I'm gonna get hate for this, but I'm actually a fan of raisins and I'm slightly annoyed that the oatmeal cookie doesn't have any raisins in it.

A, A, A, and A

F, P, I, K

No snickerdoodle or peanut butter, shame

Okay, first of all, how dare you, and second, aaaaargh, I guess A, B, H, and P? I can mix P and H and get a sort of E, and I can mix A and P and get a sort of G, but AAAAAh no L? No D? Waaaaaaah!! And I'm going to double cry over no F.

Also, who calls I churro instead of snickerdoodle? And who puts the letter for the cookie so near the name for the cookie above it so the whole thing gets read weirdly?

since these are cookies that means we're in the United States, so I can brandish a gun and take well more than 4 of them 🍪🍪🍪🍪🍪🍪🍪🍪🍪🍪

I will have four chocolate chip cookies, thank you.

DDDD.

Assuming the description is incomplete and they're oatmeal raisin. Because I see raisins.

I know some people hate oatmeal (raisin) cookies, so lemme drop some sweet truth on you. Replace the raisins with butterscotch chips. "Oatmeal Scotchies" are vastly superior to chocolate chip cookies!

I dont even know what a banoffe pie or fluffernutter is but i want to try both of them. Then after ill go for mint oreo and churro

Sweet potato pie (is this even a cookie?), Churro (whats that) and macadamia nut.

Just the oatmeal cookies for me thanks. Y'all can have all the rest.

No snickerdoodle???

Oatmeal times 4

Three chocolate chip and one oatmeal!

A, B, E, and H.

SHIT, because I'm childish

No snickerdoodle?

Nutella Swirl looks nice, Galaxy Brownie, the blueberry one, and prob the banaoffee

A - don't mess with success
B - I mean, cmon - cream cheese frosting bits mixed in?
E or F - seem equally good. All about it.
I - for science!

G, J, and the last two rows feel too experimental.

I surreptitiously knock L into the trash as I walk out the door.

Where the fuck is peanut butter or molasses!

Where's the thin mint? WHERE'S THE GOD DAMN THIN MINT?! WHERE IS IT?!

ASDF

• B
• G
• L
• R

You work for Big Cookie.

A,F

Is this from bakdcookies.ca ? Most of those seem to be on that menu.

A C H K

G, A, I, in that order!

Always oatmeal raisin. A lot of the other options you present seem too sweet without introducing any more complex flavors or new textures.

If it was sea salt caramel chocolate chip, then A would be my number one choice.

Otherwise, from this list, it would probably be D, K, F, A. Though that list isn't solid or stable.

ABDF

Red velvet is probably the sweetest cookie there that I would care to eat. The rest feel overwhelmingly sugar loaded.

B,D,E,L

OMG,A?

Choc chip, choc chip, Sweet potato and gingerbread seem like the safest choices. Don't cookie my churro, churros are fried.

AFTN

I'm a sucker for snickerdoodles so probably 4 churros

I really thought Banofee Pie was a onion ring for a minute and I was like "Hell yeah, onion rings are my favorite cookie"

ADFP