How the fuck is C++ more traditional than C?
post
Javascript being disruptive technology is.. A take for sure.
When your self driving car is written in react you'll understand.
Self driving cars? Think human interface on spaceships!
https://os-system.com/blog/javascript-in-space-spacex-devs-have-shared-crewdragons-tech-stack/
SpaceX
I'm sure Musk hand coded it in JS and then paid some underpaid dude who is only slightly less abused in the US instead of india to unfuck his dogshit.
When your self driving car is written in react you'll understand.
I'll understand briefly, as my life flashes before my eyes? Haha.
8 frameworks and waiting for fingerprinting scripte to load just for the website to run at 1 frame every minute
It always disrupted everything, and is getting only better on that with time.
I mean from inception until now it has been a huge change in programming. Node changed a lot of things. Typescript changed a lot of things. React changed a lot of things.
A long way since GWT which google was doing because its java devs hated js
But the most disruptive technology of all is Steve Jobs's face.
I'm guessing they started with the portraits and then built out a kind of mood board around them. Javascript is not disruptive in any good way, but people who like Javascript (and Apple and so on) might think they are.
what are the concentric circles above Linus?
That’s Zen, a Firefox-based browser https://zen-browser.app/
Looking at how much of a reach some of the disruptive + proprietary stuff is... Yeah, there isn't a lot of recent innovative proprietary stuff, is there?
Although I would put Chrome under "disruptive". It absolutely was when it released decades ago, and even now it's still changing the browser landscape.
Chrome was disruptive.
Part of the reason for its disruption is that Chromium is open source (BSD licence), built on Webkit that was open source, which was built on khtml from the KDE project which was open source. That is how we got to Microsoft Edge also running on Chromium.
If it wasn't for the monoculture aspect and the actions of some of the companies using it, khtml->Chromium would be a great open source success story.
A lot of the systems are quite stabilized. No need for a new OS, a new browser, a new language.
Even if the old stuff isn't perfectly optimal, having to setup a fully-new ecosystem is so incredibly costly that it's just not worth it.
That's why you see new developments (e.g. Typescript or Kotlin) piggyback on older ecosystems (e.g. JavaScript or Java compatibility).
Typescript could have been better if it was a completely fresh development without being encumbered by the madness that is JavaScript. But without JavaScript compatibility and thus acces to the JS ecosystem, nobody would have switched to TS.
All these systems heavily benefit from network effects, which makes it hard to impossible for completely new systems to emerge.
This is doubly strong for consumer-facing software. Linux only became a viable mainstream option due to Wine/Proton/... allowing users to easily run Windows programs. Without Windows compatibility, Linux would still be at <1% desktop market share.
It's also the same reason why everyone's making chromium-based browsers: Because that way they all work the same.
Disruptive change happens when you get a completely fresh use case. Microsoft completely destroyed the likes of Commodore and IBM when home computers became something that everyone had in their homes.
Smartphones becoming mainstream allowed Google and Apple, who were both completely new to the mobile OS business, to win against established mobile OS companies, because nothing was entrenched in the late 2000s mobile OS landscape.
OpenAI, Anthropic, Midjourney and so on are wiping the floor with established software powerhouses in the AI space.
But after the disruption follows stabilization. A product that has reached market saturation will only be replaced by incremental, compatible improvements.
Ok, now ... where does TempleOS and HolyC belong on this chart?
*Sigh*. Fine, let's introduce a z-axis specifically for Terry A. Davis.
Dead center with God
Maximum freedom, and somehow joining the maximum points on the tradition and disruption axes, forcefully bending the chart into some sort of cylinder
Hrm ok so your model is less of a defined space a point can exist in, and is instead a topology that a point must exist on.
Eh, I wouldn't say TempleOS is disruptive. It was literally started off as a modern-day C64 successor. So, tradition all the way.
Pasting objects into text files is pretty disruptive. The only other coding editor I know that can do that is DrRacket with images. I mean the guy invented an entire OS, C variant, several programs... all incompatible with traditional ones, simply because of his unique personal beliefs.
Pasting objects into text files is pretty disruptive
It's still text with some formatting underneath, though, just like HTML. Actually, in HTML we already have it in form of contenteditable attribute. You can straight up paste images and move other html elements into elements with it. I just checked, you can even do this with full on canvas elements and animated webgl views if you wanted to for some reason, though the code must be adjusted to account for it. I have yet to see it being useful and not a liability, though.
It needs a Z axis for hobby vs enterprise.
There we go, there, that actually makes sense to me, thank you!
I want to know what a corpo hobbyist traditionalist language is though, lol.
Like uh... I make vba / excel macros in my spare time for fun, lol?
What is the software between Linus and rust? Never seen that icon before
Zig is actually pretty easy to get into. I got a Raylib game scaffold with scene switching running in a couple of hours from scratch, with no prior knowledge of the Zig language or ecosystem whatsoever.
Zoologist, it's a person that studies animals for a living. Hope this helps
Cowards are too afraid to place vi anywhere on these axes...
It’s open source and traditional..
So you're say remove emacs and replace it with vi? I agree!
You would need entire new compass to place vi, vim, neovim, lazyvim, spacevim, lunarvim and so on on it.
I started using git to track my dotfiles maybe one-ish years after I first fully adopted Linux as my daily driver.. I think it's been a little over 5 years and before I converted to nix that git history told a story of immense frustration of never being able to get my desktop and laptop to be identical. For some reason some projects only ran on one of the 2 machines. There was a period in my life when I didn't use my desktop for 2 months because it just didn't work well enough, OCD is really fucking painful. Nix saved my relationship with both of my computers, and my desk, and my spine. I haven't used my laptop and maybe a month and I may have changed my workstation a couple hundred times in this period, I will with absolute confidence say that the next time I decide to use my laptop I can just run git pull and nixos rebuild and my laptop will be just the same as my desktop (minus obligatory build fixes ¯\_(ツ)_/¯)
Putting Apple under disruption not tradition lol
C++ is more traditional than C? 🤔
some one in the middle

Nah, vibe coders are definitionally reliant on highy disruptive, literally economy destabilizing 'AIs', that are made by the most gigantic of megacorps and foundations.
That would make them so far into soydev they are off the chart to the bottom right, and it would also mean you'd be grilling Impossible Burgers.
But also super far into cogdev because the largest investors in those efforts by far are the established tech giants that have been around for years, so they are directly supporting the biggest players getting bigger
I hear what you are saying, but you can't ignore the disruption vs traditional axis of 'brand new shit' vs 'archaic shit that is still the basis of everything for probably a lot of good reasons.'
Thats the y axis.
The x axis is basically full corpo on the right, full foss/anarchist on the left.
So, the vibe coder is a soydev who works for cogdevs, or people somewhere between cogdev and soydev.
Here's how I look at this.
Maybe if you went with... not the corners of the quadrants, but the tips of the axes, you'd get:
top:
ancient wizard of languages that aren't even really taught anymore (COBOL, for example), but which everything actually runs on if you dig deep enough.
bottom:
hyper early adopter / innovator / formal researcher who does things because they can, asking about "should we do this?" is for cowards, yolo, etc
left:
open source radical anarchist, money is a disgusting thing that is unfortunately somewhat necessary to fund development
right:
full corpo bastard, code doesn't actually matter, making money from code matters.
Further down in this thread, under another comment, I basically tried to do a 'personality test' or maybe 'ttrpg archetype description' style write up of the corners of the quadrants... at least my way of trying to make sense out of what I think whoever made this image is going for.
yeah idk it was more of a from the hip impulsive thing. I'm a simple shitposter. I see poltiical compass and I just want to grill.
Also:
so far into soydev they are off the chart to the bottom right, and it would also mean you’d be grilling Impossible Burgers.
I didn't realize there were going to be personal attacks.
I mean, all my responses in this thread have been hip shooting as well lol.
And its not a personal attack to say if you're a soydev, you're grillin' soy burgers.
I mean sure, maybe they're not quite the same taste as beef, but uh, nothin' really wrong with a less than totally conventional burger, imo.
Its just a joke lol, didn't mean to offend, just word/concept association = joke/pun, thats roughly how my autistic ass formulates 'zingers' lol.
Amazing how RMS is now on the traditional end of traditional to disruptive.
I use C#, GitHub and arch...
(I am replacing GitHub once my homelab server is set up though)
I was about to say C# seems to be in a weird spot here.
It's entirely FOSS. It does of course have corporate daddy providing dev resources for it but it definitely is not anywhere near the location for proprietary as Java.
It should be well and truly on the same side of this graph as Rust.
I'm also replacing Github but I'm waiting for Forgejo to implement federation
Is that something that's happening?
What is this shit? I don't recognize half of this garbage. How is terminal + text editor not an option?
That's just the Emacs logo in the top-left. At least I assume Emacs has a terminal since there's that old "Vim proverb" about Emacs being a "great OS, it just lacks a good editor."
This is pretty much nonsense lol
TS, JS, Java, and Codium are proprietary?
I don't think Codium is on this image
Topleft of Soydev square? Or is that VS Code?
top 97 comments