And no one wants Teams either.
post
Like Facebook chasing the metaverse pie in the sky, but now with multiple giant corporations.
When will they chase innovation with the consumers benefit being the goal, instead of finding ways to extract money from us at the highest margine possible.
Totally - the whole ‘AI is going to replace you’ is a miserable pitch to consumers. I’ll consider subscribing when they find the time to make an AI something with the goal of making my life better.
It's their pitch to businesses. They haven't thought about how that sounds to users though.
Fortunately it's not true. I could turn up to work drunk and do a better job than the AI if only because the AI doesn't know all of the idiosyncrasies of our system. It's just a generic "one size doesn't fit anyone" general solution database. Unless the company wants to train its own AI on its own knowledge base articles (Which of course are out of date) then Microsoft, and others, generic solutions are never going to work.
Even then, an LLM isn't going to be able to actually diagnose a problem. It's just very sophisticated word prediction, it doesn't actually THINK, even if it looks like it does.
They simply won't. They have been about getting as many businesses into their ecosystem for a while now, that's all they care about. Pack as many "features" as possible, then extract value as much as they can.
From the article:
Satya Nadella is burning decades of customer good will chasing the latest tech fad.
I'd disagree with hat sentiment. I'd put it as Microsoft is finally giving people the final push they needed to break the Microsoft chain they had around their ankles.
Nobody uses Microsoft products because they're the best, they never were, they never will be. Microsoft is the VHS of the video tapes, it is as big as it is due to deception, marketing, and force. L
Let this be the obligatory "install Linux already" post, but I'm saying it as "switch everything away from US vendors to open source" as they all have turned evil and corrupt. Open source software is the only software left that can still give users what they need in a fair way.
Install Linux, setup some nextcloud instance, break that fucking Microsoft chain
I mean, people aren't really thrilled about Microsoft's non-AI products either. They spend money to churn out new versions of programs that are worse than the old ones. It's baffling to me. Just don't spend the money and don't make you're existing products worse.
Hear me out... Just add more AI and run it in a basement somewhere and leave me out of it.
Lots of people jizzing over Google in the last weeks. But Copilot and ChatGPT are by far and away the leaders in the space currently, both coupled to Microsoft.
Sure their own tools suck, but when wasn't that the case in the last 15years?
I use Claude and Cursor to help program all the time, but I made the mistake of helping my wife try to use work-supplied Copilot and it was an utter failure at generating procedure documentation. After a couple hours of pissing around getting nothing useful, I fed the prompts to claude and had what she needed in a few minutes.
If this trash is what Microsoft is pinning it's future on, they're fucked.
Its awful yeah. But Microsoft have all that enterprise licence money coming in anyway. They will still be here in 50 years. In my mind they are more certain to be here than Google.
They are awful but they have their software on almost any pc in the world. If pc's disappear and nobody needs personal computers anymore, that would be a lethal strike. But doesnt seem likely even with Ai coming in everything.
Claude models and all the rest are available in copilot from the selection box...
If you're using free model from github on GPT4 then yeah I would think it's no where near Claude 4.5
Hint: nobody wants to use Google's either.
Ohhh I get it. So MS should make the AI use mandatory and compulsory!
I was going to say, you can remove “its” and “shoddy” and the title is still accurate.
I have never seen an AI more consistently wrong on everything. It's the Apple Maps of AI.
I wanted to use Assistant but now they're butchering that to force people onto Gemini, which is functionally dogshit.
So not only are people not reading the articles any more, they're not even finishing reading the headlines all the way through?
You realize these companies can force growth via cramming it in to every channel they own, right? You realize growth on paper is not public endorsement, right?
But also, for people who do want to use ai, google's ai is just better. Nano banana is genuinely impressive.
So why aren't Microsoft's numbers going up? Everyone's faking it except them?
Because they're easier to ignore and disable than the biggest advertiser and search platform on the planet that gets their grubby hands in everything? MS doesn't have nearly as much of an online presence, and that's exactly where these "AI" are getting used.
On top of that, Google gets to feed search queries into their AI and generate results for most searches. Copilot does not get to arbitrarily answer every search someone types in to Windows.
So... yea, in a way, everyone else is more capable of forcing engagement than MS. Would you be more likely to try something that's merely available on a website, or more likely to enable a technology that could extract all of your personal information from your computer on accident?
Google Search being replaced by Gemini makes it easy for Google to have big AI numbers. Bing never got over its reputation of having bad result quality, and it's only the default search engine on Windows PCs that don't have Chrome or Firefox installed. My friend uses Windows and iOS and always sends me links to Gemini results, which normally are only slightly worse than "I'm feeling lucky."
And yet beating out both of them by a very wide margin, with 61.30% of the AI search share, is ChatGPT. Which didn't have any established reputation or pre-installed userbase or anything at all that either Microsoft or Google started out with.
Your friend uses Gemini, presumably willingly. That's not "faked." This narrative of "nobody wants AI" is false, it's just popular among social media bubbles where people want it to be true.
ChatGPT sold themselves as the easy way to add "AI" to products. I would not be surprised what so ever if the VAST majority of ChatGPT's usage came from other people forcing it into their products (like all the companion apps) and not actual, direct interest in AI from the general populace.
Think of it like mobile gaming. Most people do not spend much money at all on the microtransaction bullshit. Though it's still successful in making the company money, thanks to whales and other uncommon big spenders. It would be totally unsurprising if GPT is getting their numbers in a similar fashion. Not from end users, but from selling it as a service to other companies and a very small percentage of heavy users.
chatgpt.com is the fourth-most-visted website in the world (as of September, when this data is from). That's the website, not the API. People have to choose to go to the chatgpt.com website in their browser, when OpenAI's APIs are used by other products they don't go to the chatgpt.com website. The API is at openai.com.
How are all those people people being "forced" to go to chatgpt.com?
To be fair it's the band-aid of AI. The people that do want to use AI are using chatgpt. It works about as well as an LLM will right now and it basically sucks you off while it does it, so people like using it.
Copilot is chatGPT thrown into Microsoft apps and Gemini sucks, forcefully replaced the assistant app, and automatically comes up on Google searches with nonsense seemingly half the time.
(When I do use an LLM i use deepseek, but I recognize that I'm probably the minority in that)
They've got 70% of the desktop operating system share. Seems like every other thread about them around these parts is how they're "shoving AI down everyones' throats." I'm dubious that they're "easier to ignore."
Read my last paragraph, then. It's not how much MS gets in everyones' face. It's the specific avenues in which these companies are exposed. Google is everywhere on a platform that people don't have to install to try things out, or have it automatically execute without permission.
MS is not. Do you not remember the MASSIVE outcry when MS said they were turning on Copilot for everyone? They tried to shove it everyones' faces ala google, but their avenues for forcing shit are plainly different.
Alright. So for purposes of argument, let's accept all of that. Microsoft and Google are just faking it all, everyone's tricked or forced into using their AI offerings.
The whole table from the article:
| # | Generative AI Chatbot | AI Search Market Share | Estimated Quarterly User Growth | |
|
|
|
| | 1 | ChatGPT (excluding Copilot) | 61.30% | 7% ▲ | | 2 | Microsoft Copilot | 14.10% | 2% ▲ | | 3 | Google Gemini | 13.40% | 12% ▲ | | 4 | Perplexity | 6.40% | 4% ▲ | | 5 | Claude AI | 3.80% | 14% ▲ | | 6 | Grok | 0.60% | 6% ▲ | | 7 | Deepseek | 0.20% | 10% ▲ |
ChatGPT by far has the bigger established user base. How did they force and/or trick everyone into using them?
Claude AI is growing their userbase faster than Google, how are they tricking and/or forcing everyone to switch over to them?
None of these other AI service providers, except for Grok, have a pre-existing platform with users that they can capture artificially. People are willingly going over to these services and using them. Both Microsoft and Google could vanish completely and it would take out less than a third of the AI search market.
They got their user base by being the first ones to have open access to it. Being the first to market OFC gives a massive advantage.
You are also using flawed logic. This isn't AI vs everything. This is ONLY the "AI" products compared to themselves. These same exact numbers could happen with 1000 users across the entire world, yet you claim it's evidence of general public acceptance.
Flawed logic is bad logic. ChatGPT also sells their services to other corporations, where several of the others are end-user only, so again, you are using flawed logic to pretend like everyone actually wants this horseshit.
They got their user base by being the first ones to have open access to it. Being the first to market OFC gives a massive advantage.
Right, and then everyone chose to go use them.
This isn't AI vs everything. This is ONLY the "AI" products compared to themselves
Every single one of them showed an increase in user growth, Microsoft just didn't grow as much as the others. They're not just shuffling the same users around, they're continuing to gain new ones.
And as I pointed out in another response to you, chatgpt.com is the fourth-most-visited website in the world. They're doing that with just a thousand users?
Microsoft has nothing worth using. Microsoft hasn't made anything that's even worth talking about. Anyone with an OpenAI key and an afternoon to kill could make something every bit as good as what Microsoft has done. They put the absolute bare minimum of effort into everything they've done with AI.
The only advantage they have is customer lock-in. Historically, that's usually enough for them. I hope it's not this time.
Eventually Microsoft will probably buy a company with people who know what the fuck they're doing. I think that's their only way forward because it looks like the brain drain has finally caught up with them.
Microsoft has nothing worth using.
Mostly agree. However, Excel remains the exception. I refuse to buy/subscribe to whatever subscription they are currently peddling, but I do consider my stand alone Excel license to be worth it. And if the next version of Excel is still offered as a stand alone perpetual license and does not force AI, I’ll buy that too.
Yeah, I meant for AI stuff specifically. Their main products are...well I wouldn't say "good" but they successfully choked out all competition in the 90s so...
For basic usage, just use LibreOffice.
For any serious data storage, get PostgreSQL.
SQLite perchance, as a treat.
I feel like Google sheets is a better experience than Excel, at least for my personal usage. I'm not enterprise though, and not trying to run it like a database or anything crazy.
If I’m using it in browser, sure. But as a standalone application, no comparison IMO.
I've tried both. I think part of it is friction from little behaviors that I expect to be like Google sheets but aren't. I don't even know what they are until I hit some keys and excel does the "wrong" (but probably reasonable) thing.
Yeah there truly is no comparison to Excel (derogatory).
(I'm just bitter because of VBA okay?)
Not fair!
Microsoft has made a lot worth talking about in the last few years.
You just have to talk it in the same way you would talk about touching the tip of a soldering iron.
To Microsoft’s credit, phi3/4 were both pretty good models for their size, for a brief period before they were comely outclassed.
Well, no. Microsoft has good products, to me specially in development area. That said I moved away from Windows and office as well, because of the crap they are putting into them.
I'm surprised one of these companies hasn't bid against the AI bubble yet. Like have they considered going against the grain when there's obvious push back could actually increase profits?
Could you imagine a world where Microsoft went back to a windows 7 Era where shit just worked how it was supposed to and was super solid? I feel like people would appreciate and buy into a product that just works.
Maybe I'm completely off base here but in my mind having a product that... y'know...actually works and does what it says it does is valuable.
That is unless there's just so much money being thrown at them to force AI into their products that they seemingly cannot refuse, which could very well be the case. But it just feels weird
I feel like people would appreciate and buy into a product that just works.
The general public are no longer the market, but rather the product. Most of us have been demoted from customer to cattle. They don't care what we want. We're here to generate data for them to sell.
Problem is that they've completely bent over to shareholders and shareholders are both A) non tech people and B) believe AI will print money for them.
A company with a backbone would say "No you know what, this is insane and it's clear customers aren't biting. We will win long run if we make quality products people want". Instead they bend over to shareholders and, from my understanding they say something like "deeper plz"
Oh, you just know someone's shorting this. It just doesn't seem to get reported on.
The problem with shorting is you have to guess when the bubble pops. Call it too early, and you don't get the short at all. Call it too late, and any possible earnings may get wiped out by rebounds and/or new bubbles.
You also usually short with leverage not actual full capital. To hold a short position for a long requires solvency and hopefully you don't hit your stop loss and just lose.
While I grant these things are true, there's no way in hell multiple people aren't trying this bet.
"multiple people" doesn't mean much unless it's one of the top twenty people that own most of the stock market.
Sure, but contrarian investment and bets are built into the system. Everyone wants to think they're the genius.
Right, but this is about the noteworthiness of talking about someone shorting AI. Who cares if joe schmoe from accounting shorted their six shares? It'd only be newsworthy if it's someone with significant investment or supposed insider knowledge shorting it.
If I could turn off the Google one at work, my usage for both would drop to zero
lol today I tried to resolve an issue with Gemini chat in Google cloud console.
It gave me advice that just hid an error, so technically the task succeeded but the results were garbage.
It was my mistake for trying.
It just lies like crazy whenever I make quick searches for scientific info. Like, beyond wrong and unhelpful, it cites literature that definitively does not show what it claims. Very unhelp for when I need to know, say, what are all the known ligands for a given receptor or whether a certain cell line expresses a specific cytokine. Things that should be super easy for an "advanced" search system.
Vanguard and Fidelity don't really own that stuff. They're managing the wealth of customers. The funds they have are almost entirely or entirely owned by customers.
Vanguard and Fidelity make money so long as people hold money in their funds. They win pretty much no matter what. The bubble bursting will mean they make less money, but they can't really lose money because they don't own the underlying equities.
Same for BlackRock which I maintain gets a lot more heat than the significantly worse Blackstone. BlackRock manages a bunch of index funds and was renounced by several red states for being too woke (the CEO apparently believes in ESG). Blackstone however buys entire neighbourhoods to jack up rent in an area.
At the end of the day they're all capitalists and none should exist, but I'm still fairly sure Blackrock has gotten a lot of the heat because the CEO is Jewish and a dem supporter. That gets the conspiracy theories flowing from the right. Doesn't mean he's a good person, I just think BR gets singled out suspiciously much in a world full of similar companies with even worse leadership.
I'm typing this on a Surface, so I'm not inherently anti-MS, but they've very clearly given up on the consumer side, which is an industrywide trend.
AI is sort of like having a plug. If you know you want it, it's easy enough to find.
It's internet explorer vs Netscape navigator. Even Safari. Gemini gets pushed by Android phones. MS lost the smartphone OS war. Also lost TVs. Also lost home assistant speaker/mics. Microsoft and every other company without a major mobile OS under their unbrella is fighting a battle with a major handicap against Google
Competition is actually a good thing. Nobody wants a single giant corporation to control the majority of a technology. However I am not sure if this is really a good thing, because this means Microsoft will invest more into Ai, buy more graphics cards, fire real engineers and so on. Is competition a bad thing for once?
Rare to see an AI-positive article getting so many upvotes on @technology@beehaw.org.
According to the chart in the article every AI is seeing stronger growth than Copilot, on a percentage gain basis. Gemini's just the one that looks like it's about to surpass Copilot in total market share.
The only reason Google is doing better in this space is because they already had a whole range of smart appliances, iot devices, and a suite of apps with helpful smart features before they injected AI into everything. They already had people using the tech with an AI before it became a Generative AI LLM.
They aren't any better than MS. But a lot of people were already drinking their Kool aid.
all 20 comments