While it would be funny. Nintendo won't do it. They wanna be on friendly terms with orange boy so govco keeps helping them slap down ROM sites and prosecuting emulation enjoyers.
post
If Nintendo sued them, I'd actually be willing to buy a Switch2, just on principle.
The government is literally, and in an official capacity, posting edgy alt right teen discord videos. If I were 15 and a piece of shit again, I’d find this funny.
If you went back two decades and told them the US government would be posting edgy videos and memes on their official Twitter accounts, they'd think you grew a third head.
Bush might take a few seconds to wonder whether he set a course that would lead to the fall of democracy, but would otherwise be unfazed
Man, some people really always have a rosy propaganda filled picture of US history. Twitter didn't exists 2 decades ago but they were still propagandizing cringe through TV and news media.
Do you think uncle sam was less cringeworthy? Getting riled up to kill brown people abroad was not cringe at all.
Yankistanis will always have their head up theirs. SAD
Twitter didn’t exists 2 decades ago but they were still propagandizing cringe through TV and news media.
20 years, 17 years, there's not that much difference.
A decade ago would have been the first Trump Presidency, which wouldn't make for that different of a comparison point.
Oh I would be so happy if they manage to piss off Disney and Nintendo in the same week
From a legal perspective, this is copyright infringement.
From a PR perspective, if Nintendo did nothing, they are siding with this type of use and with those who used it in such a fashion. This may be good or bad, depending on how Nintendo actually sides. If they did something about it, they may he making enemies with the court systems, but they may be making friends with them, depending on how the court system sides.
Basically, they have precedence to sue, but whether or not they do, and what the outcome would be, is anybody's guess. But if this goes live, I would appreciate a heads up, because popcorn takes a few minutes to prepare.
This is brand tarnishment pretty clearly on the trademark side, too. If not for the apparent lasso the admin has around executives' nuts with their green cards (according to the former CLO in an article), this would represent an immense amount of liability on DHS' part. I still wonder if they might nevertheless press forward with litigation just to tamp down on the brand damage tbh
ETA: also, the potential recoverable damages are actually theoretically immense in a case like this, between statutory damages per copyright infringement and loss of sales to brand tarnishment. Very low chance, asymptotic to 0 percent likelihood, but it would be immensely satisfying if this is what zeros out ICE incredible funding bump.
.gov sites have lost the sense of taste
Hell, they've lost all sense of legitimacy and respect. Turned into your grandfather's thinly veiled racist social media posts.
My grandfather was a very based antifascist and would never post this type of shit (he also wasn't particularly great with modern tech, he had an old Nokia phone, so posting it would be quite a challenge). I miss him a lot.
I'm outraged that Nintendo has a contract with ICE to produce pokeballs for catching suspected illegal immigrants.
Nintendo should do to Kristi Noem what they (ALLEGEDLY) did to Gunpei Yokoi.
Trump prob wants to take over FED bcs getting sued by Nintendo whilst not in possession of a money-printer is not recommended.
Nintendo only targets weak prey, like customers, fans, and smaller competitors. I would be shocked if they even issued a statement, let alone action.
Lol I can't believe this is real
The video in question for those who haven't seen it yet: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9VI5tZoBZ0s
I hate to break this to you, but Nintendo aren't your friends and will happily lick ICE's boots clean.
EDIT: I will happily admit I was wrong about this. Good for you Nintendo.
It doesn't matter, Nintendo cares about their brand more than their own lives and if enough people said "I can't believe Nintendo is supporting human rights violations!" they would bury ICE under a lawsuit. We're talking about Nintendo here, the company who literally makes most of its money from suing people. Them just waving and smiling at ICE literally using their IP for nefarious purposes is so OOC it's actually insane anyone would even consider it.
Unless that slogan is trademarked (and even then)... dunno... ask Legal Eagle.
The animation video clips sure are copyrighted. Ask Ketchum is Nintendo's intellectual property. I've been in fangame spaces for years. The motto is - when the articles come out; the uploads go down.
Will the US courts side with the US government on the fair use of it?
In what way is this fair use, though?
Regardless of the other criteria of fair use (which the DHS likely doesn't meet), see factor 4:
the effect of the use upon the potential market for or value of the copyrighted work.
This is immensely harming Nintendo et. al's IP.
They have the ability but they won't because they spent the past 6 months bootlicking the current government over Trump's insane tariff nuke policies, just like every other company has.
Kia literally just got raided by ICE and they announced they were continuing to invest in the US not even a week later.
Most they'd be willing to do would be to ask Japan's ambassador local liaison to ask DHS to remove the video, which the ambassador liason or foreign diplomat himself may even refuse to do under fear of retaliation or breakdown in ongoing negotiations.
Nintendo will sacrifice its brand image all day if it means staying in the US market and not becoming the target of Trump's next company assassination in some convoluted political stunt.
If they did, I would save up for switch 2. And if Metroid prime 4 is released for the og switch, I would never buy one.



top 64 comments