[–] 1 point 2 months ago (3 children)

I understand your points, and this is one of the cruxes of the matter:

It is the same principle with students and access to research materials and I am getting really tired of this lazy nostalgia about using less efficient tools, if you want that you need to advocate for reducing the workload on students so they can afford to utilize those methods and elect to research in an inefficient manner.

That's a societal problem more than anything else. Hyper competitiveness, hyper productivity and excess convenience. People (parents and society) expect kids to become achievers ASAP. That, by itself, shows how sick society is. There's also the big push, mainly from the tech sector, to get kids to do everything on computers. As Sweden and several USA cities have shown, that didn't actually make the learning process better and, worse, offered a big possible distraction right in front of every kid. Attention is a finite resource and we'll do anything to distract ourselves from boredom, which defines the vast majority of classes.

Dunno about other places, but in Brazil, the majority of classes didn't change much in the past 70 years, they're overcrowded (both public and private, ~30 students) and make students sit down "paying attention" with a single 15 minute break after 2 hours, followed by another 2h of lessons, or 3h/15min/2h in high school. There was no attempt at motivating or in making topics relevant to anything - here's trigonometry, memorize it; here's some grammatical rules, memorize them; memorize these chemistry equations. It's frankly a miracle that such process has even produced acceptable results in the past, but it's obviously way past time it's reworked from the bottom up - it's stupid to offer the same input and run through the same process and expect better results.

Keep in mind, my complaint wasn't directed at how things are currently happening in schools and universities, because what happens outside is just as important, if not more, to our expectations. Tell me, what is being taught to a kid that is allowed to have a cell phone any time they start screaming and crying for it? What is being taught to a kid that is given a phone whenever the parents need them to "behave"? What do they learn when they have easy access to a phone whenever boredom hits? The problem isn't even the content itself, it's the fact that it's extremely easy to get that dopamine relief. Things that happen outside school reflect on their behavior there.

Notice that, at no point in my comment, I made an argument for using inefficient methods of anything. My point was that inconvenience, or friction, as you put it, should be experienced, in this case preferably in life outside school. If I can have any content I want anytime I want, my capacity for dealing with shit I would rather not (work, study) goes down, as the article stated. It's easy to compare how much effort I have to put into activities and how much I'll "feel rewarded" for doing so.

To give you an actual example of what I mean, which do you think requires more effort:

  • Turn on the TV, turn on a PS2 console, pick up a dvd case, open it, put the dvd on, sit down, pick up the controller and play;
  • Pick up the phone, unlock the screen, find the PS2 emulator, open the PS2 emulator, choose the game, play.

The end reward is effectively the same, you'll play a PS2 game, but one has lower friction, is more convenient, than the other.

Regarding Blender, if the kid can do it and learned on their own, is because something motivated them to. Humans, whether young, adult or old, can learn things if they're motivated enough to overcome the friction. Without motivation, either intrinsic or extrinsic, you don't learn.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 3 points 2 months ago

    AI, 3D graphics and cartoon characters are all interchangeable in your logic, as none of them is real or exists. If you tell me that the answer to

    does it matter if we ask AI to do creepy things we wouldn’t want a person to do

    Is different from the answer to

    does it matter if we ask AI have bugs bunny to do creepy things we wouldn’t want a person to do

    Then you're getting your priorities wrong. AI is not the problem in your argument, it's the depiction of certain acts, which is a wholly different discussion.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 2 points 2 months ago (5 children)

    “Digital media use may influence cognition mainly by recalibrating how effort is valued and allocated,” researchers explain in another 2026 study. Adults may be nostalgic about searching through encyclopedias or visiting the library to research a topic, but when the same information can be retrieved in seconds, spending hours tracking it down doesn’t feel like persistence to students, it feels like wasted effort.

    I think that's the key to understanding what's going on. When nearly everything requires little to no effort, the slightest bump up in that is enough to make you give up - probably no wonder that a bit of inconvenience is sometimes all that we need to stop certain impulses.

    It has also been something that's been cooking in my mind, how "screens", at least computer ones, weren't that evil back in the 80s and early 90s, even when they had games. Compared to TVs, where you just flipped channels, computers had to load stuff (if it was on tape, that'd could take minutes), a good part of them wouldn't multitask properly, you had to manually type specific commands and also deal with possible crashes.

    Hell, even the early internet was full of inconveniences, from "not having enough stuff", to being expensive, locking the telephone line and being slow.

  • source
  • [–] 0 points 2 months ago* (last edited 2 months ago) (1 child)

    In case the image doesn't load: "So I'm assuming you've got similar articles for mass killings under capitalists, or fascists, or colonial states, right?"

    First list is of colonial massacre, second list has more colonial massacre. It's stupid easy to find the list of japanese massacres during ww2.

    And, in case you didn't check, the image in my first post is a bottom list of "Major armed conflicts in American labor union history", which, dunno, sounds like a lot of killings happening under a capitalist regime.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • view more: ‹ prev next ›