Has prohibition ever worked? Wouldn't this just create a black market for selling tobacco?
post
Maybe I'm misremembering but didn't Australia do something like this?
New Zealand and looks like they walked back on it
https://edition.cnn.com/2023/11/28/asia/new-zealand-smoking-ban-reversal-intl-hnk
Ah makes sense. I think the heart is in the right place for these sorts of bans but prohibition just doesn't work. Tobacco usage is already way down since the 50s and that's been because of education, not prohibition. Banning it just makes it seem cool again
Yes, it won’t work. But tobacco use in the Maldives has apparently not followed the trend of the rest of the world since the 50s. From the article:
Smoking is especially prevalent among young people, with nearly half of those ages 13 to 15 consuming some form of tobacco.
Half is insane.
So there is clearly a driving factor behind that, it would seem more beneficial to address that instead of a blanket ban that is guaranteed to make things worse. Wonder why smoking is so prevalant there?
Edit: dodnt get a clear answer on why, but it seems smoking is deeply embedded in their culture. 43% of men aged 15 or older smoke, while its only 4% of women in the same group smoke. Theyve also been trying to put an end to smoking for almost a decade now, not sure how much it has helped as i just cant find much info on them.
Yep, smoking is down because of it being a taboo thing now. You make it illegal...and you got another drug war on your hands.
Prohibition will never work.
Removed by the conservative government because they needed revenue to pay for their tax cuts for millionaires.
Yup, our shit-stain conservative govt rolled back one of the most popular policies in decades against the public desire, with legislation practically copied n pasted from tobacco industry lobbyists
Might as well get rid of the farms.
Perhaps use them for reforestation and stuff.
Maybe even start some new plant-based industry.
Tobacco no longer gets rid of mosquitoes. Its benefits are either long gone or didn't exist in the first place.
won't work. Evidently The Maldives have never heard of this thing we like to call "history".
last year around 1.2 billion people were smoking that were of adult age (18), vs in 2000, it was 1.38 billion. (source WHO)
this really tells me that smoking still isn't going anywhere in this world, and it begs the question, if smoking is still going to be so prevalent, despite countries smacking warnings and such on packaging, what do we do for harm reduction that the current products available don't solve? vaping is dead there's so much negativity around it, gum, patch, etc... are not utilized much as people never stick to using it for the most part, and pouches don't satisfy the same thing a cigarette does for some people.
I smoked for 10 years, then started vaping 11 years ago. Honestly, its so hard for me to quit, and i really just want to smoke again because of how good it makes me feel, and its an internal struggle because of the negative effects of what smoking can do to your body.
I don't know what the solution to this is.
The solutions:
For the individual: Don't start in the first place, which is what the Maldives are hoping to help people achieve.
For governments: Copy whatever local legislation applies to heroin and make it apply to nicotine as well. The article doesn't say what the Maldives intend to do to underage smokers and those who'd sell to them, but I'd be making it unnecessarily draconian just so people get the message.
For people who are already smokers: Nicotine patches of decreasing strength over time and some sort of media teaching pen-flipping or other legal hand-based hobby. Having something for the hands to do is a big part of it. If these can be prescribed by medical or psychological practitioners, all the better.
see the tricky thing is that i can't find data on how many people have truly quitted smoking using NRT. I'd like to see how successful it really is, and prove myself wrong that there is in fact, good progress on abstaining from tobacco. The only thing i was able to go off of was current est. of smokers worldwide, and while vs 2000 was a drop, it's still quite high, and not optimistic outlooks on a substantial drop in smoking (but in a positive light, hopefully less cancer and ill people)
last year around 1.2 billion people were smoking that were of adult age (18), vs in 2000, it was 1.38 billion. (source WHO)
I think we have more adults alive now than we did in 2000 though. It's a slight decline in % of smokers.
this really tells me that smoking still isn’t going anywhere in this world
That's true
if smoking is still going to be so prevalent, despite countries smacking warnings and such on packaging, what do we do for harm reduction that the current products available don’t solve?
Limit the amount of nicotine, tar, etc, per cigarette.
For most smokers, one single cigarette is what they consume at once on a smoke break at work. Most people don't smoke 5 in a row. If they get less of the bad shit per cigarette, they get less of it per day.
I'd also recommend super high cigarette prices, but that just leads to more smuggling. There's a balance to be found there too.
all 36 comments