any survivors of the incineration of earth consider the billionaires that are killing BILLIONS of us for greed?
People think they understand numbers like billion because they understand thousand and billion is just thousand times thousand (million) times thousand. Multiplication is fairly intuitive, but exponentiation is not. Without explicitly thinking it through people feel like 1000^3 is not very different from 1000 * 3.
There are roughly just under 3000 people on earth with more than a billion dollars.
They have a combined net worth of over $16 Trillion
Say the almighty Cthulu/Allah/Zeus decided "yo fuck those assholes" and instantly redistributed that $16 trillion among all 8 billion+ people on earth equally
Everyone: Every man, woman and child would get just a bit shy of $2000.
Fun thought experiment
Correct, because the difference between a millionaire and a billionaire is roughly 1 billion dollars.
What are you talking about? Billionaires are what's saving this country! Everyone just needs to stop eating and be homeless. But also fuxk homeless people and you turn to drugs for comfort? Jail obviously. They're totally fixing everything! /S
We should start call them hoarders instead. They are just as obsessed and wierd about it.
Each billionaire is an individual problem AND allowing billionaires to grab and monopolize so many resources and even looking up to them is a systemic problem.
Without the systemic problem which is Capitalism and the shallow, greedy present day society, billionaires would be treated the same as other hoarders - seen mentally derranged and stopped from going too far for their own good and the good of others.
There will always be nutters, but if the social system we have wasn't broken, this very specific kind of nutter would never be allowed to cause the damage they do with their mental disease.
I think what you mean to say is capitalism is cancer. There are books written on the subject.
I am incensed by the use of the word “literally” here almost as much as I am incensed by the hyper rich denying the vast fraction of the human race basics rights and freedoms. Almost.
I think OP used literally correctly here. They are saying that one possible definition of the word cancer can include billionaires as an instance. That's not the definition you'll find in any dictionary, but those lag behind the true language as it evolves.
I think OP used literally correctly here.
Then you do not understand what the word "literally" literally means.
While several treatments would work for either, (such as carving up the offending subject with a knife, or sufficient application of chemical or radiative agents), billionaires are an economic problem, not a biologic one.
Then you do not understand what the word "literally" literally means.
Oooo, sick burn!! I don't know if I'll recover from that!
My point is that I believe OP was using the word "literally" to mean what it literally means, and not just using it for emphasis as it is so often used these days. They may still be wrong, but they did not misuse the word.
My point is that I believe OP was using the word "literally" to mean what it literally means,
You can only rationally make that argument if you are claiming that "society" is a biological organism, like an amoeba or a babboon, presumably evolved from other common ancestors of all life on earth. When you can tell me the scientific name of this organism, and what organs have been affected by tumors, we can start talking about the literality of the "cancer" OP referred to.
As the underlying logic was metaphorical, "literally" was used as figurative hyperbole, not literality.
You are refuting an argument that I did not make.
Edit to add: OP says cancer can be used literally to refer to billionaires, you say it cannot. One of you must be wrong, but neither is misusing the word "literally."
You are refuting an argument that I did not make.
I am refuting the argument that would need to be made in order to support your position. I clearly specified that necessity in my refutation. "Cancer" and "billionaire" would have to be synonymous, not analogous, for "literally" to have been used correctly.
What type of cancer are billionaires? Carcinomas are cancers of epithelial tissue, but "society" does not have epithelial tissue. Sarcomas are cancers of musculoskeletal and connective tissues, but "society" does not have bones, muscles, tendons, ligaments, etc. Myelomas are cancers of the plasma cells in bone marrow, but again, "society" doesn't have bones. Leukemias are cancers of the various blood cells, but society doesn't have "blood". Lymphomas are cancers of the lymphatic system, but society doesn't have one of those either.
In fact, "society" does not have biological tissues or organs that could even become literally cancerous. (Members of society do, indeed, have these various organs and tissues, but no member of society has been diagnosed with a "Bezosma" or "Muskaemia".)
"Billionaires are cancer" is a metaphor. "Billionaires are literally cancer" is simply a false statement, unless "literally" was used, incorrectly, as hyperbole.
"Billionaires are literally cancer" is simply a false statement, unless "literally" was used, incorrectly, as hyperbole.
That is my point. Literally can be used correctly in a statement that is not correct, and my reading of the original post is that was OP's intention. They did not misuse the word "literally."
I'm not debating the meaning of the word cancer.
So, billionaires are not "literally" cancer, but "billionaires are literally cancer" is supposedly a correct use of "literally"?
That is my point. Literally can be used correctly in a statement that is not correct,
This is generally true, but in this particular sentence, the reason the sentence is false is specifically because of the meaning of "literally".
"The sky is literally purple" is a correct use of "literally" in a false statement. This is what you are trying to argue.
"Billionaires are a cancer" is a correct, figurative statement.
"Billionaires are literally cancer" is false specifically because "literally" does not mean "figuratively".
"Billionaires are literally cancer" is false specifically because "literally" does not mean "figuratively".
Correct. But that is not what OP said. Read it again and I think you will see that OP is saying that "Billionaires are cancer" is not a figurative statement at all, but a literal one. You can disagree with them (I do, btw), but they have not misused the word "literally."
I think you will see that OP is saying that "Billionaires are cancer" is not a figurative statement at all, but a literal one.
It is a metaphorical statement rather than a simile, but both metaphors and similes are figurative, not literal.
You are refuting an argument that I did not make.
I enjoy this type of debate, but this one doesn't seem to be getting anywhere. I'm moving on. Thank you, sincerely.
Oh, this one went somewhere, just not anywhere you wanted it to go.
You can say "billionaires harm society, literally". That's a literal statement that is true.
You can say "billionaires benefit society, literally". Thats a literal statement that is untrue.
You can say "billionaires are human, literally", so long as you are talking about individuals, and not corporate entities.
You can say "billionaires are steaming piles of shit, figuratively". They are not literally turds emitting water vapor. That metaphor is quite apt, but not literally true.
Likewise, they are not masses of mutated cells. That metaphor is also apt, bit is not literally true.
You can say "teratomas are cancer, literally". You can't say "this argument is literal cancer". It is figurative cancer, not literal.
You're right about the similarities, but having similarities is not what "literally" means. That word is so fucking overused.
This was pretty much the point Agent Smith was making to Morpheus in his ‘virus’ speech.
Why can't each person. Rubbing for office get a fixed Amount of money to spend on their campaign. Make it all level playing field. Yes I said rubbing.
Corporations with more than 1 billion are more of a cancer than individual billionaires
You know in hungarian we would flip this a bit on its head as we have a curse, "a rák vigye el", which means may cancer "bring them away"(kill them). I support this idea in this specific case.
Been saying it for years. Sadly there are too many at the bottom mesmerized by the elite propaganda telling them "you can also be like me, if you work hard", as if they earned billions that way without any dirty tactics along the way, and despite even with success still needing such tactics to take more and more.
Luigi knew how to cure this type of cancer. It's not rocket science but nobody with the means and opportunity is willing to do the right thing for humanity.
The same applies to the human race.
Ok, Agent Smith.
Agent Smith wasn't wrong. Most villains have a weak motivation; Smith's was strong, because it is true.
I'd like to share a revelation that I've had during my time here. It came to me when I tried to classify your species. I realized that you're not actually mammals. Every mammal on this planet instinctively develops a natural equilibrium with the surrounding environment, but you humans do not. You move to an area, and you multiply, and multiply, until every natural resource is consumed. The only way you can survive is to spread to another area. There is another organism on this planet that follows the same pattern. A virus. Human beings are a disease, a cancer of this planet, you are a plague, and we are the cure.
Fuck man. Now I need to rewatch The Matrix
Let’s take the original comment at face value and in earnest for a moment.
Wouldn’t the human race be more like a parasite?
In all honesty, I don’t think the earth needs us, nor would we qualify for a symbiotic relationship. Earth really doesn’t need most of its inhabitants.
That would move to a more existential question of what it means for earth to survive or be “alive”? Support any life?
Do you think I'm promoting voluntary extinction? I don't think anyone has to do that - not only would it not make a dent in the race to doomsday, but it's unnecessary since we've probably already passed the point at which we're capable of halting the runaway ecological collapse we've engineered - even if there was any indication of willingness on the part of the biggest polluters to draw down, which there isn't.
What I find funny is those people who are still making more people, as if they're not dooming them to live through a true apocalypse: global societal and ecological collapse, technological regression, famine, and the resurgence of self-perpetuating oligarchies. A dark ages, but one we'll never come out of.
top 69 comments