post
Ragebait trash article
- Why not link the original source? Axios
- Apparently the "study" used this "AI detector"
All "AI detectors" are crap and this detector is no different.
But why? Well I just put the first 3 paragraphs of the GDPR into it and it said it was 100% AI generated.
One: the original Axios article requires you to log in.
Two: The researchers were aware of the limits of AI detectors, and tested the one they used. From the article:
We should also take the judgments of AI detectors with a grain of salt, since their reliability is up for question. In its own testing of Surfer’s accuracy, Graphite had the detector analyze a sample of AI-generated articles and another sample of human articles, finding that it labeled human-written articles as AI-made 4.2 percent of the time — a common problem with these tools — but only mistook AI-written articles as human 0.6 percent of the time.
And really, judging from the quality of search results these days, I would have expected a lot more than 50% of new online articles to be AI generated, so from that standpoint the article might be good news 😆
One: the original Axios article requires you to log in.
I can read the entire article without any login.
Anyway here's an archived version without authwall: https://archive.is/31K69
Oh shit, we bout to go back to talking to each other in person again?
I have created several dumb little web pages on various free hosts. They are not AI contents. They either don’t get indexed by search engines, or don’t get returned in the results. But search results return plenty of AI garbage.
You might be interested in taking a look at the following video.
The Dead Internet Theory is WRONG (but its worse than you thought) [16:56]
I am also concerned of AI-slop, so thanks for sharing. However, I do not think the headline here does justice to the article. There is a more interesting message in there. First of all, the study concerned new content, not all of the internet. Second, and more important, the researchers seemed to have found some kind of a saturation point for AI slop, where it's share of new content was not rising anymore. I think it would be crucial to understand the mechanisms behind this current limitation of AI slop, and whether they could be utilized to combat AI slop in the future.
all 19 comments