By most measures, the new GLP-1 pills are underwhelming. Earlier this month, the pharmaceutical giant Eli Lilly debuted a weight-loss tablet that is far less effective than its popular injectable counterpart, Zepbound. Oral Wegovy, which hit the market in December, can hold its own with the shot version—but it has to be taken on an empty stomach with fewer than four ounces of water. And both pills come with many of the same side effects as the shots, namely nausea and diarrhea.

As someone who’s currently on a GLP-1 injection, I still can’t wait to start taking the pills instead. No, I’m not afraid of needles. The injector pens that are used to administer GLP-1s are so quick and painless that sometimes I worry the needle didn’t actually go into my skin. But the shots are a nuisance nonetheless. They’re supposed to be taken on the same day every week, but I struggle to stick to the schedule. The injections also need to be refrigerated—which is especially a hassle whenever I travel. Last month, I visited relatives who don’t know that I’m on a weight-loss drug. I was too sheepish to have a conversation with them about it, so I left the pen in my toiletry bag and didn’t throw it in the trash until I got home.

This might all seem trivial, but a mere annoyance compounds when it must be repeated every week for the rest of your life. Even though many GLP-1 users hit a weight-loss plateau after several months, they have to continue injecting themselves to avoid gaining the weight back. “Over time—particularly as patients transition from the active-weight-loss phase to long-term maintenance—the psychological burden of ongoing injections can become more apparent,” Akshay Jain, a clinical instructor at the University of British Columbia, told me. (Jain has consulted for both Eli Lilly and Novo Nordisk.)

[Read: The Ozempic plateau]

This may be where the true value in weight-loss pills lies. Patients may be able to use the injections to actually lose weight, and then lean on the tablets to keep it off. The pills can be downed with a swig of water just like statins, SSRIs, and so many other pharmaceuticals that are already part of people’s daily routine. On that front, Eli Lilly’s pill, sold under the brand name Foundayo, is especially notable. For most people, the drug doesn’t come with fussy rules about when it should be taken. Doctors I spoke with were enthusiastic about the idea of switching some patients to pills because it allows them to feel as if they’ve made meaningful progress toward normalcy.

So far, doctors just haven’t had very good options for GLP-1 patients who are looking to maintain their weight loss. Some have attempted to switch patients to older weight-loss pills. Others have suggested that patients space out injections to every few weeks. But neither strategy is foolproof. The older drugs have been successfully tested as a way to maintain weight after bariatric surgery, but they haven’t been studied among people coming off of GLP-1s, David Cummings, a professor at the University of Washington, told me. Anecdotal evidence suggests that the method may not be all that effective. “I have a lot of patients that regain all of their weight,” Catherine Varney, the director of obesity medicine at UVA Health, told me. (Varney has done paid speaking gigs for Eli Lilly.) The tactic of taking a GLP-1 shot less frequently, meanwhile, hasn’t been tested in a large randomized clinical trial.

By contrast, a recent clinical trial by Eli Lilly tracked nearly 400 subjects who switched from shots to Foundayo, and found that on average, they maintained most of their weight loss after 52 weeks. (The study has not yet been published in a peer-reviewed journal.) A comparable study hasn’t been done with oral Wegovy, but Novo Nordisk, the company that manufactures the drug, believes that patients should be able to switch from the Wegovy shot without affecting their weight. Because the two drugs are made with the same molecule, “there’s no reason to think that there’d be any difference,” Andrea Traina, the senior medical director for obesity at Novo Nordisk, told me. Doctors told me that they have been encouraged by patients who have already switched from shots to oral Wegovy. “Initial anecdotal reports are promising, but we still need more long data to form conclusions,” Katie Robinson, an assistant professor at the University of Iowa, told me.

All of this comes with a significant caveat. These pills may not remedy the biggest reason people stop taking GLP-1s: price. The new tablets are cheaper than the shots, but they’re still not cheap. If you pay out of pocket, the lowest dose of Foundayo costs $149 a month, which is about half the price of the cheapest version of Zepbound. The Wegovy pill also starts at $149, compared with $199 for the injection. Again, this is $149 every month indefinitely—it quickly adds up. With insurance, the cost of these drugs can be much lower, but few people can count on that. A recent survey of employers found that only about one in five insurance plans at large companies covered GLP-1s for weight loss. The situation gets especially tricky for older Americans. Medicare is technically banned by law from covering weight-loss drugs, though the Trump administration is piloting a program to provide beneficiaries with access.

[Read: The obesity-drug revolution is stalling]

There is hope that the price of Foundayo, in particular, will drop over time because of the way it is manufactured. Unlike all of the other GLP-1s on the market, it is not a peptide—a class of drugs that mimics hormones in the body—which makes it much simpler to produce. But even if the price plummets, not everyone may be as eager to switch to a pill as I am. Everyone who takes a GLP-1 has their own issues that affect whether they stick with their regimen. For some, the once-weekly injection may be more convenient than daily pills; others may want drugs that come with fewer side effects; and still others may just decide to take whatever is cheapest and does the job.

So much of the attention surrounding GLP-1s has been on their remarkable efficacy at shedding weight—and the search for drugs that are even better. Retatrutide, a much-hyped injection that is in the works, can apparently lead to nearly 30 percent loss in body weight on average. But options that lessen the burden of taking a forever drug may matter even more.


From The Atlantic via this RSS feed

submitted 7 months ago by [B] to c/theatlantic@ibbit.at
 

When canceled became a common label applied to basically anyone who’d done anything to offend anyone, it had many unfortunate effects. One was rolling transgressions as serious as sexual assault and as trivial as accidentally not being nice to a fan (maybe) into one bucket of misbehavior. Another was implying that society was run, more than ever, by mob rule. The truth is that the age of consensus has ended, and even the canceled can continue their careers by pitching themselves directly to the public—which is how, for example, the allegedly disgraced Morgan Wallen became the most popular man in country music.

Another consequence was making collective judgment seem cruelly irreversible. Cancel culture, as many a podcaster has ranted over the past decade, offers no obvious path to redemption. Examples of people expressing sincere apologies, changing their behavior, and winning forgiveness have been rare. Transgressors who’ve returned to public life, such as President Trump, have mostly offered denials of wrongdoing and worn their cancellation as a badge of honor.

So when Ye (formerly Kanye West) placed an ad in The Wall Street Journal in January apologizing to “those I’ve hurt,” it was genuinely surprising. A decade ago, after spending years defining the sound of 21st-century hip-hop, Ye began to alienate portions of his listenership by going MAGA. But he remained a bankable celebrity—in a lucrative partnership with Adidas—until 2022, when he went all in on anti-Semitism. He took to shouting out Hitler, selling swastika T-shirts, and otherwise preaching about how Jews control everything and must be stopped. Record labels, brands, and many fans distanced themselves from him.

In the Journal, though, he wrote that this behavior had been the result of an undiagnosed brain injury he’d suffered 25 years earlier. He had “lost touch with reality” but now, armed with a new health routine and outlook on life, had amends to make. “I aspire to earn your forgiveness,” he wrote.

The letter was well written. It conveyed that he’d wrestled with great shame and was humbly offering himself to the world’s mercy. A reader might ask: What if what happened to Ye—mental-health problems giving way to a Third Reich fetish—had happened to me? Wouldn’t I want a chance to make good?

But Ye is not like most people. He’s a celebrity whose words reverberate throughout the culture, and whose reputation is worth a lot of money. In recent weeks, he seemed to be inching his way back into normalcy by releasing an album (Bully) and playing gigs. Then, on Tuesday, the United Kingdom banned him from entry, citing the “public good.” Forgiveness had been the wrong concept to apply to his situation all along. The language of individual morality obscures what so-called cancellations—and ever-elusive uncancellations—really should be about: doing what’s best not for the celebrity but for the rest of us.

The timing of Ye’s apology always seemed a bit convenient. In the same week that the Journal published Ye’s letter, the rapper signed a seven-figure record deal with the media company Gamma. Co-founded by Ye’s former manager Larry Jackson, Gamma is a new music-industry player that’s trying to compete with the major labels. A separate article in the Journal reported that Jackson had discussed Ye’s signing during an all-hands meeting with his staff, some of whom had reservations. The company’s leadership reportedly believed that Ye “was committed to creating music with positive messaging.”

The run-ups to Ye’s albums have traditionally been littered with explosive statements, publicity stunts, and repeated delays. Before his 2024 album Vultures 1, he offered a public apology to Jewish people—then soon doubled down on hating them. By contrast, Bully’s rollout has been serene and slick. Its official release date was pushed back only once, by a week. Ye has given no interviews and posted nothing of note since his January mea culpa.

Until just a few days ago, the low-drama PR strategy seemed to be working. Fans were praising Bully as a heartening return to Ye’s early, soulful sound. Its lyrics contained no inflammatory content. He’d played two sold-out shows at Los Angeles’s SoFi Stadium. Lauryn Hill joined him on stage, and other celebrities were cheering in the audience. Little attention was being paid to the other scandals in his life—such as a lawsuit from his former assistant alleging multiple instances of abuse (he has denied the allegations), which came after previous reports that he’d bullied and harassed employees at Adidas (about which he has not commented).

He was then announced as the headliner for all three days of the Wireless Festival, a long-running and prominent hip-hop event in London. This was the kind of gig that, if it went off without a hitch, would smooth his return to the status of globe-trotting, big-tent pop star.

But not everyone was going along with the rehab plan. After all, less than a year ago Ye was working on openly anti-Semitic music with song titles including “Gas Chambers” and “Heil Hitler.” Creative Communities for Peace and other Jewish groups excoriated the Wireless booking, and PepsiCo dropped its sponsorship of the festival.

The managing director of Festival Republic (which, along with Live Nation, runs Wireless), Melvin Benn, released an impassioned defense of the booking. He identified himself as an anti-fascist and a supporter of Jews. He expressed the view that “forgiveness and giving people a second chance are becoming a lost virtue in this ever-increasing divisive world,” and urged people to “offer some forgiveness and hope to him as I have decided to do.” Ye put out a statement saying that his “only goal is to come to London and present a show of change, bringing unity, peace, and love through my music.” He added that he wanted to meet with members of the Jewish community to listen and learn.

[Read: Cling to your disgust]

That same day, the U.K. government denied Ye’s visa, banning him from coming to the country. Prime Minister Keir Starmer wrote online that he “will not stop in our fight to confront and defeat the poison of antisemitism. We will always take the action necessary to protect the public and uphold our values.” Wireless subsequently announced that it was canceling the entire festival.

The government intervention quickly redefined the conversation around Ye, bringing up questions of free speech and legal precedent (the U.K. generally has less permissive expression laws than the United States, though both countries have lately wielded immigration policy against artists and activists for things they’ve said). It also, predictably, fed the sense of persecution that Ye’s followers have long clung to. On Reddit and X, some fans are griping that their idol is being subjected to harsher punishments than associates of Jeffrey Epstein have been. They are alluding darkly to a conspiracy … by a certain group of people … who seem to control the world …

In a way, though, the decision by Starmer’s government is clarifying. The question of whether Ye should be “allowed” into public life again—meaning given mainstream platforms and institutional support—was never about whether Ye deserved a comeback. He was shunned not because he’d morally transgressed (though he had) but because he’d used his platform to spread dangerous myths about a group of people already experiencing a rising tide of bigotry. His single “Heil Hitler” (which, again, is recent—released in May 2025) became a rallying song for people such as Nick Fuentes, the ascendent influencer who pushes open racism, sexism, homophobia, and anti-Semitism. In 2022, a hate group hung a banner over a Los Angeles freeway that read Kanye Is Right About the Jews.

Speech laws, of course, vary from country to country. And record companies, corporations, and concert organizers can’t stop anyone from saying whatever they want. But institutions can and probably should try to not give money, megaphones, and credibility to someone who might use those things to spread messages that can get people killed.

Making judgment calls about public harm can be tricky, and the process is muddied by the forgiveness-focused language that rules so much of the conversation about celebrity conduct. Ye’s redemption campaign has foregrounded a theme that fits our parasocial zeitgeist: empathy for the individual. Yet while many of us may want Ye to get better, or believe he’s entitled to personal redemption, none of us has any real idea what’s in his heart. All we have is the record of how he’s acted before, and all we can do is make inferences about how he’s acting now.

My inferences say not to trust him, not yet. After spending decades expressing himself in freewheeling interviews, lately he’s mostly shared his thoughts in highly curated statements. On Bully, he raps in bland and mechanical fashion about conquering darkness and achieving a comeback. His lyrics, once outlandishly specific, are now flagrantly generic: “Know the Lord’s intervention was divine / Political and social tensions on the climb.” Listening, I wondered when the real Ye would crash back in and say what he really thinks, for better or ill. Only time and evidence can make that suspicion wane. And the only reason to rush that process is profit.


From The Atlantic via this RSS feed

submitted 7 months ago by [B] to c/theatlantic@ibbit.at
 

This is an edition of Time-Travel Thursdays, a journey through The Atlantic*’s archives to contextualize the present. Sign up here.*

From the window of Orion, home looks like a pale-blue marble slipping under the dark felt of the universe. The four people aboard the spacecraft, now earthbound after finishing their lunar flyby, have traveled farther from our planet than any person has ever ventured, and have seen more of the moon’s far side than any person has ever beheld. The Artemis II crew includes Christina Koch, the first woman to fly around the moon; Victor Glover, the first person of color to journey there; Jeremy Hansen, the first lunar-bound Canuck; and Reid Wiseman, husband to the late Carroll Wiseman, the namesake of a newly identified bright spot on the moon’s surface.

Down here, their space adventure has stirred feelings of awe—“moon joy,” as one NASA officer recently put it. Moon joy at this scale has been on hiatus for the better half of a century. The last crewed lunar expedition was Apollo 17, and it took off in 1972. Artemis II’s voyage has revived a thrilling sensation from missions past: the feeling of inching together toward the edge of new knowledge. If all goes according to plan, there will be an Artemis III and an Artemis IV and an Artemis V, at which point NASA hopes to establish a permanent presence on the lunar south pole. But what will we do with all that moon when we get up there for good?

Humanity’s attitudes toward that great orb in the night sky have shifted over the centuries: A powerful lunar deity morphed into an object of scientific fascination. Later it became a possible arena for war (America considered detonating a nuclear bomb there partly as a show of force against Russia in the late 1950s) and then a real, tangible place, one that few humans have felt underfoot (the Apollo 17 astronaut Harrison Schmitt reported that lunar dust smelled like “spent gunpowder”). During the 54-year lunar-exploration freeze, public interest waned and government funding for more missions dried up. But that didn’t mean everybody suddenly forgot about space—instead, the cogs of economic ambition went right to work. We tried to monetize the moon.

For the handsome fee of $1,600, you too could have shipped a quarter-size object to the moon via Astrobotic Technology’s moon-mail service, announced in 2014. But many mementos were likely lost a decade later when the company’s Peregrine Mission One lunar lander failed to reach its destination and burned up upon reentry to the Earth’s atmosphere—along with other cargo, including, and not limited to, a Bitcoin Genesis Plate, a physical Dogecoin, a sticker from a young space enthusiast, and some copies of Reddit posts, as well as a powdered sports drink whose voyage was sponsored by a Japanese beverage company. (Astrobotic is planning another launch for later this year, and more personal keepsakes will exit the stratosphere in MoonBoxes, which are now sold out.) “The march of human progress has come to an inevitable point in its evolution,” my colleague Megan Garber wrote in 2014. “We’re about to use our celestial neighbor as an enormous billboard.”

The idea of a lunar economy has floated around for years, as humans have searched for resources that could benefit Earth dwellers and future moon dwellers alike: Private companies are intrigued by the financial rewards of harvesting the moon’s rare metals, ice (to use in life-support systems on the moon, or to refine for rocket fuel), and helium-3, a rare-on-Earth isotope that could be used in nuclear fusion, which could in turn replace fossil fuels. In a few years, there may even be lunar Wi-Fi or lunar 4G—NASA tapped Nokia to furnish the moon with its own cellular network, which was operational on the surface for roughly 25 minutes last year.

If we do indeed manage to build a permanent space home for ourselves, we should take care to remember the sentiments that propelled us up there in the first place. Before the moon became a site to push product or dig for profit, the question of why we should visit it in person roused much debate. Two NASA scientists made the case in these pages in 1963, and their reasoning was simple: scientific and technological advancement, political clout, and an appeal “to the imagination of the student.” In other words, by fulfilling our lunar aspirations, not only will we creep closer to unlocking the universe’s secrets—we will also introduce young generations to that great frontier of celestial speculation.

When Buzz Aldrin became the second person to walk on the moon, he took it all in and remarked, “Magnificent desolation.” And it was magnificent—enough to show the precarity of what yokes us to one another, enough to kick-start a worldwide environmental movement to protect what we have now. There will always be those who, understandably, doubt what can be gained from going out there rather than from fixing everything that’s wrong right here. But “human nature is blessed, or perhaps cursed, with an inquiring mind and an itch for adventure, two qualities that may well spring from the same fount,” N. J. Berrill wrote in this magazine a few years after the Apollo program was established.

In a message recorded before his death, the Apollo astronaut Jim Lovell welcomed Artemis II’s astronauts to “my old neighborhood.” Koch, Glover, Hansen, and Wiseman listened to his tape before their lunar flyby, more than 200,000 miles from home. “I’m proud to pass that torch on to you,” Lovell said. “It’s a historic day, and I know how busy you’ll be. But don’t forget to enjoy the view.” His words were a reminder to his fellow space travelers that they come from a short line of people who have peered out at the swirling mass of the universe, and also a reminder to us: to look up instead of down, if only for a little while.


From The Atlantic via this RSS feed

 

This is an edition of The Atlantic Daily, a newsletter that guides you through the biggest stories of the day, helps you discover new ideas, and recommends the best in culture. Sign up for it here.

Legal opinions tend to be dry, wordy, and intentionally vague. One issued by the Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel earlier this month is none of these.

“You have asked whether the Presidential Records Act of 1978 (‘PRA’ or ‘Act’) is constitutional. We conclude that it is not,” Assistant Attorney General T. Elliot Gaiser declares. The law, passed after Watergate, is designed to ensure a reliable and accessible public record. It makes presidential documents public by law, and governs how and when they must be preserved.

If the opinion stands, it will allow Trump to destroy the records of his administration’s actions, or take records with him at the end of his term. Combined with alleged violations of PRA in his first term, this could make Trump the most poorly documented president since at least Richard Nixon, and perhaps going back even further. (As my colleague Henry Grabar writes, the actual library part of his planned presidential library is an afterthought at best.) Yet Trump’s habit of making policy without deliberation, and often with stream-of-consciousness speeches and posts on social media, means that his administration is a paradox: simultaneously one of the most transparent and most opaque in American history.

The Office of Legal Counsel exists to issue sophisticated legal guidance to the White House, and in effect is frequently asked to provide justification for an administration’s actions; perhaps the most infamous instance was the “Torture Memos,” many produced by the OLC’s John Yoo during the George W. Bush administration to justify the use of, well, torture during the War on Terror. And guessing why the Trump administration would want to be rid of PRA isn’t difficult.

Trump and his aides have reportedly broken the law on many occasions. During his first term, he was reported to routinely tear up documents, despite staffers imploring him not to. (Some aides were tasked with painstakingly taping them back together to comply with the law.) In other cases, he flushed papers down toilets. Chief of Staff Mark Meadows reportedly fed documents into fireplaces at the end of the presidency. Trump’s staffers then took boxes and boxes of surviving documents, many of them highly sensitive, when they left the White House. He refused to return them upon request from the federal government, then allegedly attempted to obstruct their recovery. According to photographs included in a federal indictment, Trump haphazardly stored documents in a Mar-a-Lago bathroom and a ballroom stage. Trump pleaded not guilty, and his election led to the case being dismissed, which meant he was never tried on charges of obstructing the investigation, but now he would like to erase the accusation entirely by eliminating PRA.

Former Special Counsel Jack Smith, who investigated the documents case, also believed that Trump wanted to use documents his team took from the White House to further his business interests, according to Democratic Representative Jamie Raskin, who obtained Smith’s memo—in other words, stealing public records to make a private fortune. (Absurdly, Trump’s Justice Department returned to Trump the documents that had been collected from Mar-a-Lago by the FBI.)

The Trump presidency is in some ways unusually transparent. The president takes questions from reporters regularly—sometimes in a gaggle, sometimes in cold calls on his phone. The president is temperamentally unable to keep his own counsel, to the point that French President Emmanuel Macron scolded him last week: “Perhaps you shouldn’t talk every day.” There’s simply less policy process to be recorded in preserved documents, because Trump has drastically shrunk bodies like the National Security Council and replaced them with his id and instincts, chronicled in real time on Truth Social.

Yet if Trump is allowed to destroy or remove documents, the American Historical Association argues in a new lawsuit challenging the OLC opinion, historians “would be left with an incomplete historical record by which to professionally research, produce scholarship on, and teach U.S. history.” They add, “Once lost, this information is irretrievable and thus the harm irreparable.” The suit notes that federal courts rejected similar arguments about the law’s constitutionality immediately after its enactment, when Nixon sued to block it.

The history of Nixon’s presidential record also shows the value of the law, even long after a president leaves office. Nixon loyalists controlled the former president’s library for years, and presented a whitewashed version of Watergate to the public. But the law required that the warts-and-all records be preserved, and when control of the library was finally wrested away and handed to Tim Naftali, a professional historian, in 2006, the library began presenting a more accurate account and providing access to historians, who have in turn presented more complete chronicles of Nixon’s career.

Trump is the most corrupt and scandal-plagued president since Nixon; indeed, his fiascoes eclipse Nixon’s, but many of them remain mostly or somewhat hidden, thanks in part to a much more acquiescent Republican Congress than the one Nixon had. In Watergate, the crimes were known; the question was, in the words of Senator Howard Baker Jr., “What did the president know and when did he know it?” With the Trump administration, the situation is perhaps the reverse: We know much about the president’s stated motivations and beliefs, but we do not have a full accounting of what he and his aides have done. Keeping a record would allow the nation to fully understand his actions and their consequences—if not now, then at least later.

Related:

Tim Naftali: The death of nonpartisan presidential history (From 2022)The Trump Library symbolizes his presidency perfectly.

Here are three new stories from The Atlantic:

Trump made a deal that gives him nothing he wanted.J. D. Vance is definitely against foreign election interference.A new geopolitical reality is here.

Today’s News

President Trump agreed to a two-week cease-fire with Iran last night, pausing planned U.S. strikes. Iran released a 10-point cease-fire proposal that includes demands for U.S.-troop withdrawal, sanctions relief, and the right to nuclear enrichment, many of which conflict with Washington’s position.Iran said it would restrict ship traffic through the Strait of Hormuz during the cease-fire, requiring vessels to coordinate with its military and pay tolls, signaling that Tehran plans to maintain control over the key oil route.Republicans won a Georgia special election, but the district shifted sharply toward Democrats, and liberal candidates secured another decisive victory in Wisconsin’s Supreme Court race last night.

Evening Read

A person piloting a pencil

Illustration by Alisa Gao / The Atlantic

The Literary Job AI Can’t Replace

By Rebecca Ackermann

Nothing seems to make literary-minded people angrier than an author taking credit for writing they didn’t do. A few weeks ago, Hachette canceled the U.S. release of a novel, Shy Girl, following a barrage of online accusations that it had been written with the unacknowledged help of AI …

The collective outrage overlooks a fact that the publishing industry acknowledged long before the rise of artificial intelligence: Not everyone with a great idea or unique story has the skill, experience, or time to write a book—or even a book review. Right now, AI tools are cheap and widespread, ready to tap in with a service that some people do need. But these models have been trained on uncompensated creative labor. They plagiarize. They lie, and they lie about lying. So instead, I’d like to make the case for a frequently maligned profession—one I’ve participated in—that rewards good writing, helps authors survive in an ever more challenging field, and allows remarkable perspectives to reach an audience they otherwise wouldn’t. That’s right: Ghostwriting is good, actually—when it’s done by humans.

Read the full article.

More From The Atlantic

Charlie Warzel: An incredibly weird time to be aliveAmerica looks like a paper tiger.The forgotten war that Iran already wonWhat the astronauts see that Trump cannotThe David Frum Show: What it means to be American

Culture Break

Donald Faison and Zach Braff sharing a single shirt and doctor's jacket, in a scene from "Scrubs"

Touchstone Pictures / Getty

Watch. Scrubs has a sneakily radical vision of male friendship, Julie Beck writes.

Explore. The NBA isn’t the same for everyone, Jemele Hill argues.

Play our daily crossword.

PS

Last month, I wrote about the many instances of waste, fraud, and abuse popping up across the Trump administration. One prime example was a $70 million jet that the Department of Homeland Security had leased and wanted to buy—supposedly for immigrant deportations, even though it included a luxe bedroom cabin. The purchase was too ostentatious even for Trump, and it reportedly played a role in Secretary Kristi Noem’s ouster. But that doesn’t mean the administration is letting the plane go. The Wall Street Journal reports today that the government will hold on to the jet, making it available to First Lady Melania Trump, among others. Noem, it seems, was more a symptom than a cause of the administration living the high life on taxpayer dollars.

— David

Rafaela Jinich contributed to this newsletter.

When you buy a book using a link in this newsletter, we receive a commission. Thank you for supporting The Atlantic*.*


From The Atlantic via this RSS feed

 

Service in wartime has long been a reliable path for Americans denied full citizenship to secure their rights. Black troops’ contributions to the Union cause during the Civil War helped convince Abraham Lincoln of the righteousness of extending suffrage to Black men. Women’s work on the home front during World War I persuaded a reluctant Woodrow Wilson to urge passage of the Nineteenth Amendment as a “war measure.” The military’s repeal of Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell was followed a few years later by the Supreme Court’s recognition of the marriage rights of same-sex couples.

Perhaps the Trump administration is hoping the process works just as well in reverse.

Despite the conflict with Iran and other recent military activity overseas, the Pentagon seems focused on purging minorities and women. Last week, NBC News reported that Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth had intervened to block or delay the promotions of more than a dozen Black and female senior officers. According to both NBC and The New York Times, some officials are concerned that officers are being targeted because of their race, gender, or perceived political affiliation. In one instance last year, Hegseth’s chief of staff, Ricky Buria, bluntly stated that “President Trump would not want to stand next to a Black female officer at military events,” the Times reported. (Buria denied this.)

The Pentagon told NBC and the Times that promotions under Hegseth are “apolitical and unbiased.” Nevertheless, the episode is part of a broader pattern. So far, Trump and Hegseth have dismissed or forced the retirements of several high-ranking Black and/or female officers: General C. Q. Brown as chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff; Admiral Lisa Franchetti as chief of naval operations; Lieutenant General Telita Crosland as head of the Defense Health Agency; and most recently Major General William Green as the Army’s chief of chaplains. Hegseth has publicly said that “our diversity is our strength” is the “dumbest phrase in military history.” By erasing Defense Department histories of nonwhite service members, and seeking to restore tributes to Confederate soldiers who took up arms against their country in defense of slavery, Hegseth has demonstrated a limited view of whose service is to be honored.

Trump is likely also seeking to ensure that remaining officers lack any qualms about following potentially illegal orders. Both he and Hegseth have long seen war crimes as worthy of admiration rather than scorn. As far back as 2016, Trump was regaling audiences at rallies with apocryphal stories about an American general shooting Muslims with bullets coated in pig’s blood. In 2020, he fantasized about turning the military’s guns on American citizens, but faced opposition from the leadership at the Pentagon. Yesterday morning, Trump publicly threatened to destroy Iran’s “whole civilization” and target civilian infrastructure, both war crimes. He subsequently backed down, handing Iran the ability to charge tolls for ships passing through the Strait of Hormuz; passage was free prior to the American attack.

Enlisted service members are disproportionately nonwhite compared with the U.S. population as a whole, while officers are disproportionately white. Women are also serving in larger numbers than ever before: About a fifth of active-duty military personnel are women. Yet Hegseth has long been dismissive of women’s service, particularly in combat roles, and once wrote that, under leaders like Brown, “black troops, at all levels, will be promoted simply based on their race” (this is called confession by accusation). Hegseth seems to want the pool of high-ranking officers to be even less diverse than it already is, having complained in his book that “America’s white sons and daughters are walking away” from the military. And he and Trump seem to be purging not only women and people of color, but officers who see them as equally capable—such as the Army chief of staff, General Randy George, who was fired after reportedly refusing to remove several Black and female officials from the promotion list to general.

[Adam Serwer: The war-crimes president]

Hegseth infamously claimed at the beginning of his tenure that promotions in the military would be “color-blind and merit-based.” It is now clear that this was not true. During his confirmation hearing, Hegseth was unable to provide any evidence whatsoever that the military had lowered standards in the name of diversity. If that is the case, then why have we seen so many well-qualified Black and female senior officers dismissed? Why did the Pentagon, for no plausible reason other than animus, expel trans service members after years of honorable service? “Color-blind and merit-based” now appears to have been a smoke screen for a politically motivated purge of not only Black people and women from leadership positions, but white officers who value their service.

The message being sent to lower-ranking officers is that they will be assessed on the basis of their gender, race, or politics, rather than their abilites—which will cause many officers to leave rather than stay and be mistreated, and many potential officers not to enlist to begin with. It is hard to deny the full benefits of citizenship to those who are willing to fight and die for their country; it is easier if that sacrifice is minimized or erased. Rewarding or punishing officers based on race, gender, or perceived political loyalty to Trump could also aid the administration’s larger project of undermining the claims of women and ethnic and religious minorities to equal treatment under the law in other parts of American society.

The progress earned by ethnic minorities and women in the armed services was hard-won. During the Civil War, Frederick Douglass argued that Black men’s service in the Union Army would strengthen their demands for equal rights. “Let the black man get upon his person the brass letters U.S.; let him get an eagle on his button, and a musket on his shoulder, and bullets in his pocket, and there is no power on the earth or under the earth which can deny that he has earned the right of citizenship in the United States,” Douglass said in 1863. “Nothing can be more plain, nothing more certain, than that the speediest and best possible way open to us to manhood, equal rights, and elevation is that we enter this service.”

Douglass was right, although the process was not as straightforward as he might have hoped. Black service helped justify the passage of the Reconstruction Amendments, but Reconstruction saw Black men disenfranchised and subjected to Jim Crow segregation. W. E. B. Du Bois made a similar argument for Black service in World War I. Returning Black veterans were subjected to horrific racist violence that ultimately strengthened Black resolve. Only after World War II—and over the objections of much of the brass—was the military integrated, and then only after an exhaustive internal investigation disproved racist assumptions that Black troops could only fill menial roles or serve in segregated units.

“Insofar as a service refused to a single Negro the technical training and job for which he was qualified, by just so much did the service waste potential skills and impair its own effectiveness. Quite apart from the question of equal opportunity, the Committee did not believe the country or the military services could afford this human wastage,” the final report from the Truman-era President’s Committee on Equality of Treatment and Opportunity in the Armed Services reads. “The Committee found, in fact, that inequality had contributed to inefficiency.”

[Adam Harris: The only thing integrating America]

Another way to put it is that overt racial discrimination and stereotyping made the military worse, not better. But that was before Hegseth, and his insistence that the problem with the armed services is that they are too diverse and too “woke.”

The result has been something like an inverse caricature of Republican complaints about diversity, equity, and inclusion, a system in which the incompetent rise not because of their abilities but because of their sycophancy. Authoritarian regimes behave as the Trump administration is behaving—optimizing for political loyalty rather than competence. Merit, in short, has little to do with it.

Hegseth is a prime example. Deeply unqualified for the job and convinced that brutality provides an easy path to victory, he has led the United States to the verge of a strategic defeat with a weaker adversary in Iran. The current cease-fire leaves Iran with a more hard-line government than before, one in total control of a shipping lane crucial to the world economy. The Islamic Republic is arguably in a stronger position today than it was when the war started, and probably in a stronger position than it was before Trump, in his first term, scrapped the Obama-era nuclear deal.

On Sunday, Trump posted on his social network a refrain that he and his toadies seem to think is insightful: “If you import The Third World, you become The Third World!” This archaic social Darwinism is the ideological mortar of the Trump project. It fuses Hegseth’s disdain for diversity in the military’s senior leadership and valorization of brutality with the administration’s attack on birthright citizenship and its deployment of federal agents to occupy American cities. It is a worldview that would assume an easy victory against a country like Iran, especially with America’s new, “unwoke” military. Bigotry isn’t just inefficient, as the U.S. military discovered in the 1940s. It also makes you stupid.


From The Atlantic via this RSS feed

 

I Wish I Didn’t Care About 'Marathon' Player Numbers, But I Do

For the last month Joseph and I have been playing as much Marathon as we can fit into our busy lives. During the pandemic, we bonded over playing Call of Duty: Warzone, and we’ve been chasing that high for years with little success. Bungie’s new extraction shooter finally gave it to us.

We should be happy, and we are as long as we’re focused on the game we’re playing and not the industry that’s collapsing around it. Marathon’s commercial success, measured by outsiders mostly by the number of people Steam shows is actively playing the game at any given moment, has no bearing on our enjoyment. But I can’t help but follow those numbers because they are a reminder of how brutal the video game industry is right now, where it might be headed, and how viable Marathon and games like it are in the future.

We don’t know how much Marathon cost to develop or what Sony Interactive Entertainment, which owns Bungie and is publishing the game, wants from it. The game has been a critical success, has reportedly sold 1.2 million copies, and players who have latched onto it like myself love how Bungie has been updating and balancing it after release. People are making horny fan art of Marathon characters.

At the same time, I watch the number of concurrent players on Steam, currently hovering at between 20,000 and 30,000, and fret. Is that enough for Sony to support Marathon for the long haul, and is it enough for the rest of the industry that’s watching this unfold to decide that the kind of player who enjoys a game like Marathon is still worth catering to?

Whether 20,000-30,000 concurrent players is a good number or not is relative and ultimately a decision only Sony can make. More than 19,000 games released on Steam in 2025 and only 6,000 of them earned more than $100,000. With at least tens of millions of dollars worth of sales on Steam alone, Marathon is one of the highest earning games on that platform. Marathon’s numbers are also considerably higher than Sony’s other big competitive shooter, Concord, which barely cracked 700 concurrent players on Steam before it was shuttered in 2024, barely a month after it was released. Highguard, another multiplayer shooter that was unveiled at the end of 2025’s Game Awards, also shuttered just a bit over a month after it launched. It peaked at almost 100,000 concurrent players on Steam, but it was free to play.

One might naively assume that the basic math at Sony would be to see how much Marathon cost to develop and maintain, see how much money it’s making after launch, and to keep the party going as long as it’s turning a profit. The reality is probably a bit more cynical and complicated than that. Bungie is a big studio that employees hundreds of developers that Sony acquired for $3.7 billion. One line item on Marathon’s budget that’s extremely hard to calculate is the opportunity cost of Bungie making Marathon as opposed to the next Fortnite, now that it’s becoming increasingly clear that Marathon will not be doing Fortnite numbers.

That doesn’t mean there isn’t a tremendously profitable business to be had there, given some patience and care. Ubisoft launched Rainbow Six Siege in 2015 to a tepid response, but has turned it into a decade-old cash cow with consistent support, updates, and a devious loot box-based monetization scheme. It essentially did the same thing for For Honor, a melee multiplayer game that I bet you forgot existed but that’s been going since 2017.

But Sony is a publicly traded company that wants to show quarter over quarter growth, and a modestly healthy profit that also happens to keep hundreds of game developers employed is not what shareholders are salivating over. Sony wants to do Fortnite numbers, which is a very tall order considering that even Fortnite isn’t doing Fortnite numbers anymore.

Our friends at Remap Radio have spoken at length about why discussions about player numbers teach us little about games and are often toxic. Part of the reason that games like Concord and Highguard can crash and burn so quickly is that the numbers become a self-fulfilling prophecy. There’s skepticism about the game before it launches, and when it fails to go viral, people write it off because why would they invest their time in an online game with player numbers that signal imminent and unceremonious execution by its financial backers, which only leads to even lower player numbers. It also shifts the conversation entirely away from what the game is, what people like about it, and why, and to its business model, infecting players with the quarterly earnings report view of the world. Games and players become expressions and subjects of business models, and the part where we play games because we enjoy them are reduced to a curious byproduct of Sony’s Earnings Before Interest, Taxes, Depreciation, and Amortization. Games from major publishers become either mega hits or are quickly slapped with the “dead game” label before they’re taken offline. What the game actually was is barely relevant.

Everyone I’m playing Marathon with is aware of the player numbers anxiety but is responding to it in different ways. Most of us are doing armchair video game industry analysis, while others are actively trying to enjoy Marathon’s popularity while we can precisely because it may be fleeting and eventually unavailable to play. Some of us are buying in-game cosmetic items not because we want them that bad, but as a signal to Sony that there’s money to be made here.

Adding to this player count anxiety is the fact that the video game industry appears to be going through what is increasingly looking like a proper crash. I don’t think we’ll ever have another near extinction event like the video game crash of 1983, where for a moment it didn’t seem like video games would even continue to be a thing, but a full one third of game developers in the U.S. were laid off last year, and the huge layoffs just keep on coming.

The question of whether Marathon is a viable business for Sony naturally leads us to the question: What business does Sony even want to be in going forward? Is it a business that’s in continuity with the games we grew up playing on the PlayStation and PlayStation 2, or will the market force it to chase something like Roblox or other free-to-play models? Can this continuity even exist when a PlayStation 5 Pro now costs $899 and a PlayStation 6 will cost more? Those are prices for 30 and 40 year-olds with disposable income, not the younger audiences game publishers need to be winning over now for their future business. Sony and other video game publishers are already losing them to different kinds of games and forms of entertainment.

“Marathon's low gravity, bouncy physics, and methodical boot clunks echo Master Chief's graceful, weighty gait circa 2004. It's got modern conveniences like aim-down-sights, sprinting, sliding—and yet Marathon evokes a more civilized age,” Morgan Park wrote in his excellent review in PC Gamer. “Those qualities make it more accessible to a range of people who struggle to keep up in faster games while maintaining a skill range in other disciplines: timing, positioning, and perception. It's fairly easy to track targets, but you're still rewarded for nailing headshots, taking the high ground, and utilizing shell abilities. Does that make Marathon an unc game?”

pic.twitter.com/WgxIBEHd3g

— 定 (@de3dsoul) March 19, 2026

To answer Park’s rhetorical question for him, yes, Marathon is in fact an unc game, which explains both why I like it so much and why I’m worried about its future. As you probably know, unc, short for uncle, is a way to jokingly refer to old, potentially out of touch people. As far as I can tell, it entered the video game discourse in the form of this meme in which a soyfaced unc excitedly points at the hall of fame of so-called “unc slop,” or, in other words, games that old people say are very good. Some of the games in this collage of video game box art includes Half-Life 2, Dawn of War, World of Warcraft, STALKER, Mass Effect, and Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic. Or, many of my favorite games of all time.

Marathon could easily fit in that collage. It’s excellent, and, I worry, catering to a dwindling audience of uncs who are having a great time while the culture and business of video games is largely moving on and eventually leaving them behind.


From 404 Media via this RSS feed

 

This article was featured in the One Story to Read Today newsletter. Sign up for it here.

The president of the United States is losing his head, and that means the rest of us must keep ours. At 8:06 a.m. eastern daylight time, Donald Trump posted this on his Truth Social site:

A whole civilization will die tonight, never to be brought back again. I don’t want that to happen, but it probably will. However, now that we have Complete and Total Regime Change, where different, smarter, and less radicalized minds prevail, maybe something revolutionarily wonderful can happen, WHO KNOWS? We will find out tonight, one of the most important moments in the long and complex history of the World. 47 years of extortion, corruption, and death, will finally end. God Bless the Great People of Iran!

The world, unfortunately, has gotten used to Trump’s overheated rhetoric, and to dismissing the commander in chief as something of a crank who (as the French president recently advised) should perhaps keep more of his thoughts to himself.

But the president’s statements are policy, and he has now made it the policy of the government of the United States that at 8 p.m. Washington, D.C., time (3:30 a.m. in Tehran), he will order the U.S. military to destroy Iran and its entire civilization—permanently—unless his terms are met. (He did not specify those terms, but on Easter Sunday, he posted a frenzied and obscenity-laden message on Truth Social demanding that Iran reopen the Strait of Hormuz.) Whether the president is saying this with full control of his faculties or has well and truly lost his mind is irrelevant: He is still the president, and so we must consider the meaning of this policy.

[Read: Trump threatens to destroy an entire nation]

First, Trump is vowing to eradicate a nation of 92 million people and their entire culture, “never to be brought back again.” No leader standing in front of a court at The Hague would be able to finesse that language: “A whole civilization will die tonight, never to be brought back again” doesn’t leave a lot of room for charitable interpretations. Even Richard Nixon, the author of the “madman theory”—the notion that a president might seek advantage over an enemy by appearing to be irrational—never publicly threatened to wipe out Vietnam. Trump could argue that his threats against bridges and electricity plants might not be war crimes, if they have a military use, but his promise to erase a civilization from the Earth is a flat threat of genocide.

Second, the most important aspect of Trump’s threat is that it implies the use of nuclear weapons. Trump did not explicitly invoke nuclear arms, and he claims to abhor the idea of using them. (He has also, of course, asked why America has them if they can’t be used.) But the United States could launch every conventional munition it has, and although that kind of onslaught would immiserate the people of Iran, result in many deaths, and make reconstruction a long-term nightmare, Iranian civilization would survive. German civilization survived years of bombing so intense that the firestorms melted glass and asphalt; Japanese civilization survived similar incendiary attacks and two nuclear bombs. A threat to destroy an entire civilization in one night, assuming he means it, can be fulfilled only with the wide use of nuclear weapons.

The president now sounds no different from the authoritarian rulers of the world’s worst regimes. North Korea, when it was pursuing nuclear arms, would threaten to turn cities into “lakes of fire”; Iran, of course, has often threatened to “wipe Israel from the map,” which is why the world has been trying to stop Iran from getting nuclear weapons. Now Trump is making those same kinds of threats—and he has nuclear weapons.

In the past, Trump’s sycophants in the conservative media have tried to wave away his bellicosity as just the way he talks and dismiss concerns as pearl-clutching from people who just don’t get him. But would any American offer the same grace to Kim Jong Un or Iranian Supreme Leader Mojtaba Khamenei, if they used the language Trump employed today?

Imagine how the United States would react if the leader of a major nuclear-armed power made a similar threat—if Russian President Vladimir Putin said something like Ukraine must submit to my demands by 0800 hours, or I will eradicate Ukrainian civilization, or if Chinese President Xi Jinping said, Taiwan must accept Chinese rule by sundown, or Taiwan, in one of the most important moments in the long and complex history of the world, will be gone and never return. At the least, the United States would likely go on heightened military alert—and might even raise the readiness of its nuclear forces—because we would have to assume that such statements from a national leader are not mere bluster.

Even during the Cold War, American planners avoided such pronouncements. U.S. nuclear strategy prioritized targeting enemy nuclear weapons, command and control, military assets, and the enemy government. There were good reasons for this list of priorities: Those targets mirrored what the Soviets would strike in the United States. Had World War III erupted, the net effect would have been something akin to what Trump is threatening now, but as the horrifying consequence of a nuclear exchange, not as an intended goal. (In 1967, Robert McNamara, in a moment of exasperation with some hawkish questioning from Congress, blurted out that the Kremlin’s leaders knew that if they attacked America, we’d kill 120 million Soviets; he was trying, however, only to reaffirm the deterrent logic of mutual assured destruction, not advocating for such action.)

If Trump did give an order to attack civilian targets that have no military value as a means of collectively punishing the Iranian people, he would be ordering war crimes. If he directs the widespread and irrevocable destruction of Iranian civilization—that is, if he commands a genocide and especially if he approves the release of nuclear weapons—the U.S. military should refuse such blatantly illegal orders.

In a better world, Trump would face a revolt in his Cabinet over such orders. Unfortunately, his Cabinet is stocked with needy courtiers who, to date, have preferred to enable the president’s reckless schemes rather than argue with him or resign in protest. Indeed, they were chosen not for the strength of their character but for their pliancy: People such as Pete Hegseth and Tulsi Gabbard exist as national political figures only because they circle Trump like dwarf moons around a gas giant. They are not going to stop him.

[Barbara A. Perry: This is not how presidents typically communicate]

Only Marco Rubio’s resignation would matter. Rubio, as secretary of state (and, concurrently, national security adviser), has a certain amount of political gravitas left, and if he spent it by threatening to walk out of the White House tonight as a private citizen, he might sway Trump from his mad threats. If Trump wishes to follow through on his threats, and the Cabinet declines to stop him, Congress could in theory convene and attempt to restrain him—but that seems even less likely to happen, despite some panicky concern from a few GOP senators.

Should Trump persist in his threatened course of action, then only a mass resignation of senior officers would stand between the president and a campaign of genocide. By this, I do not mean a mutiny or coup. The answer to Trump’s lawlessness is not more lawlessness. But American officers have a positive duty to refuse illegal orders, and the destruction of an entire civilization with nuclear weapons—which poses no similar threat to the United States—is as illegal as it gets. We must all hope that Trump’s message was an early-morning rant that got loose in the wild before anyone could stop him. But it’s out there now, and we are just hours away from his deadline. He is the president, and his words have meaning, and he has publicly committed the United States to the extermination of an entire nation.

If Trump gives that order, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff should lay his stars down in front of Trump. Then, each general who gets the order should do likewise, and each man—and it will be men, in Hegseth’s Pentagon—promoted as a replacement should do likewise, until Trump has a pile of stars and eagles on his desk. Trump may eventually find someone to fulfill his orders, but people of honor and duty need not be the unwilling instruments of so great a sin.


From The Atlantic via this RSS feed

submitted 7 months ago by [B] to c/theatlantic@ibbit.at
 

In 2005, a bipartisan commission of lawmakers and security experts concluded that “the Intelligence Community was dead wrong in almost all of its pre-war judgments about Iraq’s weapons of mass destruction.” America’s spies had told President George W. Bush that Saddam Hussein had reconstituted a nuclear-weapons program and that Iraq possessed biological weapons and mobile production facilities, as well as stockpiles of chemical weapons. These supposed facts became the basis for a U.S. invasion and an eight-year occupation. “Not one bit of it could be confirmed when the war was over,” the commission found. “This was a major intelligence failure.”

If a similar panel of experts scrutinized the run-up to the current war in Iran, their assessment might go something like this:

The intelligence community was accurate and consistent in its prewar judgments about Iran’s capabilities and intentions to attack the United States and its allies. Contrary to what President Trump has said to justify his decision, the intelligence showed that the Iranian regime was not preparing to use a nuclear weapon; it did not have ballistic missiles capable of reaching the United States; and in response to a U.S. military attack, Iran was likely to strike at neighboring countries in the Persian Gulf and try to close the Strait of Hormuz, precipitating a global economic crisis. All of this was known before the war and presented to President Trump. This was an intelligence success.

Trump’s “excursion,” as he calls the biggest U.S. military operation of his second term, has unleashed a parade of horribles. Iran now controls the strait, where it plans to charge vessels a toll and can govern global flows of oil, natural gas, fertilizer, and chemicals that are crucial for manufacturing. A regime that Trump claims to have replaced still remains in the hands of hard-liners, whose repression of the Iranian people will be strengthened for having survived a decapitation strike by the world’s only superpower. And neighboring countries in the Gulf, whose livelihoods depend on exporting energy and creating safe places for people to visit, live, and work, will amass new weapons and reconsider their strategic partnerships with the United States.

Two decades ago, a president embraced information that turned out to be wrong, and disaster followed. Today, a president disregards assessments that proved to be right, and the predictable comes to pass. There’s a failure of intelligence there too—just not the kind we’re used to seeing.

“Your successes are unheralded—your failures are trumpeted,” President John F. Kennedy remarked in a speech to CIA staff at their headquarters, in Langley, Virginia, in 1961. Ever since, intelligence officers have ruefully invoked that truism whenever they’re blamed for a major screwup. The familiar storyline of an intelligence failure features analysts who neglect to “connect the dots,” case officers who get seduced by sources who exaggerate or lie, and politicians who contort ambiguous information to align with their preferred outcome. That’s what happened in the months before the Iraq War.

The lead-up to Operation Epic Fury turns this narrative on its head. The spies called it right, but the president went another direction. The failures of the intelligence community on Iraq’s WMDs produced systemic changes meant to keep botched calls like that one from recurring. In many respects, those reforms have worked. But they couldn’t account for a decision maker who had been seduced by previous military successes into thinking that the U.S. armed forces, under his inspired and perhaps divinely endowed command, could never stumble.

Some of Trump’s allies have criticized him for not making a public case for war, as the Bush administration did. But if he had accurately presented the intelligence, the facts would have argued against attacking Iran—or at least for not striking before the diplomatic options had been exhausted. Perhaps that’s why the president ignored, and later misrepresented, what his advisers told him.

[Read: Trump’s fateful choice]

“The regime already had missiles capable of hitting Europe and our bases, both local and overseas, and would soon have had missiles capable of reaching our beautiful America,” Trump said before a Medal of Honor ceremony at the White House on March 2. But the Defense Intelligence Agency had concluded that building a missile that could hit the United States would take Iran until 2035, and only then if it was determined to do so, which analysts concluded it was not. When Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard—hardly the model of an apolitical presidential adviser—testified before Congress a few weeks later, she reported that Iran had missile technology that “it could use to begin to develop a militarily viable ICBM before 2035,” but did not say that it had done so. That timeline is crucial to understand, because to hit the United States with the ultimate weapon, Iran would have to place a nuclear warhead on top of an intercontinental ballistic missile.

That threat was not years away, Trump insisted. Iran was “going to take over the Middle East. They were going to knock out Israel with their nuclear weapon,” he told reporters in the Oval Office on March 16. A charitable reading might be that Trump believes Iran wants to use a nuclear weapon. But desire, or even intention, does not equal capability.

It’s true that Iran possesses uranium that could eventually be used to build a nuclear weapon, were it to be further enriched. But in late June, U.S. bombers struck nuclear-related facilities in Iran, which had made “no efforts since then to try to rebuild their enrichment capability,” Gabbard said in her written statement to Congress. “The entrances to the underground facilities that were bombed have been buried and shuttered with cement.” That’s not a picture of a country on the brink of using a nuclear weapon.

Trump not only has misstated intelligence about Iran’s military potential. He has expressed surprise at the regime’s response to American and Israeli bombing, particularly Iran’s closure of the Strait of Hormuz and the heavy drone and missile attacks it has launched on its neighbors in the Persian Gulf. But the president’s advisers had told him this was likely to happen. They knew that restricting a shipping artery would give Iran a chokehold on the world’s economy. It’s such a no-brainer maneuver that the Pentagon has built it into its war planning. When Trump’s military advisers apprised him of this possibility, he appeared to have shrugged them off. Iran would probably capitulate before trying to close the strait, he said, and in any event, he thought the military could handle it, The Wall Street Journal reported.

After threatening to bomb Iran if ships weren’t allowed to travel freely, Trump now says other nations should bear the burden of reopening the waterway. “The United States imports almost no oil through the Hormuz Strait and won’t be taking any in the future,” Trump said in a primetime address to the nation on Wednesday. “We don’t need it.” Oil prices rose following his remarks.

Trump has also said that no one told him that Iran was likely to attack Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates, Qatar, and other Gulf nations that are close allies of the United States and host vital military bases. “They weren’t supposed to go after all these other countries in the Middle East,” Trump said during a White House event on March 16. “Nobody expected that. We were shocked.”

How could they be? In 2025, the U.S. intelligence community publicly reported that “Iran’s large conventional forces are capable of inflicting substantial damage to an attacker, executing regional strikes, and disrupting shipping, particularly energy supplies, through the Strait of Hormuz.” No less than Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth, perhaps the war’s biggest cheerleader in the administration, had to admit that Iran’s regional retaliation was not exactly a surprise. “I can’t say that we anticipated necessarily that’s exactly how they would react, but we knew it was a possibility,” he said at a press conference on March 10.

Before the war, officials from two Arab countries told Trump and his top aides that they worried Iran could launch counterattacks on them, in order to halt the flow of oil, drive up prices, and trigger a global economic crisis, Politico reported. In early February, as U.S. warships were moving into position, I met with several of Qatar’s senior government officials. The likelihood of an Iranian reprisal was top of mind. One official pointed out the obvious, that a war could make it impossible for Qatar to produce and ship liquefied natural gas, the foundation of its economy. That’s exactly what happened.

After conducting its own war-gaming, one of the United States’ closest intelligence-sharing partners in Europe determined that a major American attack would compel Iran to hit countries in the Gulf and try to close the strait, an official in that government recently told me on the condition of anonymity to discuss a sensitive assessment. The Americans were aware of those conclusions, according to the official, who was baffled that Trump claimed to be surprised.

Members of the Senate Intelligence Committee were also nonplussed, and angry, when Gabbard appeared before them last month. “There seems to be a discrepancy between what the intelligence community has reported over the years and what the president has said in terms of this action” in Iran, Senator Angus King, an independent from Maine, said. “And my question is, did you tell him?”

Gabbard avoided answering directly. But she said that the agencies she oversees had provided Trump “with the intelligence related to this operation in Iran, before and on an ongoing basis.” CIA Director John Ratcliffe, who was also present, said that he had participated in “dozens and dozens of briefings with the president,” including in the weeks before the war. He emphasized that “Iran had specific plans to hit U.S. interests in energy sites across the region.” Gabbard backed him up, noting that “this has long been an assessment of the IC that Iran would likely hold the Strait of Hormuz as leverage,” using a shorthand to refer to the intelligence community.

Senators were also keen to understand why one of Gabbard’s top deputies had quit his job over the president’s decision to go to war. “Iran posed no imminent threat to our nation,” Joe Kent, whom Trump had nominated to run the National Counterterrorism Center, wrote in his resignation letter, a revealing statement from an official who had access to some of the most highly classified intelligence in the U.S. government. Ratcliffe told the committee that he disagreed with Kent and that Iran maintained an aspiration to build a nuclear weapon. But that is not the same thing as actually building one and preparing to use it, as Trump has claimed Iran was doing.

[Read: An Army shake-up in the middle of a war ]

Senator Jon Ossoff, a Democrat from Georgia, read aloud a portion of a White House statement from the day after the war began: Trump had ordered “a military campaign to eliminate the imminent nuclear threat posed by the Iranian regime.” He asked Gabbard: Had the intelligence community assessed that the threat was imminent?

The intelligence director, who had taken passionately anti-war stances as a member of Congress, walked an awkward line. She told Ossoff that the president is “the only person who can determine what is and is not an imminent threat,” and that doing so was not the intelligence community’s job. In fact, it is precisely the job of the intelligence community to make that determination. But putting Gabbard’s evasive characterization aside, she said that “Iran maintained the intention to rebuild and to continue to grow their nuclear enrichment capability.” What she didn’t mention: There is a world of difference between intention and imminent threat.

Plenty of presidents have dismissed the warnings and prognostications of their intelligence advisers, or simply not made time to hear them. When a stolen Cessna crashed on the South Lawn of the White House in 1994, some joked that it was flown by Bill Clinton’s CIA briefer, trying desperately to get a meeting with the president. At the other end of the spectrum, George W. Bush became obsessed with the minutiae of counterterrorism operations, keeping track of the various al-Qaeda members whom the CIA was hunting and killing.

Trump’s relationship with the intelligence community is more fraught than any of his predecessors’. As a candidate, he excoriated the agencies for their botched call on Iraq’s WMDs. As president, he has railed against a “deep state” that he claims has been out to get him for more than a decade. Trump has long said that he trusts his gut. He’ll know the war in Iran is over, he recently told an interviewer, “when I feel it, feel it in my bones.”

The U.S. intelligence community is neither designed nor equipped to restrain a president who is moved by impulse, emotion, and his own feelings. It can only provide him with information. When the president disregards what he’s told, or distorts it, that failure is his alone.


From The Atlantic via this RSS feed

 

Subscribe here: Apple Podcasts | Spotify | YouTube

How is AI changing the way we work? This week on Galaxy Brain, Charlie Warzel is joined by Johnathan and Melissa Nightingale, two experts in management and leadership training. They discuss how chatbots and AI agents are winding their way through the workforce, offering a firsthand view of how companies are (and aren’t) adopting AI tools. The conversation covers the gap between AI hype and what’s actually happening in offices. It also touches on how overreliance on AI tools may be making bosses worse at their jobs, and how work may be one of the last bastions of sustained social connection in a period of cultural alienation and isolation.

The following is a transcript of the episode:

Johnathan Nightingale: It turns out that humans really care about doing work they believe in, with people they care about. And when you hollow those things out, people have these emotional responses to it that I don’t see predicted by the marketing materials from the AI companies.

[Music]

Charlie Warzel: I’m Charlie Warzel, and this is Galaxy Brain: a show where today we are going to talk about work. Trying to talk about jobs right now—how we work, what that work means, what the future of white-collar work looks like—it is just extremely difficult.

We all seem to be situated in this very confusing moment, one that I think is captured very well by my Atlantic colleague Josh Tyrangiel’s story. It ran with this rather ominous headline: “America Isn’t Ready for What AI Will Do to Jobs.” The piece is great, and you should totally seek it out. But the illustration of the piece I found quite apt.

It’s of this man; he’s in a tree. His eyes are two dollar signs, and he’s smiling while holding a chainsaw and cutting into the branch that’s supporting his own weight. This in many ways is the vibe of 2026. This feeling that this certain subset of people motivated by profit and efficiency are conducting an experiment that, if it succeeds, is not gonna just rewire the economy forever but change the very nature and essence of labor.

For the last few years, since the arrival of chatbots, the AI conversation around work has been some version of this. The tools are useful in automating busywork and drudgery. They’re getting better.

And so what does that mean for jobs? Well, AI executives have been issuing dire warnings. In 2025, for example, Dario Amide—the CEO of the AI company Anthropic—told Axios that AI could drive unemployment up 10 to 20 percent in the next one to five years and wipe out half of all entry-level white-collar jobs.

Meanwhile, those who are running companies seem quite eager to unleash this technology on knowledge work—labor force be damned. They’re driven by profit incentives and a good amount of FOMO. AI is the future. Get on board or be left behind. What’s your AI strategy? In some cases, the fastest way to show results is to simply reduce head count.

Workers, especially young workers, are concerned. According to the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, the unemployment rate for college graduates ages 22 to 27 ballooned to 5.6 percent at the end of last year. And as The New York Times notes: “For those who are employed, more than 40 percent held jobs that do not typically require college degrees, the highest level since 2020.”

You can feel the weirdness in the economy right now. This fear of a kind of job-market stagnation, but no exact sense of what is happening on the ground. How much of all of this is actually AI driven? Simply put, there are huge fears here that AI is not only changing the way we might do our jobs, but it might be changing how we get them, whether we can keep them. AI executives are out here arguing that most of us, no matter the job, are destined to become middle managers for a host of AI agents. And you can take that with a grain of salt as just another tech CEO prognostication. But if there’s any truth to it, it would represent a massive change. And the concerns go well beyond the economy into something much more existential. What does it mean to be a human in a world that all of a sudden doesn’t value human labor in the same way?

So are we all destined to become middle managers? Is AI really ripping through the workforce? What is the value of work in this strange economy? And how can people survive—maintain dignity, human connection, all of that—in a world where decision makers driven by dollar signs are pruning the trees for every possible efficiency? Even if we’re all just sitting on the branches?

Johnathan and Melissa Nightingale are here to help me answer some of these thorny questions. They’re the founders of Raw Signal, a leadership and management training firm. Johnathan and Melissa have worked with thousands of executives and managers and companies across tech and other industries, and they’re keen observers of the ways that modern white-collar work and workplace communication is broken. But they also offer this clear vision of how work can stay human and humane. They join me now to talk it all through.

[Music]

Warzel: Melissa and Johnathan, welcome to Galaxy Brain.

Johnathan Nightingale: Thank you.

Melissa Nightingale: Thanks, Charlie.

Johnathan Nightingale: It’s lovely to be here.

Warzel: So it is a weird time in the economy, especially in America. We’re in this low-hire, low-fire labor market. There’s this very amorphous and pressing fear right now about artificial intelligence taking or threatening jobs, especially entry-level jobs. And the labor market just looks increasingly grim and feels increasingly grim to younger workers. The vibes—they’re off, they’re not good.

I wanted to start just by asking you all: You’re talking to businesses, to people. You’re on the ground. What are people telling you about the vibes right now? Report on the vibes for me.

Melissa Nightingale: I love “Report on the vibes.”

Johnathan Nightingale: “The vibes” is such a great place to start. Because I don’t know if you remember, but it wasn’t so many years ago that companies were appointing “chief vibes officers.”

Melissa Nightingale: Do you remember this? Like, in 2022?

Warzel: I don’t really, no.

Melissa Nightingale: Okay; there’s a very weird future-of-work moment where everybody was, like, a future-of-work thought leader in 2022. And The New York Times reported they had a big story about chief vibes officers being like…

Johnathan Nightingale: The new jobs of the new economy.

Warzel: Man, I missed out on that. I would love to be chief vibes officer.

Melissa Nightingale: But that was the new hot title.

Johnathan Nightingale: Because, like, in 2022, like everybody was fighting. I think junior engineers were getting, you know, 100, 200, 300,000-dollar offer packages because everybody was starved for this tech talent. And that was the story of the moment—“Wow, how much worker empowerment there is.”

Melissa Nightingale: And so, we’re not trying to make the vibe sad. But it is worth starting with: Where were the vibes as we head into … like, where are the vibes now? So 2022: still relatively hot labor market; still a lot of competition for talent. Particularly junior talent; particularly junior engineering talent.

Johnathan Nightingale: And you could tell that senior leaders were pissed off about them. It was too expensive. These people were too entitled, right? Like, “chief vibes officer” makes good buzz. But you could tell in early 2022 that this was about to get some pushback.

Melissa Nightingale: Remember, this was the earliest version of return-to-office mandates. People saying: “We went home. We did amazing work at home. Why do we have to go back? And also, like, if you make me go back, I have another $300,000 job offer lined up tomorrow.”

Johnathan Nightingale: Just walk across the street. And so, it’s funny because people talk about AI and all the layoffs. And there’s been, you know, half a million layoffs in the last several years, and technology workers and stuff like that. Those layoffs started before the first ChatGPT release.

Melissa Nightingale: What it did was reset the market, right? It recalibrated. Like, you had folks who had that sort of early engineering role. And they got a little bit more skittish about, Should I leave to go across the street, or should I stay put? Should I feel grateful that I have a job, that I have this opportunity? And you started to see people feeling a little bit more nervous, and a little bit more uncomfortable around the market overall.

Johnathan Nightingale: These days, AI has sucked all the oxygen out of the room. And people are like: “That’s all driven by AI.” I’m like: no. First of all, November ChatGPT couldn’t count how many Rs there were in strawberry. That’s not a reason to turn your whole business upside down. But also, the layoffs happened six months before that too. It’s really been part of a pattern of executives in some organizations reasserting power and making sure that, especially, junior workers lose that sense of entitlement. I think vibes-wise, that’s happened. They succeeded in that.

Warzel: It was such an interesting moment. I wrote back in—I think it was 2021, but it might’ve been 2022—in that time period of a hot labor market. Also of, as you say, some real worker empowerment. I remember writing this piece that was like: “Do workers, do people even want a career?” Right? Like, do the young, Gen Z people coming up, do they even want a career? They’re questioning the idea of the standard thing, because there’s just so many different options. And maybe I don’t want to work the way that my parents worked. And to compare that feeling to now, where it’s like “Could I even get in the door to have a career, or am I going to have to figure out something else completely different?” I think that that’s extremely stark in terms of that shift. What are people telling you on the ground now in terms of this moment? Obviously there is that sense of precarity with workers. But in terms of that force, of generative AI, how are people feeling about it?

Melissa Nightingale: Johnathan and I both come from tech, right? We’ve both been working in tech since the first dot-com boom, all the way on through. And we work with a lot of organizations with tech leaders. And what we’re hearing from folks is—on the one hand, you sign up for tech as your industry and as your career, you like working on the cool new stuff, right? Like, we are an industry that loves our toys. We love innovation. We love sort of taking things out and experimenting. Sometimes they last; sometimes they don’t last. But as an industry, if that doesn’t get you lit up, you’ve picked the wrong job.

But what we’re hearing from a lot of folks is that the day-to-day of “We’re playing with these tools” is no longer lining up to “What are we supposed to be doing here?” And that playing with the tools has become sort of an end into itself. And a lot of folks are finding: “We’re using them, but I don’t know—what are we running toward?”

Warzel: Do you get the sense that this is like, if we’re going down the chain: This is executives high up on top, see a thing. They’re reading a lot about it; there’s a lot of hype. They feel, Okay, more than anything, I have to make sure that we do not get left behind here. And then the sort of middle-manager layer is feeling that it’s forced on them. Or is there sort of, broadly speaking, a lot of enthusiasm—but there’s just not enough time to figure it out?

Melissa Nightingale: All of the above. Like, we met a lady who’s a really skilled executive, and she was working in an organization where she’s like: “I came in as a fixer, right? My whole job was fixer. And I was really excited about it. Like, the opportunity was cool. Came in, doing the work. And starting to see the impact of that work, right?” And she’s like, “And then my CEO got really excited about GPT, and I started sending things that were strategic plans for my division, for my department. And what started coming back from my CEO—who I report directly into—wasn’t from him. It was clear he hadn’t read any of the plans that I was putting forward. He just pushed them through and said, Generate an email in response to this.” And she’s like, “I went from being so excited about the turnaround potential for this business, for this organization, and for my department and team, to feeling really sad. Like fundamentally—just having a very hard time figuring out, What am I doing if I’m putting in all this effort?”

Johnathan Nightingale: When you look at a story like that—that’s a management failure. It can take one of a couple flavors. One thing you can say is, “That person’s work is now useless because GPT replaces it well enough. And so that person should have just been given a firm handshake and a goodbye package and sent out the door.” Or you can say “GPT can’t replace human ingenuity at the senior levels.” And so there’s a real dereliction there, because you had a motivated, engaged senior employee, and you burnt them. In either case, that’s a management failure. A thing that’s coming up a fair bit is that people look at what code generation can do in LLMs today. And they sort of do the “well naturally”: Well, naturally, in time, it will write good poems. Well, naturally, in time, it will be your accountant. And well, naturally, in time, it will manage as well or better than most people do. It’s just this leap, this linear leap, that is not borne out by what we’re seeing on the ground today.

Warzel: Do you feel like that’s a broader trend of, especially on the executive layer—and I’m not trying to paint people as caricatures here—but this idea that, especially with these higher, more like “vision strategy” jobs, where there is a lot of busywork involved in that sense of communication. That, you know, what I’ve heard is that AI is a perfect CEO, right? Like, it could be—it’s just sort of broad, broad pronouncements—being able to speak with maybe more confidence than is earned or deserved, right?

Johnathan Nightingale: Incredible executive presence.

Warzel: Great presence in that sense. And so, naturally, people higher up on the end of the management chain might be enamored with it or the ability of it. Do you feel like CEOs are overly AI-pilled right now?

Johnathan Nightingale: I think they’re a vulnerable group. I think one of the challenges with being a CEO is that even an incredibly effective CEO shouldn’t know more about every function in their business than the people working those functions do. Right? If you’re an expert engineer and you become a CEO, you might know a lot about engineering.

Melissa Nightingale: But over time, you’ll actually know less than the people who are typing on keyboards all day.

Johnathan Nightingale: And your head of sales should know more about sales than you do. Your head of marketing should know more about marketing than you do. Right? Like, that part of the job of building a senior team is to make sure those people are, one, lighting you on fire with great ideas, and two, are credible leaders for their own functions in a way that you couldn’t be. Because a person can’t know everything about everything. And so, it’s tempting from that seat to flatten a lot of that work, and to say “If an AI can do that work 80 percent as well, maybe I have to spend some more compute over there in order to get the result I want. But, like, do I even need a marketing department? Do I even need an engineering department? Do I even need a finance department?” They’re vulnerable to it if they don’t hold on to a sort of core “go touch grass” reality. Which is that it takes a long time to learn some things, and human judgment is valuable.

Warzel: Where do you all think we are in terms of adoption? Because again, for someone on the outside, who’s not speaking to managers and the rank-and-file types of employees at all times, it’s hard to get a good sense.

But how much have these tools already changed what is happening day in, day out? Versus how much of it is that feeling of like, I need to be doing this. This is something that we need to have? There is the, you know, the FOMO element. Where do you see the balance there?

Johnathan Nightingale: Certainly among the groups that we work with, people in engineering roles have been the most curious about it, and in some cases the most compelled to engage with it. You definitely have people who are very credulous—“We’re playing with it a lot”—who feel like they’re getting super productive about it. We’re starting to see studies about how those people are burning themselves out. Right? Those people are really struggling, because they’re orchestrating so many bots that they never want to close their laptop. Because they’re getting this dopamine hit from productivity. They’re not necessarily deepening their skills; they’re just doing a bunch of stuff. But like, there you see a ton of adoption.

Melissa Nightingale: We’re starting to see the fingerprints of AI-adoption mandates in context where it makes no damn sense. So like, prompt saying,“We have a client organization that was building technology to respond to bots infiltrating contact forms on websites.” Because so many people were having their agent basically go: “Reach out to this organization; we’re trying to get this work done. Can you go figure out a quote for this thing? Like, go write them with a description of what we’re trying to get done; have it come back.” But the cycle times are considerably longer, in part because the context that you can anticipate a human responding to it needing just isn’t there. And so you end up with, like—it’s meant to save a step, but it causes three more. And we’ve all had the experience of somebody like a junior person sending a shitty email and being like, Fuck, I gotta go unwind that. Right? Like, I gotta go unwind that you sent an email. And, it makes no damn sense. And now I’ve got 30 people in the organization going on, running and chasing a thing.

Johnathan Nightingale: Or “You sent it to a client, and now I gotta go apologize for that.”

Melissa Nightingale: Right. But imagine that multiplied across many workforces right now. Where you’ve got a lot of communication and requests flowing that, like, just missed an important key step before they went out the door. And so there’s a bunch of weird context and cleanup that’s taking longer than the original initial task would have taken to just do the damn thing.

Johnathan Nightingale: And there’s this rigidity forming, too, which is worth fighting against. Which is that you’ll have people farming everything out to GPT—even really obvious ways, right? You get emails from a colleague, and you’re like, “This is not what you sound like. This is obviously GPT. And what am I meant to do with the fact that you didn’t bother to write this email?” Right?

Warzel: Absolutely.

Johnathan Nightingale: And then like the alternative is to say, “Well, screw it. I will never let GPT do that. It’s an insult when somebody does it to me; I’m not gonna do that to other people.” And from that place, this sort of entrench and say, I refuse to engage with these tools. And then you’re putting your refusal up against management pressure. And, it’s driving conflict that isn’t very helpful.

Warzel: When I hear, “Oh, these agents are filling up these contact forms; it’s creating a whole bunch of extra work.” The guy who’s been listening to people in Silicon Valley talk about this technology for a very long time says, “Yes, well; their solution to that is you need agents on both ends, because having agents on just one end is, you know, not balanced.” There’s this way in which I can see that. People are creating—it’s a very classic tech thing to create a bunch of problems and then offer a technological solution to the problem that you created.

Johnathan Nightingale: Yeah.

Warzel: That all adds to more problems down the line. I also think, though, that what I wanna highlight there is the way in which this creates these asymmetries and builds these little cracks and pieces of distrust. That seems like something that feels really important in the context of all of this going forward, if you are somebody who cares a lot about what you do and puts a lot of effort into these things.

And then you have a group of people who may also care, but they use these tools. And there’s not this standardization of work output. And you see somebody respond to your email with something general. I think it’s really interesting that it creates that fracture, based off of how AI-pilled you are or how excited you are about the technology. And that feels like a bigger problem than I think people are thinking about right now.

Melissa Nightingale: We’re seeing that play out across like technology right now. Where you’ve got folks who feel like maybe you’re being incredibly efficient, and you’ve got like 12 agents working for you, and you’re getting a ton of stuff done. And I think, Wow, what a go-getter. Or I think, You’re really fucking rude, and you don’t give a shit about your work or the impact to my organization on you sending garbage across as a transmission.

Johnathan Nightingale: Isn’t that interesting? Like, not from a culture war, “red team versus blue team” shit. But like: why? Like, why can so many people nod along to this idea of like, Oh yeah, when you get a GPT email, that feels rude. Like, That feels like the person didn’t care. Right. I thought these agents were supposed to be solving all kinds of problems. I thought they were more talented. They’re passing the LSATs. They’re like, you know—they’re doctors, they’re therapists, they’re whatever. Like, why would we receive it as rude?

It turns out that humans really care about doing work they believe in, with people they care about. And when you hollow those things out, people have these emotional responses to it that I don’t see predicted by the marketing materials from the AI companies.

Melissa Nightingale: And the hyper-rationalists will fall short on this one every time. Because, fundamentally, being more efficient should, like, it goes—

Johnathan Nightingale: You ought.

Melissa Nightingale: You ought to be excited about being 10 times more productive than you were yesterday. You ought to be excited that your colleagues sent you an email that they didn’t spend any time on, because you also don’t have to spend any time on reading it or consuming it. Like, that should be exciting.

Warzel: You’re both management and leadership trainers. Which means your job is ostensibly to try to make people better bosses, right? And I wanna ground some of this in asking: What makes a good manager? Or what makes a good middle manager? What are those qualities there?

Melissa Nightingale: We have bosses who show up in programs. And they’re like, “I am a good manager because my team likes me.” Wrong. “I am a good manager because, like …

Johnathan and Melissa Nightingale: “My team is happy.”

Melissa Nightingale: We’re like, “Wrong.” Happy is an impermanent state, right?

Johnathan Nightingale: And you can’t take custody for people’s emotions.

Melissa Nightingale: No. Fundamentally, you are a good manager if you are making your team more effective.

Johnathan Nightingale: And effective feels really mercenary, but it isn’t. Because it turns out as you get deeper into this, you learn that the best way to build an effective team is to see them as individuals: to align their personal motivations and aspirations and sense of mastery, the things they want to learn, their curiosity with the things your organization is trying to get done. It turns out that, like, that only happens if there’s a high level of psychological safety. If they’re able to take risks; if they’re able to talk to you about their struggles.

Melissa Nightingale: If you’re able to give critical feedback on the work, where it is showing up exactly as it should and where it isn’t showing up exactly as it should.

Johnathan Nightingale: And if they see you engaging as an authentic leader. They don’t need you to be perfect, but they need you to not be bullshit, right? It’s an important part of how they cohere as a team, and how they find anything that you have to say remotely credible. But many people in management roles lack those skills. And if you’re like, “Wouldn’t that make work terrible for a lot of people?” Yes.

Warzel: There we go. Well, part of the reason I ask is because it seems in this AI conversation, the term management is a skill set that AI companies seem to want to impose on all of us, right? Recently the co-founder of Anthropic, Jack Clark, went on a podcast, he’s talking about the way that chatbots and increasingly these coding agents are, you know, going to be sent off to accomplish these tasks. And there’s going to be all of what we’re talking about, right? These things happening on behalf of us: goose chases, all kinds of stuff. And he had this quote that I thought was striking. It’s one of the reasons I wanted to have this conversation with you all. Which is, he says, quote, “Everyone becomes a manager, and the thing that is increasingly limited—or the thing that’s going to be the slowest part—is having good taste and intuitions about what to do next.” What do you make of that line? “Everyone becomes a manager.”

Johnathan Nightingale: It’s such a shallow read on management, isn’t it? Like, if you think about it—let’s say he’s right. Let’s say he’s right that when I fire up my Claude Code instance and I say, “Claude, create a marketing team for me. I want a content marketer. Want somebody on social media.” Right. Have I done it now? Like, can I transfer those skills over to the humans that are still on my team? Is it the same thing? Can I just go to Tony and be, like, “Tony, get Alex and Sam in a room? You got new jobs. Now. Here’s what you’re doing.”

Is that going to work? Nobody thinks that’s going to work.

Melissa Nightingale: I also think any model for management that doesn’t come with employees who have needs and, like, labor and rights—there’s a bunch of pieces that are missing from that mental model. And either that’s accidental, or that’s on purpose. But we should all be really concerned about a model of labor and a model of management that includes work happening without any capacity for what the people doing that work—or what the folks who are supposed to be responsible for that output—need.

Johnathan Nightingale: Buddy seems to know a lot about AI. I know the podcast you’re talking about. It’s cool. He’s built something that’s very big and seems to be changing a lot of people’s lives. And, I hope, some of them for the better. Like, that’s super neat. But on management, I’m not convinced he has the range to give anybody advice on what constitutes good management. You can build a very wealthy company and still be cooking a bunch of people inside it. And saying something like that—I don’t know, you can call that an insult, you can call that a threat, but that’s not what management is.

Warzel: Well, what’s interesting is, you know: As you’re describing what makes a good manager, and you pause and say, “This could sound mercenary.” Right? But what’s actually involved in all of this is the very human work of recognition. Of getting to know people. Of caring. Of giving a shit, right? It seems like that idea of “everyone becomes a manager”—that definition from an AI executive—it pauses at the mercenary point. It says, “He’s with you until that moment where you say, But then it requires all this.”

And part of the reason why I want to have this part of the conversation is also because my partner, Anne Helen Petersen, and I wrote this book about the rise of remote work in 2020. We spoke to you guys a lot about that book. And one of my broader takeaways from all the reporting is that—despite being in the boss layer, right?—the managers and especially middle managers were pretty miserable. Just in general. Just, like, a pretty miserable, core of that thing. Like, maybe miserable in different and unique ways than, you like oppressed rank-and-file workers. But pretty miserable. S

So when I hear that we’re all gonna become managers? From that, I hear: Man, that’s a lot of task switching and a lot of, “I’m getting incoming from two sides of this thing.” Like, two groups of people are kind of converging on me. I’ve got these unhappy people on one side; this unhappy thing on the other side. I kind of have to figure out how to exist in this world. I’m being pulled in a hundred directions.

Melissa Nightingale: Charlie, you’re selling it. You’re making it sound so compelling.

Johnathan Nightingale: Strong pitch, strong pitch.

Warzel: But that, to me, is like: I don’t know. I mean, does it seem as dystopian to you? Or do you just recognize this as, I don’t know, a guy pontificating? Without, as you said, the understanding?

Melissa Nightingale: We have a working mental model; like, we have a real-world model for where automation takes more of the front seat on management. Amazon warehouses are a good example. Uber drivers are a good example.

Johnathan Nightingale: Already being managed by algorithms. The common thread there is this idea that where people are working in Amazon warehouses because they can’t automate that piece yet. Right. And so they build all the automation around these little stations where the human stands, and the humans are reaching up and reaching down. That shouldn’t be our vision for the future of work. And when you listen to a lot of the people who are like, “Oh, everyone’s going to be a manager.” You’re to have this swarm of agents. Who’s doing stuff? Like, what’s the end state there? That you’re a team of one? That you’re a company of one? And so, when you try and sell me this story about a billion-dollar company with one person, I’m like: Think about the best times you’ve had at work. Best times. You might have had a shit boss. I get it. There’s a lot of them. We’re working as hard as we can. But, like, the best times you’ve had at work—and I guarantee that story involves colleagues. Right? And so when somebody tries to sell you on, “Don’t worry; you don’t need colleagues anymore,” I’m like: What are you doing? Like, that’s an anti-signal. I understand your technology is very impressive, but, like, that’s a weird thing to sell.

Melissa Nightingale: Unless you’re annoyed at paying the junior engineers $300,000 a year straight out of school. And then it’s a very compelling sell.

Warzel: There’s a lot here, right? Some of these people who are talking this … some of them, yes, are people who are inside large companies right now that are building all this. That have this workforce. So I think that argument makes a lot of sense. There’s another group, though, of, let’s just say “venture capitalists” who are actually on that island, right? A little bit. I mean, yes; there are plenty of people who work in some of these venture firms, no doubt. But the idea is that sort of like, life of the mind. Like “I’m this tech soothsayer.” And I think in some sense there is this, “How can I push this to the furthest possible extent?” Right? And there’s this idea, always, with the efficiency, right? The reason why the AI bro–type person who’s saying this thing about the excitement of the first one-person, you know, unicorn company, I think, speaks to the idea of … like, this is “efficiency” pushed to its broadest level, right? This is like the cheat code for late-stage capitalism.

And I think it ties though to this broader premise of how productive this stuff actually is, right? So there’s this recent survey from this company called ActiveTrack. And they analyzed over 10,000 workers across 376 companies. And they did it 180 days before and after AI adoption. And the thing that I think won’t be surprising to a lot of people who follow this is: email, up 104 percent. Chat and messaging, up 145 percent. Collaboration time surged 34 percent to an hour a day. Multitasking rose 12 percent. It’s that classic, you know, Parkinson’s-law, “work expands to fill the time available for its completion”–type thing. What do you make of those types of numbers and the idea of productivity?

Melissa Nightingale: We tell bosses all the time: Busy is not the same as effective. Like, you can run your team totally ragged in terms of having them chase every idea that seems like a good idea. But if that’s not what we’re here to do, then you’re wasting their time and your own.

Johnathan Nightingale: Yeah, the maximalist arguments are always so weird, right? Like, the thing you could do is say to your team: “This is a cool tool; we should figure out where we can apply it.”

Melissa Nightingale: Where is there an annoying problem within the organization that you wish someone would fix for you? Where is there an internal tooling thing that would be so cool to have and get a thing out of your way in your workflow? Like, great—let’s go build that.

Warzel: Right. Software-size problems.

Johnathan Nightingale: That could be the end of a sentence. It doesn’t have to be. And then we fire everyone. Like, it doesn’t. You can just end. They’re like, “Well, but if all your competitors are cutting to the bone and outsourcing all their sort of, you know, friendships to ChatGPT or whatever, then you’re going to have margin pressure. And you’re going to have to do the same thing.” And I’m like, man, “Maybe.” But it turns out that creative, resourceful, adaptable humans are good at some shit. And that an LLM—which however amazing you might find it to be—is trained on yesterday. It’s at some point going to run into problems inventing tomorrow, right? And like, that’s a thing people can do. And then tomorrow it’ll train on it. But I will bet on people. Again, not like a team thing. It’s cool for the people to have tools. “We’ve got lots of tools.” That’s great.

But it’s so weird to bet your business on entirely outsourcing critical thought, creativity, collaboration, partnership to this thing that can generate grammatically correct paragraphs. Like, it just feels like such a weak-sauce version of leadership.

Warzel: How hard has it been to give that message to this group of people? Have you been effective in conveying that? Is the siren song of all of this, you know, too difficult to resist? Like, what are you butting up against with this?

Melissa Nightingale: Two things. Okay, so it’s a great question. Like, on the one hand, you spend a third of your waking hours at work. If you’re lucky and have like a normal work schedule, you spend a third of your waking hours at work. So I think for a large number of people, the idea that like one—we just fully and outright reject the idea that that’s how we’re going to spend a third of our waking hours, as a collective. Like, absolutely not.

Two, we’ve seen it, and that lends some credibility. In that we’ve seen inside a lot of organizations, and we talk to a lot of leaders about moments at work that really mattered to them. And it’s like: I think the conventional wisdom is nobody would have any moments at work that mattered to them. Nobody would have any moments where a boss saw them, connected with them, brought them up, helped skill them up. Helped unlock the next stage of their career, because work is crappy. We have to spend a third of our life there, and it’s always going to be crappy. But the fact of the matter is, you ask people: Do you have one of these moments? Do you have one of these things that happened where work really mattered to you, or was a support or a stability for you at a time where the rest of your life was, like, really rocky? People, by and large, do. And so our starting point, I think, for a lot of folks is that the idea that it could be good for a lot of folks is one, a radical concept, and two, a very welcome idea.

Johnathan Nightingale: But when you ask about receptiveness, it’s funny. One of the first companies we ever worked with was an AI company. And I remember meeting with the leaders that were going to be coming through a program with us. And this one guy, very sort of eccentric-professor vibes when he came in. Sort of scattered, came in a couple of minutes late. And he said, you know, “I’m coming to this management program. They’re sending everybody to this management program. But I need you to know something right up front. I don’t believe any human should manage any other human.”

Warzel: Yeah.

Johnathan Nightingale: Cool, fair, yeah, great. He’s a bit, “I’ve never done a program like this before; so you know, I’m open to it. I just want you to know that upfront.” By like the third week of the program, he’s sitting there reading High Output Management by Andy Grove. Which is sort of, former CEO of Intel; like a standard management text, particularly in tech circles. We’re talking about hiring, and he’s looking at a job description. And he’s like, there’s a bunch of gendered stuff in that job description. You’re going to end up with a really tilted candidate pool if you keep doing it. Like, he’s fully engaged with it, and is really thoughtful and conscientious about how to engage with it. He just didn’t know the receptiveness is a really easy sell. It’s a surprisingly easy sell. Nobody likes to be in a job that they don’t know how to do and feel like they’re failing all the time. And if you can give them some stuff, you know, there’s this moment where you give them some tools. And they’re like, “I don’t know if that’s going to work.” And then you get them back next week, and they’re like, “That did work. What else do you have?” Right. And like, it’s actually really easy to convince.

Warzel: How worried, just hearing you say this, how worried are you guys that these tools, these AI tools, will effectively just act as a Band-Aid for any of these moments? Of “Instead of having to think about it hard, and have that conversation that’s ultimately really fruitful and ultimately helps me and everyone else around, I’ll press this button instead”?

Melissa Nightingale: We come back around again, right? It’s like, if I am your direct report and I fucked up in a meeting, like: I’m sorry, I just didn’t know that thing, and I said that thing, and I thought it was a good idea at the time. But like, whatever, I screw up in a meeting. And what happens after that meeting is you send me a thing to tell me I screwed up in that meeting, and it is perfectly outlined.

Johnathan Nightingale: Lots of em dashes.

Melissa Nightingale: It is perfectly structured. And, you know, you’ve given the feedback to an LLM, but it spit out a thing. And then I get the thing; we’re back to the part where I’m like, That’s rude as shit. Like, if I screw up, tell me. I am a grown-up; I can absolutely handle it.

But you’re back to this weird moment in work culture right now. Well, either that’s a well-intentioned manager trying to format a thing so that it lands correctly without having to, like, have the like social risk in that moment. Of, like, “If I send it to Melissa and she’s upset about it … well, if GPT wrote it, she’s mad at GPT. She’s not mad at me. But if I actually put time and effort and energy into it, I might get it wrong. It might not land well. And I might have to spend some time reflecting on, like, That isn’t the way I wanted that to go. I want it to go differently next time.”

Johnathan Nightingale: There’s this study. Even if it never touches the employee, even if it’s just something that the manager does, you know, they go into their own chat window and say, “Here’s what happened. What am I supposed to think about it?” Study came out a little while ago, talking about sycophancy in LLM chats and its effect on sort of attribution of fault during conflict. Right?

So I get into a fight with someone, or my direct report is pissed off because they didn’t get a promotion. Or I’ve got hard feedback to give to them, and I gave them the feedback, but it didn’t go the way I wanted it to. And so I’m using Chat to help me debug it. And what the study found is that the more sycophantic the LLM is, the more likely I am to feel like I did nothing wrong. The more likely I am to bring that sense that I did nothing wrong into my future interactions with that person. And then you cross-multiply with the studies that are well established now, that LLM use suppresses critical thought and critical reflection. And that a major component for leadership development is critical thought and critical reflection. And you’re in a bad spot. Even if the employee never receives that GPT message, just me using GPT as my leadership coach is likely to really impair my sense of my relationship with my people, and also my own reflection.

Melissa Nightingale: Outside of management and leadership circles, it may not be obvious why that’s such a core component. But basically: If you are in a modern organization today, one of the biggest problems that we have of getting bosses to show up differently in the role is that they are often running from meeting to meeting to meeting to meeting to meeting. So if something goes wrong in my first meeting of the day, I have no opportunity—other than 2 a.m. when I’m staring at the ceiling—to think about, like, How did that go, and what do I want to have happen next time? Learning like humans are really freaking good at like: “This went this way; like I touched the hot stove. I don’t want to touch the hot stove again. And here’s what I’m going to do differently.”

If they’ve got time to think about it. The hard part that we have, in our industry and in our sort of line of work, is that for many leaders there’s not any of that baked in anymore.

Warzel: I want to get here, near the end, of something bigger, though. That we’re kind of circling around all this. Which is: this idea of a constant replacement in work, right? Replacing the expectations of how much work should take up someone’s life. You know, the expectations of how much dignity someone should be able to derive from it; the expectations of the path of predictable progress in a given career. The technology is often that we put into these spaces, you know, as we said. They free up space that is then used to, you know, fill more in. You keep piling stuff on here, without the attention and as much of the focus on the nourishing qualities that we’re talking about here. And the things that might give people some purchase and some connection. And you’ve all been writing a little bit around this idea lately of social atrophy, and the role that work plays. What is work’s role right now in this broader loneliness epidemic? Third-space dwindling, broader-disconnection feeling that a lot of people are experiencing?

Melissa Nightingale: We started to see weird glimmers about two years ago. Where a lot of organizations were saying, like: “I’m managing a team, but my team is geo-distributed, right. And so, I’m managing people all over the world. And sometimes I’m managing them, occasionally in office, but sometimes I’m managing them [remotely] … and we just don’t share a lot of overlapping daylight hours. And we work in sort of our own Zoom windows. And for my folks, where I’m managing them, and they’re not interacting with a lot of people, things have gone a little bit weird. And what do I do about that?”

Like as a management question, right? Would come into our programs and say, like, “It’s not a performance problem, per se. They’re showing up for meetings. Like, the camera’s off, but they’re showing up. Things have just gotten wobbly enough that I have an overarching wellness concern. What do I do with that?”

[Content truncated due to length...]


From The Atlantic via this RSS feed

view more: next ›