Hi! (lemmy.ca)
submitted 4 days ago by to c/australia
 

Just checking this instance to see how the politics of Australia matches with a podcast I heard espousing the benefits of ranked choice representation. If there’s any takers I’ll appreciate whatever you have to say of your experiences. One thing that caught my attention is the fact of pulling away from the colonial mindset. Due to allowing all to have a voice and feel heard, thereby reducing the demegaugs/corruption. Just throwing feelers out as I want to start endorsing a new way of voting. Thanks

all 13 comments

sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[–] 4 points 4 days ago* (last edited 4 days ago) (4 children)

The biggest downside with it is that the preference system is just complex enough that people think they understand it, but don't, so FUD is easy to spread.

We had an issue two elections ago where our Greens party (a minor party) performed more poorly than they had done in the previous election, losing seats to our center left major party. This was purely a result of the way preferences flowed, and their primary vote percentage didn't change at all, but because it's non trivial to understand how that works and because the outcome isn't intuitively obvious, the narrative developed that the greens had lost relevance, despite their primary vote count not changing.

Explanation of how that played out

Background - Australia (at the time of the last two elections) had two major parties, a center right/right wing party (the Liberals) and a center left party (the Labor party). In 2022, the Liberals lost the election and the government and Labor took power with a simple majority. In 2025, the Liberals were absolutely decimated in the election and Labor won in a landslide. In 2022 and in 2025, the Greens pulled up 3rd, with 12% of the primary vote, but only got 1 seat in 2025 as opposed to 4 in 2022

Preferential voting 101 - Votes are tallied. If no one has over 50%, the candidate with lowest number of votes is ruled out. The second choice for voters voting for the losing party now come in to play and get spread around the remaining parties. If no one has over 50%, the process repeats each time moving further down peoples ranked choice list redistributing their votes, until a candidate gets more than 50% of the votes.

And now how it all played out.

In 2022, Labor won the election, but didn't destroy the Liberals. The liberals still won plenty of seats, but not enough to form government. In seats where Labor was not in the final two parties for the seat, their ranked choice preferences largely favoured the Greens over the Liberals, meaning that the Greens effectively got all of Labors votes. In a handful of instances, this boost was enough to push the Greens in front of the Liberals and give the seat to the Greens. Hence 4 seats.

In 2025, the Liberals were annihilated in the voting. People who vote for the Liberals tend to preference Labor over the Greens though, and thus, because there was a large swing against Liberals, there were a large number of seats where they weren't in the top 2 parties, and in most of these, the Greens didn't see any of the ranked choice/preferential votes. And without that boost, as a minor party, they only claimed 1 seat.

In both cases, 12% of the population put the Greens as their first choice. In 2022, that was 4 seats. In 2025, that was 1 seat.

Edit - It's worth noting, this is still a simplified summary, as there are more than 3 parties, there is a Senate as well as the House of Reps, and the way ranked choice/preferences work are different between the two. And this is also only federal elections. There are state and local government elections as well, which have their own rules.

  • source
  • hideshow 4 child comments
  • [–] [S] 1 point 3 days ago (2 children)

    Thank you for the full reply, Yes complex for sure, I still don’t understand. The greens were 12 percent of the primary but the liberals were the second choice for people more than the greens is that correct?

    If so I toatally thought a percentage of votes means they get a percentage of power. But it’s not set up that way by the way your describing.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 1 point 3 days ago (1 child)

    So lets say there is a seat with only 3 candidates (most have more than that, but we'll keep it to 3 to make it easier to work with). A labor candidate, a liberal candidate and a green candidate.

    Because labor and liberal are our two major parties most of the time, in most seats, in most elections, this means that Labor and the Liberals come 1st and 2nd in some order, and the Greens come in 3rd. If neither Labor nor Liberals have more than 50% on their own, then greens are eliminated and their votes tend to go to Labor. If this puts Labor above 50%, they win the seat.

    But it gets interesting when Labor and the Liberals aren't in 1st and 2nd place. Lets say Labor gets 40%, Greens get 35% and Liberals get 25% of a particular seat. Liberals get knocked out, and for simplicities sake, their preferences go to Labor. That puts Labor above 50% and they win the seat.

    But lets say there is a swing to the Liberals and instead the Liberals get 40%, the Greens get 35% and Labor gets 25%. In this scenario, the Labor preferences go to the Greens, putting them above 50% and the Greens win that seat.

    So in both cases, the Greens have the same number of votes, but in one scenario they win a seat and in another they don't. And also more interestingly, a swing to the right, favouring the Liberals instead of Labor, is more likely to land a seat or two for the Greens, despite them being left.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 3 points 4 days ago (5 children)

    Something that everyone interested should check out some time. It should be mandatory for voters.

    https://www.chickennation.com/voting/

    One of the obvious issues with our electoral system is voter confusion, another is deliberate manipulation of that by the duopoly, who regardless of Australia supposedly being a democracy, always end up in power. The systems major flaw is the voters at the end of the day, especially the ones we refer to as 'rusties' (rusted ons) the ones who just keep backing one side of the duopoly, just to keep the other side of the duopoly out. (the lesser evil vs evil).

    Perhaps that is why canada ended up with mark carney.

  • source
  • hideshow 5 child comments
  • [–] [S] 1 point 3 days ago (4 children)

    Spot on with mark carney, I had other priorities to support but just like with the comic in the link, I couldn’t vote for nice party without keeping obvious scumbag out. A lot of people had same sentiments

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 4 child comments
  • [–] 2 points 3 days ago

    That is what the duopoly wants. The thing about the lesser evil is... they are still evil. If you look at a duopoly as a single entity then it makes more sense. Here in Australia the duopoly have been in power for decades, they never lose, they just change colours every now and again, they play the long game, and they play the people.

    If you want things to change for the best, then you have to vote for good.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 1 point 3 days ago (2 children)

    Australia currently has a far right party polling above all other parties btw, with a state election this month, another state election early next year, as well as the federal, another state, and 2 territory elections in 2028.

    I'm not sure if there is an electoral system on earth that truly protects democracy for the sake of a decent society. First past the post does seem like an obvious big party con though.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] [S] 1 point 2 days ago (1 child)

    Micgenre did mention Arrows imposssibility theorem that seems to suggest there’s no way to have a voting system that doesn’t have a spoiler possibility. In video games it’s called griefing.

    And as for far right parties getting hold of swaying the general public. Alberta held a referendum if they wanted to join the states, it held off on that possibility for now but those far right are getting even more entrenched from each defeat. I don’t understand how to civilly combat them. Other then tell them they are stupid. And punching. Which is not democratic lol

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 1 point 1 day ago

    'Good' always has an obstacle that 'evil' can ignore, good needs to play by the rules, including honesty, and pacifism, otherwise good is no longer... good. Evil has the upper hand in that respect, and people are so easily manipulated by their own flaws, and by the agendas of others.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 1 point 4 days ago* (last edited 4 days ago) (1 child)

    it's a good system but not perfect. 3-way contests can lead to scenarios where it's better to not vote for your preferred candidate.

    It's not possible to have an ordinal voting system that prevents a spoiler effect. See Arrow's impossibility theorem.

  • source
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] [S] 1 point 3 days ago

    Ada said same, it’s wild there can be a 3 way vote split. The one thing I thought this system kept out. Have you heard about any suggestions that people talk about to help that issue?

  • source
  • parent