This day and age with a growing positive sentiment toward authoritarianism, anti intellectualism, and fascism, I think some punk would be good. A lot of punk, even.
post
In 1960, minimum wage was $1.00/hour and the price of the average US home was $11,000.00
A Boomer could graduate high school and be living in their own place with no roommates with money they'd earned delivering newspapers.
And depending on their area, that house may sell for a million+ now to millenials who have no other option if they want to live the classic american white picket fence dream
I think that the US as a country needs to abandon the idea that every family should have a detached house with four bedrooms, two cars, and a lush green front garden surrounded by a picket fence. It's just not sustainable. That made sense in 1960, but the country's population has doubled since then.
On the other hand, I would like to see it possible for every family to be able to at least afford a basic 2-bedroom condominium with all the amenities that modern life has to offer, including walkable spaces, accessible green areas, and reliable public transportation.
11,000 hours of minimum wage labour in my city would be $185,000. Maybe a bit too low to be entirely realistic, but $200,000 is probably within reach with a bit of elbow grease on the government side.
There are a ton of factors but most problems simply stem from greed. Boomers pulling the ladder up behind oneself and then making fun of millenials for having less assets and saying it's because we're lazy.
I don't agree that the reason single-family detached homes with lawns are necessarily unaffordable primarily because of greed. That might be one factor, but I think the main factor as to why they're unaffordable is simple geometry. Councils don't want to pay for miles of roads, pipes, and electrical cables just to serve less than a hundred families, so these costs get imposed on the developers and homeowners. Some states, including mine, will require new single-family developments to have an HOA, which is responsible for paying for the upkeep of some of these resources. That directly results in higher assessments for ratepayers. Or, where the council absorbs the costs, they still get passed on to owners and renters through higher property taxes.
So while I'm sympathetic to your arguments, I feel that blaming only greed is a shallow understanding of why nobody can afford a house.
"Councils don't want to pay for miles of roads, pipes, and electrical cables just to serve less than a hundred families"
Yes, correct, they don't want to pay for it. We need to allocate more taxpayer money to corporate bailouts.
To make my point clearer because you missed it: Councils should NOT be paying for these regardless of whether anything relating to corporate bailouts happens, because detached single-family houses are a poor use of resources and an inefficient and wasteful form of housing.
Remember to add the 's/' for sarcasm
There may be GOPs reading this and that's their mantra
Yeah - you forgot the realtors and realtor groups.
Absolute scumbags.
This is not a popular observation around these parts, but it's true. My city has almost no private equity presence in the market, yet we still have a housing affordability crisis. The geometry problem came first, caused here in the U.S. by zoning and building codes; then houses became the biggest source of investment wealth for individuals because of the artificial scarcity those codes created; then private equity smelled money and moved in.
I live in one of Italy's richest cities, gross wages for millennials may go from 24k€/y to 60k€/y for the luckiest ones. A normal 80m² apartment goes for about 200-400k€.
It's not just an American problem, and apparently more efficient housing isn't enough of a solution.
I think that is a different situation in your city. I don't know which city it is, and I don't claim to know much about how the Italian economy works, but housing prices seem similar to what I've got in my city (Portland, Oregon, USA), except that wages are drastically lower. So my guess is that it's a problem with people being underpaid as Italy is a developed economy, similar to the US.
€24,000 a year would be about €12 an hour which is below minimum wage in my city. A minimum-wage worker would be paid about $34,000 annually, or €29,500. The mean hourly wage in my city works out to about $76,000 annually (€66,000). I prefer the median as a better estimate of what ordinary people make, but the census bureau only reports the mean as far as I could find.
Older Millennial's had options after the 08 crash
True, but you had to be in a position with money saved up and your career unaffected by the recession so unfortunately that's a relatively low percentage
I mean prices were lower for like 8 years before exploding with low interest rates, time was there to save
Sure but the job market was a joke so if you weren't already established in a stable career, your income was going to be pretty garbage on top of school loans. Realistically, you would be looking at college grads who have enough seniority in their career that wouldn't put them at risk of being let go as well as having little to no school debt. You're looking at people who are at least 23, more likely late 20s in 2009ish. That's certainly near the '81 cutoff for millenials. I was 18 in 2008, luckily retained my low paying retail job while going through uni, with my school debt and the garbage job market, it wasn't feasible at all for me to take advantage of the prices.
Wait, when did the cutoff for millennial become 1986? Last I saw it was 1981-1996, with some fuzziness at the edges.
I was also in uni in 2008 but graduated in 2010, bought my first place in 2011
I'm happy for people that were able to do that but you gotta understand you're probably in the like <10% that could do that. I doubt you would say you were in the same situation as most people born between '81-'96. Gen x was in the best position to take advantage.
My younger sister somehow bought a house with her friend. Her first job paid $80k a year. I made $7.25 and hour and this was not an option.
Just another, the privledged got to buy, and the poors didnt.
I was dead broke after I bought. Making $16 per house and my wife was making $20 an hour so not a lot by anymeans
double income. You married so young?
$20 an hour for 2008 is A LOT.
threw it into the inflation calc. $20 an hour in 2008 is $31 today.
I was making $7.25 with a ten cent raise at the end of the year.
you were lucky, no shame, but both you and my sister were lucky.
They do not give you a loan if you earn nothing because you're unemployed and you don't have any capital in the bank.
There would have been a way for me but not without generational wealth and immediately landing a great job out of college.
TLDR: if things went great in your life yes you're right.
Yeah I had the option of being ruined
And they could get educated by earning a few shekels at the bursar that they found on a street corner.
We're also mad about the corruption, industrial scale pedophilia, and the land theft and genocide. Thats not going away. There needs to be paybacks. The guillotines arent for show. We have criminals to round up.
Capitalism baby!
Capitalism isn't the problem, it's wealth inequality. Do you think things were better back under the Manorialism system? No capitalism there, but the rich owned vast manors and the poor who worked their lands were born there and had to work that land for their entire lives.
All capitalism did was to give a shred of social mobility where none existed before.
I think we're both saying the same thing. I don't have the answer, but I sure as shit know what the problem is.
The answer is guillotines. Make the rich scared enough about losing their lives and they'll voluntarily surrender some of their power. The trick is to scare the rich without the rest of the death and chaos that were part of the French Revolution.
some good things happened as a result of the french revolution. Sometimes a revolution NEEDs to happen in order for a slower but persistent and endless level of oppression and rampant structural abuse to be fixed. The revolution produced the Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen, setting a wbenchmark for civil liberties that we still go by. It abolished the feudal system and the social injustices, starvation, and brutalities that persisted. It erased forced labor practices of the corvee-- where peasants had to spend a portion of their time laboring for their lord-- essentially a period of hard labor slavery. Lords could force peasants to do extra labor at their whim, and the peasants were bound to drop everything and do as they were told, without pay. It enabled equal representation under the law, where before the revolution birth and wealth were the measure of the availability of justice. It also pulled back the power of the church in France, which was full to bursting with rampant corruption, decadence, and brutal abuse.
The heads of the elite were well worth the trouble, it was the death of the starving and oppressed peasants that was the real cost. Those rich fucks and corrupt rapist priests had it coming and then some. The vast majority of the deaths were due to the elite and their forces attacking peasants and employing scorched earth tactics in fear, around famine and bankruptcies, and the loss of feudal authority. If the people had been more savage in coming after the elite, some of the needless deaths could have been avoided. The years of famine, ill treatment by government and bankruptcies made "the Great Fear" that started it unavoidable and inevitable. Lots of interesting parallels to the US now eh? Although we're pretty far from being gangs of starving rabble yet. Still a ways to go but we're on our way.
You mean Nuremberg style trials and hangings? Pretty much every American above the level of mayor going back about 80 years should be put up on trial for crimes against humanity.
...driven by anger over economic futures...
Sounds pretty punk rock to me.
top 76 comments