I have a wild idea, bear with me, maybe education shouldn't be a profit-making industry.
post
*in the US.
Yeah, because they suck.
Businesses that suck in a shrinking market, are going to close. Education is a business in the USA, not a public good.
I knew people who went to these schools... they were often indebted for poor quality educations in basic liberal arts fields and spent their 20s doing service jobs because nobody wants to hire someone from a fourth rate no name college who reads/writes at a 10th grade level. A lot of my peers who went to these schools got scammed, and frankly had no business going to college in the first place.
Good riddance. Students and governments are better off expanding their flagship and 1st tier institutions and making those more accessible by expanding their seats and their aid packages. Kids who get C averages in high school shouldn't be going to college anyway. They should be going to trades or other labor training.
I agree with nearly all of your sentiment here, other than “people with C’s shouldn’t go to college”.
I like Scott Galloway’s take: colleges and universities are the opportunity to take the unremarkable and give them a chance at being remarkable.
Of course there needs to be a cut off here, but I’d say curriculum is a better indicator than average letter grade. Often, I’d rather work with someone who has really struggled to earn mediocre grades, but knuckled down and made it through because they wanted it that badly. Because that’s most of life after school. Most of my friends that struggled after school were the ones that never had to try when we were in school. Then they graduated and life hit them in the face for the first time.
My undergrad degree is in Computer Science and I really struggled because I didn’t have a quality maths foundation. That said, I worked my ass off and graduated with a 3.8 in my major, and now am the Sr. Solutions Architect at my city’s largest employer, soon to clinch a director position. College enabled me to do that and fostered a life long curiosity of all things.
My partner is another good example. She barely earned C’s in high school, worked at a grocery store, and decided she wanted something better. She went to community college when she was ready, and now owns two extremely successful businesses. She would have not done well in trades.
Having access to higher education at the “right” time for people is critical. And as you said, also having options for those who aren’t motivated to continue in higher education but still want to make a fair wage, like trade school.
Almost as if making higher education a privatized tiered for-profit scam instead of publicly available paid-for-by-our-fucking-tax-dollars free accessible opportunity was a bad idea!
This is due to the demographic crunch. There are just fewer young people to go around.
Less choices from smaller trade focused colleges like the one in the article will focus into larger city focused colleges.
The article is talking about a farming specific school that was small and hands on. Some tasks can be learned in a trade school, but stuff like running a farm will be learned from family, or in places like this.
So you'll have to be born into it or be wealthy enough to go to a top tier school to run a farm. Now working on the farm would be a trade.
It would be nice if you put the country in the title. The majority of Lemmy users are not American.
Just what we need, Americans to be DUMBER.
You can learn exactly the same things with accreditation or without it. Especially now that there are fewer standards of excellency. Are there any jobs for the many college graduates everywhere that still are being pumped out, with all of their degrees? I don't think there are.
I don’t think there are.
My Son will graduate from College this May, was recruited to a company a year ago, and will start work in June. You will not be hired for his kind of work without a Degree either, at least not in the United States. The jobs are out there and many of the better ones require the Accreditation.
That might be true, but a lot of unaccredited institutions are that way because they're no good.
I don’t think there are.
There are. Here's some anecdata: two of my kids went to college straight after high school. Both got jobs within a month of graduating and are still employed. One graduated with an arts degree.
The other kid started a small business, did great at that until Covid killed demand. He then apprenticed in a trade, made some decent money at that, and has now gone back to college to move up the food chain from his chosen trade. He's already got offers.
So I won't overgeneralize, but I can confidently say that it still works for some. And, when I graduated a very long time ago, it wasn't a cakewalk then, either. A degree was never a guarantee of a job. That was a myth. I got my degree at the start of a recession and classmates of mine who were smart, hardworking people, struggled for months or years. I lucked my way into a job because I discovered that an interviewer was the cousin of my college advisor. They talked, and I ended up learning some very interesting tech and doing world travel.
"Smart people don't like me." Quoth the moron currently stinking up the WH
Intelligent people don't vote republikkkan. Ofc they want to shut down as many colleges as possible. Keeping people stupid, easy to control, and indoctrinated is part of their plan.
all 31 comments