I should probably stop being surprised, but somehow whenever I bring up stuff AGAINST rapists, people show up to tell me I'm wrong, too emotional, going to somehow get everyone killed (against all evidence), or other insane shit about why we just CAN'T put rapists in jail for life without parole or at least 20+ years, as if they committed a crime that harmed someone for life in extreme ways and will likely continue to seek victims to abuse.
post
This seems like a bad faith argument tbh. First of all, if someone killed someone in a robbery or something in a terrible desperate time in their life and then cleans themselves up and has been married with kids for a dozen years and has been a good productive member of society, there are lots of people who would argue that they shouldn't have to go to prison still. But mostly it fails to recognize that different people have different beliefs regarding the purpose of imprisonment, with significant overlap but massive differences of opinion. There are basically three schools of thought, deterrence, rehabilitative and protective. In deterrence, prison is seen as a punishment that exists to deter people from committing crimes that could result in imprisonment, and to deter individuals from being repeat offenders because they don't want to go back to prison. In rehabilitative prison exists as a sort of school, to teach people socially and literally to be better members of society and not continue to commit crime after release. And protective where people who have shown that they are dangerous to society are removed from society and kept watch over so that they can't hurt people anymore. Imprisoning after 20 years of good and reformed behavior is expensive and only makes any sense under the first school of thought. They have already self rehabilitated and there is no real evidence of them being a current, enduring threat to society. That said, none of this really applies to Russell Brand, he seems creepy as hell and is very likely an unreformed and dangerous predator, the evidence to convict him is simply old. Also he can go fuck himself. But I hate bad arguments even more when I agree with their conclusion, it makes my own views look bad.
Later edit: sorry Miisha, this was a neurodivergent rant I hope you didn't feel targeted by. I am just waiting for my bus.
I think this might be about Jacob Geller. Geller claims he's rehabilitated, but the evidence of such is poor. He only posted an apology on Bluesky, not on youtube or patreon where most of his money comes from. And a lot of women he worked with say he never disclosed the rape he did, and they feel betrayed for having endorsed him. Geller might have learned more about consent in the bedroom, but he hasn't learned about participating in rape culture, he hasn't learned how to apologise or disclose. Or he doesn't want to apologise or disclose.
IMO, all three approaches are needed for different situations:
- Deterrence, because rules without consequences do not work in general
- Rehabilitation, because both society and the offender benefit a lot more if the offender gets their shit together, and it's also a lot cheaper for the public if done correctly
- Protective, because there are people that are so damaged that their chances of being rehabilitated are miniscule - can't rehabilitate someone who's unable to process the consequences of their deeds.
Sadly, there a fourth approach being actual practice in the US: Profit, and it uses Vengeance as a fig leaf.
We don't need to pick just one option, it can be a mix of all three approaches
People saying this might not be making a sophisticated argument, but rather just repeating what the law says. In Western countries, crimes generally fall under the statute of limitations, meaning you can't be litigated anymore many years later, but murder is often excluded from that.
Because as a society, we decided at some point that murder is so problematic, and the grief can still be felt decades later, so we want to allow families to get closure even decades later still.
We can decide to do the same for rape, but the statute of limitations exists for good reasons and there's ethical arguments to be made on what the purpose of the punishment is after all this time.
If you think that the punishment for rape isn't harsh enough to scare people off from doing it, or to take potential repeat offenders out of society, then just increasing the jail time might rather be what you want to lobby for.
That's about as much as I can say without even knowing what jurisdiction we're talking about...
It's been shown that increasing punishment for a crime only deters it to a point. What it mainly achieves is make criminals more violent to ensure witneses do not speak. What actually reduces crime is in fact making sure crimes are punished, as often it's not that criminals are ok with the consequences they just think they can avoid getting caught. With rape specifically, the issue is that many men don't seem to understand how wrong it is and think the punishment is way too exaggerated already. Witnesses will cover for each other and the actual people prosecuting might choose to look the other way. This, in turn, leads to the victims not speaking out because it means a very small chance of punishment for the rapist and for themselves no real benefit, only making a very traumatic and shameful episode in their lives publicly known and risking people calling them liars.
The following is my opinion. I am myself a man with limited perspective so maybe i don't know what i'm saying. I meant this rebuttal specifically about your solution to increase prison time. I don't think this invalidates the argument for statute of limitations. I just think the solution is more about education than increasing punishment.
You forgot the second effect kiss cool(as they say in France), the perpetrators are off the market when they are in prison.
So it's not only to persuade people to not do bad things, it's also to remove them from society (rehabilitate them if possible etc ofc) so that they cannot do the bad things.
Believe it or not, the funny title wasn't intentional. This is a serious topic.
A woman I know told me that she thinks his sentence was too harsh. Like really? 6-7 years in prison is too harsh for raping someone (amongst other sex offences)???
What the fuck is wrong with people?
In this man's opinion rape and torture should have no statute of limitations just like murder. Those are crimes that traumatize the victim for life, there should be no getting out of it because the perp happened to get away with it for a while.
I agree with your comment, absolutely, just...which man are we talking about?
Because from my understanding, the person in the background is Russell Brand, the person tweeting is (I'm assuming, sorry) apparently a woman...who did you mean? I doubt Brand is saying this 😂
Which man did you mean? Sorry, I'm dumb
I thought the comment above was in defense of rapists saying that well the statute time limit is up so they shouldn't be charged. I was disagreeing and suggesting the law should be changed.
That’s the fucked up thing! They caught a like 93 year old Nazi not that long ago, and I saw people who were asking what the point of putting him in jail was! And the Golden State Killer! People were genuinely suggesting that he should be let out because he’s old and hadn’t killed anyone in a while that we know of for a while. Fuck.
Wouldn't a 93 year old have been like 9 years old in 1942? I'm aware of the Nazi Youth, but I'm pretty sure it was mandatory.
Not saying I know for sure that the guy didn't do evil shit, he very well might have. But I dunno, he was a literal child.
Anyone who said that shit about the Golden State Killer is a fucking moron though.
https://www.npr.org/2021/10/07/1043971890/100-year-old-nazi-guard-on-trial-germany
He was 100, and it was 2021, but damn I hate how easily you came up with excuses on vague time frames.
This is callous, but the person raped is actually worse off. They live with the repercussions of the crime - fear, trauma, PTSD, physical injury, etc.. The murder victim is dead. That is an extreme shock to their loved ones, but not to the one who has passed on.
:cyan_verify:
- Because laws protect rulers, while oppress the governed. Laws aren't just. Prisons aren't rehabilitation or reparations.
I see you The Rapy Nazi.
Not to lower the seriousness of the act, but to any victims that may read this:
Hey, no. Your life was not ruined. We are all going to be proud of how strong you are! You can heal. Show off yot resilience!!
(Let's consider this "the half full" of the glass half empty glass. It's not fully empty, please! We also need to show victims that there's life ahead and healing is possible. All the doom-speak is perpetuating the hurt imho.)
all 36 comments