Ah, I thought these were the top marginal tax rates.
post
"If we tax the rich, they just move to another country!1!!1!"
Yea, we will tax them there too. And take half of your hoard when they move. You stole long enough from us...
Tax wealth, not work.
Wealth is partly exploited work.
That’s bad math.
Is it though? What is wealth made up of?
Assets is one thing. So you inherit a castle that keeps increasing in value.
Tax wealth not work is a slogan in the UK right now from Gary Stephenson of Gary’s Economics.
That castle was built from corporate profits that almost certainly came in part from severely under-compensating employees.
Which are now long dead. So we tax the wealth that is the castles value.
I was referring to the castle metaphorically, as if it were any large purchase by a Sociopathic Oligarch. Substitute mansion or yacht for castle.
And we should tax all forms of revenues for the wealthy, including income, investment, capital gains, inheritance, etc.
And we should tax the shit out of churches.
There's a difference between workers and work. I don't own the work I produce for my boss.
No, but that work should be generating profit, and almost every employee should share in a higher percentage of those profits. Those at the top just make sure the profit increases, they don't actually earn it, yet they get the far higher share. It's the workers who actually create the profit, and they should be compensated with a much higher percentage of those profits.
Of course, that means lower profits for the company, but if employees are getting fairly compensated, then they will have more buying power, and corporations will make up the difference in lower profit margins with increased sales volume from workers with expendable income.
Taxing the wealth would be repeating history and policy mistakes. They already tried since decades ago. They all abolished it because it doesn't work. It's 1) difficult to execute and 2) impossible to calculate.
Sounds like a bunch of lame, unsupported excuses to me. Tax them hard!
And if they want to leave, let them leave. America is the primary market everybody wants. If you want to move your company to avoid paying taxes, go ahead, but your access to the American market will end, and the government will confiscate ALL your American assets. Good luck making the same profit in the rest of the world.
And tax churches, too.
I'm confused, what does America have to do with anything?
America is the default country on the internet. Whenever somebody makes a country-specific comment on the internet, you can assume they're from the US, because they're the only one imagining that they're the only relevant country in the world.
This post is highlighting the tax rates of European countries, which are them supposed to be compared with the extremely low AMERICAN tax rates.
Austria, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Iceland, Ireland, Italy, the Netherlands, Luxembourg, and Sweden have all repealed them. Wealth taxes survive only in Norway, Spain, and Switzerland.
I'm unsure how America specifically is relevant here.
You can call it unsupported, but the economics literature would just call you uninformed.
We do have some forms of wealth taxing, for example land or building ownership. Home leasing is the one of the few surviving methods of wealth taxing because the rent numbers are clear even over time.
Tax the rich more and put in place a general wealth cap. You can’t have more than say $100,000,000 and that is already a ridiculous sum for anyone person to have. If you are found to be over the limit then anything you own here can be taken to get you under the limit. Land and property can be taken, stocks can be taken, cash directly can be taken.
Also introduce a ban on private jets and yachts, you absolutely need to fly somewhere for a meeting? Join us plebeians on normal flights then, otherwise learn to use zoom and other such tools. A ban on yachts doesn’t mean a ban on all boats, normal smaller boats are fine, cruise ships, cargo ships and tankers are as fine as ever. Just means none of your luxurious mega yachts for you and your rich buddies anymore. Again join us plebeians at the bottom for a change so you understand what it’s like.
The people of Russia, Turkey, and Germany can tell they’ve been swindled by the Oligarchs for far too long!
And spain, don't forget spain.
What’s going in Estonia?
Now find a map of wealth inequality and see how well they correlate.
I'm embarrassed my country is as low as 75% here.
What a fucked up democratic system(s) where such an overwhelming public support doesn't get shit done immediately.
Well, as it turns out, it's "not the worst", but that is no consolation.
"But then the rich/companies will move to another country!" Better have them pay not enough taxes here (and exarcebate the problem) than not having them pay taxes i guess.
¡Viva España!
This is why representative democracy is flawed. Nobody holds the elected officials accountable if they don't handle according to the population's opinion. I wish more countries included some direct democracy measures, too.
To me the issue is caused by how we determine how much tax is paid.
If you're wealthy, you can structure your income in such a way that you are not earning any and therefore don't need to pay tax on that "non-existent" income.
It's also how the multinational companies structure their finances to make little or no profit except in the lowest taxing country around where "all" their "profits" are taxed.
In other words, we need to restructure the tax system globally to measure income and profit differently instead.
With the current crop of Neanderthals in charge, it's unlikely to happen in our lifetime unless something drastically changes. I'm not holding my breath.
as i say, there's a lot of loopholes and gotchas that one doesn't think of at first. That's why we need to draft serious plans and discuss them carefully, so things get moving.
Not sure whom you're replying to here, but I can tell you that the Australian Tax legislation is absolutely massive to account for such "loopholes". There was an enquiry into this and I believe that most of the recommendations have been ignored. I do not think that globally there is an appetite to actually fix this, because those in charge have amassed their wealth from the exisiting tax infrastructure and there is no incentive to address the inequities surrounding this, since the majority of those who vote are subject to the same tax code.
The "use assets as collateral to get a loan, and loans aren't taxed as income" thing needs to be patched out. There are probably many other exploits but that one seems like an easier fix.
What we need is an actual playbook that gives a step-by-step guide towards taxing the rich. Contrary to what many people believe, it's actually a bit tricky to avoid loopholes and other problems.
It makes sense to discuss these measures in detail, before they are implemented; in other words: now.
In Denmark we have something called top tax where everyone over a certain income level are taxed a little over 50% of their income.
Unless, of course, you are a mega-rich corporation, then you pay 4% tax or less because you have the power to take your business elsewhere if you get offended and your 4% tax or less still contributes a pretty significant amount to our country, so no one dares to put pressure on you to contribute what you owe to society. 🫠
So it isn't exactly perfect. Those who are rich enough get to do whatever they want even in a system that is otherwise built to support the collective.
It sometimes pisses me off to know how easily most of our issues could be solved if companies like Mærsk and Novo Nordisk paid one or two percent more in taxes. Not even close to what they actually owe, but just one or two percent more. It could be a fucking game changer for our healthcare and educational system.
I feel like the percentages should be higher in Denmark, but I don't think people think about corporations getting to cheat the system when they are asked this question. They think about the well off civilians among us who already pay over half of their income in taxes and they will probably feel like it would be unfair to have to pay even more. At that point the thought would go to: why the fuck did I even get this degree, took on this responsibility and worked these hours if at the end of the day I have the same money after tax as a school teacher?
I can't speak for all the other Nordic countries, though I suspect similar constellations there.
Basically the same in Sweden. I think the reason %-turnout is a bit higher here is because of some very beneficial tax structures on existing wealth for private individuals. Capital gains is normally taxed at 30% of the earnings but you can opt to place (parts of) your portfolio in special accounts (”Investeringssparkonto” and ”Kapitalförsäkring” for example) where the tax is below 1% of that entire account’s value. Makes it possible to get much more out of certain investments.
One argument might then be that if you have enough capital to invest from the beginning, you’ll be at an advantage compared to those that don’t. And wealth gaps might become larger as a result
Portugal is accurate but you don't need to be rich to get to these ridiculous levels. I'm talking about direct and indirect taxes.
all 68 comments