It happened. No matter how long ago, a person's life was ruined. That person was seriously hurt, probably even physically, but definitely mentally...and those scars fucking stay. So, it shouldn't matter how long ago it happened...just that it did happen.

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 39 points 16 hours ago* (last edited 13 hours ago) (3 children)

This seems like a bad faith argument tbh. First of all, if someone killed someone in a robbery or something in a terrible desperate time in their life and then cleans themselves up and has been married with kids for a dozen years and has been a good productive member of society, there are lots of people who would argue that they shouldn't have to go to prison still. But mostly it fails to recognize that different people have different beliefs regarding the purpose of imprisonment, with significant overlap but massive differences of opinion. There are basically three schools of thought, deterrence, rehabilitative and protective. In deterrence, prison is seen as a punishment that exists to deter people from committing crimes that could result in imprisonment, and to deter individuals from being repeat offenders because they don't want to go back to prison. In rehabilitative prison exists as a sort of school, to teach people socially and literally to be better members of society and not continue to commit crime after release. And protective where people who have shown that they are dangerous to society are removed from society and kept watch over so that they can't hurt people anymore. Imprisoning after 20 years of good and reformed behavior is expensive and only makes any sense under the first school of thought. They have already self rehabilitated and there is no real evidence of them being a current, enduring threat to society. That said, none of this really applies to Russell Brand, he seems creepy as hell and is very likely an unreformed and dangerous predator, the evidence to convict him is simply old. Also he can go fuck himself. But I hate bad arguments even more when I agree with their conclusion, it makes my own views look bad.

Later edit: sorry Miisha, this was a neurodivergent rant I hope you didn't feel targeted by. I am just waiting for my bus.

  • source
  • hideshow 3 child comments
  • [–] 4 points 11 hours ago

    I think this might be about Jacob Geller. Geller claims he's rehabilitated, but the evidence of such is poor. He only posted an apology on Bluesky, not on youtube or patreon where most of his money comes from. And a lot of women he worked with say he never disclosed the rape he did, and they feel betrayed for having endorsed him. Geller might have learned more about consent in the bedroom, but he hasn't learned about participating in rape culture, he hasn't learned how to apologise or disclose. Or he doesn't want to apologise or disclose.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 1 point 6 hours ago

    IMO, all three approaches are needed for different situations:

    • Deterrence, because rules without consequences do not work in general
    • Rehabilitation, because both society and the offender benefit a lot more if the offender gets their shit together, and it's also a lot cheaper for the public if done correctly
    • Protective, because there are people that are so damaged that their chances of being rehabilitated are miniscule - can't rehabilitate someone who's unable to process the consequences of their deeds.

    Sadly, there a fourth approach being actual practice in the US: Profit, and it uses Vengeance as a fig leaf.

  • source
  • parent