You wouldn't have this fucking problem if you actually treated your wastewater before pumping it into the sea like a civilised city would.
post
Unholy shit.
literal shit post
Sydney is such an embarrassment to this country. Always so behind. Not treating their waste in a country where there are often massive water shortages is crazy. When you see the lengths other parts of this country go to to conserve and treat water and all the tech we use. And Sydney just pumps shit onto their beaches. Dumbarses.
A modern western city that dumps fucking raw sewage directly into the ocean. Embarrassing.
oh my what did I even read
FatbergBirthingPooBalls is actually a fantastic username.
The headline
How can you design a system and think that not allowing any maintenance of this section is a good idea?!
I'm certain a lot of people raised the same question during construction, and the answer was definately "it'll be too expensive".
As long as capital is the foremost concern, sensibility, sustainability and common good will never be. Can never be.
Everything needs to change before that becomes an option. A revolution has to happen, on a large enough scale to change that.
Funny story there (well, not "haha" funny). I recently finished my bachelors in Architectual Technologies and Construction Management in Denmark. The exam for this bachelors is defending a project you've worked on for 4-ish months. It's a construction project, where you alone have to design a building of a decent size while making sure you don't break a bunch of laws or building codes. My exam was a catastrophe. Part of what made it so incredibly bad, was that I insisted on making a building that was good for the end-user. Unfortunately, part of our building codes here in Denmark is that we have to build a building that is good for the customer, not the end-user. This meant that I went directly against code, by e.g. soundproofing the building better than the nationally agreed minimum soundproofing, because that would be more expensive for the customer, or by insulating the building more than legally required, because we live in fucking Denmark, and heating of a building is a big environmental factor.
According to our codes (apparently), you have to only ever do the absolutely legal minimum when designing a construction project, unless the customer has expressly stated otherwise, because if not, you're not securing your customer's interest. So in other words, the quality of the building isn't important, only the cost of it.
Do you not interact with your customer? As a software engineer, it’s part of my job to sell the project manager or customer on details they haven’t thought of or may not fully understand
In a real life scenario, I interact with customers on a daily basis, but I'm further along the chain in the construction process, and don't deal with design in any way. However, the exam was a completely fictional scenario with a fictional construction project, so no customer to talk to. The examiners decided they didn't care much for sound proofing, and didn't care for my reasoning.
Funny how humans put this shit into the ocean, and the ocean spits it back out. I think there's something in that for all of us.
Trump loves having big things named after him.
Kinda like the garbage dump named Mt. Cleese in honour of John Cleese.
I would support naming awful things after Trump, but I want to forget about that fucker as quickly as possible.
Fixing the problem would require shutting down the outfall – which reaches 2.3km offshore – for maintenance and diverting sewage to “cliff face discharge”, which would close Sydney’s beaches “for months”
"Cleaning up the massive rancid fat lump on the beach would be too much work, so we're just not gonna. It would inconvenience beach goers."
That's not quite it. The wastewater treatment plant is located high up on the cliffs above the ocean. It has a big pipe that they tunneled through bedrock so it discharges at the bottom of the ocean 2.3km from shore. The fatberg is in the junction between the plant and the pipe. To clean it out, they'd have to stop using the big drain pipe, and y'know, just dump sewage off the edge of the cliff into the ocean, pretty much right onto the beach.
Oh, I got the impression it was just... Floating there right out in the ocean.
How the fuck is this not an engineering problem they must have foreseen? I mean now what, the pipes just stay clogged? What a literal shitfest.
IKR? The need for maintenance eventually should be foreseen! If they went to all the trouble to put a pipe through bedrock, why not put 2 pipes, so there's a backup?
The need for maintenance is forseen, but it's generally deferred. There was probably a plan to do something every year or two, but they weren't willing to shut the beach down for a week or so. A second pipe would be absurdly expensive.
I want to hear FriendlyJordies take on this. I bet it's going to end up being a case of low bid mafia-connected contractors building the damn thing.
Jaws but with a fatberg instead of a shark
Maybe they can mine it...and turn it into luxury soap...that's what I learned from survival games at least.
I like your drive! ...So I looked it up. First off, you can't. Because that's not a thing that is done. Second off, you can't. Because it isn't yours to keep. Even if you wanted to and offered to take care of it, it's a maritime thing and technically it belongs to the state. Let me break it down for you with this imaginary, but realistic, exchange:
"We are not going to remove the rancid fat berg. It's too expensive."
"Oh. Ok. Can I take it?"
"NO! IT'S MINE!"
Since olden 4chan (rip) days Australians have always been top of the heap when it came to shit posting. If anyone could make a giant poopy fatberg it's them.
Have they called Bruce?
It sounds like they need to call Bruce. Where would you rather be?
Just wait until a luxury cruise liner hits it and and gets shit everywhere then they might clean it up.
Like Titanic except they will wish that the ship went down when they are covered in literal months old rancid fat.
Yeah, fat isn't supposed to go through plumbing, it's why you aren't supposed to dump grease down sinks or put fatty tissue through a garburator. It's why commercial kitchens have a grease trap that needs cleaning.
To be fair that fatberg is massive.
Every so often there's a post on Lemmy about how you should stick it to your landlord and put grease down the drain.
This is why that's a bad idea, and it sucks for everyone, not just your landlord.
It's also not just fat! If you flush "flushable" wipes, don't! They don't disintegrate like toilet paper does, and just clump together with everything else
Unlike most cities, Sydney only does primary treatment of its sewage – straining out the solids. Elsewhere, secondary treatment uses settlement tanks and disinfection techniques before releasing the wastewater or recycling it.
Stay classy!
Sydney Water’s deepwater ocean outfalls (DOOF) assessment report, dated 30 August 2025, was produced for the New South Wales Environment Protection Authority, which has been investigating the “debris balls” that closed numerous beaches in late 2024 and early 2025.
They did not use a single real unit in the whole article.
Edit: I was wrong. There were two
Still a good read, though.
They could try this method - Whale Removal
At some point they'll need to do it. But, probably, it won't happen until the political cost is too high, and they just can't hide or ignore the problem anymore. They'll try some cheaper, interim fix that won't work, wasting more money. If they do it now, it will cost what it will cost. If they wait, it will cost much more. But, of course, if they can push it off onto the next administration that would be ideal.



all 4 comments