Dr. Georgia Ede and Dr. Bret Scher discuss the recently released EAT-Lancet diet report.

I found it particularly interesting that they responded to the criticism of the first report by re-releasing it and removing the parts of the report that were criticised, without directly addressing the criticism.

Dr. Sher:

In advance of the release of the 2.0 [diet report], there was actually a release of the "mis-influencers" who have done an organized approach to discredit and attack EAT-Lancet. Their words, not mine. And you were listed as a very high-ranking member of this. So first, how does it feel to be labeled as a "misinfluencer"?

Dr. Ede:

It's interesting. I actually think it's a very good thing. And the reason why is clearly [that] the content that I produced that criticized the EAT-Lancet report came to their attention. I think that that's no small thing, and I would like to believe that the content that I and others produced had a lot to do with the fact that they felt the need to produce this report to try to discredit all of us. I think it may also have had something to do with the way the report was re-released. I noticed that certain things that I criticized about the report are no longer there, and I'm not the only one who produced content critiquing the report.

Also, there are certain concerns that I and others voiced about the content of the report, and it appears as though the authors have gone to great lengths to try to acknowledge and address [these concerns] without actually addressing them. But they're trying to make it look as though they're addressing these shortcomings.

SummaryTitle: Exposing the Truth Behind EAT-Lancet’s Diet Report & MisInfluencer Campaign

  • The EAT-Lancet report aims to control global dietary habits by promoting a plant-based diet for planetary health, but its scientific foundation is questioned.
  • The report's dietary recommendations are criticized for being nutritionally inadequate, particularly for vulnerable groups like pregnant women, children, and the elderly.
  • The EAT-Lancet diet is accused of disregarding the nutritional benefits of animal-based foods, which are essential for optimal human health, including brain development and mental health.
  • The report heavily relies on nutrition epidemiology, which is considered unreliable for making global dietary recommendations.
  • The EAT-Lancet diet is criticized for being overly restrictive and not accounting for individual differences in metabolism, genetics, and cultural food preferences.
  • The report's authors are accused of having conflicts of interest, as they are connected to major food corporations that produce ultra-processed foods and chemical fertilizers.
  • The EAT-Lancet diet is seen as an attempt to control people's eating habits, rather than promoting a flexible and inclusive approach to nutrition.
  • The report's dietary recommendations are criticized for being based on untested theories and guesswork, rather than solid scientific evidence.
  • The EAT-Lancet diet is accused of being environmentally unfriendly, as it does not adequately address the environmental impact of industrial plant food production.
  • The report's authors are criticized for labeling critics as 'mis-influencers' without providing substantial evidence to support their claims.
other discussions
 

The EAT-Lancet Commission recently released their updated "Planetary Health Diet" and preemptively labeled a number of health experts who pushed back as “mis-influencers.”

Dr. Georgia Ede was one of those health experts labeled and in this episode of the Metabolic Mind podcast, she joins Dr. Bret Scher to unpack the many flaws of the EAT-Lancet 2.0 report.

At Metabolic Mind, we believe optimal human nutrition begins with asking the right scientific questions—starting with what’s healthiest for the brain and body, then considering sustainable solutions.

Human and planetary health are too complex for one-size-fits-all solutions—and if such a diet existed, we wouldn’t uncover it through untested epidemiological guesswork.

summerizer

Video Summary — EAT-Lancet “Planetary Health Diet” & “Misinfluencer” Campaign

Context

  • The video discusses the EAT-Lancet “Planetary Health Diet” (PHD)—its goals and scientific basis—and a new “misinfluencer” campaign launched around the forthcoming EAT-Lancet 2.0 update.
  • Guest: Dr. Georgia Ede (named in the campaign) responds to the label and critiques the report’s methods and conclusions.

What EAT-Lancet Proposes (as described in the video)

  • A global dietary pattern intended to be healthy for humans and environmentally sustainable by 2050.
  • Core recommendation: minimize or eliminate animal-source foods; emphasize grains, legumes, nuts, with supplements and fortified processed foods filling nutritional gaps.

Methodological Concerns Raised in the Video

  • Heavy reliance on nutrition epidemiology (observational associations) rather than:
    • Randomized controlled trials
    • Clinical experiments
    • Human biology/mechanistic evidence
  • Evidence that would challenge or nuance conclusions is dismissed, excluded, or downplayed.
  • The report’s broad, universal prescription is questioned given heterogeneity in human needs and contexts.

Nutrient Adequacy & Supplementation (quotations/paraphrases from the report cited in the video)

  • The report acknowledges shortfalls for at least four key nutrients on the recommended pattern:
    • Calcium, **Vitamin B12, Iron, Iodine
  • States that B12 intake is already low globally and would be further reduced without optimization.
  • Advises supplementation and fortified processed foods to cover gaps.
  • The video emphasizes that these nutrients are most easily—or sometimes only—reliably obtained from animal foods.

Populations of Concern (as stated in the video)

  • The report itself flags risks for:
    • Women, children, malnourished/impoverished populations, and older adults.
  • The video stresses heightened vulnerability for women and children, who may be more likely to adopt such guidance and more susceptible to nutrient deficits.

Risk Framing

  • The video characterizes the recommended diet as “incredibly risky” if broadly prescribed, due to:
    • Dependence on supplements/fortification
    • Potential nutrient insufficiencies
    • Lack of strong experimental evidence underpinning sweeping global recommendations

Environmental Framing

  • The video argues it’s overly simplistic to label animal agriculture as inherently worse and plant agriculture as inherently better for the environment.
  • Notes industrial production of both plant and animal foods raises distinct environmental concerns not fully addressed by the report.

“Misinfluencer” Campaign (as described in the video)

  • Ahead of EAT-Lancet 2.0, an organized communications effort labeled critics as “misinfluencers.”
  • Georgia Ede (guest) was listed; the video says the campaign names people and claims but does not substantively rebut their specific arguments.
  • The campaign is presented as an attempt to discredit dissent rather than engage with evidence.

Protein & Brain Health (discussion points)

  • The video raises concerns about adequacy of high-quality protein (and specific fatty acids) for brain development and function within the recommended pattern.
  • Emphasizes biological needs that may not be fully met without animal-source foods or targeted supplementation.

Bottom Line from the Video

  • A single global diet prescription is portrayed as unsupported by robust experimental evidence and potentially unsafe for many, especially vulnerable populations.
  • The video calls for higher-quality evidence (RCTs, clinical and mechanistic studies) and nuanced, context-specific guidance rather than one-size-fits-all recommendations.

Referenced Paper(s) with DOI