That guy "wrote" and sold AI generated math textbooks for a while, so do be careful.
(Yine de eski videolarında iyi matematik önerileri var)
That guy "wrote" and sold AI generated math textbooks for a while, so do be careful.
(Yine de eski videolarında iyi matematik önerileri var)
If its so discrete why are they talking about it?
Unlike those continuous whores
Continuous whore over here.
Fuck discrete math, do you see the world being processed as discrete units, no!
This is where you shove your digital computer up your ass, its now time for analog. \s
Mathematicians are usually far down the spectrum and have issues with body language and social cues. There are exceptions, but they're rare. 3Blue1Brown is a freak case. And If you think this guy's weird, try group theory.
edit: I never do this, but umm.. to the people that downvote me: how's that math career going?
While mathematicians are significantly more likely to be autistic than the general population, "usually" is a gross over-estimate.
The first study I found had a rate of 1.85% (against 0.24%). Even accounting for undiagnosed and unreported cases which would of course push that number up a fair bit, you've clearly got an incorrect impression.
Uh huh, uh huh. Interesting. Interesting you find the word "usually" referring to a broad location within a distribution curve so research-worthy. Reread my comment, please, and have a nice day. Much love, friend. <3
when someone says "usually", I don't picture them meaning 1.8%
I have re-read your comment and don't see what you were trying to get me to see, sorry.
Apology accepted. <3
Oh. You seem to be being an ass. Don't do that.
Mathematicians are not "usually far down the spectrum" and you shouldn't tell untruths like that.
Most people are quirky in some way. Maths is a niche interest so that already counts as a quirk - but that doesn't make it a diagnosable condition.
I have spent a lot of time with plenty of good mathematicians, and while they have their quirks, most are just like everyone else. They're pretty smart as a rule, and so a lot of them are in fact very charming. Don't forget that while they are not all the same thing, all kinds of intelligence are well correlated, so that being good at maths (one kind of intelligence) actually correlates quite highly with emotional intelligence.
Having spent that time with them... you can also see the other people. The difference is not that subtle in many cases!
I'm not being an ass. I'm stating things that are quite obvious to most, but may be hurtful to some that have not come to accept them. I'm not trying to be hurtful. I'm trying to hint towards things that are important to understand and accept.
Being down the spectrum is nothing anyone should ever be ashamed of. It's a strength, not a weakness. And studying math is a beautiful thing. There's not a lot of money in math. People who study it do it for true love of their field and craft. I value people who are passionate about knowledge and do things out of love.
Maybe you don't see it now, but all of my messages in this comment section come from an actual place of love.
Oh, it's "obvious" to you, so I guess that's enough.
I don't care if someone is autistic - I have loads of autistic and non-autistic friends and it's not any kind of insult to me. I just think truth is important - it's the same as saying that a group of people is mostly gay or mostly trans - it's not a bad thing, but it's bad to mislabel people.
I've spent a lot of time around mathematicians, and a bunch are autistic. But most aren't. What's "obvious" to you is wrong, sorry. If you love them you won't misdiagnose them.
I may not be autistic. That does not mean I don't have a powdered sugar coating of the 'tism
Truth IS very important. You want me to get technical? I can do that. We could have spared ourselves this debate, but here we go I guess.
You say "1.85% against 0.24%". That's autism. Not "far down the spectrum". These are different things. Autism is the end tail of this spectrum. The end of the distribution. If you were to find that within a group, a sample is found to be 7.7 times more likely to display a trait than the general population is, what would you guess about less extreme expressions of that trait?
Do you think they would be more present within the general population or within the group?
Look, I don't want to be mean or anything but like... You're proving my point both with the study you linked and through this argument.
And i honestly truly wish you a wonderful day, and I honestly truly didn't mean to upset you or misrepresent the truth.
So people without autism can be "far down the autism spectrum"? I don't think that makes sense. "Far down the spectrum" that has at its far end non-verbal, highly dependent people, implies to me someone with something diagnosable at minimum.
And even if I didn't think that, I think you are relying on a stereotype from popular culture, anecdote and bias more than anything else. What sub-disorder-level symptoms of autism spectrum disorder other than the most stereotypical ones do you think mathematicians tend to have, and what reason do you have to believe that? Do you know many mathematicians who have unusual eating behaviours? Who engage in self-harm?
You’re proving my point both with the study you linked and through this argument.
Sounds to me that you think pushing back on falsehoods is a sign of autism? Is that right? It's not autistic to think that it's important to get stuff like this right.
Oh and also....
It’s not autistic to think that it’s important to get stuff like this right.
This made my day. Bless you.
Yes, they can be far down a spectrum. Look it up... Or do you want to be petty and talk percentiles? I'll go there but man.. idk I just had lunch and am a bit tired.
I didn't diagnose anyone, friend. Just let it go and ask yourself why my claim was so upsetting to you.
Look, imagine if I said "Mathematicians usually are very picky about chalk".
Would you have asked that I backed up my claim? Would you have replied to everything you did reply to here? Why did you, then? Why is this something that cannot be ignored?
These might prove to be more interesting questions than whether or not mathematicians are wherever in any kind of curve.
You can get into percentiles if you think it would help convince someone that "pretty far down the spectrum" is "not even really on the spectrum." Or maybe you'd like to anchor the discussion by saying how far down the spectrum the median person is, or someone with Asperger's?
Some mathematicians are pretty picky about chalk, but most are not. Probably most mathematicians have an opinion about chalk but like... probably most truck drivers have an opinion about gear sticks. I can't really tell you if I would have replied since we're not in that situation, but I can tell you that I don't think it's nearly as important to get right.
Why is this something that cannot be ignored?
It can be, I just didn't - because, as I say, I think it's important to get right. I also don't think you should go around saying people are "pretty far down the spectrum" of OCD, or depression or anything like that, either.
Ps: i could use your help in a different thread about NaN. Do you think NaN as a programming concept is a number? Also, what is a number, to begin with, in non-tautological terms? No good answers there so far. If you have any ideas, look at my post hiatory and feel free to chime in.
In this thread you've been fairly resistant to responding substantively and have added a fair few patronising jibes, so I have no interest in doing that.
That's fair. I hope you understamd that when I was arguing with you, in my mind, i was arguing to aspects of my past self.
As someone who has struggled with self loathing the vast majority of their life, i don't speak kindly to myself sometimes.
You're right that i was patronizing to you in some messages and that's not cool. I'll be more careful about how i express myself in the future and keep this in mind. This is a promise.
I was teased as a kid for being different. It fucked me up. Real bad. I'll spare you the details but i often wish i could tell that kid that yes, he was very different and very weird and that's a good thing. That he should love himself more, not less because of it. That what he would get and understand thanks to that weirdness is worth going through anything anyone could ever say to him.
This is my struggle, and today you were collateral damage of my bs. I sincerely apologize. I was rude and patronizing while you just wanted to get things straight, and you didn't deserve the way i treated you.
I have a story, but no excuse. I'm sorry.
Please share your data.
It really seems like you're basing pretty broad claims on your anecdotal experience rather than on any kind of hard evidence.
Note: I'm not a mathematician, not diagnosed with anything, and therefore not a.part of any group you're trying to characterize. I'm just a drive-by comment reader with very basic understanding of science, data and proving claims.
FishFace linked a study. It's useful.
Where is your data? You are the one making a claim. What study backs up what you have said and how?
This is basic science stuff. Your responses make me pretty concerned you have some serious biases that only data would alleviate.
Oh you're the same person as before? Sorry, genuinely didn't realize.. Ignore my previous answer.
This is basic science stuff
OH YEAH? WHERE'S YOUR DATA ON THAT CLAIM?
Usually means more often than not.
And making fun of that is low
How is it low? Do you know what I studied or where I lie within the spectrum?
Are you the person depicted in the OP? Or are you being defensive?
I am not the person depicted and am being slightly defensive. How about you?
I am saying that making fun of someone for their appearance and for being likely on the spectrum is low (aka: the OP is low). But someone you interpreted it as an attack?
The mathematicians at my institute seem by far better socially adjusted than me, a lowly engineer.
You are getting down voted because you are associating part of the wide and beautiful array of personality types found in humans into a medical diagnosis. I'll accept that mathematics draw certain personality types but not that they "have issues with body language and social queues".
That's something you gotta give facts for. You're just calling people dweebs like a bad 80s movie but actually worse, because calling them a dweeb doesn't imply some sort of disability.
I see your point but please try to see mine. I don't find having issues with body language and social cues as a bad thing. I don't think claiming certain people tend to be further of nearer the beginning of the autism spectrum requires me to cite sources or back up my claim with hard facts or conclusive studies because I don't believe anyone should feel offended or attacked by being possibly located anywhere within that curve.
You're right that it is like calling people dweebs, only I don't assign negative value to being a dweeb. Like... you know.. If I called graphic design students "artsy", I doubt anyone would feel like I need to back that.
I can see your point, though and you're definitely right that I should be more careful with people's feelings in this matter.
PS: Autism being a disability is not a scientific claim. What a disability is and isn't is a matter of opinion and value, not an irrevocable fact of medicine. I am friends with the mother of a non-verbal autistic child. That kid will never have a normal job or be able to take care of himself in a socially acceptable way. He will suffer, though, and he will never be able to do things we are all told we all have to do to be responsible adults since we're young children. I don't consider the kid disabled, though. I consider a society that demands things from him in order to let him survive and preserve his liberty sick. Know what I mean?
As one of those people, there's maybe a higher rate than normal but most mathematicians are not autistic or socially impaired.
The only good thing you have done is a bash dice simulator, maybe you should stick to that instead of ragebaiting.
Or, and hear me out, we all just love our field.
We're the lucky kids whose interests aligned with the perceived necessities of our society. Also, if your job was reading a large amount of texts, dealing with the daycare center that is university leadership, and writing papers for your survival (40--50 hour weeks), then you too might get some social skill rust!
Maths career is going great by the way - slowly grinding my way to proctologist (associate prof).
I couldn't agree more and have mad respect for those in the field. This whole thread was a cluster fuck. I got all defensive and what i thought would come across as banter and acceptance didn't fly that way. I probably should have shut up a while ago, but I will now.
Apologies for being a dick.
Naaaber lan birader? İstanbul bokgönderi fakültesi nasıl?
Yooo iyi gidiyor!!!
Burası ufak bir mahalle gibi lol.
Okul baya iyi gidiyor ya ismilazımdeğil yerkeşkesinde sonunda kendi okulumdan 3-5 düzgün insan buldum, zaten elektronik'te de hobici bilgisi 2. sınıfın sonuna kadar rahat taşıyacak gibi duruyor onda sürtmeye de vakit kalıyor.
Senin durumlar nasıl?
Seni iyi bulmak beni mutlandırdı. Şu anda olaylar boktan bizde, iş kaybettim birkaç ay evvel, gurbette böyle olmak çok boktan, uzun günler geçiriyorum kızıma bakarak...
Ama en azından bi iş görüşmesi buldum, ikinci etaptayım, umarım bitirir bu boktan durumu.
all 68 comments