No. Shit.
post
Where I live, phones have never been allowed in classrooms. Students aren't even allowed to use them in the break between classes. Obviously, there are violations of this rule, but they're clear exceptions, not the norm.
The idea that this is just being implemented in some schools and hasn't been for a while feels... preposterous.
Right? I'm here wondering when they started allowing them in the first place.
The change was about a decade ago where I am. When I was in school (even later during the time where nearly everyone had smartphones they were addicted to) they were very strictly not allowed at all. If you said you needed to contact your parent? You'd walk to the office and use their phone to call them - if it was important and couldn't wait. If a teacher or admin saw your phone, even if you weren't using it, it meant at least an after school detention and they'd take your phone; to get it back, a parent had to come sign for it and pick it up in person after school. Some years you had to pay a small fee to get it back on top of that. Consequences worsened from there for repeat offenders. This applied even during lunch and in between classes.
Then, a couple years after I left, one of my younger friends video called me during school in the middle of a class. I was shocked and was all "what the hell are you doing!?" and she was confused. I asked her and other friends who were still in the school I went to and, yep, now you're allowed to have your phones out whenever. Bizarre!
I would guess that they just got sick of enforcing it and got sick of parents (and students) complaining, but who knows. It's a shame. As if decent teachers didn't already have it hard enough without having to compete with the addictive easy dopamine machine. We're failing them and these kids. :(
It's actually a step worse (well, better). I mostly know American education but I've heard from friends other countries had it too where schools actively suggested and encouraged phone/computer use in classrooms. The argument was they'd use them to look up things the teacher was talking about and help them understand better or the teacher could direct them to an interactive learning experience online or something.
This is a very needed reversal of that.
Yup, I've heard Scandinavian countries were big on "digital learning", but reverted to physical books recently. Apparently, successful learning is a matter of good teaching, not good technology. Who woulda thunk?
spoiler
Answer: everyone paying even a modicum of attention and not prioritising the marketing of tech companies over what actual teachers have to say.
In class: phone is silent / off in the bag.
Else : whatever.
No need for a straight ban.
I would violate the shit out of this rule when I was a teen to be honest.
This seems like the obvious right choice. If someone's on their phone, they're not paying attention. If they're not paying attention to the lesson, they're not learning the lesson.
If I'd had a smart phone in class, I would have finished every snes and nes era JRPG, and learned nothing.
My calculus teacher back in HS didn’t care if we paid attention; her attitude was it was our funeral if we didn’t. That led to a bunch of us seniors bringing in our gameboys and playing Pokemon. I may have caught all 151 (yes even Mew glitch) in Red, but all I got in return was a D+ in calculus. With a smartphone I would have been in even worse shape.
Not surprising, but there’s a useful lesson in why it works.
A ban takes away the decision, and the daily willpower fight against old habits. Same thing I’ve seen in change projects: if the new way depends on people choosing it again and again, it fades.
Make it the default and it sticks.
In the Netherlands, schools have banned smartphones in schools for a while now. I'm glad that's the case.
Took your time.
There's just no place for a phone in the school. Students will use and have used any and all reasons possible to try to use the phone. It's always an emergency. It's always something, so long as they can excuse themselves to use the phone.
Can they just ban phones in general? Or just for me please, make it socially acceptable to not use a phone at all please.
Wtf why allow them at all? IPad parenting at school too now?? No one wants to parent these days /s but not really
Limiting distractions is conducive to learning? Sacre bleu!
Just because this thumbnail... This further improves as screen usage is reduced. That means no laptops and especially no tablets.
I know some would call me ableist because hand writing has its own challenges, but hand writing improves learning and removes dependence on corporate platforms which are designed and proven to extract money, privacy, and attention from users, regardless if they're kids.
It's not ableist if you provide accommodations for the students who need them, which is going to be a tiny percentage anyway.
dependence on corporate platforms which are designed and proven to extract money, privacy, and attention from users
Would be great if y'know, we'd actually invest more in open source versions of these systems and schools pick these instead of falling back to all of these commercial solutions.
First time my son complained about doing badly on a test but he can't review it with me because it was on a computer I got royally pissed.
Why would they ever allow it in the first place?
So many parents are mad they can't text or call their kids at school. It's insane.
Also, the tech lobby works at the state level against statewide bans, so it usually ends up district-by-district or school-by-school.
I've also heard folks argue the kids should have them to learn to use them responsibly (which, for many, is functionally impossible).
I can see why parents would want their kids to have a way to contact them in case of like a school shooting which as we know are entirely too common in America. But to text and call the kids is almost abusive, school is stressful but being able to craft a personality without constant connect to you parents is good for development. And that’s aside from the educational distractions
I sorta get the shooting thing, though the actual risk is so vanishingly rare that it shouldn't be a thing they plan for. Also, we don't want kids to have phones during an emergency like a shooting because they jam up emergency services/phone lines and it keeps them from effectively following instructions that could keep them safe.
And on the independence front, they're absolutely tethered to their folks. So many parents have tracking apps on and are constantly keeping tabs on their kids' locations. I personally know multiple kids whose parents have showed up at minor car accidents before emergency services because they're just watching the kid dot on the tracking map. Plus, kids almost all share their locations with their friends and are socially expected to be available on whatever app.
So many kids growing up with smartphones are functionally never alone and you can see the anxiety it breeds.
Parents barely parent anyway. Why do they need to contact their kids DURING school?
This is a good example of confirmation bias in action.
Let's be clear about what this article actually reports. One study, examining 3.3 million students across approximately 4,600 schools, identified modest improvements in academic performance associated with strict cellphone restrictions. The estimated improvement amounted to roughly one to two additional weeks of instruction per academic year.
That's hardly the educational revolution some people in this comment section seem to think it is.
More importantly, this is not a settled scientific conclusion. The article itself acknowledges that another major study, published through the National Bureau of Economic Research, found that the average effects of cellphone bans on academic achievement were consistently close to zero. It identified modest improvements in some high school mathematics results, but also small negative effects in middle schools.
A separate international review of 22 studies found that the evidence was limited, inconsistent, and lacking randomized controlled trials. Several studies found no relationship between phone bans and academic achievement whatsoever.
The problem here is that people appear to have already decided that banning phones improves education, and they are treating any research that supports that belief as confirmation while conveniently ignoring research that contradicts it.
There is also a fundamental distinction between identifying a statistical association and establishing a meaningful causal relationship. Even when a study identifies an improvement following a policy change, that does not automatically establish that the policy itself was responsible for the improvement, much less that the effect is substantial or generalizable.
I'm not arguing that students should spend their school day scrolling through TikTok. Obviously, phones can be distracting. I'm arguing that we should distinguish between a policy that sounds intuitively reasonable and one that has actually demonstrated measurable educational benefits.
So far, the broader research does not support the certainty with which some people are advocating these bans. A small, inconsistent improvement in some studies is not proof that banning phones meaningfully improves academic performance.
Read the research, not just the headline. And perhaps consider whether you're evaluating the evidence objectively or simply looking for studies that validate what you've already decided to believe.
For anyone reading this, the NBER study actually found that it DID improve scores, but declared otherwise because they're a private think tank that literally just says whatever corporations pay them to. They have a long and storied history of providing pro-corpo 'studies.'
Do you happen to know of studies that look at places that removed all screen-based teaching from schools? I remember reading some articles about the issue being not just phones, but also using laptops and tablets as teaching devices. Perhaps more screens than just phones should be banned/limited for there to be a significant effect.
Yeah, in the end, if someone is gonna get distracted with the phone, i assure you that they are gonna get distracted even without, be it just fiddling, doodling or looking at the void
Meta will probably interpret this as an infringement on the company’s freedom of expression and challenge it in court.
In other news, 2035, as the cult of Trump has finally been stamped out, the long range implications of his dire presidency and collapse of the United States will probably not be in the minds of the survivors.
They'll ban them during work hours and from inmates during "rehabilitation" and work hours too. Children are deemed property in the US. They are always the lab rats for what's to come. It sickens me deeply.
all 22 comments