"Contributors: Claude"
Please refer to rules 7 and 8 of this community.
"Contributors: Claude"
Please refer to rules 7 and 8 of this community.
How much Claude is in this?
What does this offer that the other major systems don't already provide?
For basic ad and tracker blocking the overlap is large and AdGuard Home covers most of it . JustDNS isn't trying to redo that part Three things set it apart:
Attribution. It groups queries by the company behind the domains, not just by domain, and does it per device. You can block a company across all its domains and CNAMEs, for one device or the whole network, in a single action.
Built-in HA. Pi-hole and AdGuard Home have no native high availability you add a third-party sync tool. JustDNS replicates config and query state across nodes over an authenticated channel so one node failing doesn't take DNS down.
DNS only. No HTTPS interception, unlike eBlocker. No CA to trust for the filtering, nothing terminating your TLS. One container, local only, no account, config encrypted at rest.
Technitium is a full DNS server (zones, DHCP, scripting), a different scope(in the moment). JustDNS is a filtering resolver focused on attribution and per-device policy.
Why is this down voted? I think it's good to hear explanations to see if OP (or anyone) understands what they're building and what issues they look to solve.
Good to know there's some competency.
Why is this down voted?
People love to pretend being special for hating on AI.
Whenever you see the word A*, you have to automatically downvote the whole post and smack its op around whenever you see them. It doesn’t matter if it has anything genuinely useful, as long as Clau*** or Cod** is somewhere in the post or the repo on GitHub.
Interesting, thanks for sharing.
I see comparisons to pihole, but how does it compare to Technitium, especially since it supports clustering.
Honestly glad you are doing this, because I was a bit bummed that the only DNS filter I found that easily supported HA was written in C# (personal preference/prejudice). I'll give this a go when I find some time to ϲнαπgє τнє ⲅμππίπg ϛψϛτєϻ
Thanks! Fair question, and Technitium is the right comparison once you want more than Pi-hole.
Honest framing: Technitium is a full DNS server (authoritative zones, DHCP, scripting, the lot) and it's mature and battle-tested. If you need a complete DNS platform, it's hard to beat. JustDNS is narrower on purpose. It's a filtering resolver built around one idea: showing which companies your devices actually talk to, with per-device attribution, a world map, and the ability to block a company for a single device or the whole network, plus per-device and per-group policies. So it's less "DNS server" and more "privacy-focused filter with a dashboard."
On clustering/HA: JustDNS has optional multi-node HA, but it works differently from zone replication. Nodes share one config and query state over an authenticated channel (HKDF-SHA256 + ChaCha20-Poly1305), up to a handful of nodes, with a cluster-wide update that rolls them together. It's aimed at "run two or three boxes, keep them identical, no single point of failure," not authoritative zone transfer.
And yes, it's Rust, which is partly why I started it. It's young though, so Technitium wins on maturity and breadth today. If you give it a go I'd genuinely like to hear where it falls short for your setup.
At least the first section of this response sounds like it was AI generated.
I'll take that as a compliment on the structure though I actually wrote the whole thing myself
Honest Framing: it sounds like you're not being truthful or you've used/read AI so much that you've started to emulate the linguistic patterns. This isn't accusatory, I've found myself typing similar things and I find it infuriating in my own life. My honest advice, be more up front with AI usage in this forum. It buys a lot of good will.
Most people would just ship their logs to something like Graylog if they need this type of analysis.
Fair point, but analysis isn't really the goal. Graylog shows you logs, it doesn't resolve DNS, block anything, or enforce a per-device policy. JustDNS is the resolver itself: the company attribution is a byproduct, the actual job is acting on it. Block a company for a single device or the whole network, with per-device and per-group rules.
The real reasons it's its own thing: everything stays local, no query history shipped off to another system, no external data at all, which is kind of the whole point for a privacy tool. On top of that, DNSSEC, encrypted client DNS (DoT/DoH), and optional multi-node HA so it isn't a single point of failure. The attribution and the world map are built in, with no log pipeline, parsing or GeoIP setup to maintain.
So Graylog is great if you just want to look at logs. JustDNS is for when you want the resolver to see it, show it, and actually do something about it, without handing your full DNS history to yet another box.
Is the company id by AS number? If so I think that would always show the hosting provider but not the actual operator. Like anyone hosting on GCP would be using a Google AS, or do I have that wrong?
The company attribution is domain-based a compiled in catalogue mapping registrable domains to the operator (connect.facebook.net to Meta, etc.), so hosting AS doesn't matter there. The limitation is that it's a curated set not exhaustive. The world map is the ASN part you mean: offline IP-to-ASN, which does show the host (GCP, Cloudflare). So "who" comes from the domain, "where" from the AS.
all 22 comments