Don't you know that spells just do what they are called. The rest of the description can be ignored and just base it off what you think "suggestion" means. So you suggest that the king gives you the kingdom and he does.
post
This is incredible! 😂😂😂
Dang OP has some awful players.
"Magic has rules?!"
That was very funny, thanks for a good laugh.
Honestly, I dislike spell slots. It's my least favorite magic system.
Basically my reaction when i learned that that charmed humanoid would still attack my friends even though we were evidently now chums. Great use of a 2nd lvl spell slot
Speaking as a DM:
Charm Person - DM's fault, should not have let a 7 year old play at their table
Zone of Truth - DM's fault, should not have expected PCs to just do what he wrote as the obvious response in the movie script they thought they were writing
Wild Shape - DM's fault, DM must always be ready to monkey's paw. 'Ok, you're a kraken. The party is dead because you crushed them against the walls and brought down the roof, and you are dying because this is a room with no water to breathe.'
Sacred Weapon on the Sly - DM's fault, DM must be ready to call out attempts to cheat and stop them. Part of their duty as organizer.
Sneak Attack - DM's fault. Players don't win arguments against the DM for the same reason you can't convince gravity that flapping your arms real hard lets you fly. The DM must be the laws of physics, consistent or thw world crumbles.
Cleric - everyone's fault. Why is this person playing DnD if they don't want to do crunchy rules-based combat? They aren't interested.
Spellbook - DM's fault, should not have let a 7 year old play at their table
Spell Slots - DM's fault, should not have let a 7 year old play at their table
Zone of Truth - DM's fault, should not have expected PCs to just do what he wrote as the obvious response in the movie script they thought they were writing
This i agree with. IPart od the charm is that everything can and will happen, to me at least. But i do prefer to play sandboxes. Obviously GM and players should be on the same page here.
Bingo. And it's part of the DM's job to do something (session 0, disclaimer, pre-game meeting, whatever) that establishes what kind of game they run vs what kind of game tbe players want. If the players and DM want different things from a game, it's going to go poorly.
Me and a few of my partymates had the message cantrip, and I pointed out that due to the cantrip's effects, we can virtually "have a telepathic group chat" via those of us who have the cantrip.
At first, I tried to stick to the illusion that I act as an intermediary to those in my range but doesn't have the cantrip, and that I identify myself before I speak up ("Megane here... blah blah blah").
The more it went on, the more the facade broke and eventually we were just discussing strategy under the assumption that it's "message-mediated".
The DM allowed it, and later gave all party members an artifact that has the following effects:
- anyone with the artifact can telepathically send a message to everyone else who has the artifact (within range)
- those who have the artifact can hear any and all such messages sent through the artifact (within range)
Later on, even the range stipulation was handwaved off (within limits—basically those who are in the same scene are assumed to be in range of each other).
Near the end of the campaign, the DM reminded us through an NPC that we're all "staring off into the distance" whenever we use this telepathic "group chat". We basically forgot to talk to each other normally (in character).
What a great way to handwave that because yeah, mediating with message gets annoying after a while and your DM’s solution is just better. And funnier!
My Aberrant Mind Sorceress had been making frequent use of her telepathy ability to communicate silently and to keep in touch with allies that went scouting away from the party. Then she opened something she was told not to and ended up with a piece of Nyarlathotep living in her mind. When she later used her telepathy on the Monk, the DM ruled that it allowed the outer god to enter his head as well. Now we had a permanent three-way group chat that neither I nor the Monk could leave, whose moderator frequently posted literal nightmare fuel, and the rest of the party was suddenly very insistent that I only communicate with them verbally from now on.
One time I tried using my telepathy on an enemy. His head exploded. Gnarly was very unhappy about me adding people to the chat without permission and suggested that I not do it again.
For your group I would have a DM screen and a DM stick. The screen to obscure roles, notes and and have all that nifty quick reference stuff on the inside.
The stick so I can wack anyone tryin his bullshit. Week one it would started as a padded wiffle bat. And each week it would be upgraded to a more solid and rougher hitting object
This sounds like it would quickly spiral into the other kind of dungeon with stocks and whips
My favorite thing to do when I was a monk was walk on water or walls. My DM would tell me that I could not end my turn while walking up a wall and that I would need to roll an athletics roll to hold on. I would retort Nuh uh, because that is bullshit.
My buddy was recently a rogue that could get surprise attacks in shadows. He would jump from shadow to shadow. We were in the underdark. A cabin was in the middle of an open cavern, it was well lit by lanterns. Said friend wanted to jump from porch post shadow to porch post shadow until he was in the shadows of a rocking chair where a sleepy enemy sat. DM and buddy got in a 30 minute shouting match countering each others argument with bullshit.
I had an echo knight once. Could leap and teleport onto ledges and escape prisons. DM got so flustered that he was the one that called bullshit. Character was promptly incinerated.
DND nights are fun.
That party never would have survived in 2nd ed.
Presdigitation (not even gonna try to spell it right), Druidcraft, and Thaumaturgy
- Cantrip
- Does, like, whatever I fuckin' feel like and can get away with. What do you mean Druidcraft can make buds open? No, if can make whole plants!
I'd rather have this than solving every puzzle with an axe
If problems don't want to be solved they shouldn't be hittable with an axe
The irony being in my games I'd rather people solve things with an ace, just because so many magic users in my group use these cantrips to do absolutely insane things they aren't supposed to do lol.
Oml, I could never, that's some problem player shit right there.
If I wrote a CRPG game, like an ASCII roguelike or something, I would totally include a spell that makes the target shit its pants. You could make that work, it would even be a useful thing in combat. Vampire lord misses a turn because he just shat his pants.
pathfinder (2e) fixes this by adding flavor text and/or being more specific
i totally don't just have a group of lazy people who don't even want to use spells

all 11 comments