comments
Do you want one company controlling all the AI out there? Controlling all the answers AI gives?
Do you really think that there won't be multiple models even if the bubble bursts? The "best" models are from China and are open source. "We" don't control China at all! So I don't see this as likely.
Mozilla claims they want to develop responsible AI.
Put up or shut up, right?
They say they want to make their AI private, and work on-device. I believe we should be encouraging this, so that we don’t end up with control of AI in the hands of Google, Meta, or Musk.
I had no issue with the AI features in Firefox - the tab sorter and the translations, etc.
What I DO have an issue with is Mozilla turning its users into training fodder for the AI companies - instead of just building that private AI they keep jawboning about.
Why not both? (I know lots of folks will hate this take, but please hear me out.)
Because let's be real: AI is not going away. Yes, we're all waiting for the AI bubble to bust. And I really want it to, these companies are getting so terrible. But when it bursts, AI isn't going to disappear. It will condense down to a few companies, or even just one. Do you want one company controlling all the AI out there? Controlling all the answers AI gives? Saying how you or others can use it?
Mozilla claims they want to develop responsible AI. They say they want to make their AI private, and work on-device. I believe we should be encouraging this, so that we don't end up with control of AI in the hands of Google, Meta, or Musk.
We need alternatives, badly. Because AI is here to stay, no matter how much we hate it. This Pandora's Box has already been opened, and things aren't going back.
Saving neither, is my feeling.
Back when Mozilla was building Firefox to save the web, Mozilla was actually producing a product that people could use that did what the big bad companies were pushing. This time around, Mozilla is just selling our eyeballs to the big bad companies while jawboning about how virtuous they are.
More like antitrust laws, or lack of them.
If Mozilla is in danger because they're not modernizing fast enough, then Firefox forks without Mozilla providing core updates will fall even farther behind.
Not to mention that adding AI features is part of that modernizing. I know it's a common refrain around here that "nobody's asking for AI" but that doesn't seem to actually be the case given how much actual demand there is for AI tools and services. If Firefox doesn't add these features that means they're handing that entire market over to closed-source browsers voluntarily.
IIRC, the devs of at least one of the forks - thought I forget which - have said they'd be forced quit if there was no upstream Firefox to constantly rebase from.
I wonder how many of the forks (or rather, their dev teams) would be able to handle the load of becoming 'The Main Project' if Firefox-proper went away.
blame fucking google
Ruining both.
@itsfoss this is really useful. Why download another browser when you can convert your daily driver into a productivity aid.
@oopsallnaps yep, security updates are totally essential but I doubt those daily "refresh" activities (which I see increasingly being adopted by many open source projects) are security related.In fact these "too frequent" updates will induce people to disable or delay updates and will achieve the opposite goal (the cry wolf effect) 😟
If you don't want daily updates you can swap over to their ESR builds which besides security updates are updated once a year iirc.
It's 1000% a good idea to keep your browser up to date with security updates, the web just isn't what it use to be. (Which was also swarming with security vulnerabilities but we had those awesome underconstruction gifs everywhere.)
collapses unreferenced CSS variables declarations in the Rules view
Improved [dev tools] performance on pages making heavy usage of CSS variables
There have been pages that were lagging to death and where I had to scroll through endless css variables to find anything.
This should make them workable.
Hopefully, soon. Servo is making progress, Ladybird is progressing really nicely.... There soon will be the day
If you are unhappy with firefox ceo or whatever, I would advise to use a fork like ironfox.
Right now firefox remains the best choice for internet freedom even after these "controversies".
No. I avoid Chromium entirely. When there is a worthy contender to Firefox, I will check it out and weigh the options as well as do my research.
Chrome/Chromium has a monopoly on web browsing. And I will not support it.
Vivaldi is not free software and is therefore not worthy of consideration as a replacement for Firefox.
Based on the answers to this StackOverflow question and this blog post, here are the 16 (!!!) AI-related settings in new versions of Firefox that you'll want to disable/set to false, and that might be turned back on with each update:- browser.aiwindow.enabled- browser.ml.chat.enabled- browser.ml.chat.menu- browser.ml.chat.page.footerBadge- browser.ml.chat.page.menuBadge- browser.ml.chat.page- browser.ml.chat.shortcuts- browser.ml.chat.sidebar- browser.ml.enable- browser.ml.linkPreview.enabled- browser.ml.pageAssist.enabled- browser.ml.smartAssist.enabled- browser.tabs.groups.smart.enabled- browser.tabs.groups.smart.userEnabled- extensions.ml.enabled- sidebar.notification.badge.aichat Enter "about:config" in the browser bar and then search for each of these and disable them, turn them off, or set them to false as appropriate.Depending on which version of Firefox you have you may not have all these configuration options.#firefox #mozilla #AI #GenAI #GenerativeAI #SmartIsSurveillance #tech #dev #web #NoAI #AICruft #antifeatures
Sure. Doing everything is something that can be done by companies with abundant resources. My point was more how that isn't the situation for Mozilla. They have limited resources available. They already laid off developers, they don't have a lot of money these days and their market share isn't great either. I think they need to pick their fights. It's either one project or the other one. And it's been like that for some time. We already had the discussion whether it's clever to invest in side-projects. Or Pocket. Or have the same developers work on the browser itself. And then there's Thunderbird as well and I really think the UX could benefit from some modernization. Thunderbird Pro sounds nice and they could provide the server side of it to businesses, now's the time for projecs like that. It'd need money and developers, though.
I really think chasing their competition with similar features and delivering a slightly worse alternative is going to lead to less and less market share unless Firefox becomes meaningless in the grand picture. And they need to grow to attract money and add developers. At this point I don't see how that'd work unless they deliver something better than Google. In my eyes that's something like the Plugin interface which Google messed up. That could have been a selling point for Firefox. Or privacy features. Or just a solid, fast and reliable browser which feels better to their users. Even if that's mostly marketing. And I think they regularly waste those opportunities. Sure, hypothetically they could do a lot of stuff. It's just that they rarely do.
And then AI is a bit of a weird one in my opinion. I think Firefox has roughly 3% market share these days. That's probably the last remaining Linux nerds and privacy advocates... And they try to sell cloud services and AI to them which is kinda the opposite of privacy. So what do we expect to happen? I think they're likely going to lose their last few users with these kind of business decisions. At least it's not clear to me whether they really cater to their core user base any more. And this could be problematic for the future of Firefox, Thunderbird and their entire company. Idk. It's not my call and I have little to no idea about the business side of things, but it doesn't feel like a good fit to me.
@hendrik Implementing one thing doesn't make the other impossible. Specially if it something that could improve the popularity of Firefox as a modern web browser.
@remixtures I limit my use of AI. It's a tool. I don't want it thinking for me. But sometimes it's helpful (as long as I check the results).For example, I asked Craiyon for an image of Koala Lumpur (the prompt was "Kuala Lumpur but with koalas instead of people") and here's what it gave me:craiyon.com/en/image/Bs7Omur0RFun, silly, good for a Mastodon toot. But ¿would I invest in it? No. If I want art I want the work of artists.
@remixtures Interesting article. One point I disagree with (not taking a position on the rest of the article) is that having a single turn-all-AI-off switch is expensive over the life of a product. Firefox has an extreme amount of customizability; just visit the about:config page and list all settings available.
What in the Kentucky fried fuck are they smoking over at Mozilla?
@remixtures How is it in any way honest that Mozilla is going to protect is from the rapacious AI companies when they are serving up their userbase to the same companies?