There have been several opportunities to break up major tech monopolies and in each case, the relevant authorities failed. Imagine a world where Meta, Alphabet, Microsoft, etc. were each less than 1/5th their current size, and meaningfully punished for breaking otherwise unenforced laws, and prevented from hiding their financial chicanery. The mind boggles.
post
A tale as old as time.
We would most likely have distributed computing everywhere if we let engineers finish their work on the next generation of operating systems, but IBM needed to sell mainframes. And who knows what the Web would be like if we didn't let Google write half of the modern RFCs...
The fear of opening a port is what killed us IMO.
Imagine connecting to another computer, without (Gasp!) going through a centralised server?!!
/Rant off I guess
I'm still kinda that Opera Unite didn't take off. It was a decentralized server built into the Opera browser, that was easy enough for regular people to use. You just set it up in a config UI in the browser and could enable features like chat, blogs, photo galleries, a music player, etc. At the time, everyone had UPnP enabled, CGNAT wasn't a thing, and Opera handled UDP hole punching for it, so it mostly just worked. https://www.wired.com/2009/10/opera-unite-puts-the-web-server-in-your-web-browser/
This was back when Opera were still based in Norway, had their own browser engine, and were very innovative. A large number of features that became commonplace were in Opera years before any other browser, like tabbed browsing, full-page zoom (browser zoom used to only increase font size while keeping everything else the same size!), restoring your tabs when you re-open the browser, pop-up blocker, a new tab page that shows your commonly accessed sites, private/incognito browsing, sidebars, and more.
Sure, there's a bunch of downsides to a server being built into your browser, but it was an interesting idea. People that don't know anything about servers were able to easily try it out.
Oh man, now you ruined my evening, I didn't know about that, it's awesome!
Maybe I wouldn't have spent so much time building a modern P2P decentralised sharing protocol if I already knew it was tried and killed off...
Thanks for the history nugget!
++
Unfortunately regular people don't understand why they'd use something like this rather than just using Facebook, Instagram, Google Photos, etc. and the major limitation of self-hosting this way is that it's only accessible when your computer is on, which regular people aren't used to.
A lot of people also had pretty limited bandwidth. I was in Australia on ADSL2+ with around 9Mbps down and 700Kbps up.
I think plug-and-play NAS systems are the closest equivalent today, especially now that a lot of people have faster connections. Comcast boosted upload speeds in some markets last year - in my area their regular plans start at 300Mbps down and 100Mbps up. A lot of NAS systems are still missing the "regular person can easily set it up" aspect though, and I'm not sure if they handle sharing stuff with external users.
I really hope technologies like Veilid, Tailcat, and I2P take off more, but they require Developer, Developers, Developers!
what if instead of doing that, we put all of society's resources towards inventing a fascist mode of production where the a curated fake-ass prohibitively expensive to update past-slurry is projected onto the future in such a way that expertise is devalued truth is slain the zone is always flooded with shit and everything is garbage that only sometimes looks like it works?
Its a genuine risk though. People get hacked left right n center with the protective layers we currently have. If that was taken away it would be to risky to do anything serious on a computer.
I think that's already a consequence, TCP/IP is very much a protocol suite that works well for client/server architectures, and HTTP (which eventually, somehow, became the de facto "everything" protocol) even more so. So when you mix these roles and you have machines that act as both client and server at the same time all the deficiencies come to light quite easily. A world with first-class support for mutual authentication and authorization, encryption, peering, roaming, etc at the lowest of network levels was possible, but that ship has sailed.
And who knows what the Web would be like if we didn't let Google write half of the modern RFCs...
Could you elaborate on this? What was this operating-system-to-be?
Plan 9/Inferno chiefly, but more broadly if you read RFCs and other design documents written around that era it's pretty clear that engineers envisioned a decentralised, interoperable, resilient, "modular" computing environment. Some concepts read like fables/alternate universes as they are quite removed to what we have hands-on experience with, but seeing a distributed filesystem in action is a trip. If you have an interest in this stuff, either from an historical or technical standpoint, I highly suggest spending a weekend messing around with a bunch of p9 VMs :)
The only reason video games, Adobe products, MacOS specific apps, and all these other isolated platforms rig themselves to be monopolies is because they choose to be closed source.
The lie they tell people is that open source is more vulnerable because of source being open, yet we see nonstop vulnerabilities for the same closed source swindlers.
They rig everything because of capitalism. So long as the people behind the scenes are around to hoard more wealth on top of their greed, this will always continue.
Then they go out and say we are the industry standard and sell the software to schools on discounts to hook people on them. They also go out and say if you don't use our software, you will be left behind.
They wouldn't even disclose/fix bugs and vulns if it didn't impact their own bottom line. Think about how much in closed source is yet to be discovered or exploited.
Open source is known to fix bugs ASAP; i don't know many major vulnerabilities in the linux kernel that lasted more than a week
It's also the case that the corporate world loathes not having vendors and a chain of accountability and proprietary tech companies have been using these to attack OSS and prevent its wide adoption for decades.
But most importantly corporate and government IT loves Microsoft's Active Directory and there's no alternative to that in Linux.
Fun fact: the same applies to society at large, and especially economies.
Eh. When you start talking about "society", you're implicitly talking about a thing real humans run. A whole lot of ideas have been tried, over the centuries; the power structures that are still around are a good sample of the ones that were actually able to last.
Economies, there's more latitude to talk about.
"It doesn't have to be like this."
-Every system that is demonstrably horrible and propped up by people who are too apathetic, lazy, or tired to change.
Or more like some dumbass back in 1986 made an arbitrary decision and it's now hardcoded into every system on the planet, and the improvement is not enough of an improvement to justify breaking backwards compatibility.
Yeah, it certainly doesn't. What happened yesterday could've been easily avoided if so many countries and businesses had made their own in-house systems rather than depending on Microsoft...
But the problem is that for a lot of businesses, it just doesn't make financial sense to set up their own decentralised systems when centralised systems already exist, offering services way cheaper than you could ever make for yourself - unless there is a specific need it can't fulfill, or you already have appropriate staff and equipment to facilitate/maintain it on the cheap.
And it doesn't help that the general population also lean towards centralisation, all coralling where their friends and family are. And beating that momentum is almost impossible - heck, I'm still stuck using centralised chatting services because convincing anyone who doesn't already want to move with you is like pulling teeth, and worst part is, it only takes one minor inconvenience to undo all that convincing.
Having said all that, the one group I won't excuse is the Government and Public Sector. There's no excuse for tax-payer funded services to not be operating on their own services and/or using other sovereign services, rather than continuing to pump money out if their economy and into the hands of US tech giants!
Having said all that, the one group I won’t excuse is the Government and Public Sector. There’s no excuse for tax-payer funded services to not be operating on their own services and/or using other sovereign services, rather than continuing to pump money out if their economy and into the hands of US tech giants!
Oh man, here in Australia it turns out there was an internal review into whether or not putting all our eggs into the MS basket was a good idea just a couple of months ago, said an outage could have potentially catastrophic impacts.
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2026-11-13/microsoft-reliance-national-security-risk/107382100
And then they came to this conclusion.
While acknowledging the need for diversity of tech providers, Mr Hansford also said it was "unrealistic" for Australia to find alternatives to major US providers, and that it should instead seek closer ties with the company.
🤷
but if they don't give all their money yo Americans, who will fund the fascist mode of production?
I can tell. Intentionally bad UI design so I have to lose time trying to make it work somehow, an OS that hides the settings from you as best as it can, the digital equivalent to putting spikes on a bench to keep homeless away.
This is why I prefer FOSS software, I avoid subscriptions, and I am completelly anti-profit.
I want these motherfuckers to outright die out.
Dog the most recent W11 update on my PC failed and now I don't have a lock screen anymore. I can't lock the computer, it wakes straight to desktop and the option is no longer there despite all the settings requiring a password. Previous update a couple weeks ago completely bricked the system and it took me hours to unfuck it.
I just want the AI coded slop to end.
the digital equivalent to
My autocomplete thought was grocery stores intentionally re/arranging the layout to make you stay as long as possible.
Yep, I run the distro Trisquel. It is one of the few distro's that is FSF approved because it is 100% FLOSS but that is not the only reason. It is because it is also wonderfully usable.
Solar punk is slowly moving ahead. Might not be popular now but it is laying down the frame work for a better future when people come calling.
Solar what now?
Explain. I am genuinely interested.
are you saying we should replace 1's and 0's?
I have a degree in interactive media design.
Yes. This 100%. It'd take a VERY long time for a proper analysis of just how fucked things are.
Also this is being posted to Lemmy. ;-;
But it has to be like something and there will be consequences of any system. TBH I'm fascinated by the possibilities that aren't too. But there are many more "broken" than fixed and that could matter who you are. Not saying it's great is it is, but I feel like we are at an end.
Most big tech companies were seeded by the CIA; it definitely doesn't have to be like this but the way it is is not some accidental thing
Republicans: "We don't understand it. We gave the "tech oligarchs" all the money and all the fame and all the power... Why does everything suck and cost so much!?"
Look... Rant on.
The people that suddenly these days are all about "omg these websites are awful" are the same exact fucking people that DRAGGED US ALL KICKING AND SCREAMING TO THOSE WEBSITES.... AND THEY STILL ARE USING THEM.... CONSTANTLY...
And as a result if the rest of us want to keep in online touch with these people, we have to stay on the platforms too.
It started with the millennials, who looked at all the free and open stuff that existed and went "eww lame" and when MySpace and all came along, went OOH SHINY PRETTY and jumped on it wholesale, and compelled everyone else to too. Meanwhile, the free and open stuff slowly died off. When told why it was bad, they just said, lol nerrrrrrd.
And even now that we have free and open options again (gestures around) the same people -- including the ones going "omg these platforms suck" but still use them exclusively -- look at them and go "eww lame."
Normies prefer fascism because it's prettier and easier. Who needs choice when you can have stupid?
Relevant XKCD from sixteen years ago. It's frustrating how this lesson never seems to sink in for a critical mass of people.
Convenience is the most addictive and powerful drug ever made. People will trade their freedoms for convenience until it gets too hard to ignore.

all 64 comments