[–] [S] 3 points 2 months ago* (2 children)

The hypervisor is just nixos running kvm and incus - it doesn't have any opinion about pxe booting; So pxe gets dhcp from the san, which supplies the bootstrap, which is a tpm wrapped luks volume, which supplies the iscsi target, which bootstraps nixos over iscsi.... Once the nixos kernel loads anything goes, so KVM isn't aware of the iscsi nature of the diskless system at all.

I did play with nixos -> xen, but nested virtualization wasn't a thing with xen yet, so i went back to KVM. incus over libvirt so i can have a proper hypervisor API, so i can have projects with different credentials and scopes creating and destroying VMs willy nilly.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] [S] 8 points 2 months ago* (4 children)

    i'm on my third refund request! so far they have been quite negative, they are quite polarized on this current topic... but no point in being overly charged, I see the potential benefits here!

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] [S] 7 points 2 months ago (6 children)

    Cut the plug of and rewire it?

    Yeah, I can do that, but then what am I giving them any money for in the first place?

    The live and neutral are both safely terminated inside the PSU’s, so you can’t accidentally touch live.

    Depends also on how surge / overvoltage protections operate, they might throw open the neutral line and leave live connected to the device... so yes it would break a circuit, but it would leave the device hot.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] [S] 4 points 2 months ago (10 children)

    To have a fair comparison, you should pit an average plant meal vs an average meat meal in the world today. Then the plant meal wins because the animal eats a lot of crops during its lifetime and gets slaughtered too in the end.

    Zero carb people are not average, they only need a single cow for a family for a year. That is one life. Animals should not be eating human raised crops, that is not optimal and zero carb people try to avoid it if they can afford it.

    Or you should compare the ideal case scenarios for both. The vegan version will be growing plants in sterile, isolated environments without animal deaths. And the best case for carnivores is to kill a large wild animal once a year. Plants still win.

    Where do the inputs of your sterile, isolated environments come from? You can't claim sustainable solutions unless you look at the cost of the entire cycle, not one element in isolation. Those inputs are not free from death. One intentional death a year still wins.

    But you have compared plant agriculture as it is today to an ideal case carnivore diet to make it look good.

    You can buy whole grass fed, grass finished cows today - you can get to know your local rancher, its doable, and practical.

    this argument fallacious. (imo)

    Right back at you buddy.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] -1 points 2 months ago

    A central proxy adds a central point of failure.

    However, if you give each service its own DNS entry, your proxy can look at the incoming DNS of the request, and use that to proxy to the service. At least for http services

    I think it'd be much cleaner, to give each VM its own DNS entry, run the service on Port 80, or 443 so you don't have to remember port numbers.

    I'm not sure the reverse proxy is buying you much ease of use for a totally internal system. If you like, you can have a central web page, that links to all your different services from one location.

  • source
  •  

    How Carl got his groove back

    summerizerChildhood obesity, vegetarian years, and the first low-carb turn

    • I grew up in the 1970s as one of the few overweight children at school, while eating the same food as parents who were not overweight.
    • My mother followed the conventional low-fat healthy-diet pattern, and the nurse still accused her of feeding me too much.
    • By age 50, I was 160 kg, had type 2 diabetes, and had already been vegetarian for 35 years.
    • Vegetarianism came through early interest in yoga, Buddhism, Hinduism, and Ayurveda, and I believed the diet was good.
    • My vegetarian meals included homemade ghee from cultured butter, spinach curries, paneer, and other foods I thought were healthy.
    • Every year I became stiffer, until I could not wipe myself properly or bend down to tie my shoelaces.
    • A Radio New Zealand headline led me to Dr. Andrew Jenkinson's Why We Eat (Too Much), my first real exposure to low-carb high-fat eating.
    • The next day I removed vegetable oil, sugar, grains, and processed food, and began a pescatarian low-carb high-fat diet at about 100 g of carbs per day.
    • Those carbs came from foods such as sweet potatoes, blackberries, and raw honey, while the rest of the diet became much lower in processed food.
    • Weight loss started quickly, stiffness disappeared within weeks, and I felt decades younger.

    Skin flares, histamine, carnivore, and ferments

    • Lifelong doctor-diagnosed psoriasis worsened during the early low-carb period, and food tracking connected flares to spinach, celery, aged cheese, and other foods.
    • Most triggers were plants, and removing them cleared most of the condition that had been called psoriasis.
    • Smoked wild sockeye salmon produced a major flare, which pointed the problem toward histamine, not ordinary psoriasis.
    • Beef, bacon, butter, and eggs on a strict carnivore pattern cleared the skin almost completely, but high-histamine foods still required caution.
    • Dr. Sean O'Mara's living diet added ferments to carnivore, including sauerkraut juice in drinking water.
    • After three weeks of sauerkraut juice, I could eat anything without flares, my skin was fully clear, and the flares have not returned for over a year.
    • Carnivore solved the main problems, and the living diet removed the remaining histamine limit.

    Training, weight loss, fasting, and body changes

    • I started the journey on February 1, 2024.
    • I lost 70 kg in 10 months, reached 90 kg by October 2024, and kept the weight off.
    • I later gained about 5 kg of muscle while my waist continued to shrink.
    • Weekly 48-hour fasting, hill sprints, and sprint interval work restarted fat loss after a long plateau.
    • Sprint training now includes work every second day, six to ten hill repetitions, plus one 10-second maximum-effort sprint even on rest days.
    • Hill sprints reduced speed enough to avoid injury after a hamstring issue.
    • At age 53 and 174 cm tall, I measured 2 cm taller than before the diet.
    • Food cravings, hunger, and even ordinary like-dislike pressure around food disappeared.
    • The freedom I had searched for through spiritual systems came through fixing food and health.

    Current food routine

    • I eat two meals per day.
    • Breakfast at 9:00 usually contains six pasture-raised eggs, a can of sardines in spring water, sauerkraut, and raw A2 kefir.
    • The second meal between 4:00 and 5:00 p.m. usually contains 250 g of grass-fed red meat, especially lamb or beef.
    • Lamb is cheap in New Zealand and tastes best to me, so lamb shoulder chops and slow-cooked lamb with bones are staples.
    • I drink grass-fed beef bone broth daily.
    • I also eat raw cheeses, including French Comté.
    • Sardine quality matters because some brands pack fish in spring water or olive oil after frying them in sunflower oil first.

    Family changes and medical markers

    • My parents are in their 90s and are thrilled after watching me carry excess weight for my whole life.
    • After vascular events in both parents, dietary changes improved their health, weight, and energy.
    • My father lost weight and felt decades younger.
    • My 92-year-old mother added lamb's fry and pasture-raised eggs for breakfast, and her iron deficiency resolved after low ferritin had been missed.
    • My parents are not carnivore, but they now avoid processed food and vegetable oil, use allulose, and eat more saturated fat.
    • My own triglycerides fell to 1.1, HDL rose to 1.54, and LDL rose from about 2.9 to 6.6.
    • My LDL rose while I felt better.
    • My HbA1c was 52 after three months of low-carb high-fat eating and later reached 31.
    • Type 2 diabetes medication is no longer part of my life.

    Adherence, work, and outlook

    • Since February 1, 2024, I have not eaten sugar, processed food, or vegetable oil.
    • I have not eaten restaurant meals and have cooked everything myself.
    • Food noise is gone, eating is functional, and life is available again.
    • An old boss gave up sugar after seeing my changes and could bend down without pain, but alcohol kept him from continuing.
    • Before the health change, I worked mainly in call centers, Inland Revenue, and telecommunications.
    • Occupational overuse, finger pain, frozen shoulder, sore shoulders, extreme weight, and sickness made work harder.
    • When Spark New Zealand closed and outsourced the collections department, I took redundancy and did not apply for another role.
    • At 53, I am not winding down; I am ready for something new.
    • Growing older now feels like a challenge worth taking, not another decline to dread.

    Advice for trying carnivore

    • Cut ultra-processed food, sugar, flour, and seed oils from day one.
    • Move toward carnivore gradually over a few weeks.
    • A sudden dietary change is not ideal for the microbiome.
    • The practical path is immediate removal of the worst foods, then a slower transition into full carnivore.

    References

     

    Dr. David Klurfeld—longtime USDA scientist and one of the few insiders to publicly challenge the WHO's classification of red meat as a carcinogen. We go deep into the flawed evidence behind the infamous 2015 IARC report, why nutritional epidemiology often fails to prove causality, and how a small group of researchers helped shape global policy with low-quality science. If you've ever felt confused about meat, saturated fat, or dietary guidelines, this conversation will help you think critically about what “counts” as evidence—and who gets to decide.

    We cover:

    • Dr. Klurfeld’s personal journey and lessons from a career in public health
    • Why the 2015 IARC red meat classification was based on weak and inconsistent evidence
    • How observational studies and “allegiance bias” mislead nutrition science
    • The politics of dietary guidelines and the role of the USDA and WHO
    • What the media got wrong—and why red meat remains a nutrient-dense food

    Whether you're a clinician, dietitian, or simply trying to make better nutrition decisions, this episode is a powerful reminder that bias, groupthink and weak data can distort science and mislead the public. We need to be discerning about the nutrition and health advice we follow.

    Who is Dr. David Klurfeld?

    Dr. David Klurfeld is a nutritional scientist and former National Program Leader for Human Nutrition at the USDA’s Agricultural Research Service. He also served as Professor and Chair of Nutrition and Food Science at Wayne State University and Associate Editor of The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition. He has authored more than 200 scientific publications and was one of 22 experts invited to the 2015 IARC working group on red meat and cancer. He is a longtime advocate for scientific integrity in public health policy.

    Timestamps

    • 00:00 – Dr. Gabrielle Lyon introduces Dr. David Klurfeld and the controversy around red meat and cancer.
    • 03:18 – Dr. Klurfeld explains his unconventional path into nutrition science and his early influences.
    • 06:07 – He describes how "allegiance bias" distorts nutrition research outcomes.
    • 09:08 – Klurfeld calls the IARC red meat classification “the most frustrating professional experience of my life.”
    • 12:15 – He explains why epidemiology and food questionnaires are unreliable for determining dietary risk.
    • 15:30 – Red meat is misleadingly grouped with engine exhaust and radiation in cancer risk categories.
    • 22:15 – Many IARC scientists had pre-existing biases and used the panel to reinforce prior publications.
    • 26:08 – Klurfeld critiques the misuse of correlation in nutrition
    • 32:06 – He debunks the commonly cited 17% increase in colorectal cancer risk from red meat.
    • 48:44 – Activist groups filed FOIA requests to access years of Klurfeld’s emails during public-private research.
    • 1:09:21 – He explains why nitrogen content alone is an inadequate way to assess protein quality.

    summerizerOpening thesis

    • The red-meat cancer story needs separation from headlines, ideology, and weak causal thinking.
    • Klurfeld’s view is that unprocessed red meat has not been shown to be an identifiable cancer risk.
    • Processed meat and unprocessed red meat received handling that created public fear without enough attention to magnitude, mechanism, or uncertainty.
    • The most durable nutrition advice in the talk is moderation, variety, and reluctance to change behavior from a single study.

    Scientific background and habits of mind

    • Klurfeld came from agriculture, pathology, and decades of animal and human nutrition research.
    • Early alarmist food books influenced him when young, but later he judged much of that material as fear-driven.
    • Work with David Kritchevsky taught him to respect careful experimentation, humility, and people outside elite institutions.
    • In nutrition, one study should almost never change behavior, because isolated findings are too easy to overread.
    • Allegiance bias is common; once the investigator is known, the conclusion is often predictable.
    • Human nutrition papers sometimes look too clean compared with animal experiments, which makes Klurfeld wary of their precision.
    • Nutrition fights are not new; they are simply more visible now.

    IARC red-meat and processed-meat review

    • The IARC red-meat working group was one of the most frustrating professional experiences of Klurfeld’s career.
    • IARC is a WHO cancer agency that evaluates hazards, not ordinary-life absolute risk.
    • The working group had twenty-two scientists, with epidemiologists exerting major influence.
    • The IARC process was not a systematic review and did not run a formal meta-analysis inside the meeting.
    • Staff prepared large evidence documents, then the group voted on carcinogenic-hazard categories.
    • Risk assessors and risk managers are usually separated in government, but the IARC vote blurred that line.
    • Klurfeld could have accepted a cautious finding that more research was needed, but not a causal conclusion from that evidence base.
    • Nutritional epidemiology used for diet-cancer questions is weaker than the standards normally used for causal proof.

    Why the causal case against red meat looked weak

    • Most of the case rested on observational associations, not controlled experiments showing that red meat causes cancer.
    • Food-frequency data often measure diet once or a few times and then assume it represents decades of intake.
    • When many foods, nutrients, and disease endpoints are tested, chance findings become easy to generate.
    • A database with dozens of foods, dozens of nutrients, and many endpoints can produce thousands of nominally significant results by chance.
    • Spurious examples such as margarine or cheese correlations with divorce show why association is not causation.
    • Meat eaters and low-meat eaters differ in smoking, exercise, weight, education, health behavior, and other factors that models cannot fully fix.
    • Statistical swaps between meat and plant foods are not the same as real people changing food patterns under controlled conditions.

    Animal and mechanism evidence

    • Klurfeld’s rat studies did not show meat increasing colon-cancer risk.
    • Some mechanism work used calcium-deficient rat models and blood sausage, which do not resemble ordinary roast beef consumption.
    • Bacon in a chemically induced rat model reduced precancerous lesions in one study, which complicates a simple processed-meat story.
    • Calcium deficiency was a major issue in some rodent work, so the meat effect could not be cleanly separated from the mineral context.
    • Mechanistic work around heme iron and nitroso compounds did not become clear human proof.
    • The animal evidence did not give the strong biological proof needed to turn weak associations into causation.

    Human cohort findings and confounding

    • The 2012 Harvard cohort paper linked red meat with higher mortality and modeled lower mortality when other protein foods were swapped in.
    • Klurfeld sees those modeled swaps as statistical constructs, not proof that changing one food will create the predicted outcome.
    • The EPIC and meta-analysis estimates around colorectal cancer produced small relative risks, including the commonly cited 17% per 100 grams.
    • Small relative risks in nutritional epidemiology are especially vulnerable to residual confounding and measurement error.
    • A later dose-response pattern looked biologically weak when high-red-meat groups had similar risks despite very different intake levels.
    • The NIH-AARP study linked red meat with heart disease, cancer, total mortality, accidents, and other causes of death.
    • If roast beef seems linked with fatal accidents, that is a warning sign for uncontrolled lifestyle confounding.
    • White meat looking protective for almost everything in the same dataset strengthens the concern that broad behavior patterns are driving results.

    Conflicts, ideology, and committees

    • Financial conflicts matter, but intellectual and dietary commitments can matter too.
    • Vegetarians on a meat-cancer panel should disclose that commitment just as industry-linked scientists disclose funding.
    • Klurfeld did not see an explicit agenda, but he did see people who had built careers on meat-cancer associations evaluating their own area.
    • Nutrition committees can become echo chambers when the same people, assumptions, and methods recur across panels.
    • Public-health language often turns weak evidence into simple warnings that the public hears as certainty.

    IARC bias and process problems

    • The IARC red-meat panel was the most frustrating professional experience of my life.
    • IARC evaluates cancer hazards, not real-world absolute risk, so its categories can make weak food-risk evidence sound much stronger than it is.
    • The working group had 22 self-nominated scientists from 10 countries, but 11 were epidemiologists, so observational methods dominated the process.
    • The review was not a systematic review, and IARC staff did not run a formal meta-analysis during the meeting, even though epidemiology drove the final decision.
    • The animal evidence was mixed, with some studies showing increase, no change, or decrease, so it contributed almost nothing to the decision.
    • The mechanistic evidence showed possible pathways, not mechanisms clearly demonstrated in people eating meat.
    • A “possible risk” conclusion for processed meat would have been acceptable, but the conclusion that unprocessed red meat had an identifiable cancer risk was not supported.
    • The red-meat conclusion was based exclusively on epidemiology, and nutritional epidemiology does not deserve that level of respect for causal conclusions.
    • The Lancet Oncology summary said 800 studies were examined, but only 18 were used; roughly 780 were discarded for not showing anything, not showing the desired result, or other reasons.
    • The final monograph was supposed to appear within six months, but took almost three years, and working-group members did not see it before publication.
    • The epidemiologists worked separately, reached their own conclusions, and the rest of the committee was effectively expected to accept them.
    • Many epidemiologists on the panel were friends, had served on previous IARC committees, and had already published work linking red or processed meat with colon-cancer risk.
    • The process gave them an opportunity to reinforce the importance of their own work, even though there was no explicit “we’re going to nail red meat” agenda.
    • I entered skeptical of the meat-cancer relationship, but the evidence looked even softer after review, and I could not conclude that either red meat or processed meat caused any examined disease endpoint.
    • The evidence has become weaker with time, not stronger.
    • A number of committee members were vegetarians, and vegetarianism on a meat-cancer panel is an intellectual conflict of interest that should be disclosed.
    • After the WHO head of nutrition told me she was vegetarian, I watched what members ate and estimated that at least half, probably two-thirds, were vegetarian.
    • IARC’s hazard categories also create public confusion because red meat ends up near examples such as smoking, radiation, alcohol, DDT, engine exhaust, and lead, without proper risk perspective.
    • IARC formerly had a category 4 for “not carcinogenic,” but after roughly a thousand reviews only one chemical received it, and the category was later eliminated.
    • That reflects the deeper problem: once IARC investigates something, it is effectively treated as guilty unless not proven.
    • Coffee shows the same pattern: it was treated as a probable carcinogen, then reassessed after years of criticism, while California Prop 65 warnings amplified public confusion.

    Dietary Guidelines and federal nutrition work

    • USDA and HHS dietary guidelines are written by small government offices and committees, not by the whole nutrition-research enterprise.
    • Klurfeld’s USDA role involved overseeing human nutrition research centers, not personally writing the Dietary Guidelines for Americans.
    • The USDA centers included inpatient facilities and long-term research planning across many scientists and topics.
    • The public follows dietary guidelines poorly, but the food industry follows them closely because products and school meals are built around them.
    • Low-fat guidance reshaped food products, but low-fat cookies and reformulated snacks were never automatically healthy foods.
    • The 10% saturated-fat target traces back to rough expert judgment, not a precise biological threshold.
    • The broad dietary-guideline message has changed less than the page count: reduce salt, sugar, fat, and saturated fat, and eat more fruits and vegetables.
    • Klurfeld would prefer guideline conclusions to carry explicit strength-of-evidence grades.

    Protein, meat, and nutrient density

    • The idea that everyone eats too much protein is too broad.
    • RDAs are minimum estimates from nitrogen balance, not optimal targets for aging, exercise, growth, or metabolic resilience.
    • Young men may exceed minimum protein needs, while older adults, active people, children, and some women may need more attention to protein quality.
    • Animal protein and plant protein are not nutritionally identical just because nitrogen content can be converted to ounce equivalents.
    • Meat supplies highly bioavailable iron, zinc, vitamin B12, selenium, and other nutrients that can be harder to obtain from plant-only patterns.
    • Young women are a key risk group for iron and calcium shortfalls, especially when red meat intake falls.
    • Vegetarian diets can be healthy when carefully planned by knowledgeable people.
    • Plant-based meat analogs may require larger portions or additional planning to match animal-source amino acids and micronutrients.

    NHANES and dietary measurement limits

    • NHANES is the best national dietary snapshot available, but it is still a snapshot.
    • It uses about five thousand people and two twenty-four-hour recalls, which is useful for population averages.
    • Two recalls are not enough to know an individual’s usual intake with high precision.
    • Older USDA work found that many repeated recalls may be needed for individual nutrient estimates.
    • NHANES is useful for estimating group distributions and identifying subgroups at nutrient risk.
    • NHANES is often overused when people try to make conclusions beyond what two recalls can support.

    Women’s Health Initiative and controlled trials

    • The Women’s Health Initiative low-fat trial was enormous and expensive, with roughly twenty thousand women in the intervention and thirty thousand controls.
    • After about nine years, the low-fat pattern did not reduce colon-cancer risk.
    • The intervention also cut meat intake substantially, which makes it relevant to the red-meat issue even if it was not designed as a red-meat trial.
    • Dismissing WHI because it was not designed specifically around red meat is inconsistent when many observational meat papers were also not designed around red meat.
    • Long-term randomized diet trials are rare because they are expensive, difficult, and slow.

    The beef matrix and whole-food context

    • Beef should be studied as a whole food, not as isolated saturated fat, heme iron, or single nutrients.
    • Beef tallow is not beef, just as butter is not the same as milk with its fat-globule membrane.
    • Muscle, connective tissue, fat, cell membranes, minerals, and bioactive compounds create a matrix that can alter biological effects.
    • Beef, pork, poultry, and plant foods differ in heme iron, amino acids, micronutrients, and bioactives.
    • Creatine, carnosine, anserine, and other compounds may matter even when they are not classed as essential nutrients.
    • Food categories that look interchangeable in guidelines may not be metabolically interchangeable.

    Microbiome, biomarkers, and future nutrition science

    • Nutrition needs better intermediate biomarkers, especially for cancer.
    • Serum cholesterol became a major endpoint partly because it was measurable, not because it captured every health outcome.
    • Cancer lacks many accepted intermediate markers; colon polyps are one of the few markers used clinically.
    • CRP is too nonspecific to answer many diet questions cleanly.
    • The microbiome adds another layer because intestinal bacteria produce compounds that enter human metabolism.
    • Stool tests mostly show which organisms are in stool, not what is happening across the small intestine, large intestine, and metabolic networks.
    • Future progress depends on better biomarkers, better causal methods, and more humility about what nutrition studies can prove.

    Career and public communication

    • Being a naysayer made Klurfeld less popular with some institutions, but skepticism is necessary in nutrition.
    • He was not invited back by some groups after saying the diet-heart story was more complicated than they wanted.
    • He is not active on social media and does not enjoy public fighting.
    • The central message is that red-meat fear has outrun the quality of the evidence, and nutrition advice should be proportional to what the evidence can actually show.

    References

    Updating the summarization with the new engine's better results.

     

    When everyone thinks you are crazy, but you know you are sane...

    Based on the ASIP skit: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GiJXALBX3KM

    Why Ellen G White - Her visions and religion fund educational and nutritional programs to promote the total avoidance of meat, they basically started every dietetics association in the world.

    Why Ancel Keys : Promoted the diet heart hypothesis that saturated fat drove CVD, doctored results and drop studies when they didn't lineup with his hypothesis.

    Why Walter Willett : Pumps out weak, poorly powered, and associatively only epidemiology headline grabbers every 2-3 months vilifying meat.

    Science is about reproducible results, asking for that shouldn't be crazy.

     

    Reviews focused on the ketogenic diet (KD) based on the increase in fat-free mass (FFM) have been carried out with pathological populations or, failing that, without population differentiation. The aim of this review and meta-analysis was to verify whether a ketogenic diet without programmed energy restriction generates increases in fat-free mass (FFM) in resistance-trained participants. We evaluated the effect of the ketogenic diet, in conjunction with resistance training, on fat-free mass in trained participants. Boolean algorithms from various databases (PubMed, Scopus. and Web of Science) were used, and a total of five studies were located that related to both ketogenic diets and resistance-trained participants. In all, 111 athletes or resistance-trained participants (87 male and 24 female) were evaluated in the studies analyzed. We found no significant differences between groups in the FFM variables, and more research is needed to perform studies with similar ketogenic diets and control diet interventions. Ketogenic diets, taking into account the possible side effects, can be an alternative for increasing muscle mass as long as energy surplus is generated; however, their application for eight weeks or more without interruption does not seem to be the best option due to the satiety and lack of adherence generated.

    Full Paper - https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph191912629

     

    Welcome back Dr. Nash Jocic: celebrated bodybuilder, cutting-edge scholar, and a sought-after coach whose expertise is revolutionizing how athletes achieve peak performance and longevity. Dr. Anthony Chaffee sits down with Dr. Jocic for an unfiltered conversation that promises to challenge everything you think you know about fueling workouts, muscle growth, and lasting strength. Dive in as Dr. Jocic reveals real-life transformations, scientific discoveries, and firsthand experiences. Curious about what can take elite athletes to the next level and how they can remain strong well into their later years? Tune in now to discover why Dr. Nash Jocic is changing the game—and see for yourself what makes his approach so compelling.

    summerizerCentral thesis

    • Dietary carbohydrates are not needed to keep training performance, muscle glycogen, or bodybuilding fullness.
    • The fitness world teaches that no carbs means empty glycogen, weak training, and poor athletic output.
    • Protein and fat can support high-volume lifting, contest preparation, and year-round condition.

    Glycogen without dietary carbohydrates

    • Glycogen does not come only from carbohydrates; gluconeogenesis can convert amino acids and glycerol into glucose and glycogen.
    • A hard workout may use roughly 100 grams of local muscle glycogen, and the body can restore that amount over 24 to 48 hours.
    • Glycogen restoration is local to the trained muscle; chest, back, legs, and shoulders refill what they used.
    • The FASTER trial shows keto-adapted runners had comparable muscle glycogen before, immediately after, and during recovery from a three-hour run.
    • Human evolution also connects meat-and-fat diets with fighting, running, hunting, escaping danger, and survival.

    Contest preparation and carb loading

    • Competitors usually stay on high-protein, medium-fat diets year-round and need only an 8-to-12-week precision phase before a show.
    • Protein and fat adjustments, not carbohydrates, make a bodybuilder harder, leaner, and drier.
    • Carb depletion and carb loading often disrupt an already lean look through water, bloating, insulin effects, and digestive unpredictability.
    • The peak-week method keeps the process that produced the best condition and avoids last-minute experiments.

    Fat oxidation, endurance, and energy supply

    • Keto-adapted athletes can shift much more exercise energy toward fat, even at high percentages of VO2 max.
    • Glycerol from triglycerides and lactate recycling provide glucose and glycogen while training demand rises.
    • High-carb endurance athletes often depend on gels because blood glucose rises and crashes; fat-adapted athletes can reduce that dependence.
    • A marathon client cut carbohydrates, ate fewer meals, lost weight, felt calmer around food, and improved his time by about 20%.

    Carbohydrates, cravings, and glycation

    • Carbohydrates are easy, tasty, addictive, and emotionally comforting because they drive reward chemistry.
    • Stress is a poor time to eat because sympathetic physiology conflicts with digestion.
    • Glucose and carbohydrate exposure create advanced glycation end products that damage arteries, kidneys, eyes, joints, cartilage, and spinal discs.
    • Avoiding glycation helps preserve the athletic tools of the body and can lengthen an athletic career.

    Building muscle without carbs

    • Carbohydrates are not structural building blocks; muscle growth needs essential amino acids, essential fatty acids, training, recovery, and enough energy.
    • Golden-era physiques relied more on training, high-volume work, protein, and fat than on modern drug-driven mass building.
    • High-carb professional bodybuilding is tied to exogenous insulin, growth hormone, and large drug stacks, not to ordinary natural physiology.
    • Nasser’s two-steak, no-potato meal is used as an example of protein being prioritized over carbohydrate for size.
    • Dorian-era mass bodybuilding changed the culture because insulin use required carbohydrate intake to prevent hypoglycemia.
    • Recent hypertrophy and keto-performance research is used to say matched protein matters more than carbohydrate intake.
    • AGE research is used to say excessive glycation may impair muscle protein synthesis, extracellular matrix quality, and hypertrophy.

    Training method and long-term physique

    • The training method is high volume, short rest, 30 to 40 sets per session, 45 to 50 minutes, and one or two reps short of failure.
    • Training five times per week at age 64, visible leanness, and injury-free longevity are linked to high-volume training and no-carb protein-fat eating.
    • The 90-day transformation challenge uses similar training and diet principles, adjusted by individual level, and early four-week changes are large.
    • The same pattern across thousands of clients is high protein, medium fat, low or zero carbs, and high-volume training.

    Protein absorption, meal timing, and fat

    • A person is not what they eat; a person is what they absorb.
    • Three larger protein-and-fat meals can be better absorbed than six smaller protein-and-carb meals because fat slows digestion.
    • Chicken and rice can spike glucose and amino acids, while fat-containing meals create slower amino-acid release and lower insulin exposure between meals.
    • Protein alone digests too fast; steak, eggs, fattier cuts, chicken legs with skin, or added cheese are better than dry chicken breast alone.
    • Whey protein can shoot amino acids into the blood too quickly, so much of it may be burned as energy and not used as building material.

    Plant foods, fiber, and protein quality

    • Plant-food protein counts on paper do not equal absorbed protein in the body.
    • Plant foods bring lower bioavailability, protease inhibitors, tannins, fiber, and other barriers to digestion.
    • Gluten is a wheat protein with no useful bioavailability and gut-damaging effects.
    • Humans cannot digest fiber like gorillas because humans lack the same active appendix-based fermentation system.
    • Vegetarian and vegan bodybuilding cases usually depend on powders, supplements, and sometimes steroids, so they do not prove whole-plant diets equal meat.

    Practical diet pattern

    • The target pattern is high protein with enough fat, usually three meals spaced five to six hours apart.
    • If carbs are cut but protein and fat are not increased, energy collapses and training performance drops.
    • The preferred foods are meat, eggs, steak, fatty cuts, fish, chicken legs, and small amounts of vegetables only if desired.
    • The overall goal is a strong, lean, healthy body year-round, not short-term contest tricks or offseason bulking fat.

    References

     

    A gene mutation that reduces ketone production in the fasted state is associated with sudden infant death in modern populations. But in the ancestral context where it evolved alongside an omega-3-rich diet, it may have been part of what kept infants alive.

    Dr. Gideon Mailer and Nicola Hale join The Metabolic Link to present their hypothesis that the CPT1A L479 Arctic variant is not anti-ketogenic but pro-metabolic flexibility, conserving glucose by upregulating ketosis at the fed-state threshold. Their work explains why SIDS rates are dramatically elevated in modern Inuit communities no longer eating the ancestral Inuit diet, and how omega-3 fatty acids counteract the downregulation the mutation produces.

    The clinical picture extends beyond infancy. Modern carriers of the variant show lower triglycerides, lower VLDL, slightly higher HDL, and a "healthy obesity" phenotype with favorable fat distribution. But the health advantages seen in traditional Inuit populations disappear with Western diet adoption, as cardiovascular disease and diabetes rates rise to match the general population.

    summerizer1. Setup and thesis

    • The old assumption is that Arctic populations were the cleanest human example of chronic ketosis.
    • The story moves toward metabolic flexibility: glucose and ketones both mattered, and the Arctic setting changed when each fuel was useful.
    • Nicola Hale enters through metabolic-health research, chronic-fatigue recovery, ancestral health, and the question of whether long-term ketosis is optimal.
    • Gideon Mailer enters through early American history, ancient North American populations, archives, and the metabolism of Arctic migration.
    • The collaboration joins biochemistry, evolutionary genetics, archaeology, and history across more than one discipline.
    • The 2020 Hale paper becomes the center of the conversation because it reinterprets CPT1A L479 as glucose conservation and preserved fuel switching.

    2. CPT1A L479 and the Arctic variant

    • CPT1A encodes carnitine palmitoyltransferase 1A, the liver gatekeeper for long-chain fatty-acid entry into mitochondrial oxidation.
    • The Arctic L479 variant is counterintuitive because a low-carbohydrate, high-fat population carries a variant often called anti-ketogenic.
    • The sweep ranks as one of the fastest known human selective sweeps, faster than familiar diet and skin-pigmentation examples.
    • The key is timing: in fasted mode, the variant lowers ketone output; near the fed, high-protein threshold, it can raise ketone use.
    • That threshold behavior lets ketones spare glucose when protein and glucose have high strategic value.
    • The variant is therefore not a simple thrifty gene and not a simple anti-keto gene; it is a stress-resilience fuel-partitioning gene.

    3. Traditional Inuit diet and ketogenic ratio

    • The traditional food pattern is very low carbohydrate, high fat, and high protein, with small carbohydrate inputs from glycogen, seaweed, berries, and related foods.
    • Seasonal carbohydrate intake is near 25 to 30 grams, not a high-carbohydrate ancestral pattern.
    • Four 20th-century macronutrient estimates test whether the diet actually crosses a ketogenic threshold.
    • The Woodyatt ketogenic-ratio calculation puts the threshold around 1.5 to 2, depending on person, setting, and chosen cutoff.
    • Using a 2:1 standard, the estimates sit close to the threshold but usually do not cross into chronic ketosis.
    • The likely pattern is periodic ketosis: sleep, fasting, long hunts, scarcity, infection, and other stress windows.
    • High protein matters because it can move a very low-carbohydrate meal away from sustained ketosis.
    • The diet still creates glucose pressure because carbohydrate is scarce even when chronic ketosis is absent.

    4. Glucose conservation and the brain

    • The adult brain still needs a minimum amount of glucose even when ketones are available.
    • The glucose range is roughly 30 grams per day as an absolute minimum and about 110 grams per day under ordinary adult conditions.
    • Glucose also matters for immune function, especially when infection raises immune-cell demand and insulin resistance helps keep blood glucose available.
    • The infant brain intensifies the problem because it consumes a much larger share of body energy and glucose.
    • The selective pressure is therefore strongest where infant survival, fasting, infection, cold, and scarce protein overlap.
    • The fed-mode ketone rise makes sense as a way to save glucose for the next fasted or stressed interval.

    5. Infant risk and hypoketotic hypoglycemia

    • The dangerous side of the variant is low ketones plus low glucose during sleep, missed feeding, or infection.
    • Greenberg's work enters through family clusters, high allele frequency, and sudden-infant-death concern.
    • A Nunavut example has sudden-infant-death frequency moving from 5.4 per thousand to 32.7 per thousand in one community.
    • Mechanistically, lower hepatic CPT1A activity lowers ketone output when the liver should supply the brain.
    • The P479L enzyme activity figure is about 22 percent of wild-type activity in fibroblast work.
    • Pancreatic CPT1A may also lower glucagon support, so blood glucose can fall at the same time that ketones are low.
    • Infants are vulnerable because their brains can become energy deficient during sleep and illness.

    6. Omega-3 buffering

    • Omega-3 intake is the central ancestral buffer in this model.
    • Marine omega-3s increase CPT1A activity and concentration, offsetting the low basal activity of the variant.
    • Traditional marine foods therefore make the variant safer in fasted mode and useful near the fed-mode threshold.
    • A modern shift toward more glucose, less marine fat, and lower fatty-acid oxidation removes that buffer.
    • The Inuit and Yup'ik context is therefore diet-gene-environment interaction, not the isolated effect of a mutation.
    • High omega-3 intake helps explain how the mutation can be common without constant infant catastrophe.

    7. Food ecology and migration

    • The ancestral food system includes seals, fish, salmon, whale oil, whole dried marine foods, birds, caribou, deer, and other land mammals.
    • Leaner land protein remains important, so the food system is not just fat and fish oil.
    • The migration story moves away from a simple Bering Land Bridge remnant model.
    • Paleo-Inuit ancestry is placed in ancient Northeast Asia, with Neo-Siberian-related communities moving toward riverine and maritime niches.
    • Boat and coastal routes matter because the Bering Land Bridge had already sunk before the relevant Paleo-Inuit movement.
    • The marine-superhighway or kelp-superhighway model fits the route and food-system explanation.
    • Pottery and storage evidence supports dried omega-3-rich fish, stored marine foods, and oil extraction for eating.
    • Seal oils and whale oils matter, but whole-food marine storage matters too.

    8. Timing of selection

    • The selective sweep is placed mainly after the Ice Age and not simply inside the Younger Dryas story.
    • Ancient DNA from Northeast Asia before the key migration has not yet yielded the variant in this account.
    • The first ancient-DNA occurrence here is the roughly 4,000-year-old Saqqaq Paleo-Eskimo genome from Greenland.
    • Clemente's estimate leaves a broad window, but the working model narrows attention to about 6,000 to 4,000 years ago.
    • The pressure is a sudden combination of colder conditions, less reliable protein, new disease risk, isolation, and marine specialization.
    • The goal of selection is preserved metabolic flexibility under longer and harsher stress intervals.

    9. Cold, clothing, and energy demand

    • Cold does not need to mean a direct CPT1A cold-tolerance mechanism.
    • The separate stature and growth-signaling idea remains limited here.
    • Cold still raises glucose demand through inspired cold air, frozen food, higher metabolic rate, and heat production.
    • Efficient clothing reduces the need for core-temperature conservation adaptations, so metabolism and technology both belong in the story.
    • The cold-stress example uses minus-40 Fahrenheit and an extra-energy estimate near 1,000 calories per day.
    • The variant helps by protecting glucose supply when cold adds another drain on fuel availability.

    10. Current-day carriers and disease patterns

    • Lemas 2012 compares L479 homozygotes, heterozygotes, and P479 homozygotes in Yup'ik Eskimos.
    • The L479 pattern is linked to lower triglycerides, lower VLDL, slightly higher HDL, lower overall fat mass, and healthier fat distribution.
    • This is a healthy-obesity pattern because fat storage is less centered on high-risk abdominal distribution.
    • The mutation does not protect people against a Western diet.
    • As traditional foods recede, diabetes and cardiovascular disease can rise toward the broader population pattern.
    • Higher omega-3 intake remains linked to better health markers, but not as complete protection.

    11. Paleo-Eskimo and Neo-Eskimo contrast

    • The Paleo-Eskimo and Neo-Eskimo transition works as an ancient test case for the omega-3 buffer.
    • Paleo-Eskimo groups carry the variant but may have moved away from the marine omega-3 complex toward more land mammals.
    • Neo-Eskimo groups gained dog-sled coastal technology that improved access to marine mammals and omega-3-rich foods.
    • The proposed difference is not possession of the variant, but access to the food system that makes the variant work.
    • Loss of marine fat would expose the fasted-mode downside in infants and reduce the fed-mode advantage.
    • This metabolic story helps explain a major Arctic population transition.

    12. Wider human-brain evolution

    • Wang 2014 supplies the deeper evolutionary lens: ketogenesis and lipid energy metabolism conserve glucose for the brain.
    • This links to HMG synthase duplication, liver SCOT repression, and the old mammalian machinery of ketone production.
    • Crawford and Cunnane supply the infant-brain lens, where fat babies, ketones, glucose, DHA, and marine foods support brain expansion.
    • The African shore-based or Rift Valley food model becomes a far older parallel to the Arctic omega-3 story.
    • The Arctic case is therefore a late, local version of a broader fuel problem in human evolution.
    • The exogenous-ketone analogy works because the variant may keep ketones available during a fed-mode crossover period.

    13. Public meaning and diet takeaways

    • The Inuit should not be used as a weapon in diet wars about permanent ketosis versus anti-ketosis.
    • The core lesson is that ketosis is one tool inside a larger metabolic arsenal.
    • Chronic strict ketosis may be useful in some therapeutic contexts, but it should not become the universal ideal.
    • Metabolic flexibility means being able to use glucose and ketones at the right time, under the right stress, in the right environment.
    • Precision nutrition should study individual differences in switching between glucose and ketones.
    • The Arctic variant teaches that genes, diet, life stage, infection, cold, and technology all shape the same metabolic outcome.

    References

    References

    This is the paper they wrote (paywall) https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ymgme.2020.01.010

     

    Background Diabetes can be detected at the primary health-care level, and effective treatments lower the risk of complications. There are insufficient data on the coverage of treatment for diabetes and how it has changed. We estimated trends from 1990 to 2022 in diabetes prevalence and treatment for 200 countries and territories.

    Methods We used data from 1108 population-representative studies with 141 million participants aged 18 years and older with measurements of fasting glucose and glycated haemoglobin (HbA1c), and information on diabetes treatment. We defined diabetes as having a fasting plasma glucose (FPG) of 7·0 mmol/L or higher, having an HbA1c of 6·5% or higher, or taking medication for diabetes. We defined diabetes treatment as the proportion of people with diabetes who were taking medication for diabetes. We analysed the data in a Bayesian hierarchical meta-regression model to estimate diabetes prevalence and treatment.

    Findings In 2022, an estimated 828 million (95% credible interval [CrI] 757–908) adults (those aged 18 years and older) had diabetes, an increase of 630 million (554–713) from 1990. From 1990 to 2022, the age-standardised prevalence of diabetes increased in 131 countries for women and in 155 countries for men with a posterior probability of more than 0·80. The largest increases were in low-income and middle-income countries in southeast Asia (eg, Malaysia), south Asia (eg, Pakistan), the Middle East and north Africa (eg, Egypt), and Latin America and the Caribbean (eg, Jamaica, Trinidad and Tobago, and Costa Rica). Age-standardised prevalence neither increased nor decreased with a posterior probability of more than 0·80 in some countries in western and central Europe, sub-Saharan Africa, east Asia and the Pacific, Canada, and some Pacific island nations where prevalence was already high in 1990; it decreased with a posterior probability of more than 0·80 in women in Japan, Spain, and France, and in men in Nauru. The lowest prevalence in the world in 2022 was in western Europe and east Africa for both sexes, and in Japan and Canada for women, and the highest prevalence in the world in 2022 was in countries in Polynesia and Micronesia, some countries in the Caribbean and the Middle East and north Africa, as well as Pakistan and Malaysia. In 2022, 445 million (95% CrI 401–496) adults aged 30 years or older with diabetes did not receive treatment (59% of adults aged 30 years or older with diabetes), 3·5 times the number in 1990. From 1990 to 2022, diabetes treatment coverage increased in 118 countries for women and 98 countries for men with a posterior probability of more than 0·80. The largest improvement in treatment coverage was in some countries from central and western Europe and Latin America (Mexico, Colombia, Chile, and Costa Rica), Canada, South Korea, Russia, Seychelles, and Jordan. There was no increase in treatment coverage in most countries in sub-Saharan Africa; the Caribbean; Pacific island nations; and south, southeast, and central Asia. In 2022, age-standardised treatment coverage was lowest in countries in sub-Saharan Africa and south Asia, and treatment coverage was less than 10% in some African countries. Treatment coverage was 55% or higher in South Korea, many high-income western countries, and some countries in central and eastern Europe (eg, Poland, Czechia, and Russia), Latin America (eg, Costa Rica, Chile, and Mexico), and the Middle East and north Africa (eg, Jordan, Qatar, and Kuwait).

    Interpretation In most countries, especially in low-income and middle-income countries, diabetes treatment has not increased at all or has not increased sufficiently in comparison with the rise in prevalence. The burden of diabetes and untreated diabetes is increasingly borne by low-income and middle-income countries. The expansion of health insurance and primary health care should be accompanied with diabetes programmes that realign and resource health services to enhance the early detection and effective treatment of diabetes.

    Full paper: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(24)02317-1

    (Reposting since it was originally on lemm.ee which is gone now)

     

    We are sick. Around the world, we struggle with diseases that were once considered rare. Cancer, heart disease, Alzheimer's disease, and diabetes affect millions each year; many people are also struggling with hypertension, weight gain, fatty liver, dementia, low testosterone, menstrual irregularities and infertility, and more. We treat the symptoms, not realizing that all of these diseases and disorders have something in common. Each of them is caused or made worse by a condition known as insulin resistance. And you might have it. Odds are you do—over half of all adults in the United States are insulin resistant, with most other countries either worse or not far behind. In Why We Get Sick, internationally renowned scientist and pathophysiology professor Benjamin Bikman explores why insulin resistance has become so prevalent and why it matters. Unless we recognize it and take steps to reverse the trend, major chronic diseases will be even more widespread. But reversing insulin resistance is possible, and Bikman offers an evidence-based plan to stop and prevent it, with helpful food lists, meal suggestions, easy exercise principles, and more. Full of surprising research and practical advice, Why We Get Sick will help you to take control of your health.

    I've posted this book before, it's super impactful and makes a great demonstration of why hyperinsulinemia is so bad. It's written in a very easy to understand and compelling way. I can not recommend this book enough. I've given out nearly a dozen copies of it to friends suffering from metabolic problems.

    I just discovered, today, that a official chinese version is now available! If you have relatives, friends, who arn't so great at English (especially such they wont try to read a book).. this is a great gift. Especially the auntie who smiles kindly at you, but never stops chain smoking and pops metformin like candy.

     

    Stephen and Dr Shawn Baker discuss various aspects of health and nutrition, focusing on the carnivore diet, the influence of dietary guidelines, the role of testosterone, the importance of fibre, and the impact of the pharmaceutical industry on healthcare. They explore how dietary choices can affect autoimmune conditions and emphasise the importance of personal responsibility in health management. Chapters

    summerizerGuidelines and food policy

    • The new U.S. dietary guidance is a step in the right direction, with protein, red meat, eggs, full-fat dairy, whole foods, and lower added sugar pushed more openly.
    • The remaining 10% saturated-fat cap still makes carnivore and ketogenic diets difficult for many people, but the chronic-disease carveout for lower-carbohydrate diets matters.
    • The upside-down food image was intentional: protein, dairy, and healthy fats sit at the top, whole grains are deemphasized, and highly processed foods are targeted.
    • The guideline process moved because public pressure showed that many people eat red meat liberally and become healthier, even though policy still protects parts of the old order.
    • Policy will not save individuals by itself; the practical route is for people to change markets by buying real food and refusing products they view as poison.

    Red meat evidence

    • The WHO/IARC red-meat cancer line is rejected because later systematic reviews, including NutriRECS and a 2022 Washington University analysis, found the evidence extremely weak.
    • The red-meat case has relied heavily on epidemiology, and stronger data built around actual carnivore eaters is the goal.
    • The first randomized interventional trial on a carnivore-ish diet is underway in people with obesity and prediabetes, using about 70% beef, 20% other animal foods, and optional low-glycemic foods.
    • It is short, about five weeks and roughly sixty people, but it is a start that can lead to more work.
    • Better data is expected to support eating meat as liberally as a person wants.

    Testosterone, biomarkers, and performance

    • Testosterone numbers are like other biomarkers: useful only when tied to sensitivity, function, and outcomes.
    • Resistance training, infrequent meals, and carnitine from red meat can increase androgen sensitivity, and muscle androgen receptor density can matter more than blood testosterone.
    • Baker's own testosterone has ranged from low to normal, but his performance, muscle, work capacity, and long training history matter more than a single lab value.
    • The testosterone industry preys on male insecurity by turning ordinary numbers into a reason for testosterone drugs.
    • Health is not a magic set of biomarkers; it is the ability to function, stay free from disease, and perform well with age.

    Labs and practical health

    • Blood work is useful when someone is sick, but healthy people should not make lab values the center of health.
    • The better questions are how people feel, function, look, sleep, move, and carry energy through the day.
    • The first visible priority is removing the large belly, because a flat stomach would improve health for many men and women regardless of their labs.
    • Nutrition is the biggest lever for body composition and metabolic health, but it is not the only lever.
    • Six pillars matter together: nutrition, sleep, activity and exercise, stress, light, and purpose or community.

    Fiber and saturated fat

    • Fiber is not essential, but it can be conditionally helpful when the background diet is ultraprocessed and high glycemic.
    • Low-carbohydrate or zero-carbohydrate eating can limit glucose excursions without fiber, and ketosis, protein, butter, and butyrate can cover many cited fiber benefits.
    • Fiber associations are mixed with affluence, socioeconomic level, and overall diet quality, so wood pulp in the colon is not the causal magic.
    • Saturated fat should be judged by the food package: eggs, meat, and milk are different from pizza and prepared desserts.
    • Whole unprocessed animal foods contain saturated fats in a broader nutrient matrix, and convincing evidence has not shown that red meat in a high-quality diet increases heart disease.

    Autoimmunity and gut health

    • Carnivore is not dogma, but it is a powerful healthcare tool that should be used more freely.
    • Inflammatory bowel disease is the strongest indication in Baker's view, especially ulcerative colitis and Crohn's disease.
    • Many people improve enough to stop medications, avoid surgery, and move disease into remission.
    • The same pattern shows promise across psoriasis, rheumatoid arthritis, multiple sclerosis, Hashimoto thyroiditis, myasthenia gravis, and other autoimmune diseases.
    • A common mechanism may begin in gut pathology and impaired barrier function, in line with Alessio Fasano's gut-autoimmunity work.

    Medicine, markets, and drugs

    • Modern medicine too often becomes disease management: keep people perpetually medicated instead of fixing the root drivers.
    • Surgery has an important place, especially trauma, but the pill-for-every-ill model is too profitable and too dominant.
    • Weight-loss drugs show the same pattern when muscle-loss concerns create another drug to reduce the side effect of the first drug.
    • Physicians are trained around drugs, so prescriptions become the default tool even when nutrition and lifestyle would be better.
    • Utah's AI prescription-refill pilot shows a future where the consumer moves even closer to the drug channel.
    • Food dye and drug-advertising reforms will face lawsuits, delays, and industry pressure, so the market must change from the ground up.

    Studies and future generations

    • Critics say carnivore has no long-term studies, so carnivore eaters should be studied directly without extrapolating from red-meat epidemiology.
    • Existing carnivore evidence includes case series and observational data, but no true interventional trial had been done before this new trial.
    • The ongoing trial is carnivore-ish, funded partly by cattlemen's groups, and built as an opening move for better nutrition research.
    • A future IBD carnivore study would be valuable, but raising seven-figure nutrition-study money is hard.
    • Health is beyond carnivore: diet matters, but sleep, exercise, stress, light, and purpose also shape outcomes.
    • The larger job is to pass health down the family tree so children and grandchildren are stronger and healthier.

    References

  • [05:50] "We cannot depend upon the legislators and public policy to save us individually. We have to do it ourselves."

  • [06:47] "This data that would suggest that red meat is carcinogenic... is all based on extremely, extremely weak evidence."

  • [10:27] "We have this testosterone industry... where we prey upon men's insecurities."

  • [11:27] "Health is not like some magic collection of biomarkers. It's actually your capacity, your ability to do things."

  • [13:56] "Nutrition is clearly the biggest lever you can pull, but it's not the only lever you can pull."

  • [20:36] "I've not seen any convincing evidence... that eating red meat as part of an overall high-quality diet increases rates of heart disease or any other disease."

  • [21:15] "I am not a dogmatic zealot about carnivore. I think it is an incredibly important, impactful tool."

  • [23:08] "We've kind of changed healthcare into this disease-management system... to keep people perpetually medicated for the rest of their life."

  • [31:04] "We've got to keep the pressure on as individuals and we've got to change the markets ourselves... stop buying poison."

  •  

    The two go into exactly why they believe that what they promote makes the most sense (carnivore vs. vegan) and give us real data. Dr. Chaffee, a well known Doctor who promotes carnivore takes on Dr. Nagra, a Vegan Doctor.

    summerizerSetup and shared ground

    • Dr. Nagra enters as a vegan naturopathic doctor in Vancouver with microbiology training, nutrition writing, textbook contribution, plant-based experience, and clinical work around cardiometabolic risk.
    • Dr. Chaffee enters as an American MD in Perth with molecular and cellular biology training, long nutrition study, carnivore practice, and clinical use of dietary intervention.
    • Both doctors agree that the prevailing Western diet is unhealthy and that processed-food reliance is a major shared problem.
    • The host sets a debate format: define the question, let each doctor give a stance, then let them respond to each other.
    • The first major question is what humans are biologically and evolutionarily designed to eat.

    Evolution, adaptation, and health outcomes

    • Dr. Nagra separates evolutionary adaptation from long-term health and says reproductive success does not automatically equal late-life disease protection.
    • He uses sickle-cell protection against malaria as the example: a trait can help survival to reproduction while still carrying later cardiovascular risk.
    • He says the relevant endpoint is long-term disease and mortality risk, not whether humans can digest or use a given food.
    • Dr. Nagra links higher intake of whole grains, vegetables, fruits, nuts, and legumes with lower all-cause mortality in prospective data.
    • He uses enterolactone biomarkers as an intake marker for lignan-rich foods and links higher levels with lower all-cause and cardiovascular mortality.
    • He uses the Lyon Diet Heart Study as randomized long-term support for a Mediterranean-style pattern with more bread, fruit, margarine, and less butter, cream, meat, and deli foods.
    • Dr. Chaffee says the biological starting point matters because long adaptation to a food group makes harm from that food group unlikely.
    • He says wild animals become sick when fed outside their natural diet, and he uses zoos, parks, veterinary medicine, and livestock feeding as analogies.
    • He links human evolution with meat dependence, large-animal hunting, ice-age survival, and high human trophic level.
    • He says average life expectancy at birth underrates ancestral longevity because infant and child mortality distort the average.
    • Their central disagreement is whether diet should start from evolutionary design or measured long-term health outcomes in modern humans.

    Vegetables, cohorts, and study interpretation

    • Dr. Chaffee uses a UK vegetable-intake paper as an example of mixed nutrition literature and confounding.
    • Dr. Nagra checks the table and says fully adjusted all-cause mortality was lower with cooked, raw, and total vegetable intake.
    • Dr. Chaffee clarifies that he was focused on cardiovascular risk, not all-cause mortality.
    • Dr. Nagra says the study still showed benefit for all-cause mortality and therefore should not be used as a simple no-benefit example.
    • Dr. Chaffee says comparisons against the standard diet are limited because both sides already see the standard diet as poor.
    • Dr. Nagra answers that swap models do not only compare plant foods with a standard Western diet; they model moving calories or protein from red meat to plant sources.
    • Dr. Nagra uses dairy, nuts, legumes, and plant protein swaps as evidence for lower cardiovascular or mortality risk when unprocessed red meat is reduced.
    • Dr. Chaffee says each paper needs methodological review and that population averages can conflict with repeated clinical outcomes.

    Carnivore survey, selection bias, and calcium scans

    • Dr. Chaffee uses the Harvard carnivore survey as evidence that adults on a carnivore diet self-tell improved health.
    • Dr. Nagra says the survey recruited from carnivore communities and therefore has strong selection bias.
    • Dr. Nagra focuses on coronary artery calcium in people with before-and-after scans and says the score rose from 55 before diet to 81 after or current diet.
    • Dr. Nagra says accepting only favorable self-told outcomes while ignoring unfavorable scan data is not a complete use of the paper.
    • Dr. Chaffee answers that self-told clinical improvement still matters when many severe conditions reverse in practice.
    • The survey becomes a recurring test case for what kind of evidence counts: subjective improvement, objective scans, cohort risk, or patient-level clinical change.

    Zoo animals, cancer, and species-appropriate diet

    • Dr. Chaffee says animals fed species-appropriate diets in zoos rarely develop diseases such as diabetes, autoimmune disease, cancer, or cardiovascular disease.
    • Dr. Nagra answers with zoo-mammal cancer data and says carnivores had the highest cancer mortality among the animal categories he shows.
    • Dr. Nagra also raises arthritis and cross-species disease patterns as problems for a simple species-appropriate-diet explanation.
    • Dr. Chaffee says animal categories and causes of disease are complex and that the key human issue remains whether humans are adapted to heavy meat intake.
    • The exchange tests whether animal feeding analogies can be mapped onto human chronic disease.

    Plant-based adequacy, B12, and supplementation

    • Dr. Nagra accepts that an unsupplemented and unfortified plant-only diet is not nutritionally complete because vitamin B12 must come from supplements or fortified foods.
    • He says a supplemented or fortified plant-based diet can yield nutrient status comparable with omnivores in real populations.
    • Dr. Chaffee says a diet needing supplementation is unlikely to be the ancestral human diet.
    • Dr. Nagra separates ancestry from adequacy and says modern tools can make a diet workable even when ancestral humans did not eat that way.
    • Dr. Chaffee raises B12, heme iron, carnitine, taurine, EPA, DHA, vitamin A, vitamin K2, iodine, zinc, and bioavailability as concerns.
    • Dr. Nagra answers that supplementation, fortified foods, K1 conversion, MK7 from natto, beta-carotene conversion, and careful food choice can cover many of those concerns.
    • Dr. Chaffee remains focused on whether a diet built from whole animal foods avoids the need for supplementation and conversion uncertainty.

    Protein, muscle, and athletic performance

    • Dr. Chaffee says animal protein is complete, bioavailable, and naturally packaged with fat-soluble nutrients and fatty acids.
    • Dr. Nagra uses protein-matched studies to say plant-based diets can support similar gains in strength and hypertrophy when total protein is adequate.
    • Soy isolate, whey, mycoprotein, high-protein vegan diets, and resistance training enter as examples where the total protein dose is controlled.
    • Dr. Chaffee questions whether short-term performance and hypertrophy trials settle long-term nutrition quality.
    • Dr. Nagra says plant proteins can work in practice when intake and planning are sufficient.
    • The disagreement is not only about protein grams; it is also about bioavailability, nutrient package, long-term outcomes, and how much planning is acceptable.

    Fiber, diverticular disease, and gut conditions

    • Dr. Chaffee challenges common advice around fiber and diverticular disease and says some recommendations historically warned against seeds and fiber.
    • Dr. Nagra says current practice in his setting recommends fiber for diverticular disease and gut health.
    • Dr. Chaffee says patients with Crohn's, ulcerative colitis, diverticulitis, and related gut problems can improve when plants are removed.
    • Dr. Nagra says observational evidence should not be called causal but still needs direct critique if it is used in the debate.
    • The gut section becomes a broader clash between clinical elimination results and population-level fiber data.

    Anecdotes, clinical reversals, and causal weight

    • Dr. Chaffee says his own health improved when he moved away from plant-heavy eating and toward fatty meat.
    • He says patients with Crohn's, ulcerative colitis, rheumatoid arthritis, MS, lupus, Hashimoto's, diabetes, insulin resistance, high CRP, high leptin, and dementia-like decline improve on meat-only or meat-centered diets.
    • Dr. Nagra says anecdotes run both directions, including carnivore failures, plant reintroductions, vegan improvements, and non-diet examples.
    • Dr. Nagra uses smoking with Parkinson's disease or ulcerative colitis as an example where symptom or risk patterns do not make a behavior broadly healthy.
    • Dr. Chaffee says repeated elimination and reintroduction effects in patients function like experiment-like evidence when the same disease patterns improve.
    • Dr. Nagra says personal stories are not enough to override long-term disease-risk evidence.
    • Dr. Chaffee says population evidence should not erase visible patient recovery when severe symptoms stop.

    Plants, toxins, and preparation

    • Dr. Chaffee says plants defend themselves chemically and that indiscriminate plant eating can cause harm.
    • He uses lectins, kidney beans, oxalates, rhubarb, spinach, animal-husbandry examples, and traditional preparation practices as support.
    • Dr. Nagra accepts that some plants need preparation but says ordinary soaking, boiling, pressure cooking, and food practices usually reduce the risk.
    • Dr. Nagra uses the white kidney bean incident as an example of acute illness from improper preparation, not proof that all beans are unsafe.
    • Dr. Chaffee says plant toxins are not imaginary and that processing traditions exist for a reason.
    • Dr. Nagra says animal foods also require preparation and carry contamination risk.

    Foodborne illness and contamination

    • Dr. Nagra contrasts lectin-poisoning incidents with Salmonella and E. coli burdens from animal foods.
    • He gives annual Salmonella figures of 1.35 million infections, 26,500 hospitalizations, and 420 deaths in the United States.
    • He says a portion of Salmonella burden is attributable to chicken and turkey.
    • He also uses E. coli outbreak attribution to ground beef as a counterpoint to plant-toxin concern.
    • Dr. Chaffee answers that foodborne contamination and intrinsic plant toxins are different categories of risk.
    • The shared practical point is that both plant and animal foods can be harmful when selection, storage, or preparation fails.

    Traditional populations and historical diet comparisons

    • Dr. Chaffee uses the Maasai and Kikuyu comparison to support the view that the higher-meat pastoral population had greater stature, strength, and health markers.
    • Dr. Nagra says the Kikuyu pattern in that old comparison was low-protein, low-fat, low-calcium, and not a modern well-planned plant-based diet.
    • Dr. Chaffee says a whole civilization living generationally on a plant-heavy diet is still relevant evidence if health markers were worse.
    • Dr. Nagra raises confounders such as genetics, hospital access, disease environment, life expectancy, and cardiovascular endpoints.
    • Dr. Chaffee also points to Plains Indians, Inuit diet history, and ice-age hunting as evidence for meat-centered human adaptation.
    • Dr. Nagra points to Greenland Inuit mummies, Egyptian mummies, Lithuanian mummies, and Maasai autopsy material as evidence that atherosclerosis can occur in traditional or high-animal-food settings.
    • Dr. Chaffee answers that atherosclerosis has many possible causes, including stress, smoking, infection, and other exposures.

    Closing split

    • Dr. Nagra closes on outcome evidence: higher intake of healthful plant foods, especially when replacing meat, aligns with lower cardiometabolic, diabetes, cancer, and mortality risk.
    • Dr. Chaffee closes on biology and clinical response: humans are meat-adapted, severe disease often improves on carnivore, and studies that conflict with repeated patient outcomes deserve skepticism.
    • Both sides agree that processed food is a core problem.
    • They remain split on whether plant-forward long-term outcome data or carnivore evolutionary logic is the stronger guide.
    • The debate also remains split on what evidence has priority: cohorts, trials, biomarkers, mechanistic biology, ancestral reconstruction, objective scans, or clinical reversals.

    References

     

    Dr. Jay Wortman studied Biology and Chemistry at the University of Alberta and Medicine at the University of Calgary. He completed the Family Medicine residency at UBC before starting a private practice in Vancouver. He began combining that with part-time clinics at the STI/HIV the BC Centre for Disease Control where he eventually became the full-time Associate Director. He moved on the First Nations and Inuit Health Branch of Health Canada where he held senior management positions in Ottawa and Vancouver.

    In 1992, Dr. Wortman developed type 2 diabetes and quickly discovered that it could be controlled by restricting dietary carbohydrates. He went on to do clinical research on low-carbohydrate diets and became a little bit famous for a study he did in the Namgis First Nation of Alert Bay which was the subject of the CBC documentary film, "My Big Fat Diet". His research interest in the dietary management of obesity, pre-diabetes and diabetes led him back into clinical practice.

    summerizerAnti-meat pressure and my own route into low carb

    • Patients often cut back on red meat because they hear it is healthier and better for the environment.
    • The 2019 survey puts health first and environment second as the main motives for eating less meat.
    • My Métis family history of type 2 diabetes made the issue personal, because my grandparents, their children, and my mother all had diabetes.
    • My childhood breakfast of corn flakes, skim milk, and white sugar matched the same skim milk and grain pattern used to fatten pigs.
    • After type 2 diabetes developed, I removed carbohydrates, lost weight rapidly, and saw blood sugar improve.
    • The First Nations traditional-diet project and My Big Fat Diet showed that low-carbohydrate traditional foods could improve metabolic health.
    • Medical training left diet to the food guide, but the food guide had not earned the authority that clinicians give it.

    The anti-meat pattern has institutional roots

    • Seventh-day Adventist nutrition history runs through Ellen G. White, Battle Creek, Kellogg, sanitariums, dietetics, and Loma Linda.
    • The vegetarian health halo rests heavily on observational Adventist cohorts, which mix diet with religion, community, abstinence, and other behaviors.
    • The SDA-versus-non-SDA comparison matters because the protective vegetarian signal is stronger inside Adventist studies than outside them.
    • The Adventist water finding shows the weakness of relying on such cohorts, because drinking more water looked more powerful than major drug therapy.
    • Mormon longevity and the Roseto effect make the same point: tight communities can look cardioprotective without the diet being the cause.

    Cancer fears about meat are weaker than the public story

    • The IARC cancer process leaned on observational studies and turned mixed red-meat data into a public cancer warning.
    • Red meat colorectal data split almost evenly, while processed-meat data carried more of the adverse signal.
    • David Klurfeld's work and experience inside the IARC process show why confounding, committee structure, and omitted evidence matter.
    • Red meat remains a nutrient-dense food, and the case against it depends on fragile epidemiology.

    The climate and protein case for beef is being distorted

    • Environmental fear is the other major reason patients reduce meat, even though the emissions picture is broader than cattle.
    • Greenpeace, European media, fake-meat promoters, and Bill Gates all fit the wider push to cut beef.
    • Frank Mitloehner's comparisons about horses, dairy cows, dogs, and cats expose selective attention in livestock climate messaging.
    • Grazing-land carbon work shows grasslands can store carbon and can offset parts of rural emissions.
    • U.S. emissions data place energy far above agriculture, while land use and forestry are a major sink.
    • Beef net-protein work shows the U.S. beef chain produces more human-edible protein quality than it consumes.
    • Human evolution also fits a meat-heavy pattern, with Pleistocene evidence for a high trophic level and fat-oriented physiology.

    Nutrition science has deep reliability problems

    • Richard Horton and John Ioannidis capture the broader problem: much medical and nutritional literature is unreliable.
    • NutriRECS reviewed red and processed meat and made weak recommendations against reducing intake, triggering intense backlash.
    • The backlash before publication, along with True Health Initiative activity, shows how nutrition authorities defend the anti-meat script.
    • Raising my children low carb did not impair their academics, athletics, or development in my household experience.
    • Jared Diamond's agriculture essay fits the skeletal record I use: health markers worsened when humans moved from hunting and gathering to farming.

    Q&A and practice points

    • The Netherlands farmer policy, Canadian fertilizer targets, meatless-school policies, and fake-meat promotion all look like parts of the same pressure on animal agriculture.
    • Carnivore and paleo-keto diets helped my neck pain and other patients' joint pain or asthma by removing plants and targeting gut-driven inflammation.
    • The oyster-zinc study shows why plant anti-nutrients matter: black beans reduce zinc absorption and corn tortillas reduce it further.
    • My one-page patient advice is simple: avoid carbohydrates, avoid vegetable oils, and eat fatty meat and fatty dairy.
    • Vegan diets can create fertility, infant, and micronutrient problems when nutrients must come from supplements instead of animal foods.
    • In older or kidney-compromised patients, I am cautious with protein but still use carbohydrate restriction and higher fat when appropriate.
    • My own high-carb vegetarian period ended in diabetes; 21 years of low carb improved my skiing stamina without extra exercise.
    • Hunter-gatherer energy research supports the idea that metabolic health is not mainly a story of exercise volume.
    • TMAO, saturated fat, and kidney-nitrogen fears do not give me a convincing mechanism for meat harm.
    • Ooligan grease shows the sophistication of First Nations fat knowledge, because its fatty-acid profile resembles human adipose tissue.

    References

    view more: ‹ prev next ›