I'm using a Garmin watch with GadgetBridge. I've never had the watch connected to any Garmin app.
post
Suunto ... sends your data to finland china.
Annoying as I bought it to keep my data in Europe (better of multiple evils) but it's china now anyway. sigh
I really want more F/OSS hardware to become a thing.
Look into Withings, a French company. Not sure what cloud infra they use though.
These valid conversations seem to flush out the "you're not interesting to anyone" comments.
Privacy must be a choice and sadly one denied to most people by the packaged software. All data is interesting enough to create multibillion dollar networks and net worth.
Best to just not have a fitness tracker.
Seriously, this. The things are genuinely useless. They canโt even measure your heart rate correctly (seriously look it up. They use algorithms to โestimateโ your heart rate. Different brands give different results. People wear elaborate chest strap setups to try and get an accurate value and even then itโs subject to a huge margin of error).
Get a $10 dumbwatch with a stopwatch function. Run or cycle a familiar route once in a while to track your progress. Find different ways to challenge yourself. Do some runs all out. Hill sprints. Do some longer runs a bit slower than you would think, so that even if your breathing is a little heavier you could still hold a conversation with someone while maintaining that pace.
Ignore all the senselessly overcomplicated 5 stage heartrate zone V02max aerobic astrology bull that these companies advertise to you as a big benefit of their product. Having a 3d map of your route is not going to make you a better runner. Having a virtual leaderboard where 99% of people you compete against are using a wonky cellphone gps that teleports them 1000ft off course isnโt going to make you a better runner
And once I considered making a real tracker. Free market told me to screw myself, becausr
- it'll be more expensive obviously
- nobody cared for real data, very few users understand this point
- regular users want something really simple, nonsense apps work just because all people need is motivation
- professionals do not care for they do not really know what to do with this data, they want a slice of contract paid by investors
- doesn't matter what the product is, it's how it is marketed
Bottom line: nobody really needs good trackers, and also it's all in your head. Just authentically enjoy your workout and if you need a technology for motivation - take some free app from f-droid and keep it local!
I have "looked it up" and I have designed medical PPG devices professionally also. They absolutely do not "estimate" your heart rate any more than holding your finger to your wrist and counting your heart beats in a minute. That is also "estimation" just like literally all physical measurements that are measured for less than t=infinity are.
Of course, there are manufacturers and models that do it badly, especially during weightlifting or heavy flexion/high wrist impact activities.
1 lead ECG can also very very reliably measure your heart rate even during and that is what chest straps like the Polar H10 do in a variety of exercises.
Here is a good overview of fitness watch PPG testing in a variety of scenarios and how it correlates to 1 lead ECG. This guy does tons and tons of extended tests. I just chose a recent one that has recent devices. Even sleep cycle recognition in modern smart watches is getting better and better correlation to EEG, which this guy also tests sometimes.
Stress, recovery times, VO2max, etc.. All of the "1 degree removed" statistics are generally a loose educated guess and generally crap.
Heart rate, HRV, skin temperature, speed with GPS + IMUs, and to a certain extent relative activity intensity can be directly measured and are not a guess if the device is designed and tested well (which admittedly, only like 10% of devices are)
Blood pressure measurements using the principle of delay between electrical signals and pressure wave elasticity is also being FDA certified right now as accurate to a certain percentage of medical pressure cuffs.
if the device is designed and tested well (which admittedly, only like 10% of devices are)
Pretty condescending post only for you to โadmitโ that the overwhelming supermajority of products on the market are badly designed. And then to agree with me that the information they extrapolate is โcrapโ, too.
Did you know that virtually all runners are using tech from that 90% crap category? Thatโs also who my post aimed at. You know, the people currently being scammed by these marketing companies, not people with the specific medical grade equipment you personally designed.
Thank you, nonetheless, for the interesting info and further reading. Hopefully it will help steer people towards good equipment if they do decide they want to track these metrics as accurately as possible
This would be tough unless you plan to self-host or use something like "Gadgetbridge" to keep the data local.
Nearly every service I know of will use some kind of American backend, or sells/"shares" their data with Americans.
It's basic. It's open source, it doesn't need GPlay, and it works.
Between this and a GPX track recorder you most of the data these things use except heart rate, and heart rate trackers are really bad at what they do.
I can also recommend MediLog for manual recording of real data from external tools.
I use fitotrack, as it keeps everything offline. I use trale to track my weight. Both are on fdroid
While AWS is an American company, you might not know that it has data centres all over the planet. Anyone using AWS can configure where their data lives, and therefore which laws apply.
That said, I'd be interested in something that doesn't store the data remotely at all.
False.
And if you're supporting AWS that means that the profits are flowing back to its American executive team.
Yeah and the Feds are soooooooo interested in fitness data.
GPS location of your home and work, plus a map of isolated locations where you can regularly be found? Yeah, I can't see any reason why they'd be interested in that.
I assume youโre from the UK. Why would any US agency be interested in data from regular UK citizens? Because I really donโt get it. And people usually overestimate the resources that actually get put in into observing individuals. Even the US cannot simply track anyone with a pulse.
Bigger datasets are usefuller.
It's all automated anyway. They don't manually track people anymore unless you are a high-value target.
Because of the five eyes program tUK could ask US for the info
Yes. Then what? Whatโs the use case?
Well they can get lods of information that can give them answers to their questions about you even if it is not admissible in court it could lead to more surveillance. You are probably doing something illegal at some point so you can be targeted too
Quick example, tracking if you were at a protest.
Whatever your stance on Palestine/Iran, it's scary that a perfectly peaceful protest is resulting in arrests. And your location data like a fitness tracker pins you to that protest.
all 28 comments